1/13
aim
to investigate the brain dysfunction in violent offenders pleading NGRI
sample
41 murderers pleading NGRI and 41 non-murderers
research method
quasi experiment
IV: murderer / non-murderer
DV: activity in specified brain regions
procedure
injected with a glucose tracer before performing a CPT to activate their prefrontal cortex
PET scans were used to show the patterns of brain activity
results
murderers had reduced activity in the prefrontal cortex, left angular gyrus, and corpus callosum
applications
nutritional interventions:
poor nutrition may affect mood regulation, concentration, and impulse control
gesch et al suggests supplements may reduce disciplinary incidents
low risk and benefits health
drug treatment:
SSRI increases serotonin availability
high serotonin may reduce aggressive outbursts
does not teach skills, empathy, or problem solving
nature vs nurture
both sides
nature:
criminality is due to a hereditary predisposition of brain dysfunction in certain areas of the brain such as the prefrontal cortex, amygdala, and hippocampus
nurture:
raine et al. don't state that violence is down to biology alone, PET scans can’t be used to 'diagnose' potential murderers
criminality, and criminal behaviour can be learnt from influences in the environment, such as role models in real life or in the media (social learning theory)
reductionism vs holism
both sides
reductionism:
focused on studying biological factors using PET scans (brain abnormalities in murderers; anatomy in terms of brain structure and function resulting in criminal behaviour)
holism:
raine et al. don't state that violence is down to biology alone, PET scans can’t be used to 'diagnose' potential murderers
usefulness of research
useful
statistical significance of results and high number of controls suggests results can be used to predict individuals who may be predisposed to commit murder and then plead NGRI - but also has practical applications to reduce criminal behaviour (biological interventions like drug therapy/medication)
results could be used in an immoral/unethical way - implications for those with mental health (subject to stigmatisation) and how they are viewed by society
ethical considerations
ethically questionable
+ participants signed consent forms approved by the Human Subjects Committee of the University of California - protected from harm
- didn't have the right to withdraw - NGRI participants may have been more vulnerable to persuasion
- withholding medication for 2 weeks could have had negative implication on their psychological wellbeing and caused psychological harm (especially if they had schizophrenia)
- breaking ethical guidelines harms the reputation of psychology as a science and potentially reduces the likelihood of future participants volunteering for psychological studies
socially sensitive research
investigated socially sensitive topic, with participants who were murderers who pleaded NGRI (links to mental health and stigmatization, particularly if results used or interpreted in an immoral/unethical way)
labels people with brain abnormalities as criminals (negative implications on individuals' lives)
however, concluded that PET scans is not enough to label someone a murderer
psychology as a science
+ quantifiable measurements/data collected + highly controlled and standardised
+ objectively measures brain activity and function using PET scans on NGRI murderers and non-murderers - scanning was non-intrusive by looking at brain function in 'real time' through the PET scans
+ high in reliability, therefore increased replicability
+ manipulated IV and measured DV - scientific methodology used
- possibly biased and subjective to an individuals' perspective as PET scans are only done by one person (even an expert doesn't possess the objectivity of a computer or the brain scanner itself)
validity and reliability
high in reliability
used standardised brain scanning techniques and a number of controls, such as all of the participants having a brain scan on the same PET machine, being medication-free 2 weeks prior to task, and completing the same standardised CPT for the same amount of time
high in validity
brain scans can't be affected by factors such as demand characteristics or differences in the procedure
high internal validity through matched pairs design (use of a control group to validate results)
sampling bias
- biased sample of 39 males and 2 females who were pleading NGRI in the American state of California, so can't generalise the results of brain abnormalities in violent offenders to other populations
- doesn't account for the different types of murderers, such as non-violent murderers.
- further research required to determine whether other violent offenders also have these brain abnormalities (low generalisability)
+ not many female murderers - matches gender bias of murderers