1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are some examples of a study before the BPS code of ethics?
Beecher (1966):
Patients were treated with sulfadiazine for streptococcal pharyngitis
Control patients with same illness didn’t receive sulfadiazine
Was known that antibiotics would prevent the development of rheumatic fever but patients didn’t receive this
24 patients developed rheumatic fever
Patients weren't informed (unaware of participation in experiment), wouldn't have wanted to be exposed to risk → no consent or ability to withdraw
Johnson (1939):
Study of stuttering with 2 groups of orphan children
Praised for speech vs belittled + criticised
Some children in 2nd group became withdrawn + self-conscious → later life problems
No consent
Study kept secret until 2001
SPE, Milgram
How did Burger (2009) replicate some of Milgram’s studies in a way that could get modern ethical approval?
Pre-screening to exclude PPTs who could have a negative reaction
PPTs told about right to withdraw
Study stopped when voltage reached 150v
PPTs were informed immediately of false shocks
Experimenter was overseeing experiment to make sure everything was okay
Gave very small electric shock (that could hardly be felt) for realism (vs 450v in og experiment)
What 4 principles is the BPS code of ethics based on?
Respect
Autonomy
Privacy
Dignity
Integrity
Contribution
Quality
Transparency
Responsibility
Common good
Collegiality
Professionalism
Benefit vs harm
Cost-benefit
Distress
Self-doubt
What is the principle of respect?
Researchers respect the knowledge + experience of PPTs
Researchers respect individual, cultural + role differences among PPTs
Researchers must explain the nature of the research
Respect for PPT’s privacy
Researchers must allow PPTs to make an informed decision of whether to participate + whether data is kept
Withdraw before, during or after experiment
What should the participant be informed of before they can conset?
Project aims
Types of data to be collected
Methods of collecting data
Confidentiality + anonymity conditions
Compliance with Data Protection Act (2018)
Expected time commitment
Right to decline to give requested info
Opportunity to withdraw from the study at any time
Right to have data deleted
Detailed of any risks
Any payment made (if applicable)
Name + contact details of principle investigator (overseer/supervisor of experiment)
Name + contact details of one other person (e.g. chair of ethics committee)
Details of insurance (if applicable)
Whether a debriefing is planned
How the data will be stored + shared
Privacy notice
Planned outcomes + potential benefits of the research
How the results of the research will be made available to the PPTs
What is the principle of scientific integrity?
Research should be of high quality + contribute to knowledge/understanding
Poorly designed research wastes resources + can lead to the spread of misleading info (causing harm(
Researchers should be honest in how they explain their research to PPTs + how their report said research to others
What is the principle of social responsibility?
Research should lead to beneficial outcomes
Must at least contribute to our knowledge (if not applied research)
Researchers should be aware of consequences of outcomes of research + the potential of problematic nature of interpretation + findings
Researchers should always work within the limits of their competence
Shouldn't try to make a claim about something you know nothing about
What is the principle of maximising benefit and minimising harm?
Benefits to society should be maximised as much as possible
Harm to PPTs should be minimised
If risks are inevitable, risk assessment is needed
Risk of harm shouldn’t be greater than those in daily life
What are some examples of risk?
Research involving vulnerable groups
Research involving sensitive topics
Research involving deception
Research involving access to confidential info
Research that could cause psychological stress
Research involving invasive interventions
How does informed consent and right to withdraw relate to the respect and integrity principles?
Consent is necessary for each PPT
Consent must be based on sufficient info about the study
PPTs should have the right to withdraw consent during data collection
Can terminate the study at any time including withdrawing data
PPTs should have the right to request their data to be deleted after data collection
How does confidentiality relate to respect and integrity?
PPTs personal info should be kept private
Distinction between identifiable + unidentifiable data:
Identifiable = individual could be identified (e.g. name, specific info in data, video recording)
Unusual cases may still be identifiable even if its attempted to be reported anonymously
Would need a really good reason to be identifiable
Unidentifiable = data is anonymous + it’s very unlikely that the individual could be identified from the info in the data
If data is publicly available, it should normally be unidentifiable
PPTs should be informed of how the data will be treated (even if it’s unidentifiable)
What is a key rule of deception in psychological studies?
Deception must be of such a nature where the PPT wouldn't be more uncomfortable than average/daily life after the debrief