1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Textualism
Interpreting the Constitution based on the ordinary, common meaning of its words and examining the text itself without considering external factors or intentions. Guided by definitions, diction, syntax, and structure of the words
Weakness: many constitutional phrases are intentionally broad or ambiguous, leaving text alone unable to resolve hard cases
Originalism
Fixing constitutional meaning at the time of ratification. Interprets based on what the drafters/Framers subjectively intended, or how an ordinary, informed citizen at the time would have understood the text.
Weakness: Historical records are often incomplete, contradictory, or silent on modern problems.
Structuralism
Inferring constitutional rules from the overall design, relationships, and architecture of the three branches and the states. Diffusing power horizontally and vertically protects individual liberty and preserves democratic accountability.
Weakness: Structural rules are inferred; justices can reach opposite conclusions based on which structural value they prioritize
Living Constitutionalism
The meaning of the text to ordinary readers today matters. Reflects that language evolves and old terms can take on new meaning over time
Weakness: Undermines democratic legitimacy and judicial restraint by allowing unelected judges to update the Constitution
Purposivism
Focuses on the underlying purposes of the drafters/ratifiers - understanding WHY a term was included and what broader principles it stands for
Weakness: Multiple drafters/ratifiers often had conflicting purposes, allowing judges to cherry-pick a broad “purpose” that matches their preferred policy outcome
Stare Decisis
Previous decisions of the Court matter
Weakness: Clashes with Textualism/Originalism when an older precedent is clearly incorrect, and justices lack a consistent rule for when to overrule vs. retain bad precedent
Defining “jurisdiction” as territorial governance or defining “recess”
Textualism
13th Amendment “badges and incidents of slavery”; defining 1868 meaning of “jurisdiction”
Originalism
Expanding Equal Protection and Due Process applications beyond 1868 societal norms
Living constitutionalism
Reading the Reconstruction Amendments broadly to eradicate systemic racial subjugation; interpreting federal regulatory powers to meet modern national crises
Purposivism