1/64
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is Personality Psychology?
People are different
Personality psychologists try to understand how & why
Define Personality
Consistent Patterns of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
The psychological mechanisms behind those patterns
Where did those thoughts, feelings, and behaviors come from?
The study of the “whole” person
Who you are; what makes you unique; different from others
The Psychological Triad
Individual Differences between people
Thoughts (beliefs, values, expectations)
I believe that most people can be trusted
I tend to have a positive outlook on life
Feelings (emotions)
I feel happy most of the time
I often feel nervous when I meet someone
Behaviors (actions; what you do)
I go to a lot of parties
I enjoy risky sports like skydiving
What CAN well-validated personality tests predict?
Academic achievement
Occupational success
Delinquency and crime
Having a happy and lasting relationship
Healthy and longevity
What do personality theories make assumptions and propositions about?
What people are like in general (human nature)
How and why people differ (individual differences)
What makes a person unique and different from all others (individual uniqueness)
Scientific Method
Research Question
Populations: who do you want to study
Study Designs: How do you want to study it?
Experimental Study
Random assignment and manipulation of independent variable in highly controlled setting
E.g., in-lab experiments, randomized control trials / clinical interventions
Treatment & control condition
Not often used in this field
Whether one variable CAN affect another variable
Experimental Study Advantages & Disadvantages
A: can allow for causal inferences
D:
Random assignment not always possible
Difficult to manipulate and randomly assign personality
Manipulations are not always reliable/valid
Study not always ecologically valid
Observational Study
Observe variables in the real world and quantify their associations
most common in this field
2 Types: Cross-Sectional & Longitudinal
Observational Study Advantages & Disadvantages
Advantages
Typically large samples
Ecologically valid
Measurement tends to be strong
Disadvantages
Difficult to establish causality (i.e., correlation does not equal causation)
Cross-Sectional Design
Independent and dependent variables are assessed at one timepoint
Longitudinal Design
The same participants are repeatedly assessed over time – hours, days, weeks, months, years, decades
Independent and dependent variables are assessed at multiple timepoints
Case Study (advantages & disadvantages included)
Closely studying one person to find out as much as possible
Advantages
Great depth (describes the whole person)
Can inform our understanding of psychological phenomena
Sometimes it is necessary
Disadvantages
Unknown generalizability
Types of Personality Data: BLIS
Behavioral Data
Life Outcome Data
BLIS: Behavioral Data
Real-world behaviors
E.g., electronically activated recorder (EAR)
Behavior in standardized conditions
Projective techniques
Non-verbal behavior
BLIS: Life Outcome Data
Information obtained from the events, activities, and outcomes in a person’s life
School records, criminal records, health records, death, divorce, credit report, number of jobs, number of children, etc.
BLIS: Behavioral Data - Advantages & Disadvantages
Advantages
Wide range of contexts (real and contrived)
Disadvantages
Difficult and expensive
BLIS: Life Outcome Data - Advantages & Disadvantages
Advantages
Objective and verifiable
Intrinsically important
Disadvantage
Multi-determinations: there are a number of diff reasons for why an outcome comes to be
What could Behavioral Data in a structured situation look like?
Meeting stranger, novel toy, oral presentation
Trier Social Stress Test
Projective Techniques
personality assessment tools that present individuals with unstructured or ambiguous stimuli (such as inkblots or incomplete pictures) to uncover hidden emotions, internal conflicts, and unconscious motives
BLIS = Informant-Report Data
Reports provided by people who know the individual being assessed
Parents, friends, teachers, romantic partners
Usually collected by questionnaires or rating form
(BLIS) Informant-Report Data Advantage & Disadvantages
A:
Large amount of information
Real-world basis
Rooted in experience with person and context
Some I data are true by definition (e.g., likeability)
D:
Limited behavioral information
Lack of access to private/internal experience
Error
Bias
BLIS: Self-Report
People describe their typical thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
Standardized questionnaires, life narrative data
(BLIS) Self Report — Advantages & Disadvantages
Advantages
Large amount of information
Access to all thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
Some S data are true by definition (e.g., self-esteem)
Causal force
Simple, easy, and cost-effective
Disadvantages
Error
Bias
Too simple and easy?
Funder’s Second Law
There are no perfect indicators of personality
Advantages and disadvantages of all methods
To understand personality you need to collect multiple clues (Types of data)
Replicability vs. Generalizability
R:
Replicable: did the outcome occur by chance, or is it something that we will find over and over again?
Doing the same study to answer the same question
G:
Generalize: is the outcome specific to one particular group of people, or is it generalizable across groups?
Doing the same study to answer the same question in a different population or context
Non-Scientific Methods of Determining Personality
Astrology
Personality assessment based on birth date
Physiognomy
Personality assessment based on shape of body, particularly the face
Phrenology
Personality assessment based on morphology (shape) of skull
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)
Enneagram
Why are the Non-Scientific Methods Invalid?
Not developed scientifically
Not reliable
50% of people get a different score/type when they re-take the test a few weeks later
Not much evidence for predictive validity
Scores do not predict health, happiness, job performance, and other life outcomes
All dimensions are positive
Assumes personality falls into categories
You’re either an extrovert or introvert (tho most ppl fall in the middle_
Use of types is problematic
Why are Non-Scientific Methods Invalid: Barnum Effect
Summaries of “types” often have generalized statements or events that people naturally assign to themselves and give specific meaning
What are the commonly used Measures today
Big Five personality traits
NEO-personality Inventory (NEO-PI)
Big Five Inventory (BFI)
Life Narratives
McAdams Life Story Interview
Individual Measures for Specific Constructs
Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale
Dispositional Optimism Scale
Self-Control Scale
Self-Report Items — Transparent & Non-Transparent
Transparent: statements are obvious in what they intend to measure
Features of Scientific Personality Assessments
Captures thoughts, feelings AND behaviors
Assessed on a continuum – NOT categories or types
Assesses both positive and negative dimensions of personality
Aims to know what you are like in general
Reliable
Valid
Reliability
are you hitting the same spot each time? (target)
If we are truly measuring “personality” your results should not change from week to week
|
Validity
are you actually hitting the bullseye?
Do the scores actually measure what they are supposed to measure
Face
Predictive
Structural
Convergent
Discriminant
Low validity: Bumps on head as a measure of self-control
High validity: Marshmallow task as a measure of self-control
Personality Judgment
Everyone does it ALL the time
These judgments can have important consequences
Opportunities
Employment
Relationships
Expectancies/self-fulfilling prophecies
(Personality Judgment) Accuracy
What criteria can be used to assess accuracy of personality judgments?
Depends on who you ask
Answer from constructivism: none; personality is a social construction
Answer from critical realism: all information that might be helpful
Accuracy doesn’t exist
What are possible criteria for determining accuracy
Convergent validity: two measures that should be related are observed to be related
The “duck test”
Interjudge agreement
Behavioral prediction and predictive validity
First Impressions
Mostly automatic
We use visible (non-verbal) information such as:
Face
Clothes
Belongings
Eye contact
We use verbal cues such as:
Gestures
Storytelling
Musical preferences
How loud you talk
Affect expression
How much information do you need?
More information is usually better, especially for some traits
The longer you know someone, the more accurate you are
BUT even 5 min interacting with a stranger is almost just as “accurate” for predicting behavior as a well-informed judge
The information needs to be of good quality
E.g., weak versus strong situations
What makes a Good Judge
Good judges tend to be socially skilled, open minded, well-adjusted, and attributionally complex
Being a good judge is beneficial
People vary in the extent to which they can be accurately judged (aka judgability)
What makes a Good Target?
Good targets tend to be well-adjusted, behaviorally consistent, extraverted, agreeable and healthy
Which aspects of Personality are Easy to Judge?
Easy to observe, highly visible
Theoretical Approaches: Trait Approach
Traits are building blocks of personality: Individuals differ in their typical patterns of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, and these patterns are called traits (e.g., talkative, organized, creative)
Comparative
Traits characterize differences among people
Influence behavior
Personality traits help us understand how a person might behave
Predict important life outcomes
Consistent across situations
People who are friendly at school also tend to be friendly at home, at work, in social settings, etc.
Does NOT mean you are the same in every situation!
Stable over time from infancy to old age
James: “Set like Plaster by age of 30” (personality is inborn and we’re stuck with it), not true
Does NOT mean you are the same over time
Partially biologically based
Taxonomies
basic categories in which human personality traits are classified
Approaches to Creating Trait Taxonomies
Theoretical approaches to reducing the many to a few
Factor analytic (statistical) approaches to reducing the many to a few
Lexical approach
We use words to describe ourselves and others
If some aspect of personality is important, then people everywhere will have words for it (cross-cultural universality)
Helpful: brings order to research findings by making a “common lang”
Big Five Trait Dimensions
Openness to Experience: curious; original; intellectual; creative
Conscientiousness: organized; systematic; punctual; dependable
Extraversion: outgoing; talkative; sociable; assertive
Agreeableness: warm; kind; cooperative; sensitive
Neuroticism: anxious; irritable; moody; tense
What is implied by the Big Five Dimensions?
Note: there is more to personality than traits
Conceptually, the traits are unrelated to one another
Structure of TRAITS not people
NOT theoretically-derived
Unclear cross-cultural generalizability
Person-Situation Debate
Situationism: emphasis on the power of the situation to shape people’s behavior
Personality is not real
Personality only exists in the minds of perceivers (no real stability)
Interactionism
Situations shape how personality traits are developed and expressed
People’s personality traits shape what the environment becomes
Temperament
Temperament serves as the early roots of personality
Temperament in childhood predicts personality in adulthood
Captures individual differences in thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
3 Primary Dimensions:
Negative Emotionality
Fear, frustration, depression, aggression
Positive Emotionality
Affiliation, positive affect, high intensity pleasure, perceptual sensitivity
Effortful Control
Inhibitory control, activation control, attention control
Stability and Change
separable processes
NOT mutually exclusive
How are Stability and Change not Mutually Exclusive: Rank-Order Stability & Cumulative Continuity Principle
Rank-order stability = the degree to which the relative ordering of individuals on a given trait is consistent over time
R = .6 or .9 for 10 year span
Cumulative continuity principle = Rank-order stability increases with age
Why?
Personality Development: Mean-Level Change
stability & change
the average degree and direction of change on a given trait with age
Causes of personality trait development
Nature – genes and biological maturation
Nurture – life experiences and the environment
remember there are significant indivivdual differences in change
Social Investment THeory
Commonly-studied explanation for personality trait development across adulthood
Social roles and developmental tasks serve as catalysts for personality development
Maturity Principle
on average, people become better equipped to deal with the demands of life as they acquire experience and skills
On average, people’s personalities “get better’ as they get older
Mischel’s Personality Assessment
behavior is too inconsistent to predict using broad personality traits
Biological Approach
Reflect physiological differences
Are strongly influenced by genetics
Are rooted in our evolutionary history
Evolution → Genetic Make-up → Physiological differences (cortisol lvls etc.) → Personality
Behavioral Genetics
Addresses how personality traits that differ among individuals are passed from parent to child and shared by biological relatives
Examines how genes influence broad patterns of behavior
Complicated history due to associations with eugenics and cloning
Each person inherits one set of chromosomes from the mother and one set from the father
99% of the genes within the human genome are similar across individuals
ONLY1% makes us unique
3 Parts of Behavioral Genetics Research
Genes = your DNA
Shared environment = the family environment you share with your parents and sibling(s)
Non-shared environment = everything else; your unique experiences
Heritability
The amount of variability in personality (phenotype) due to genetic differences (genotype)
To determine heritability, we can compare personality similarity between:
People who are and are not related
E.g., biological vs. adoptive children
People who are related to different degrees
E.g., monozygotic (MZ) vs. dizygotic (DZ) twins
Key assumption - traits that are influenced by genes should be more similar among more closely related people
What Heritability DOES NOT do
Indicate extent of nature vs. Nurture
Traist with little variation will have heritabilities close to zero
Heritability coefficients cannot be sued to determine what percent of a trait is determined by genetics and by the environment
Tell us how genes affect personality
Rather, how genes create propensities to behave in certain ways
Describe genetic contributions to a single individual
Heritability refers to the average genetic contribution to individual differences
Indicate whether the effects are generalizable across historical time or populations
Heritability always refers to a particular population at a particular time
If genetic or environmental conditions change, heritability will not remain the same (e.g., the heritability of height was lower 100 years ago)
Imply genetic determinism
Behavioral Genetics Key Findings
Genes matter
All behavioral traits are at least partially heritable
Extreme situationist view is wrong – why?
Environment also matters
Heritability =/= 1.00
Biology is not destiny (phenotype =/= genotype)
3. The shared family environment matters much less than genetics
4. Almost half of the variability in personality is not due to genes OR being raised in the same family
Your personality is influenced by unique experiences not shared with other family members (differential treatment by parents, major illness, best friends, school teachers, etc.)
5. Genetic dispositions are correlated with (and influence) the environment
E.g., twins reared apart select and create similar environments
E.g., number of friends is heritable
The environment affects biology and genetic expression (aka epigenetics)
E.g., genes are light switches that can be turned on and off
Genes account for BOTH personality stability and change
Historically, was thought that genes → stability and environment → change
Current research suggests that is not the case; genes are equally responsible for personality change as the environment
MythBusting: Candidate genes and personality
genetics of behavioral phenotypes is more complicated than 1 gene
There is no such thing as an “extraversion” or “depression” gene
Traits are polygenic
I.e. GWA studies show thousands of common genetic variants have tiny effects
Environment also shapes gene expression (epigenetics)
Mythbusters: Birth Order & Personality
Effects of birth order on personality have been of continued interest for 100+ years
E.g., first-borns are more independent and rule-following than later borns
Large, high powered studies show that birth order has little-to-no substantive relation to personality