lecture 22: body 11: in a cooking pot: the anthropology of cannibalism

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/26

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

27 Terms

1
New cards

The human body as medicine: describes the consumption of processed (usually powdered) mummies in 16th-18th c AD Europe

As she details, this actually originated with the use of bitumen and other resins in ancient medicine

2
New cards

The human body as medicine: Other authors’ research on earlier medieval medical texts gives more detail on the origins of the practice

  • Earliest known references to mummy derivatives as medicine are from 10th – 12th c texts in Arabic - mūmiyā qubūrī

    • Used for conditions including trauma and fractures (perhaps only externally as the connection to corpses should have made it impermissible to eat)

  • This was seen as a substitute for mūmiyā and other plant- and soil-derived fragrant substances used in various medications

    • These could be difficult to obtain, so mūmiyā qubūrī was recommended as a more accessible substitute – Arabic texts are clear that what really worked were the resins used to mummify the bodies


3
New cards

The human body as medicine: European use of mumia vera began after Arabic medical texts began to be translated in the 12th c AD

  • This was part of a wider European adoption of medical practices from these sources – important to the historical development of Western medicine

  • Over time, ideas on the ‘power’ of mummy changed – it was seen as coming from the body, not just the resins used to embalm it

    • As Osterholtz describes, Europeans of that era also used blood, ground bone and fat from other corpses in healing

    • So, although the European use of mumia had its roots in resin use in ancient medicine, it was also linked to the identity of the corpse: seen as a powerful healing object because it was once human


4
New cards

Eating the corpse: These medical practices were a form of normative (socially permissible) cannibalism. Cross-culturally, this is an exception!

  • Most ethnographically recorded cultures have strong rules against eating human bodies

  • Depictions of cannibalism in present popular culture and past tales/accounts tend toward the spectacular and deviant

  • Still, we can clearly approach the consumption of human bodies as an anthropological topic

  • Some questions: how common is it across cultures, why did/do people do it, and can we see it in the archaeological record?


5
New cards

Eating the corpse: Humans may eat each other for a variety of reasons

  • In some cases the consumption is socially normative

    • Examples include the medicinal cannibalism just described, cannibalism as a ritual aspect of warfare, and the mortuary cannibalism practiced by some groups like the Wari’ (what Osterholtz calls compassionate cannibalism)

  • In other cases it’s done in defiance of strong social norms

    • Examples include criminal cannibalism (an act of extreme social deviance) and the survival cannibalism that may occur during severe famines or if a group of people is stranded without any other source of food

  • People may eat members of their own society (endocannibalism) or members of a different social group (exocannibalism)


6
New cards

Cannibalism as an accusation

  • A complication when discussing cannibalism is the long history of accusations of cannibalism made to portray a people as savage or animalistic

    • For example, this was widely used by Europeans as a rhetorical tool in the conquest and colonization of the Americas

    • Initially encouraged by policies of Spanish crown and Catholic Church that legitimized the conquest and enslavement of ‘cannibals’

  • These accusations persisted through the centuries and were also common in 19th c European tales of ‘savage’ peoples

    • Americas, Africa, SE Asia, Australia…

    • Again the effect was to portray these cultures as inferior, exotic and better off under European control


7
New cards

Cannibalism as a myth?

  • This has led some scholars to argue that cannibalism was never a normative practice for any culture

    • E.g. Arens 1979, The Man-Eating Myth

  • However, there is lots of evidence that this a real (though rare) cultural practice

    • One of the best-documented examples is the mortuary cannibalism practiced by the Wari’


8
New cards

The Wari’ and mortuary cannibalism: The Wari’ are an Indigenous Amazonian people whose lands are in Western Brazil

  • Hunters and cultivators

  • Came into regular contact with Western culture in 1950s as ranchers, miners and loggers moved into the area

  • This contact was marked by epidemics, loss of some of their lands, social upheaval and influence by missionaries and government agencies


9
New cards

The Wari’ and mortuary cannibalism: Conklin lived in Wari’ communities in 1985-1987

  • Precontact life and funerary customs still within living memory

  • Conklin spoke with Wari’ community members, especially elders, about life before the 1950s

  • Included speaking to them about current and past mortuary customs

  • Important: by the 1980s, funerary cannibalism was no longer practiced


10
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: Conklin reported that Wari’ dying and death rites focused on constant contact between the living and the dying/dead

  • Ill or dying people would be kept constant company, living would hold and stroke them and ask them to stay with the living

  • After death, corpse placed on mat on floor of home; kin continued to surround and hold the corpse, keening and mourning

  • Messengers would be sent to relatives and friends in other communities telling them to come for funeral


11
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: Funerals of infants and children took place day after death

For adolescents and adults all mourners had to arrive – funeral usually held three days after death

12
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: In this funeral, consanguineal relatives (blood kin) and affines (kin by marriage) played different roles

  • Close blood kin as primary mourners

  • Nari paxi (affines and distant relatives) responsible for most funeral activities including eating the corpse


13
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: Mourners needed to arrive in order of relationship, with closer relatives arriving first

  • As they arrived they would hear the closest mourners (kin in same community) sing songs about life, kin ties and death of deceased

  • They would then join in weeping and remembering

  • The ideal was for the deceased to be surrounded by many people weeping for them, remembering their living identity (especially their kindness and the times they shared food with others) and calling out their name


14
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: When it was time for the funeral itself, the nari paxi had to ‘take the body away’ from the blood kin

Close blood kin expected to object and try to hold corpse back

15
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: The corpse was then brought to another hut where a fire and cooking rack were prepared

  • The body was cut up

  • Heart, liver, torso and limbs roasted

  • Rest of corpse cremated in fire


16
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: After the body was cooked, mourners gathered

  • Close blood relatives removed the flesh from the bones

  • Nari paxi were urged to consume the flesh – an ‘unpleasant duty’


17
New cards

A Wari’ funeral: After this was complete, mourning and keening stopped

  • Bones either pounded & consumed with honey or burned to ashes

  • All possessions of deceased burned

  • Deceased mourned after this in general, but names no longer mentioned


18
New cards

Eating the corpse – Wari’ descriptions: Wari’ elders drew careful and detailed contrasts between funerary cannibalism and eating animal meat

  • An act of care and compassion

  • An unpleasant duty, not done for hunger or enjoyment

  • Important to not let any part of body decay in/on the ground (this was not true for hunted animals)

  • This treatment differs from rarer instances of Wari’ exocannibalism


19
New cards

Eating enemies – Wari’ exocannibalism: Wari’ elders also reported sometimes eating the bodies of enemies killed in combat

  • ‘We ate the enemies [wijam] because we were angry [mana’] at them.” (Wari’ elder, Conklin 2001 p. 95)

  • In many ways, this was done in an opposite way to a funeral:

    • An act of anger and aggression, rather than compassion

    • Much of body left to decay where the enemy had been killed, rather than being ‘saved’ from decaying into the ground

    • Mocking remarks made while eating, rather than expressing love/tribute

  • This denied the enemy basic respect and a normative funeral


20
New cards

Cannibalism in the past?

Osteologists looking for evidence of cannibalism in the past tend to rely on:

  • Signs of burning and dismemberment of the corpse that are unusual or non-normative for that place and time

    • This is more likely to detect ancient cases of survival cannibalism

  • Looking for signs that human bodies were treated like food animal bodies - basically, look for butchering marks


21
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe

  • Gough’s cave

  • Cave deposits include tools, decorative items (e.g. amber beads), faunal remains (food) and intensively fragmented & processed human bones

  • The human bones have been intensively processed using stone tools

  • There are also human gnawing marks on several elements

  • Intensive processing, gnawing and mixture with animal remains might suggest humans were simply used as food

  • One skull cup represents a person with no other remains in the assemblage; some other people have no ‘matching cup’

  • This is one of many mortuary cannibalism sites in the magdalenian period, several of which also have skull ‘cups’ or other evidence of special treatment of the skull


22
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe: Gough’s Cave

  • Cave site in England

  • Human bone deposit at site dates to ca. 14,700 years BP (before present) – Magdalenian period of Upper Palaeolithic

  • Anatomically modern humans

  • One of several Magdalenian sites with cut-marked human bone


23
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe: Cave deposits include tools, decorative items (e.g. amber beads), faunal remains (food) and intensively fragmented & processed human bones

  • So, both living and mortuary site

  • Human remains represent at least 6 people (child, 2 adolescents, 3 adults)


24
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe: The human bones have been intensively processed using stone tools

  • Soft tissues cut and scraped off

  • Long bones smashed open to remove marrow


25
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe: Intensive processing, gnawing and mixture with animal remains might suggest humans were simply used as food

But, heads were carefully severed, not smashed or gnawed, and processed into ‘skull cups’

  • This involved removing the top of the vault and chipping/cutting its edges to form a ‘cup’ or ‘bowl’


26
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe: One skull cup represents a person with no other remains in the assemblage; some other people have no ‘matching cup’

  • In other words, they didn’t just discard each ‘cup’ along with the rest of the skeleton

  • This suggests that skull cups may have been curated as ritual objects and carried from place to place


27
New cards

Mortuary cannibalism in ancient Europe: This is one of many mortuary cannibalism sites in the Magdalenian period, several of which also have skull ‘cups’ or other evidence of special treatment of the skull

This suggests that the activity at Gough’s Cave may have been part of a wide-ranging mortuary tradition almost 15,000 years ago