1/21
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the 4 steps of the Feldman method of art criticism (DAIE)?
Describe, Analyze, Interpret, Evaluate (Judge)
In DAIE, what happens at the 'Describe' step?
Objectively list what is visually present — subject matter, colors, materials — without interpretation
In DAIE, what happens at the 'Analyze' step?
Examine how the elements of art and principles of design are used and how they relate to each other
In DAIE, what happens at the 'Interpret' step?
Propose the meaning, mood, or message of the work based on the description and analysis
In DAIE, what happens at the 'Evaluate/Judge' step?
Make a supported judgment about the work's success or significance, using a stated critical standard
What is Formalism as an aesthetic theory?
Judging art based on its formal qualities — line, color, composition, use of elements/principles — rather than its subject matter or context
What is Expressionism as an aesthetic theory (critical lens)?
Judging art based on how successfully it conveys the artist's emotion or inner experience to the viewer
What is Imitationalism (Representationalism) as an aesthetic theory?
Judging art based on how accurately/realistically it represents its subject
What is Instrumentalism as an aesthetic theory?
Judging art based on its usefulness in conveying a moral, social, religious, or political message or purpose
What is Contextualism (a fourth/combined critical lens)?
Judging art based on the historical, cultural, and social context in which it was created and viewed
What is 'significant form,' a concept from critic Clive Bell?
The idea that certain combinations of lines, colors, and shapes move viewers aesthetically, independent of subject matter or realism
What is Plato's view of art as 'imitation' (mimesis)?
Plato viewed art as a copy of a copy (an imitation of the physical world, which is itself an imperfect copy of ideal Forms), and was suspicious of art's ability to mislead
What is Aristotle's view of mimesis, compared to Plato's?
Aristotle viewed imitation more positively — as a natural, valuable human activity that can lead to insight, learning, and emotional catharsis
What is Kant's idea of 'disinterested pleasure' in aesthetics?
The idea that genuine aesthetic judgment involves appreciating something for its own sake, without regard to personal desire, use, or self-interest
What is the Institutional Theory of Art (Danto/Dickie)?
The idea that something becomes 'art' because it is recognized as such by the art world (artists, critics, institutions), not because of inherent formal qualities
What is the 'family resemblance' theory of art (Wittgenstein-influenced)?
The idea that there is no single defining trait shared by all art; instead, artworks share overlapping similarities the way family members resemble each other without one universal trait
What did Leo Tolstoy argue art's purpose was?
That art's purpose is to communicate and transmit feeling from the artist to the audience, creating shared emotional experience
What is the difference between subjectivism and objectivism in aesthetic judgment?
Subjectivism holds that aesthetic value depends on individual taste/response; objectivism holds that aesthetic value depends on qualities inherent in the artwork itself, regardless of the viewer
What is 'aesthetic experience'?
A distinct, heightened mode of perception/attention a viewer has toward a work of art, often marked by absorbed, contemplative engagement
How might a Formalist and an Instrumentalist critic disagree about the same artwork?
A Formalist would judge it on composition/design choices alone; an Instrumentalist would judge it on whether it successfully delivers a moral or social message, regardless of formal polish
What is the difference between 'aesthetics' and 'art criticism'?
Aesthetics is the branch of philosophy asking broad questions about beauty, art, and taste; art criticism is the practice of analyzing and judging specific individual artworks
Why is knowing multiple critical lenses (formalism, expressionism, imitationalism, instrumentalism) important for teaching art critique?
Different lenses lead to different, equally valid judgments about the same artwork, and teaching multiple lenses helps students form well-reasoned, defensible opinions rather than a single 'right answer'