Consideration - Contract formation

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/11

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

12 Terms

1
New cards

Definition

Some right, interest, profit or benefit occurring to one party or some forbearance detriment loss or responsibility given, suffered or undertaken by the other one - Currie v Misa

2
New cards

Rule 1

Consideration must move from the promisee (the person can only enforce a promise made to them if they gave something in exchange for that promise)

3
New cards

Tweddle v Atkinson

  • Facts: A father and father-in-law promised to pay money to a couple when they married. The father-in-law died without paying, so the husband tried to enforce the promise.

  • Judgment: The husband could not claim the money because he was not a party to the contract and had provided no consideration.

  • Principle: Established the doctrine of privity of contract – only parties to a contract can enforce it.


4
New cards

Rule 2

Consideration must be sufficient but does not need to be adequate

5
New cards

Thomas v Thomas

  • Facts: A husband expressed a wish for his wife to live in his house after his death. His executors agreed to let her stay in return for paying £1 rent per year and maintaining the property.

  • Judgment: The agreement was enforceable because the wife provided valid consideration through the rent and maintenance.

  • Principle: Consideration must be sufficient but does not have to be adequate (it must have some legal value, but does not need to be equal in value).


6
New cards

White v Bluett

  • Facts: A son owed his father money. The father promised to forgive the debt if the son stopped complaining about how the father's property would be distributed.

  • Judgment: The son had provided no valid consideration because simply agreeing to stop complaining was not legally valuable.

  • Principle: Consideration must have some legal value; giving up something you have no legal right to do is not sufficient.

Emotional promises are not sufficient

7
New cards

Ward v Bytham

  • Facts: A father promised to pay his former wife maintenance for their child. The mother was already legally responsible for looking after the child.

  • Judgment: The mother's care of the child was not valid consideration because she was already under a legal duty to provide it.

  • Principle: Performing an existing legal duty is generally not valid consideration.

Emotional promises are not sufficient

8
New cards

Re Mcardie

  • Facts: A woman carried out improvements and repairs to her mother-in-law's house. Afterwards, the other family members promised to pay her for the work.

  • Judgment: The promise was unenforceable because the work had already been completed before the promise was made.

  • Principle: Past consideration is not valid consideration. Consideration must be given in exchange for the promise, not before it.


9
New cards

Lampleigh v Braithwait

  • Facts: Braithwait asked Lampleigh to travel to obtain a royal pardon for him. Lampleigh successfully did this, and Braithwait later promised to pay him £100.

  • Judgment: The promise was enforceable because the work was carried out at Braithwait's request, with payment understood to be expected.

  • Principle: Past consideration can be valid where the act was requested and payment was implicitly expected.

Exception: there may still be sufficient consideration if there was an implied promise to pay at the time the other party carried out their part.

10
New cards

Stilk v Myrick

  • Facts: A captain promised his sailors extra wages if they completed a voyage after some crew members abandoned the ship. The remaining sailors completed the journey but were not paid extra.

  • Judgment: The sailors could not claim the extra wages because they were already contractually obliged to complete the voyage.

  • Principle: Performing an existing contractual duty is not valid consideration for a new promise.

Performing an existing duty (under a previous contract) is also not sufficient consideration in a new contract.

11
New cards

Hartley v Ponsonby

  • Facts: Similar once enforceable to share money as the reduction made the voyage more dangerous

  • Decision: Extend element amounting to consideration

However, performing an existing duty will be sufficient consideration if something extra is done in return for the new payment


12
New cards

Williams v Rofey

  • Facts: A building contractor promised a carpenter extra money to complete work on time because he was worried about financial penalties for late completion.

  • Judgment: The carpenter was entitled to the extra payment because the contractor gained a practical benefit from the promise, including avoiding delays and penalties.

  • Principle: Performing an existing contractual duty can amount to valid consideration if the other party gains a practical benefit and there is no economic duress or fraud.