1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Stedman: Reading Question
Why do some spoilers succeed in destroying peaces processes and others fail?
Stedman: Argument
Matching the right strategy to the right spoiler is the central task
Stedman: What is a spoiler? (3)
Leaders/parties who believe peace from negotiations threatens their power, worldview, interests
Use violence to undermine attempts to achieve peace
They do this after parties have committed to a peace process
Stedman: Why do peace processes create spoilers (3)
Negotiated peace almost always creates losers
Not every conflict yields a compromise that satisfies all parties
Peace processes themselves transform combatants into supporters opponents
Stedman: What are the dimensions of a spoiler (4)
Position: Inside or outside the agreement; shapes whether spoilers use stealth of overt force
Number: One or many spoilers; multiple spoilers create compound strategic problems
Type: Limited, greedy, or total; shapes whether accomodation is possible
Locus: leaders or followers
Stedman: What does an inside spoiler do
Sign agreements but fail to implement key obligations
Stedman: What does an outside spoiler do?
Reject the process directly and attack it using overt violence
Stedman: Types of Spoilers Limited (3)
Limited goals that will share the power of followers
These goals can be non-negotiable
These goals can be accomodated through a peace settlement if demands are met
Stedman: Type of Spoilers Greedy
Goals that shift and expand based off the calculation of cost and risk
Limited goals expand under low costs, and total goals contract under high costs
Can be brought if the costs are the right amount
Stedman: Types of spoilers Total
Pursue total power and exclusive recognition of authority
All-or-nothing worldview and goals are not subject to change
Cannot be accommodated within settlement, any agreement they make it tactical and not genuine
Stedman: Locus leader-driven
Replacing the leader can shift type
Stedman: Locus follower driven
Leaders may be constrained by their base
Stedman: Why does Locus matter
Locus shapes whether the type can change, and whether there is a need to wait for leadership transitions
Stedman: What are custodians of peace
International actors who oversee implementation of peace agreements
What are the three strategies of custodians of peace?:
Inducement
Socialization
Coercion
Stedman: Strategy 1 Inducement + Risk
Address the spoilers demands directly
Risk: May reward bad behavior and perpetuate spoilers appetite
Stedman: Strategy 2 Socialization (3)
Establish norms for acceptable behavior; judge spoiler conduct against them
Combine material rewards and punishments with sustained persuasions
Long-term strategy aimed at bringing spoiler behavior in line with established norms
Stedman: Strategy 3 Coercion (3)
Coercive diplomacy: Threats and demands directed at the spoiler
Force: deafeating or weakening the spoiler militarily
Stedman: Managing limited spoilers
These can be brought into peace processes only if the demands fit the bargaining range
Stedman: Managing Greedy Spoilers