1/26
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why might think tanks have little impact on government decisions?
They lack formal decision
What examples demonstrate governments abandoning think tank proposals?
The IEA's mini
How does competing research limit think tank influence?
Contradictory research allows governments to ignore inconvenient recommendations or justify inaction using alternative evidence.
What example demonstrates the limitations of competing research?
Chatham House provides foreign
Why can think tanks have significant influence on government decisions?
They produce detailed policy proposals that parties can directly incorporate into manifestos and legislation.
What examples demonstrate direct policy influence?
Policy Exchange influenced anti
How does executive alignment increase think tank influence?
Ideologically aligned think tanks provide ministers with ready
What examples demonstrate executive alignment?
IPPR influenced the National Living Wage; the Adam Smith Institute and Centre for Policy Studies influenced Thatcherite deregulation.
What is the overall judgement for Theme 1?
Think tanks significantly influence government decisions by supplying the intellectual frameworks that become legislation, despite lacking final decision
Why might professional lobbyists have little impact?
Media exposure and public scandals can force governments to reject lobbying demands and introduce stricter regulation.
What examples demonstrate unsuccessful lobbying?
Owen Paterson's paid advocacy caused a political scandal; David Cameron's lobbying for Greensill failed to secure emergency government loans.
Why might governments reject commercial lobbying demands?
Governments prioritise electoral support and may refuse demands that risk provoking widespread public opposition.
What example demonstrates government resistance to commercial lobbying?
Public anger over sewage pollution contributed to the Water (Special Measures) Act despite opposition from water industry interests.
Why can professional lobbyists have significant influence?
Large budgets and targeted access allow commercial interests to shape legislation before proposals reach public debate.
What examples demonstrate financially powerful lobbying?
UK lobbying firms deploy billions annually, representing gambling, vaping and defence interests during regulatory discussions.
How does the revolving door increase lobbying influence?
Former politicians and civil servants use existing relationships to gain privileged access and influence legislative drafting.
What examples demonstrate revolving
door influence?
What is the overall judgement for Theme 2?
Professional lobbyists significantly influence government decisions because most lobbying occurs privately during early legislative drafting, beyond public scrutiny.
Why might pressure groups have little impact on government decisions?
Governments with strong parliamentary majorities can ignore protests and campaigns that conflict with their political ideology.
What examples demonstrate executive resistance to pressure groups?
Conservative governments resisted Just Stop Oil and Extinction Rebellion, introducing the Public Order Act 2023; pro
Why can outsider campaigns be ineffective?
Without insider access or majority support, petitions and disruptive campaigns can be ignored or provoke government suppression.
What examples demonstrate ineffective outsider campaigns?
The 6.1 million
How can industrial leverage increase pressure group impact?
Groups representing essential workers can disrupt public services and force governments into financial or policy concessions.
What examples demonstrate successful industrial action?
BMA resident doctors used strike action to secure pay concessions; ASLEF train drivers achieved a 15% pay settlement.
How can legal challenges increase pressure group impact?
Judicial review allows groups to challenge unlawful government actions, while parliamentary campaigns can force policy reversals.
What examples demonstrate successful legal and political campaigns?
Liberty challenged anti
What is the overall judgement for Theme 3?
Pressure groups have significant impact because industrial leverage, legal challenges and targeted lobbying can force governments to change decisions.