1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Schmitter and Karl: What democracy is and is not?
What Democracy is
- Core definition: Modern political democracy is a system of governance in which rulers are held accoutnable for their actions in the public realm by citizens
- No single set of democratic inistitutions and democracies widely vary
- Key Mechanisms: Relies on institutionalized procedures- such as regular elections, civil liberties, citizen association, and the competition of political groups- that allow citizens to expres and consent interests
What Democracy Is not
- Not just elections: Democracy cannot be reduced solely the regular holding of elections; elections alone do not make a regime democratic if citizens lack broader ongoing accountability and rights
- Not Economically Superior by Default
- Not a Gureantee of Social Peace or Harmony
- Not more efficient administratively
Bellin: Contingent Democracies
- Conditional support: Bussiness owners (capital) and workers (labor) back democratization only when it aligns with their interests or does not threaten their status
- Authoritarian alignment: When state-led development creates privileges or protection, both groups may ally with authoritarian regimes rather than push for democratic reform
- Contingent democrats become stronger supporters of democracy when conditions change
Key factors
- State dependence: Bussinesses and unions that rely on the state for subsidies, protection, or favorable rules are less likely to demand democratic accountability
- Social fear: Capitalists may fear that democracy empowers popular movements, redistributes wealth, or triggers instability and unrest
- Aristocratic privilige: Labor groups with protected, relatively privileged economic positions may resist democratization if they fear losing special status to broader, less privileged groups
Gandhi and Przeworki 2007
- Why institutions exist under dictatorship: Autocrats use nominally democratic institutions- such as partisan legislatures and parties- to gain outside cooperation, incorporate potential opposition, and deter rebellion
- How survival changes: Bringing opposition forces inside institutional channels gives them a stake in the regime and policy concessions, which can lengthen an autocrat's tenure
Bourgibia 1966 Tunisian Way
- Uses Tunisia's first decade of independence to review the nationalist movement and post independence nation-building
- Modernization and Social Reforms
- Pragmatic Foreign Policy- Positioned Tunisia as moderate, pro-Western, and pragmatic state balancing relations with France, the US, and the wider Arab world during the Cold War
How Autocracy Prevailed in Tunisia (Yerkes and Henneberg)
- Governance Paralysis after 2011: 2014 constitutional changes gridlocked decision making
- Unaddressed Economic Greivances: Post-2014 leaders failed to pass structural economic reforms to tackle high youth unemployment, inflation, and more
- Saied's Power Consolidation
- 2024 Election and Repression: Saied won majority of the vote
Skocpol: France, Russia, China A Structural Analysis of Social Revolutions
- Examines how social revolutions- rapid basic changes to a society's state and class structures driven by class-based upheavels from below- occured in France (1789), Russia (1917), and China (1911-1949)
Core Causes
- International Pressures and State Breakdown: Each old regime- Bourbon France, Imperial Russia, and Manchu China- was a modernizing agraian bureacuracy facing intense external military or economic competition
- Peasant Insurrections
- Role of Radical Elites: Politically marginal or educated elites stepped into the power vaccum which consolidated new revolutionary authority rather than manufacturing revolution
Revolutionary Outcomes
- Strong centralized states
- Abolition of Old Dominant Classes
Foran: Theory of Third World Outcomes
- Integrates political, economic, and cultural factors to explain why social revolutions emerge and succeed or fail
Core Elements
- Dependent development: Economic growth by foreign capital or global markets alters class and social structures, often creating inequality and strain
- Repressive, exclusionary regimes: Authoritarian or personalistic dictatorshps block political participation
- Political cultures of resistance
- Dual crisis: An economic downtown combines with a world-systemtic opening (such as shifting geopolitical pressure, war, or weakened foreign backing for the regime)
Linz: Perils of Presidentialism
Believes that parliamentarism is better than presidentialism because 1. issue of dual legitimancy, 2. rigidity of term limits, 3. style is less propitious for democracy than parliamentary 4. political outsiders more likely to win in presidential system, 5. adheres to a "winner-take-all" doctrine
Mainwaring and Shugart: Juan Linz, Presidentialism, and Democracy; A Critical Appraisal
- Argues against Linz
- Evaluates debate over presidental vs. parliamentary systems
- Argues that presidental systems are not uniform
- Executive-Legislative and Party Dynamics: Examine how factors like presidental legislative powers, electoral calendars, and multipartism affect governance and gridlock
Ropponen: Between Democracy and Authoritarianism The Illiberal Challenge
- Authoritarian actors undermine democracy while pretending to uphold its principles. Formal democratic features—such as multiple parties, serious-looking elections, and visible opposition—may still exist, and ruling parties can even lose elections
- Despite surface appearances, these systems are not truly democratic because those in power use state resources to weaken opponents and silence critics
- Regimes weaken democratic principles through strategies like controlling the media, manipulating electoral rules, and disenfranchising opposition voters.
- Ropponen examines debates around "illiberal democracy" and competitive authoritarianism, arguing for precise political labels so democratic terms are not misused
Gursoy and Baykan 2025 Frenemy of Populism
Populism can act like friend and foe to democracy
Friend: In authoritarian settings, populist movements and leaders can bring excluded or underprivileged classes into the political arena. Reflects electoral resilliance
Enemy: When populist actors govern in already fragile or unstable institutional contexts, they can weaken checks and balances, minority rights, and liberal norms
Ceka and Magalhaes: Do the rich and poor have different concepts of democracy?
Socioeconomic status shapes how people conceive of democracy, largely by aligning wealthier citizens with the existing political status quo and poorer citzens being unsatisfied with the status quo
Riedl: Neoliberalism and the third wave
The shift from early neoliberalism to "late-stage neoliberalism" now undermines global democracy. While early neoliberal reforms paired with third-wave democratization, extreme global wealth concentration and weakened state institutions now erode fair political competition and responsive governance
Levitsky and Way: The Path to American Authoritarianism
United States faces a shift toward competitive authoritarianism rather than a classic dictatorship