1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
4 main points of ethics
divine command theory (DCT)
cultural relativism
utilitarianism (act & rule)
kantian ethics
divine command theory (DCT)
the morally obligatory, permissible, or impermissible acts are the ones that god says are obligatory, permissible, or impermissible
1st issue with DCT
requires for god to exist
2nd issue with DCT
question of whether and how can we be sure about the content of god’s commands
3rd issue with DCT
do actions have their moral status because of the commands god issues? or is it the other way around?
horn 1 of DCT
god commands the actions he commands because they are morally good/obligatory
horn 2 of DCT
good actions are good because god commands them —> DCT favors this one (implies god is the source or morality)
cultural relativism
what makes an action obligatory, permissible, or impermissible in a particular culture is what that culture says about it
the only moral truth are local, there are no universal moral truths
what’s morally right here might be wrong at another place or time
different cultures have different moral codes so CR is true
goes straight from what people believe to what is true
car example
we should be tolerant and respectful or cultural difference so CR is true
tolerance has limits
what about a culture that endorses something we take to be horrible?
plus of CR
the moral facts have something to do with us people - something distinctively human
consequence 1 of CR
moral questions become sociological questions —> “source of evidence is wrong”
consequence 2 of CR
no culture can morally criticize another
consequence 3 of CR
cannot make sense of genuine progress —> has to do with time and place
consequentialism
the moral status of an action depends on its consequences
utilitarianism
an act is right if it maximizes good/utility and minimizes pain
act utilitarianism
the right action is the one that produces the greatest amount of happiness or well-being
rule utilitarianism
the principle of utility is applied to the adoption of general rules governing kinds of actions
kantian ethics
an act is right insofar as it is performed with the intention of following a principle that would be coherent for everyone to follow, and which treats others with dignity and respect
threads of kantian ethics
moral obligations are categorical - no ifs, ands, or buts
universalizability - what if everyone did that?
ends in themselves - don’t be a user
the good will: intentions over consequences
universalizability
act only “on the maxim”, in ways it would be okay for everyone to act that way
ends in themselves
treat people with the recognition that they are rational agents with their own goals & purposes, never use them only for your purposes
what kant says
what matters a lot: intention, rules
what doesn’t matter a lot: consequences
peter singer (utilitarian)
we are morally required to help prevent suffering. we have duties to distant people as well as those nearby. spending on trivialities while also not helping is morally wrong
believes people underestimate their moral obligations
singer’s claims
hardcore: if you can prevent something bad without sacrificing something of comparable moral significance, you are obligated to do so
weaker: if you can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything morally significant, you are morally obligated to do so
wolf - NOT utilitarian
does not believe she should structure her life around striving for the moral ideal
does not want to be/around moral saints
why not wolf?
believes we have many goals outside the room that aren’t moral goals
morality itself should not serve as a comprehensive guide to conduct
moral value is one kind of value among many
moral saint
someone as morally perfect as possible: every actions as morally good as it can be