1/40
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Ways a Defendant Can Respond
(1) Default (Rule 55)
(2) Pre-Answer Motion (Rule 12)
(3) Answer (Rule 8 & Rule 12)
Default
Rule 55
Defendant fails to plead or otherwise defend
Pre-Answer Motion
Rule 12
Defendant challenges a procedural or legal defect before answering
Answer
Rule 8 & Rule 12
Defendant responds to allegations, asserts affirmative defenses, and potentially asserts counterclaims
Answer Deadline
21 days after service of the summons and complaint
Rule 12(b) Defenses
(1) Lack of SMJ
(2) Lack of IPJ
(3) Improper Venue
(4) Insufficient Process
(5) Insufficient Service of Process
(6) Failure to State a Claim
(7) Failure to Join Required Party
Lack of SMJ
Rule 12(b)(1)
Court lacks authority over this case
Lack of IPJ
Rule 12(b)(2)
Court lacks authority over the defendant
Improper Venue
Rule 12(b)(3)
Case filed in the wrong judicial district
Insufficient Process
Rule 12(b)(4)
Defect in the summons itself
Insufficient Service of Process
Rule 12(b)(5)
Summons and complaint were not served properly
Failure to State a Claim
Rule 12(b)(6)
Complaint does not allege a legally sufficient claim
Failure to Join Required Party
Rule 12(b)(7)
A required party was not included
Ways Complaint is Insufficient
(1) Legal Insufficiency
(2) Factual Insufficiency
(3) Implausibility
Waivable Rule 12 Defenses
(1) Lack of PJ
(2) Improper Venue
(3) Insufficient Process
(4) Insufficient Service of Process
Responses to Complaint
(1) Admit
(2) Deny
(3) Lack of Knowledge
General Denial
Defendant intends in good faith to deny all allegations
Specific Denial
Defendant identifies the particular allegations being disputed
Partial Admission
Defendant admits part of an allegation and denies the remainder
Rule 8(b)(6)
If a responsive pleading is required, an allegation is admitted if it is not denied (does not concern the amount of damages)
Affirmative Defenses
Rule 8(c)
Even if everything the plaintiff alleges is true, the plaintiff still cannot recover all or part of the requested relief
Examples of Affirmative Defenses
(1) Statute of Limitations
(2) Contributory Negligence/Comparative Fault
(3) Statute of Frauds
Statute of Limitations
Plaintiff filed after the applicable limitations period expired
Contributory Negligence/Comparative Fault
Plaintiff’s own negligence may affect recovery
Statute of Frauds
An agreement required to satisfy a writing reqirement was not properly documented
Limitations - Written Contract
5 years
Limitation - Oral Contract
4 years
Limitations - Negligence
2 years
Counterclaims
Rule 13
Defendant asserts against the plaintiff
(1) Compulsory or (2) Permissive
Compulsory Counterclaim
Rule 13(a)
Arises out of the same conduct, transaction, or occurrence as the plaintiff’s claim
CTO Tests
(1) Logical Relationship
(2) Overlapping Evidence
Logical Relationship Test
Does the plaintiff’s claim and the defendant’s counterclaim arise from the same sequence of events?
Overlapping Evidence Test
Is at least some evidence relevant to proving or disproving the plaintiff’s claim also relevant to proving or disproving the defendant’s counterclaim?
Permissive Counterclaim
Rule 13(b)
Does not arise out of the same conduct, transaction, or occurrence as the plaintiff’s claim
Entry of Default
Rule 55(a)
When the defendant fails to plead or otherwise defend - clerk enters default on the court’s docket sheet
Default Judgment
Rule 55(b)
Rules in favor of the plaintiff without opposition by the defendant
Default Judgment by Clerk
Rule 55(b)(1)
(1) Sum certain
(2) Supporting affidavit
(3) Defendant has not appeared
(4) Defendant is not a minor or incompetent person
Default Judgment by Judge
Rule 55(b)(2)
When cannot be entered by the clerk
Limits on Default Judgment
Cannot (1) exceed the amount demanded and (2) differ from the kind of relief demanded
Setting Aside Default
Rule 55(c)
Cancels or vacates a preliminary notation of default against a party who failed to timely respond or defend a lawsuit
Setting Aside Default Considerations
For good cause if there is (1) prejudice to plaintiff (2) defendant has a meritorious defense and (3) absence of culpable conduct by defendant