1/58
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what type of crime is theft?
triable either way
which act sets out the maximum penalty for theft?
theft act 1968 (s.7)
what is the definition of theft according to s.1 theft act 1968?
a person is guilty of theft if he dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention to permanently deprive the other of it'
what is the AR of theft?
appropriation
property
belonging to another
what is appropriation (AR)?
defined in s.3(1) as any assumption of any rights of the owner
which cases illustrate appropriation?
pitham and hehl
morris
corcoran v anderton
lawrence
R v hinks
what was held in pitham and heihl?
selling property is an appropriation
what was held in morris?
switching labels on items to pay a lower price is an appropriation for theft
what was held in corcoran v anderton?
tugging a handbag can be an appropriation (even if V doesn’t let go)
which cases illustrate how an appropriation can occur even when V has consented to the taking?
lawrence
R v hinks
what was held in lawrence?
COA and HOL held taking with consent of the owner was still appropriation and was confirmed in gomez
what was held in R v hinks?
HOL decided on majority of 3 to 2 that accepting a valid gift is appropriation
has the advantage of protecting vulnerable people
what is a later assumption of a right?
s.3(1) states there can be appropriation when the D acquires property without stealing it and then later decides to keep or deal with the property as owner
what is property (AR)?
money
personal property
land and buildings
intangible property
things in action (cheques, bank accounts in credit, shares, cryptocurrency)
which cases illustrate property?
kelly and lindsay
oxford v mass
what was held in kelly and lindsay?
a dead body is not normally ‘property’ but the body parts in this case were property because they had acquired some value by the dissection and preserving techniques
what was held in oxford v moss?
D liable for stealing the examination paper but not the information on it
what are things that can’t be stolen according to the theft act?
s.4(3) - wild mushrooms or flowers
s.4(4) - wild creatures
what is belonging to another (AR)?
the property appropriated must belong to another
given a very wide meaning by the theft act and includes possession or control, as well as proprietary interests
which cases illustrate belonging to another?
R v turner
R v woodman
what was held in R v turner?
D was guilty of stealing his own car when he took it from the possession and control of the garage without their knowledge
what was held in R v woodman?
D can be liable for stealing property that the person in possession doesn’t even know is there
what is s.5(3) of the theft act?
property received under an obligation
what is property received under an obligation?
if D is under an obligation to retain and deal with property in a particular way they must do so
if they do something else with the property it will still belong to the V and this could be theft
which case illustrates property received under an obligation?
davidge v bennett
what was held in davidge v bennett?
D guilty of theft using s.5(3)
D had an obligation to use the money in a particular way
what is s.5(4) of the theft act?
property obtained by mistake
what is property obtained by mistake?
s.5(4) states that if a D receives property by mistake there is a duty to give it back
if this doesn’t happen there may be a theft
which case illustrates property obtained by a mistake?
attorney general’s reference (no.1 of 1983)
what was held in attorney general’s reference (no.1 of 1983)?
COA held that if there was not an honest attempt to pay back the money then there could be a theft however jury acquitted
what is s.2 of the theft act?
dishonesty - mens rea
what is dishonesty?
D must have appropriated the property dishonestly
theft act does not define dishonesty but gives 3 situations where D’s behaviour is not considered dishonest
what is s.2(1) of the theft act?
behaviour which is not dishonest
what are the 3 circumstances where behaviour is not dishonest?
s.2(1)(a): D believes he has a right to the property
s.2(1)(b): D believes the other would have consented to him taking it
s.2(1)(c): D believes that the owner cannot be found by taking reasonable steps
what does s.2(2) of the theft act state?
a person could still be dishonest if they take property and leave payment for it
prevents a person from taking whatever he likes regardless of the owner’s wishes
what is the common law test for dishonesty?
ivey v genting casinos: ‘whether D’s conduct is dishonest by the standards of ordinary people’
confirmed in R v barton
what is s.6 of the theft act?
intention to permanently deprive
which case illustrates intention to permanently deprive?
velumyl
what was held in velumyl?
D’s conviction for theft was upheld
banknotes he intended to replace the stolen money with would be different banknotes so he did have the intention to permanently deprive
what is borrowing and lending?
s.6 states that borrowing is not theft unless it is for a period and in circumstances making it equivalent to an outright taking or disposal
which case illustrates borrowing and lending?
R v lloyd
what was held in R v lloyd?
court held that borrowing could be theft under s.6 i the property was borrowed ‘until the goodness, the virtue, the practical value…was gone out of the article’
what is conditional intent in theft?
if D picks up property to see if it is worth stealing or not this will not satisfy the MR of theft
which case illustrates conditional intent?
easom
what was held in easom?
COA quashed conviction for theft stating that the ‘conditional’ intention to deprive was not enough to satisfy the MR of theft
what is s.8 of the theft act?
robbery
what is the definition of robbery?
a person is guilty of robbery if he steals, and immediately before or at the time of doing so, and in order to do so, he used force on any person or puts or seeks to put any person in fear of being then and there subjected to force
what 2 things are necessary for the AR of robbery?
theft
force or threat of force before or at the time of the theft
which elements of theft must be completed for a robbery to take place?
appropriation
property
belonging to another
dishonesty
intention to permanently deprive
which case illustrates completed theft in robbery?
R v robinson
what was held in R v robinson?
there must be a completed theft before there can be a robbery