Supply Chain Class 4 (Relationships and Coopetition)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/64

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

65 Terms

1
New cards

What is an arm’s-length contract?

Independent parties trading on market terms, with no special ties or commitments.

2
New cards

What is a joint venture?

A separate company owned together by two or more firms, e.g. S-LCD (Samsung and Sony).

3
New cards

What is an equity stake?

An ownership share in another firm, which ties the owner’s fortunes to the partner’s.

4
New cards

What is exit cost?

What a party loses by leaving the relationship. Comparable exit costs create mutual dependency.

5
New cards

What is a non-substitutable resource?

An input with no practical alternative, which gives its owner power, e.g. rare earths.

6
New cards

What does zero-sum mean?

One side’s gain is exactly the other’s loss, so there is nothing to gain by cooperating.

7
New cards

What is defection?

A partner stops cooperating, by cheating or leaving, to gain an advantage.

8
New cards

What is spillover?

Knowledge that flows to a partner, who can then use it against you.

9
New cards

What is social capital?

Trust, shared norms, and personal ties between firms that make cooperation easier.

10
New cards

What is social capital?

Trust, shared norms, and personal ties between firms that make cooperation easier.

11
New cards

What is backward integration?

Taking a supplier’s activity in-house, e.g. a buyer starting to make the component itself.

12
New cards

What is a vertical relationship?

A relationship between firms at different stages of the value chain (brand owner and supplier, manufacturer and distributor), shaped by power and dependency. Example: Apple and TSMC.

13
New cards

What is a horizontal relationship?

A relationship between direct competitors at the same tier, e.g. for co-innovation, shared logistics, or joint lobbying. Example: Ford builds electric cars in Cologne on VW’s MEB platform

14
New cards

What is a diagonal relationship?

A cross-industry partnership between firms that are not direct competitors but share a value chain. Illustrative example: an airline and a bank with a co-branded loyalty card.

15
New cards

What is a network relationship?

A multilateral arrangement such as an industry consortium, platform ecosystem, or buyer association. Governance is collective, not bilateral. Example: Catena-X.

16
New cards

What is the difference between the “kinds” and “strengths” of relationships?

Kinds (vertical, horizontal, ...) ask WHO the partner is. Strengths ask HOW tightly you tie yourselves to them.

17
New cards

What are the five strengths of relationships?

  1. Arm’s-length market

  2. long-term agreements

  3. contractual alliances

  4. equity alliances, and acquisition

    Commitment and incentive alignment increase, flexibility decreases.


18
New cards

What is an arm’s-length market relationship?

Short deals on market terms. Not an alliance. Example: buying standard paper.

19
New cards

What are long-term agreements?

Multi-year contracts. An alliance only if partners plan and invest together.

20
New cards

What are contractual alliances?

Cooperation without ownership. Example: Star Alliance

21
New cards

What are equity alliances?

Shares held as a stake or joint venture. Example: S-LCD (2004 to 2011).

22
New cards

Where do alliances sit between market and hierarchy?

Alliances are independent firms that work together, sitting between the market and the hierarchy (Williamson). Market is on one end, acquisition (hierarchy) on the other.

23
New cards

How does the dependency Matrix look like?


<p></p>
24
New cards

How does the dependency matrix link to coopetition?

Cooperating with a rival is most stable in the mutual dependency box. Elsewhere the stronger side can leave at low cost.

25
New cards

What is coopetition (Brandenburger & Nalebuff, 1996)?

The simultaneous pursuit of cooperation and competition between firms that are rivals in the same or adjacent markets.

26
New cards

Where does coopetition sit on the spectrum?

Between pure competition (zero-sum, information hoarding, price wars) and pure cooperation (shared investment, unified market approach). It is cooperating and competing at the same time.

27
New cards

What is the value claim of coopetition?

It creates more value than disadvantage.

28
New cards

What is the paradox of sharing vs protecting knowledge?

Cooperation asks you to share what you know, competition asks you to protect it. Example: in S-LCD, Samsung and Sony shared panel know-how while their TV divisions kept competing.

29
New cards

What is the paradox of trust vs guarding your interests?

Cooperation asks you to trust the partner, competition asks you to guard your own interests. Example: Apple sued Samsung over copying the iPhone (2011, settled 2018), yet in 2017 Samsung was still the only OLED supplier for the iPhone X.

30
New cards

What is the paradox of creating vs capturing value?

Cooperation asks you to create value together, competition asks you to capture value for yourself. Example: Gemini Cooperation, where Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd pool about 290 ships but each sells to its own customers, often the same cargo owners.

31
New cards

Is coopetition a problem you solve once?

No. It is a paradox you manage.

32
New cards

At which three levels do tensions in coopetition arise?

Between the firms, inside one firm, and for individuals.

33
New cards

What is the value net, and who is in it?

A map around the focal firm with customers (buy from the focal firm), suppliers (provide inputs), competitors (rivals for customers and suppliers), and complementors (make the focal firm’s product more valuable).

34
New cards

What does the inverted U say about coopetition?

Buying-firm performance peaks at a medium level of social capital and cooperation intensity (Villena, Revilla & Choi, 2011).

35
New cards

What is “too little” coopetition?

Over-competition: partners hoard information and defect (opportunism, price wars). Example: US carmakers before the 1990s picked suppliers mainly on price, gave them little say in design, and had adversarial relationships.

36
New cards

What is “just enough” coopetition?

Enough trust to cooperate, enough distance to keep competing. Examples: Chrysler after 1989 (SCORE: suppliers suggest savings and share in them, over $2 billion saved, supplier base cut from 2,500 to 1,140) and Toyota (suppliers learn faster in a knowledge-sharing network with rules against free-riders and leaks).

37
New cards

What is “too much” coopetition?

Over-embeddedness: partners so close they stop challenging each other, causing lock-in and blind spots. Example: Nissan before 1999 (keiretsu loyalty, about $4 billion tied up in shares of hundreds of firms, purchasing costs 20 to 25% above Renault’s). The Revival Plan cut purchasing costs by 20%, suppliers from about 1,100 to 600, and unwound cross-shareholdings.

38
New cards

What is vertical coopetition?

A supplier and buyer cooperate while competing elsewhere. Example: Samsung supplies Apple with OLED displays and memory chips (billions of dollars a year) while the two fight head-to-head for smartphone customers.

39
New cards

How do vertical coopetition partners cooperate?

Supplier development programs, shared demand forecasting and VMI, co-design and early supplier involvement, and joint quality audits.

40
New cards

Where does vertical coopetition get tense?

The supplier also sells to your rivals (the dual-sourcing dilemma), and the buyer may bring the supplier’s technology in-house (the backward-integration threat).

41
New cards

What is horizontal coopetition?

Rivals at the same tier with the same customers cooperate on pre-competitive R&D, standards, shared infrastructure, and collective lobbying, while competing on products, customers, and market share.

42
New cards

When does horizontal coopetition work?

When pre-competitive R&D is too costly for one firm alone, and for industry standardization, shared infrastructure, and collective lobbying.

43
New cards

When does horizontal coopetition fail?

When one partner’s innovation pipeline pulls ahead (free-riding), or when market-share imbalance grows and incentives diverge.

44
New cards

What can coopetition governance rest on?

Written agreements (formal) or relationships and norms (informal). Each must cover both the cooperative and the competitive side.

45
New cards

What does formal governance look like in coopetition?

Cooperative side: joint governance board, shared R&D contract, agreed information protocol (e.g. the S-LCD joint venture agreement).

Competitive side: non-compete clauses, rules on who owns IP, limits on what data may be shared (e.g. a supply contract stating the buyer’s drawings stay its property).

46
New cards

What does informal governance look like in coopetition?

Cooperative side: trust, shared norms, engineers who know each other and solve problems together.

Competitive side: reputation and mutual monitoring keep rivals within accepted limits (a firm that leaks a partner’s data is soon known and avoided).

47
New cards

What is calculative trust?

Does it pay them to keep the promise? Based on penalties, shared savings, and monitoring. Fragile: if the deal changes, the promise can change too.

48
New cards

What is competence trust?

Can they actually do it? Based on capacity, quality record, and skilled people. Damaged when the partner’s capability declines

49
New cards

What is goodwill trust?

Will they look out for us beyond the contract? They warn early, share bad news, and adapt. Hardest to build and the most powerful.

50
New cards

What is institutional trust?

Trust that sits underneath all three other types: legal systems, certification, and arbitration let strangers trade across borders.

51
New cards

What does a firewall allow and block?

Allowed through the gate: aggregate forecasts and shared capacity plans.

Blocked: proprietary process data, roadmaps, and pricing. Cooperative and competitive activities each have a dedicated team and their own systems.

52
New cards

What are the five firewall mechanisms?

  • Organizational firewalls (separate units)

  • physical separation (separate teams and systems, “clean rooms”)

  • data governance protocols (tiered sharing)

  • time-limited disclosure (shared info can’t be used after termination),

  • personnel rotation limits (key joint-project staff face mobility limits).


53
New cards

What is boundary creep?

People, files, and meetings ending up on both sides. It is the most common way the separation fails.

54
New cards

Why is structural separation needed for a firewall?

It is an operational requirement, not only a legal one

55
New cards

What is the acceptance approach to coopetition?

Look for synergies. Treat the contradiction as logical, not absurd, and hold both at once.

56
New cards

What is the splitting approach to coopetition?

Pull cooperation and competition apart so each can be managed on its own.

57
New cards

What is the difference between temporal and spatial splitting?

Temporal: separate them in time (hard, because managers face real cognitive limits).

Spatial: separate them by structure (the separation principle under another name)

58
New cards

How does Toyota handle coopetition?

Acceptance: balanced cooperation and competition simultaneously in every stage (pre-development, RFQ, series development, series production).

59
New cards

How do BMW and VW handle coopetition?

Splitting, sequentially. BMW and VW are cooperative in some stages and competitive in others.

VW: cooperative (pre-development), competitive (RFQ), cooperative (series development), competitive (series production).

BMW does a mix: it shares expertise with suppliers but still competes where beneficial.

60
New cards

How does Nissan handle coopetition?

Cooperation within projects, but fierce competition between them. Competition overshadows cooperation in every stage.

61
New cards

Why does Toyota differ from VW?

Toyota values trust more, while VW favors cost.

62
New cards

Why do coopetitions fail?

Three failure modes: knowledge leakage, value-capture asymmetry, and strategic drift.

63
New cards

What is knowledge leakage?

The most cited failure: proprietary knowledge flows through the cooperative channel into a competitor’s product.

Example: Kawasaki Heavy Industries passed 200 km/h train technology to China’s CSR Sifang in 2004. By 2011 China was filing its own high-speed rail patents abroad, and Kawasaki threatened legal action.

64
New cards

What is value-capture asymmetry?

One partner captures disproportionately more value, leading to resentment and then exit. Example: Renault and Nissan. Until 2023 Renault held about 43% of Nissan with voting rights, while Nissan held 15% of Renault without. Nissan pushed for a rebalance.

65
New cards

What is strategic drift?

Partners’ priorities diverge over time as markets change. Example: Sony and Samsung (S-LCD), formed in 2004 to secure panels. By 2011 Sony had years of TV losses and Samsung bought its stake.