Intro to Philosophy Exam 4 study guide

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/3

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

4 Terms

1
New cards

Explain Kant’s ethical view

·     Kant was a deontologist; that is, he believed that the goodness or badness of an act is in the act itself. He believed ethical statements are categorical, not hypothetical. A hypothetical statement starts with the word if. If you want a good job, then you need a good education. There is no moral imperative here. An ethical statement does not begin with if. It is categorical, that is, universal. Tell the truth. Keep your promises. Protect innocent life. These are examples of moral imperatives.

·     Kant developed two forms of the categorical imperative. The way it works is that you take some statement, run it through these two forms of the categorical imperative, and if it passes, then a person is duty bound to perform it. Here are the two versions of the categorical imperative:

1. Act only on those maxims that you could, at the same time, desire to be universal maxims.

2. Treat people as ends in themselves, not just as means to an end.

·     One objections to Kant is that since ethical statements are categorical a person cannot tell which action to perform if two ethical statements are in conflict. For instance, imagine a woman comes banging on your door and says, “Please help me. An axe murderer is after me!” So, the ethical thing to do is to protect innocent life, so you hide her. In a few minutes, there is another knock on your door, and it is the axe murderer. He asks if you have seen a woman come by here. It is an ethical imperative that you tell the truth. But in doing so, you are putting in jeopardy the life of the woman. Kant says you are duty bound to try to protect the lady; you may even have to kill the guy to do so, but you cannot lie to him. This happens because Kant does not allow us to see one ethical value as higher than another. They are all categorical. They are all the same value.

2
New cards

Discuss Utilitarianism

·     An act is good that produces the greatest pleasure for the greatest number of people. Jeremy Bentham developed the hedonic calculus which was a way of testing which act would produce the greatest units of pleasure (hedons) for the greatest number of people. John Stewart Mill believed that the pleasures to be considered should only be the higher pleasures, such as education, art, and social interactions.

·     Utilitarianism can be divided into act utilitarianism, and rule utilitarianism. Act utilitarianism says that each individual act should be evaluated based on what one believes will produce the greatest amount of pleasure for the greatest number of people. This is the view of Jeremy Bentham. A problem with this view is that people have a tendency to act in their own self interest when considering something in the moment. Furthermore, it is difficult to predict the future consequences of each individual act.

·     Rule utilitarianism, developed by John Stewart Mill, is the view that general rules should be followed which tend to produce the greatest amount of pleasure for the greatest number of people. Once those rules are established then people have a duty to follow them. An act utilitarian might object by saying that this is a lot like a deontological ethic

·     One objection to utilitarianism in general is the transplant objection. Suppose one person goes to a doctor and finds that he is completely healthy. Three other people go to the same doctor. One finds that she needs a heart transplant. The second finds that he needs a liver transplant. The third finds that she needs a lung transplant. Using the utilitarian principle the right thing to do would be to kill the healthy person and divide his organs among the other three. But that is counterintuitive to almost everyone’s beliefs.

·     A second objection is the justice objection. Imagine a crime being committed that caused a riot in a town. The riot would stop only when someone was arrested for the crime. The sheriff arrests someone that the sheriffs knows for certain did NOT do the crime, but arrests them to stop the riots. This is consistent with utilitarianism, but is unjust.

3
New cards

Discuss the egoistic ethics of Thomas Hobbes

·     Thomas Hobbes believed that everyone acts in their own self interest. Morality flows out of self interest. Consider a person who lives alone on the frontier. This person is in a state of nature where she can do anything she wants to do. Now imagine another bigger, stronger person moves next to her. In the state of nature he can do anything he wants to do, which includes taking all of the first persons belongings. In the state of nature the strongest gets what he or she wants.

·     Now imagine a third person moving to the frontier. The first person meets with the third person and tells him about the bully next door. They decide to form a pact. They go over and tell the bully that if he takes any of their stuff then they will beat him up. It is now in the bully’s self interest not to take their stuff. This is called a social contract. This happens when people in a society agree to put limits on their desires for a greater benefit.

·     Now imagine that the bully decides to test and see if the other two would follow through with their threat. The bully goes over and takes something from one of them. They protest, but do nothing else. In such a case Hobbes says the society will go back to a state of nature because there is no one to enforce the social contract.

·     Hobbes believed there has to be an enforcer, what he called a Leviathan, to make sure the social contract stays in place. Without the Leviathan, the state of nature will take over. The Leviathan must physically force compliance with the social contract if necessary.

·     One objection to Hobbes is that his system doesn’t leave room for heroes. For example, the Constitution of the United States is a type of social contract. Yet, it had slavery as part of the contract. For those who ran the underground railroad, and other antislavery campaigns, such actions would have been seen by Hobbes as needing to be put down by the Leviathan. Some people believe there is a higher standard to which any social contract needs to conform.

4
New cards

Discuss the virtue based ethic of Aristotle

·     Aristotle believed that in order to figure out what moral goodness was we need to be clear about what we mean in general about the word good. When we say “this is a good pen”, what do we mean? We meant that it writes clearly and smoothly. In other words, it fulfills the purpose for which it was designed. So, for our lives to be good we have to know what our purpose or goal is. Aristotle believed that the goal of human beings is to be happy. Since happiness is the goal, then the “good life” is a life that meets that goal to the fullest extent possible.

·     Aristotle divided the human psych into three parts: 1. Calculative – which is the intellectual part; 2. Appetitive – which has to do with our desires; 3. Vegetative – which has to do with our health. Aristotle believed that it was the appetitive aspect of our psyche that involves ethics. A person lives a morally virtuous life when the appetites are regulated in the proper way. The proper way is the way that leads to happiness. Thus, a virtuous life is connected to a happy life.

·     There are three important things Aristotle believed about moral virtues:

o  1. Virtues are learned. They are not natural. In fact, the virtues go against our natural disposition. Take the virtue of courage as an example. It is natural for people to be afraid. In order to be courageous one must go against one’s natural desires and learn how to act courageously in spite of one’s own fears.

o  2. Virtues are a mean between two extremes. For example, cowardliness is a deficit of moral virtue. However, if a person does something foolhardy, like being the only person charging, like being the only person charging up a hill to attack a thousand armed gunmen, then this is not a virtuous act. So courage is the mean between two extremes. Courage is between cowardliness and foolhardiness. This is called the golden mean.

o  3. Virtue is neither intellectual or emotional. Virtue is part of our character that regulates our emotions and desires (appetites).