1/61
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Types of critical thinking
1) logical analysis
2) evaluation of information
3) experimental inference
4) creating theories/concepts
5) historical interpretation
6) sociological imagination
7) problem-solving skills
8) self awareness/emotional intelligence
Critical thinking
general term given to a wide range of cognitive skills & intellectual dispositions needed to effectively identify, analyze, and evaluate arguments/truth claims.
Highest order thinking
routine use of critical thinking tools in analyzing and assessing thinking; constantly fair; explicitly reflective
Higher order of thinking
lacks critical thinking vocabulary; inconcistently fair; may be skilled in sophistry
Lower order of thinking
frequently relies on unexamined gut intuition; largely self-serving/self deceived; unreflective
Three kinds of thinkers
Naive, selfish-logical, fair-minded critical
Naive thinker
the person who doesn't care about, or isn't aware of his or her thinking
Selfish-logical thinker
the person who is good at thinking analytically, but unfair to others
Fairminded critical thinker
the person who is not only good at thinking analytically but also fair to others
Elemetns of though
POV, purpose, question at issue, information, interpertation & inference, concepts, assumptions, implications & consequences
Intellectual standards
clarity, accuracy, precision, relevancy, completeness, logical correctness/consistency, fairness
Barriers to critical thinking
Innate egocentrism & inate sociocentrism
Inate egocentrism
self-validation, selfishness, and wish fulfillment
Three kinds of questions
One system, no system, multi-system
One system questions
Requires evidence & reasoning within a system; a correct answer; knowledge
No system questions
Calls for stating a subjective preference; a subjective opinion; cannot be assessed
Multi-system questions
Requires evidence & reasoning within multiple, often conflicting systems; better & worse interpertations; judgement
Fallacy
a common argument mistake or error
ad hominem (personal attack) fallacy
attempts to refute a person's argument by attacking the person giving that argument
Appeal to tradition fallacy
assumes something is true because past generations claimed it to be true
Strawman fallacy
fallacy of distorting, or exaggerating, or misrepresenting your opponent's argument in order to make it easier to attack
Begging the question (circular argument) fallacy
committed when an arguer states or assumes as a premise the very thing he or she is trying to prove as a conclusion
SEE-I Method
State, Elaborate, Exemplify, Illustrate
The Upanishads (Hinduism)
900-500 BCE
Introduce metaphysics
Metaphysics
branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of self
Atman
it is the core self "that underlies (and is separate from) personality, thought patterns, bodily nature, and so forth"
Brahman
the ultimate reality of the universe
2 different divergent claims
we become brahman & we already are brahman
this view implies we are all one and the same, but there are social castes within society
Metaphysical monism
ordinary world is an illusion; every day self is superficial - true self is pure being
Philosophical monism
there is only one true reality, and our everyday sense of self obscures this true reality
Guatama Siddartha
~500 BCE
The Buddha
Anatman
the negotiation of the atman; the self lacks any substance - it is nothingness
Sixth sense of Buddhism
introspection
5 inter-related processes
the physical body, sensations/feelings, sense perceptions, mental habits, and consciousness
Buddhist realism
ordinary world is real; the everyday self is a delusion
Metaphysical dualist - Plato
there are two realities: the ordinary world & the world of forms/ideas
the ordinary world
inferiority reality; it is temporary and immanent
World of forms/ideas
superior reality; it is eternal and transcendent
Tripartite self
passions, reasons, and volition
Plato
~428-348 BCE
immortality of the soul
Ancient Judaic metaphysics
1) the ordinary world is not an illusion, it is real
2) God created the world, both exist in the same reality
3) the resurrection of the self at the end of the world involves the soul and body as a single unit.
What is the basis for a person's existence after death?
1) appeal to authority: New Testament
2) God's omnipotence & God's plan for humanity
3) Heaven is the purpose for human life: external happiness
4) Theodicy: explanation for why evil exists
5) punishment of Hell: eternal, meaningless suffering
London of the Society for Physical Research
founded in 1882; parapsychology
2 main groups of parapsychology
1) focus on mental phenomena with no reference to death (e.g., ESP & psychokinesis)
2) focus on apparitions and "spirit messages"
Platonic theory of the soul
the soul is distincy from the body; the soul is eternal
Christian soul theory
individual resurrection
Soul theory
the nonphysical soul (soul substance) is unchanging, so personal identity is not affected by the death of our bodies
Scholastic philosophy
authority of Christian doctrine; authority of Aristotelian deductive logic
Modern philosophy
search for new foundations for knowledge; secular reasoning
Epistemology
the study of the foundations of knowledge
"Mechnical" view of nature
the only substances in space are material, made up of smaller particles, and moved by physical force
Absolute skepticism
this perspective claims that there exists no adequate justification that can show why our beliefs are true; all we can have are beliefs by no knowledge
Cartesian method of doubt
required him to doubt & examine all his beliefs for certainty; dream argument & evil demon argument
Rationalism
theory of knowledge claims that knowledge is only possible through a priori reasoning alone; these necessary truths form the foundation of all our knowledge
John Locke
1632-1704
British philosopher
Came up with empiricism
Empiricism
theory of knowledge that claims knowledge is fundamentally based on perception; logical reasoning is not sufficient, we must refer to sense-experience
Cartesian Rationalism
"I am a thinking thing"
Mind = consciousness = self: "I am"
Body/brain = physical matter
Memory theory
explains personal identity (self) in terms of genuine memories
Problems for memory theory
memories are inconsistent or can fade; false memories
Empircism
theory of knowledge that claims truth is fundamentally based in perception; logical reasoning is not sufficient, we must refer to sense-experience
Direct memories
can be recalled consciously at this moment
Indirect memories
cannot be recalled directly; a former self was able to recall them