1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Aristotle calls specific justice that is different from all of the other specific virtues:
particular justice
Aristotle says that justice is a mean between
acting unjustly and being treated unjustly
Aristotle in chapter 6 distinguishes
acting unjustly and being unjust
Aristotle’s answer to the question “is the distributor of excessive shares unjust or the person who possesses the excessive share unjust?“ is…
Often the first (distributor of excessive shares) is unjust, but not always the second (the person who possesses the excessive share) is unjust
Aristotle’s answer to the question: “can one treat oneself unjustly“ is:
no
What is virtue, how is it obtained?
Virtue makes people good, and their work/activity good.
Good moral habit makes a person good AND therefore their work good
Activities vs. Capability/Capacities
if you can DO things (activities), then there is a faculty/capability to them
Activities and capabilities are connected by habits: you can build a better capability of something through habits, and then your activity will be good
What are habits?
Intellectual skills; good moral habit makes a person good (capacity to do good) AND their work (activity)good
What are the 4 Cardinal Virtues
Temperance: self-control (deals with the pleasant)
Courage (deals with the threatening/unpleasant)
Justice
Prudence: about thinking rightly about here and now
How does the bar of the virtue of temperance work?
Our virtue of temperance should lie directly between abstemious (no extremes) and indulgent (all extremes). Most people typically go towards indulgence; virtue should actually lie more towards abstemious. Since we typically are towards indulgence, we should aim over the mark of temperance, so that we will make it to where our virtue is supposed to be.
How does the bar of the virtue of courage work?
Our virtue of courage should lie directly between cowardice and recklessness. Since we typically lie close to cowardice, we should aim over our mark of leaning towards recklessness to actually get there.
What are the 2 types of justice?
General Justice: what’s owed to people because they’re people, which tie back to the moral absolutes — justice with the law
Particular justice:
What are the 2 types of particular justice?
Distributive Justice and Communitive Justice
Distributive Justice
Distributive Justice: dividing social goods— honors, wealth, political power, or resources—among members of a community
uses geometric proportion: treating equals equally and unequals unequally, based on relevant criteria
Communitive Justice
Justice in exchanges (includes contracts and promises), focuses on restoring balance or equality when it has been disturbed in transactions or interactions
uses arithmetic proportion: treats parties as strictly equal, aims to correct a wrongful gain or loss
How does the bar of the virtue of justice work? (Communitative mean)
The mean should be between acting unjustly (victimizing) and being treated unjustly (victim). Most of us tend towards acting unjustly, so we should be more willing to be treated unjustly
Justice in Distributive Matters — The 15 Distributive Principles
1st come, 1st serve
By reservation
By equality
Randomness
Need
Urgency
Merit
Achievement
Capacity/Ability/Potential
Preference
Effort
Motivational
Proportionality
Graduated Proportionality
For Parity