1/142
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Does using incentives work?
Yes
Risks of incentives
Unethical behavior, reduce intrinsic motivation, create pay inequality, less creativity + teamwork/cooperation
Green Giant Story
Green Giant gave financial incentive to whoever that could find insect parts in peas. Employees responded by brining insect parts from home + planting them in peas so they could "find them"
Hoping for A, Rewarding for B
Organizations often unknowingly incentivize the wrong types of behaviors
intrinsic motivation
I like doing this
Doing something for its own end. No apparent reward but the behavior itself
extrinsic motivation
I like what doing this brings for me
Pursuing an activity in order to attain some separable outcome
Extrinsic Incentive Bias
Assuming people are mainly motivated by outside rewards, like money or grades, and overlooking what they enjoy or value internally.
Overjustification effect
When a reward makes you less interested in doing something you already enjoyed.
Marker Study
Children who expected a reward for drawing later played with markers less during free time, showing that rewards can reduce enjoyment.
Intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation:
Intrinsic motivation better predicts persistence and quality; extrinsic motivation better predicts quantity.
How to boost intrinsic motivation
Autonomy - freedom of choice
Mastery - develop skill
Purpose - contributing to something meaningful
Connection - sense of community
In other works, make work enjoyable!
Performance-based pay and fairness
Different rewards for the same job can feel unfair because people compare their pay with others'.
Equity Theory
People compare what they put in and get out with what others do. If it feels unfair, they may lose motivation.
Distributive Justice
Whether the result or reward feels fair.
How to improve distributive justice
Set clear criteria for contributions, explain how rewards are divided, and help employees understand who they compare themselves with.
Organizational justice
How fairly employees feel their organization treats them. It includes distributive, procedural, and interactional justice.
Procedural justice
Whether the way a decision was made feels fair. People will accept a bad outcome if they think it's fait.
How to improve procedural justice
Apply rules consistently, let employees have a voice, and give advance notice before changes.
Interactional justice
How respectfully and kindly people are treated, even when they receive a negative outcome.
How to improve interactional justice
Show openness, express empathy, and allow questions and follow-up.
Expectancy theory
People are motivated when they believe their effort can lead to good performance and rewards they want.
Expectancy
Belief that effort can lead to good performance.
Instrumentality
Belief that good performance will lead to the promised reward.
Valence
How desirable or valuable the reward is to the person.
Expectancy theory example
A salesperson considers whether they can reach 100 sales, whether they'll receive the $1,000 bonus if they do, and whether the bonus matters to them.
Using expectancy theory as a manager
Set goals employees believe they can reach, follow through on promised rewards, and offer rewards employees value.
Motivation takeaways
Reward the behavior you want, support employees' intrinsic motivation, create a fair workplace, and address expectancy, instrumentality, and valence.
Conformity
The tendency to behave or think in ways that are consistent with groups
Asch Line Study
The Asch Line Study tested whether people would agree with a group even when the group was clearly wrong. People often gave the wrong answer just to fit in.
informational influence
When you follow others because a situation is unclear and you think they know the right answer. You conform because you want to be correct, and you may genuinely believe their answer.
Normative influence
When you go along with a group because you want to fit in or avoid being judged. You might agree out loud even if you privately disagree.
Compliance
A change in behavior due to direct request from another person
Six Norms of Social Influence
reciprocity, social proof, consistency, liking, authority, scarcity
Reciprocity
When someone gives you something, you may feel like you should return the favor.
Pre-giving
Giving someone a gift before asking them for something can make them more likely to agree.
Christmas card study
Researchers sent cards to strangers, and most strangers sent a card back.
"That's Not All" technique
Make an offer more appealing by adding a discount or extra benefit before the person turns it down.
Social validation (social proof)
When you're unsure what to do, you look at what other people are doing.
Using social validation
Tell someone that many other people have already agreed or participated.
Hotel towel example
Reuse rose from 38% to 53% when a sign said that many other guests reused their towels.
Consistency
People tend to follow through on what they've said or agreed to because they want to seem consistent.
Four-Walls technique
Ask questions that remind someone of their beliefs, then ask them to act in a way that matches those beliefs.
Foot-in-the-Door technique
Ask for something small first, then ask for something bigger.
Lawn sign study
17% agreed to display a large sign without an earlier request. After agreeing to a small sticker first, 76% agreed to display the sign.
Bait-and-Switch technique
Offer a low-priced item, say it's unavailable, then suggest a more expensive one after the person has decided to buy.
Liking
People are more likely to help someone they like.
What increases liking?
Familiarity, attractiveness, and similarity.
Scarcity
People may see something as more valuable when it seems rare or likely to run out.
Two scarcity tactics
Limited-number tactic: suggest there's a small supply. Deadline tactic: say the offer is available for a limited time.
Authority
People may follow someone they see as an expert because they believe that person knows more.
Alternative to gaining compliance
Try to change someone's opinions or beliefs.
Chaiken (1980): When did communicator likeability affect opinions?
Mostly when people weren't thinking carefully or weren't held accountable for their views.
Chaiken (1980): What persuaded people who were thinking carefully?
The strength of the arguments, rather than how likeable the communicator was.
Strong vs. weak argument example
Strong: A trimester system lets students take more varied courses. Weak: People like the number three more than the number two.
High elaboration
Thinking carefully about a message. People are more persuaded by the quality of its arguments.
Low elaboration
Thinking less carefully about a message.
People are more influenced by peripheral features, such as whether they like the speaker.
How can you get people to think carefully about a message?
Make it personally relevant, ask them to explain their view, use rhetorical questions, or show that the issue is happening soon or nearby.
How should you choose message features?
Match them to the audience and how much thought they are likely to give the message.
Moral appeal
A message that says a position supports important moral values or principles.
Other-focused health appeal
A message that emphasizes how an action affects or protects other people.
What did the health appeal meta-analysis find?
Other-focused health messages were slightly more persuasive than comparison messages.
Moral Matching Hypothesis
A moral appeal is more persuasive when the audience already sees the issue as a moral matter.
Anti-recycling study
Participants first rated their views on recycling and how moral the issue felt to them, then read a practical or moral argument against recycling.
Practical vs. moral anti-recycling argument
Practical: recycling is costly or inefficient.
Moral: recycling harms the environment and is therefore wrong.
When are moral appeals most likely to work?
When the audience is prepared to see the issue in a moral light.
Self-focused vs. other-focused social distancing
aSelf-focused: distancing protects your health. Other-focused: distancing helps protect people at higher risk.
Affective appeal
An appeal that uses feelings or emotion.
Cognitive appeal
An appeal that uses logic or reasoning.
Individualistic vs. collectivistic values
Individualistic appeals focus on the individual.
Collectivistic appeals focus on the group or community.
Three parts of source credibility
Bias, honesty, and expertise.
What does lack of bias mean?
The audience sees the communicator as fair and not skewing the truth.
How can a communicator build credibility?
Be unbiased, honest, and knowledgeable, and make relevant credentials clear.
Why can a communicator's impression matter later?
The audience may carry its impression from one message into future messages.
Distributive negotiation/Fixed-pie negotiation
A negotiation where the parties' interests conflict and one side's gain comes at the other's expense.
BATNA
"Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement." Your best option if you walk away without a deal.
Why does a strong BATNA help?
It gives you more leverage and makes it easier to get closer to your desired outcome.
Should you reveal your BATNA?
Don't reveal a weak BATNA. You can signal a strong one, but avoid giving away more information than needed.
Reservation price
Your walkaway point. Beyond it, you would rather pursue your BATNA than accept the deal.
Buyer and seller reservation prices
A buyer's reservation price is the most they'll pay. A seller's is the least they'll accept.
Should you reveal your reservation price?
No. If the other side knows it, they may push for a deal that is only barely acceptable to you.
When should your reservation price change?
Only if you learn new information that substantially changes the negotiation.
BATNA vs. reservation price
Your BATNA is your best alternative if talks fail. It helps you set your reservation price, but they are not the same thing.
What else can affect a reservation price?
Opportunity costs, switching costs, personal values, emotions, and brand loyalty.
Target price
Your ideal outcome. It should be ambitious but reasonable.
How should you choose a target price?
Research the other side's interests and likely reservation price, then set an ambitious but credible goal.
ZOPA
"Zone of Possible Agreement." The range where both sides can accept a deal.
Positive bargaining zone
A ZOPA exists when the buyer's maximum price is higher than the seller's minimum price.
Negative bargaining zone
There is no ZOPA when the buyer's maximum price is lower than the seller's minimum price.
Agreement bias
The tendency to accept a deal even when it is disadvantageous.
What can cause agreement bias?
Not setting a clear reservation price, feeling invested in time and effort already spent, or wanting to maintain a positive image.
Anchoring bias
The tendency to rely too heavily on an initial number and not adjust enough from it.
What should your first offer be?
A step beyond your target price, while still being reasonable and carefully prepared.
When might you avoid making the first offer?
If you know very little about the other side's alternatives or want to protect a long-term relationship.
Distributive strategy after a negotiation
Focus on your own reservation price. This can help you feel more satisfied with the outcome.
Integrative negotiation
A negotiation involving multiple issues where different priorities can create opportunities for both sides to gain.
Distributive issue
An issue where the parties want opposing outcomes.
Compatible issue
An issue where both parties want the same outcome.
Integrative issue
An issue where the parties value options differently, allowing them to trade priorities for mutual benefit.
Pareto-efficient agreement
An agreement that maximizes the total value available. One side cannot do better without making the other side worse off.
When is an agreement not Pareto-efficient?
When both sides could improve, or one side could improve without hurting the other.