1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Definition
Some right, interest, profit or benefit occurring to one party or some forbearance detriment loss or responsibility given, suffered or undertaken by the other one - Currie v Misa
Rule 1
Consideration must move from the promisee (the person can only enforce a promise made to them if they gave something in exchange for that promise)
Tweddle v Atkinson
Facts: A father and father-in-law promised to pay money to a couple when they married. The father-in-law died without paying, so the husband tried to enforce the promise.
Judgment: The husband could not claim the money because he was not a party to the contract and had provided no consideration.
Principle: Established the doctrine of privity of contract – only parties to a contract can enforce it.
Rule 2
Consideration must be sufficient but does not need to be adequate
Thomas v Thomas
Facts: A husband expressed a wish for his wife to live in his house after his death. His executors agreed to let her stay in return for paying £1 rent per year and maintaining the property.
Judgment: The agreement was enforceable because the wife provided valid consideration through the rent and maintenance.
Principle: Consideration must be sufficient but does not have to be adequate (it must have some legal value, but does not need to be equal in value).
White v Bluett
Facts: A son owed his father money. The father promised to forgive the debt if the son stopped complaining about how the father's property would be distributed.
Judgment: The son had provided no valid consideration because simply agreeing to stop complaining was not legally valuable.
Principle: Consideration must have some legal value; giving up something you have no legal right to do is not sufficient.
Emotional promises are not sufficient
Ward v Bytham
Facts: A father promised to pay his former wife maintenance for their child. The mother was already legally responsible for looking after the child.
Judgment: The mother's care of the child was not valid consideration because she was already under a legal duty to provide it.
Principle: Performing an existing legal duty is generally not valid consideration.
Emotional promises are not sufficient
Re Mcardie
Facts: A woman carried out improvements and repairs to her mother-in-law's house. Afterwards, the other family members promised to pay her for the work.
Judgment: The promise was unenforceable because the work had already been completed before the promise was made.
Principle: Past consideration is not valid consideration. Consideration must be given in exchange for the promise, not before it.
Lampleigh v Braithwait
Facts: Braithwait asked Lampleigh to travel to obtain a royal pardon for him. Lampleigh successfully did this, and Braithwait later promised to pay him £100.
Judgment: The promise was enforceable because the work was carried out at Braithwait's request, with payment understood to be expected.
Principle: Past consideration can be valid where the act was requested and payment was implicitly expected.
Exception: there may still be sufficient consideration if there was an implied promise to pay at the time the other party carried out their part.
Stilk v Myrick
Facts: A captain promised his sailors extra wages if they completed a voyage after some crew members abandoned the ship. The remaining sailors completed the journey but were not paid extra.
Judgment: The sailors could not claim the extra wages because they were already contractually obliged to complete the voyage.
Principle: Performing an existing contractual duty is not valid consideration for a new promise.
Performing an existing duty (under a previous contract) is also not sufficient consideration in a new contract.
Hartley v Ponsonby
Facts: Similar once enforceable to share money as the reduction made the voyage more dangerous
Decision: Extend element amounting to consideration
However, performing an existing duty will be sufficient consideration if something extra is done in return for the new payment
Williams v Rofey
Facts: A building contractor promised a carpenter extra money to complete work on time because he was worried about financial penalties for late completion.
Judgment: The carpenter was entitled to the extra payment because the contractor gained a practical benefit from the promise, including avoiding delays and penalties.
Principle: Performing an existing contractual duty can amount to valid consideration if the other party gains a practical benefit and there is no economic duress or fraud.