Lecture 2-Marxist Approaches to Punishment

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/35

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

36 Terms

1
New cards

How does Marxism explain criminal justice and structural inequality?

• Deprivation is linked to victimisation

• Policing and courts can reflect class inequalities

• Imprisonment disproportionately affects deprived groups

2
New cards

What is a mode of production?

• The way a society organises production

• Capitalism involves private ownership and workers producing goods or services

3
New cards

What are property relations under capitalism?

• Capitalists own productive assets

• Workers sell their labour for wages

4
New cards

What is class conflict in Marxist theory?

• Workers produce value but are not paid its full value

• Owners retain profit

• This creates exploitation and conflict

5
New cards

What are the regulatory, repressive and ideological functions of power?

• Regulatory: organise social behaviour

• Repressive: enforce control through punishment

• Ideological: shape beliefs to sustain the system

6
New cards

What is hegemony?

• Dominance of ruling-class beliefs and values

• People come to accept these ideas as normal or legitimate

7
New cards

What are fetishism and false consciousness?

• Fetishism: social arrangements appear natural or inevitable

• False consciousness: people internalise these dominant worldviews

8
New cards

How do Marxists understand the relationship between crime and punishment?

• Capitalist social relations shape criminal law

• They influence penal institutions and policies

• They help determine who is targeted

9
New cards

What is Rusche and Kirchheimer’s central argument?

• Punishment cannot be understood simply as a response to crime

• It also regulates labour and maintains dominant-class power

10
New cards

How does the labour market shape punishment according to Rusche and Kirchheimer?

• Punishment reflects labour supply and demand

• Different production systems favour different penal forms

11
New cards

What is the relationship between labour value and punishment severity?

• Labour plentiful: human life is treated as less economically valuable, encouraging harsher punishment

• Labour scarce: labour preservation and discipline become more important

12
New cards

How does Rusche and Kirchheimer’s theory explain medieval punishment?

• 13th century: low labour supply; fines and penances were more prominent

• 15th century: growing labour surplus; mutilations and executions increased

13
New cards

How did labour needs influence 18th-century punishment?

• Mining and manufacturing increased labour demand

• Prisons emphasised discipline and training

• Hard labour and transportation were used

14
New cards

What does it mean to say punishment serves the needs of the market?

• Provides labour directly

• Trains and disciplines workers

• Intimidates surplus labour during economic downturns

15
New cards

What is the principle of less eligibility?

• Prison conditions should be less desirable than those of the poorest people outside prison

• Associated with the English Poor Law Acts of the 1800s

16
New cards

What is Pashukanis’s argument about legal forms (1924)?

• Law reflects capitalist social relations

• Emphasises individualism, exchange, contracts and private property

• Prison can symbolise ā€˜paying your debt’

17
New cards

How can criminal law function as ideology, according to Hay (1975)?

• Legal language and rituals project impartiality

• Ideas of equality and justice can obscure social inequalities

• This may legitimise ruling-class power

18
New cards

What is the argument of Hall et al.’s The Law and Order Society (1978)?

• Political responses to crime and anxiety can strengthen control

• Tough-on-crime rhetoric can attract public support

• Criminalisation may divert attention from capitalist inequalities

19
New cards

What are moral panics and folk devils?

• Moral panic: an exaggerated public fear about a perceived threat

• Folk devils: groups portrayed as responsible for that threat

• Media and politicians can intensify criminalisation

20
New cards

What is meant by governing through crime?

• Governments increasingly manage insecurity and marginalised populations through criminal justice

• Welfare cuts and labour-market changes can accompany penal expansion

21
New cards

What is the neoliberal penalty?

• Penal policy shaped by market forces and privatisation

• Reduced state welfare intervention can coexist with stronger punishment

• Inequality and imprisonment may increase

22
New cards

What is LoĆÆc Wacquant’s argument about the neoliberal penal state?

• Economic and penal systems are interconnected

• Welfare retrenchment can accompany penal expansion

• Criminal justice manages marginalised populations

23
New cards

What is the prison–ghetto nexus?

• Wacquant’s account of links between ghettos and prisons

• Particularly racialised in the United States

• Marginalised Black populations face heightened social control

24
New cards

What do ā€˜workfare’ and ā€˜prison fare’ mean in Wacquant’s analysis?

• Workfare: welfare benefits become conditional on work-related requirements

• Prison fare: punishment and imprisonment help manage marginalised populations

25
New cards

What is meant by mass imprisonment as a social policy tool?

• Imprisonment manages surplus or marginalised populations

• Criminal records can restrict opportunities after release

• Penal control can reproduce inequality

26
New cards

What is punishment for profit?

• Criminal justice becomes a source of commercial revenue

• Private companies can profit from prisons and crime-control services

27
New cards

What is the penal-industrial complex?

• Nils Christie (2000) links penal expansion to profit opportunities

• Prison-related industries, governments and penal institutions form an alliance

28
New cards

What are potential benefits of prison industries?

• Develop prisoners’ skills and experience

• Potentially improve services and efficiency

• Generate revenue and community links

• May contribute to the wider economy

29
New cards

What are the institutional risks of punishment for profit?

• Accountability may weaken

• Standards of care may be threatened

• Oversight and regulation are important concerns

30
New cards

What are the political and economic risks of punishment for profit?

• Lobbying may influence penal policy

• Financial incentives may encourage prison expansion

• Conflicts of interest may arise

31
New cards

What are the social and ethical risks of punishment for profit?

• Exploitation of prisoners’ labour

• Human warehousing

• Cheap prison labour may disadvantage workers outside prison

32
New cards

What is economic determinism, and why is it a criticism of Marxist approaches?

• It explains punishment too narrowly through economic conditions

• Labour-market explanations may be overly broad or simplistic

33
New cards

How do Norway and the USA challenge simple Marxist explanations?

• Both are capitalist societies

• Norway has a smaller, less punitive prison system than the USA

• Capitalism alone cannot explain differences in punishment

34
New cards

What are intervening mechanisms in penal policy?

• Political decisions and institutions shape how policy develops

• Economic conditions alone may not explain specific outcomes

35
New cards

Why might punishment impose economic costs on capitalist societies?

Prisons require substantial resources

• Imprisonment can create further social problems

• Penal systems are not necessarily economically beneficial

36
New cards

What are the key contributions of Marxist approaches to punishment?

• Highlight economic power and class relations

• Explain how punishment can reproduce inequality

• Show how structural power shapes state punishment

• Offer insights without explaining every policy outcome