1/6
Looks like no tags are added yet.
1. The UK's withdrawal from the EU: two dimensions
The UK's withdrawal from the EU involved two separate legal dimensions: external and internal.
A. External dimension
This concerns the international legal agreements between the UK and the EU.
These include:
The EU Treaties – particularly the Treaty on European Union (TEU) and Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU).
EU Withdrawal Agreement 2019 – established the terms of the UK's departure from the EU. It includes the Ireland/Northern Ireland Protocol.
Trade and Cooperation Agreement 2020 (TCA) – established the new relationship between the UK and the EU following withdrawal.
B. Internal dimension
This concerns the domestic legal measures introduced by the UK to:
Respond to its withdrawal from the EU.
Manage the effects of EU law within the UK legal system.
Decide what status EU-derived law would have after Brexit.
Important: This topic focuses on the internal dimension, particularly the status of EU law within the UK. You are not required to know about the domestic legal effects of the TCA.
2. The status of EU law in the UK: an overview
The legal status of EU law in the UK can be divided into three periods.
1973–2020: UK as an EU Member State
EU law had to be given effect within the UK legal system because of the UK's membership obligations.
Key legislation: European Communities Act 1972.
2021–2023: Retained EU law
Following withdrawal, the EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018 determined the status of EU law within the UK, with some continuing obligations relating to Northern Ireland.
Key legislation: EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
2024 onwards: Assimilated law
The Retained EU Law (Reform and Revocation) Act 2023 changed the status of retained EU law and renamed it assimilated law.
Key legislation: REUL Act 2023.
A. While the UK was an EU Member State (1973–2020)
During this period, the UK was required to give effect to EU law.
These obligations arose from:
The EU Treaties.
Secondary legislation made under the Treaties.
The interpretation and development of EU law by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).
The European Communities Act 1972 (ECA 1972) was particularly important because it provided the domestic legal mechanism through which EU law operated within the UK legal system.
B. Following withdrawal: Phase 1 – Retained EU law (2021–2023)
After Brexit, the UK's obligations to give effect to EU law generally ended.
However, some aspects of EU law continued to apply in Northern Ireland under the Ireland/Northern Ireland Protocol, which formed part of the Withdrawal Agreement.
For the rest of the UK, the status of EU law was determined by the EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
C. Following withdrawal: Phase 2 – Assimilated law (2024 onwards)
The position concerning Northern Ireland remained broadly as described in Phase 1.
For the rest of the UK, the status of EU-derived law was changed by the Retained EU Law (Reform and Revocation) Act 2023.
This Act changed retained EU law into assimilated law and altered the relationship between EU-derived law and domestic UK law.
3. EU law in the UK while it was a Member State (1973–2020)
To understand the impact of EU law on the UK, we first need to understand what EU law required Member States to do.
From the EU's perspective:
The Treaties were legally binding on Member States.
Secondary legislation made under the Treaties had to be implemented or applied within national legal systems.
National courts had to ensure that EU law was effective.
Article 288 TFEU: Regulations and directives
Article 288 TFEU explains the different types of EU legal acts.
Regulations
A regulation:
Has general application.
Is binding in its entirety.
Is directly applicable in all Member States.
Meaning: Regulations automatically become part of the legal system of each Member State. They do not need to be separately implemented through national legislation.
Directives
A directive:
Is binding on the Member State regarding the result that must be achieved.
Allows national authorities to choose the form and methods used to achieve that result.
Meaning: Directives require Member States to achieve a particular outcome, but allow them some flexibility over how to do so, usually through national implementing legislation.
Remember the distinction
Regulation | Directive |
Directly applicable | Requires implementation |
Binding in its entirety | Binding as to the result |
No national implementation needed | National authorities choose form and methods |
4. The principles governing EU law in Member States
The CJEU developed important principles to ensure that EU law was effective throughout Member States.
These principles also applied to the UK while it was a Member State.
A. Direct effect – Van Gend en Loos
Direct effect
The principle of direct effect allows individuals to rely on certain EU law provisions before national courts.
However, not every EU law provision has direct effect.
For a provision to have direct effect, it must be:
Clear – its meaning must be sufficiently understandable.
Precise – it must establish a sufficiently specific legal obligation or right.
Unconditional – it must not depend on further action or discretion before it can be applied.
Case: Van Gend en Loos (1963)
The CJEU established the principle of direct effect.
Importance: Individuals could rely on certain EU law provisions in their national courts, rather than depending entirely on their governments to enforce EU law.
B. Supremacy of EU law – Costa, Simmenthal and IHG
Supremacy
The principle of supremacy means that where directly effective EU law conflicts with national law, EU law takes priority.
This applied regardless of:
The status of the conflicting national legislation.
Whether the national legislation was made before or after the relevant EU law.
Important cases:
Case | Principle established |
Costa v ENEL (1964) | Established the supremacy of EU law over conflicting national law. |
Simmenthal (1978) | National courts must give effect to EU law and set aside conflicting national law where necessary. |
International Handelsgesellschaft (1970) (IHG) | EU law takes priority even where the conflict involves national constitutional law. |
Meaning: UK courts could not simply apply conflicting UK legislation if doing so would breach applicable EU law.
C. Indirect effect – Von Colson and Marleasing
Indirect effect
Indirect effect requires national courts to interpret domestic law, as far as possible, in a way that is consistent with EU law.
This is particularly important where an EU provision does not have direct effect.
Important cases:
Von Colson and Kamann (1984): Established the obligation to interpret national law consistently with the wording and purpose of an EU directive.
Marleasing (1990): Extended this obligation to national legislation as a whole, including legislation passed before the directive.
Meaning: Even where individuals could not directly rely on an EU provision, national courts still had a responsibility to interpret domestic legislation consistently with EU law where possible.
D. State liability – Francovich
State liability
State liability allows individuals to claim compensation from a Member State where they suffer loss because that state breaches EU law.
Case: Francovich and Bonifaci v Italy (1991)
Italy had failed to implement a directive protecting employees whose employers became insolvent.
The CJEU recognised that individuals could claim damages from the state where the failure to implement EU law caused them loss.
Meaning: Member States could face financial consequences for failing to comply with their EU obligations.
5. How did these principles affect UK courts?
While the UK was a Member State, its courts were required to give effect to the supremacy of EU law.
This could involve using:
Direct effect: Allowing individuals to rely directly on applicable EU provisions.
Indirect effect: Interpreting UK legislation consistently with EU law.
Reading in: Interpreting domestic legislation in a way that gives effect to EU requirements, where legally possible.
Disapplication: Setting aside conflicting domestic legislation where required by EU supremacy.
Why was this potentially problematic for UK courts?
The lecture ends by raising this question.
The central tension was between the supremacy of EU law and the UK's traditional understanding of parliamentary sovereignty.
Under the traditional UK constitutional approach, Parliament is sovereign and can make or repeal any law.
However, EU law required UK courts to give priority to directly effective EU law where it conflicted with domestic legislation.
This meant that UK courts sometimes had to set aside provisions of Acts of Parliament to comply with EU law.
This is the central constitutional issue of Topic 6: How could the UK maintain the principle of parliamentary sovereignty while also complying with the supremacy of EU law?
6. Key cases and legislation to remember
Authority | Main principle |
Article 288 TFEU | Explains regulations and directives. |
Van Gend en Loos (1963) | Direct effect. |
Costa v ENEL (1964) | Supremacy of EU law. |
International Handelsgesellschaft (1970) | EU supremacy over conflicting national constitutional law. |
Simmenthal (1978) | National courts must set aside conflicting national law where necessary. |
Von Colson (1984) | Indirect effect. |
Marleasing (1990) | Indirect effect applies to all national legislation. |
Francovich (1991) | State liability for breaches of EU law. |
Period | Main domestic legislation |
1973–2020 | European Communities Act 1972 |
2021–2023 | EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018 |
2024 onwards | Retained EU Law (Reform and Revocation) Act 2023 |
7. Quick revision summary
Make sure you understand these five points:
External withdrawal concerns the agreements between the UK and EU. Internal withdrawal concerns how the UK changed its own legal system.
While the UK was a Member State, the European Communities Act 1972 provided the domestic mechanism for giving effect to EU law.
Article 288 TFEU distinguishes between regulations, which are directly applicable, and directives, which require Member States to achieve a specified result.
Direct effect, supremacy, indirect effect and state liability ensured that EU law was effective within Member States.
The major constitutional tension was that EU law supremacy could require UK courts to disapply domestic legislation, raising questions about parliamentary sovereignty.
The next important step in this topic is understanding how UK courts dealt with the conflict between EU supremacy and parliamentary sovereignty.