The Problem of Objectivity

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/16

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

17 Terms

1
New cards

What does psychological knowledge depend on?

How phenomena is described + shaped by particular aims (e.g. provide objective knowledge)

2
New cards

What is science based on and what is the issue with this?

Observation of facts independent of view (objective)

3
New cards

What is the problem with basing science on observation?

  • Can only observe from our own position (physical + mental)

    • Problem of induction → observation is limited, how can general claims be made beyond individual experiences

    • Interpreted based on prior understanding (e.g. clock)

  • Psychological phenomena is unobservable except via measurement


We don’t see things as they really are → theory laden

4
New cards

What is an example of theory being prioritised over observation?

Discovery of Uranus (1781):

  • Newtonian laws predicted orbit

  • Observations did not fit → disrupted by another planet?

  • Maintained Newtonian theory


5
New cards

What is an example of observation being interpreted differently?

Discovery of Neptune (1846):

  • Observed light in 1845 → seen as a star, not new planet

  • Was observed as a planet


Based on theory, not just observation


6
New cards

What is the myth of the given?

Mental states aren’t directly knowable + are based on prior concepts (which describe state)

E.g. yellow → can't know anything going on in our minds without language which allows understanding of a concept (which it refers to) 

7
New cards

How is bias and subjectivity introduced in psychology?

Mental stuff → descriptions → formal concepts (defined based on theoretical assumptions → measures (constructed + selected) → observable data (collected, analysed, interpreted)


Decisions made at each stage

8
New cards

How did early psychological experiments manage subjectivity?

  • Standardised procedures

  • Mechanical/automated devices

  • Limited responses from PPTs

  • Statistical inconsistency of responses

  • Behaviourism → direct observation


9
New cards

What was the solution to what can be observed and how this can be interpreted?

Operationalism (from 1930s)

10
New cards

What does operationalism do?

Define concepts via operation of measurement:

Concept x ← measure x → x data

11
New cards

What is the consequence of operational definitions/concepts?

Different operations measure different things + data refers to different things

12
New cards

What is a solution to the consequence of operationalism and how does it solve this problem?

Convergent operations → use different operations (tests, scales) to measure same concept (e.g. triangulation)

  • Concept is no longer defined by operation → refers to (separate) abstract thing

  • Defined concepts + concept-measure relationship in different ways


13
New cards

What is the purpose of replication?

Overcome limits of specific findings

14
New cards

What are the issues with replication (replication crisis)?

  • How many replications? → observations always limited

  • What counts as a replication? → must be interpreted

    • Is further evidence BUT not exactly the same (what is the difference?)


15
New cards

What did the replication crisis raise questions about?

Robustness of various findings, adequacy of methods, research + publication practices

16
New cards

What is a problem with the social nature of psychological experiments?

  • PPTs aren’t passive

  • DMCs

  • Experimented effects


17
New cards

What crisis emerged in social psychology?

  • Methodological → problem with experiments

  • Relevance → validity + utility

  • Theoretical basis → social behaviour not fixed