Property

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/573

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

574 Terms

1
New cards
Petitioner vs. respondent: which is which?
Party seeking review (e.g., on a cert. petition) / party defending the decision.
2
New cards
Cause of action
The legal claim that entitles a plaintiff to relief.
3
New cards
What is a remedy (in court)?
What the court gives the winner (damages, injunction, specific performance, ejectment).
4
New cards
What is an injunction?
Court order to do or stop doing something.
5
New cards
Nominal damages
Small award (e.g., $1) showing a legal right was violated, with no measurable harm.
6
New cards
Compensatory damages
Award that makes the plaintiff whole for measurable harm.
7
New cards
Punitive damages
Extra damages to deter wrongdoing. Barnard rule: must generally be supported by compensatory damages. Jacque exception: nominal damages for intentional trespass support punitive damages.
8
New cards
Real property
Land and things built into it.
9
New cards
Personal property
Everything else; tangible (can hold) or intangible (can't hold but has value).
10
New cards
Grantor / grantee
Person who transfers / person who receives.
11
New cards
Trover: what is it?
Action for conversion: wrongful interference with another's personal property (Armory).
12
New cards
Johnson v. M'Intosh
Holder of a grant from the U.S. beats a private grantee from Native occupants. Discovery gives the sovereign ultimate title and the exclusive power to transfer; occupants hold only a right of occupancy. Brief: P (Johnson) took from the Piankeshaw; D (M'Intosh) took from the U.S.; ejectment action. Take the rule, not the "savages" premise.
13
New cards
Johnson v. M'Intosh: how does unowned land become owned real property?
Johnson: conquest/discovery.
14
New cards
Pierson v. Post
The one who kills (or mortally wounds and takes) a wild animal beats one merely in pursuit, even with a reasonable prospect of capture.
15
New cards

Keeble v. Hickeringill (ducks in pond)

Right not to be maliciously interfered with in pursuit of one's livelihood or property.
16
New cards
Popov v. Hayashi
Baseball case: a fan who only partly gains control gets an equitable share, not full ownership.
17
New cards

Armory v. Delamirie (1722)

A finder of lost property has title good against everyone except the rightful owner. Chimney sweep found a jewel; jeweler's apprentice kept it. Property interests exist in a hierarchy. Finding does not require the item to be unowned.
18
New cards
Hannah v. Peel (1945)
The finder beats the owner of the premises who never occupied the house and was unaware of the item. Awareness and control are what the landowner lacked; the brooch was not attached to the land.
19
New cards
Jacque v. Steenberg Homes (Wis. 1997)
Nominal damages for intentional trespass to land support punitive damages. Jacques refused permission; Steenberg plowed a path anyway. Right to exclude is among the most essential property rights; deterrence rationale.
20
New cards
What is the right to exclude, and which case shows it?
Core property right; Jacque shows courts protect it even without measurable harm.
21
New cards
Edwards v. Sims (1929)
Cave runs under Lee's land; Edwards owns the entrance. Majority applies cujus est solum: surface owner owns down to the center of the earth, so Lee owns the cave beneath his land and a court-ordered survey was proper (writ of prohibition denied). Compared caves to mines.
22
New cards
Edwards v. Sims: what did Judge Logan's dissent say?
Owner of the entrance owns the cave, as far as explored and connected to the surface. Owner owns only what he can subject to his dominion (profit or use). Argues ad coelum was never true (airplanes).
23
New cards
Caves: what six rules could decide who owns a cave?
(1) Ad coelum (surface owner), (2) owner of the entrance, (3) discoverer/first occupancy, (4) all overlying owners co-own in proportion to surface, (5) party who would buy out the other, (6) the state. Epstein preferred the entrance owner (single owner avoids holdouts).
24
New cards
Edwards v. Lee's Administrator (1936)
Willful trespasser through Lee's part of the cave must pay a share (net profits, 1/3 by footage) of what he earned, not just rental value. Policy: a wrongdoer should not profit from his own wrong. Gross profits rejected. Hotel profits excluded.
25
New cards
Edwards v. Lee's Administrator: what did Judge Thomas's concurrence say?
Treats the cave as one unit co-owned by surface owners in proportion to surface; co-owner may account for the other's profits.
26
New cards
Cujus est solum (ad coelum): what does it mean?
Latin maxim: whoever owns the soil owns to the sky and to the depths. Modified for airspace (airplanes); courts still apply it below ground.
27
New cards
Trespasser
Enters private land without the owner's permission.
28
New cards
Ejectment
Civil action by the true owner to remove a trespasser.
29
New cards
Statute of limitations (SOL)
Deadline for the owner to sue. Illinois is 20 years; some states are shorter.
30
New cards
AP is not a transfer: what does that mean?
When the SOL runs and all elements were met for the full period, the old title is extinguished and a new title arises in the possessor.
31
New cards
Adverse possession: what is relation back?
Ownership relates back to the day of entry.
32
New cards
Adverse possession: what are the two requirements for title to pass?
(1) SOL on ejectment runs, and (2) every element is met for the entire period.
33
New cards

Elements of Adverse Possession


(1) actual possession, (2) open and notorious use, (3) exclusive possession, (4) hostile possession, and (5) continuous possession for the statutory period.

34
New cards
AP element: what is actual entry?
Physically occupying the land; generally you gain only what you actually possess (color of title is the exception).
35
New cards
AP element: what does exclusive mean?
Use as the true owner would; sharing with others is fine, sharing with the owner is fatal.
36
New cards
AP element: what does open and notorious mean?
Visible to a reasonably diligent owner (objective; the owner's actual knowledge is irrelevant). Constructive notice.
37
New cards
AP element: what does hostile / adverse / claim of right mean?
Hostile to the owner's title, not personal ill will. Permission negates it.
38
New cards
AP element: what does continuous and uninterrupted mean?
Used as a true owner would use that kind of land. Absence is fine if consistent with normal use (e.g., summer home).
39
New cards
AP: interruption vs. abandonment vs. absence, which restarts the clock?
Interruption (by owner or court action) or abandonment restarts the clock; mere absence does not.
40
New cards
AP: do some states require paying taxes?
Some states also require the possessor to pay taxes.
41
New cards
AP state of mind: what is the objective approach?
Possessor's state of mind irrelevant; look at the inattentive owner (Chaplin v. Sanders / Hogan view).
42
New cards
AP state of mind: what is the good-faith approach?
Only a mistaken possessor who thought they owned the land wins; knowing trespassers lose.
43
New cards
AP state of mind: what is the aggressive / bad-faith approach?
Knowing trespasser who meant to make the land theirs; may have to pay FMV.
44
New cards
AP: whose state of mind matters, the possessor's or the owner's?
Only the possessor's matters, never the owner's.
45
New cards
Color of title: what is it and what does it do?
Defective deed. Possessor can be treated as owning everything the deed purports to convey.
46
New cards
Constructive possession: what is it?
Legal possession of land not directly occupied, usually via color of title.
47
New cards
Tacking: what is it?
Adding successive possessors' periods to reach the SOL. Requires privity.
48
New cards
Privity (for tacking): what is it?
Legal relationship between successive possessors (e.g., a deed, will, or inheritance). Successive trespassers cannot tack.
49
New cards
Howard v. Kunto (Wash.)
Tacking allowed between a predecessor and successor when the disputed land was intended to be in the deed but was mistakenly omitted from the description, even without a legal claim of right. Summer-home use satisfied continuity.
50
New cards
Marengo Cave: how does AP apply to caves?
Caves: ad coelum (ownership extends up and down) vs. what counts as open and notorious for underground possession.
51
New cards
AP: how do disabilities and tolling work?
Disability (e.g., minority, insanity) tolls the SOL only if it exists when the cause of action accrues (at entry). Disabilities cannot be tacked, and the clock starts at entry.
52
New cards
Can you adversely possess government land?
Government land cannot be adversely possessed.
53
New cards
AP against a life tenant: who does the clock run against?
Runs against the life tenant, not the remainderman, until the remainder becomes possessory.
54
New cards
AP and defeasible fees: possibility of reverter vs. right of entry
Possibility of reverter: SOL runs. Right of entry: possession is permissive until the right is exercised.
55
New cards
Ejectment defense vs. quiet title action: what's the difference?
Ejectment: court denies removal because title already passed. Quiet title: possessor sues to get a judgment and record documentation.
56
New cards
AP boundary doctrines: agreed boundary, acquiescence, estoppel
Agreed boundary, acquiescence, estoppel can fix a line without full AP.
57
New cards
Mistaken improver vs. knowing trespasser: how do remedies differ?
Remedies differ; innocent improvers often get compensation or an option to buy.
58
New cards
What are the purposes of adverse possession?
Stale claims, quiet titles, protect attachment to land, reward productive use, penalize inattentive owners, marketability.
59
New cards
Is title from adverse possession marketable?
Title that rests on AP is not marketable without a quiet title judgment.
60
New cards
Special warranty deed and AP: can the grantee sue if the SOL ran under a prior owner?
Defect arises when SOL fully runs; if that happened under a prior owner, grantee cannot sue the grantor.
61
New cards
What is adverse possession (AP)?
(1) A statute of limitations on ejectment plus (2) a change of title that relates back to entry. Origin: Statute of 21 James I (1623), 20 years.
62
New cards
AP: what are its purposes?
Punish the inattentive true owner; reward the improving trespasser; put land to productive use; clear titles.
63
New cards
AP: what are the elements?
Actual occupation (only what you actually possess, except color of title); exclusive; open and notorious; continuous (as a true owner would use it); for the statutory period; adverse/under claim of right. Some states add paying taxes.
64
New cards
AP: what does exclusive require?
Sharing with the true owner is fatal; inviting others in is fine.
65
New cards
AP: what is the open and notorious test?
A constructive notice test: would put a reasonably diligent owner on notice. Not about the owner's actual knowledge.
66
New cards
AP: what does hostile mean?
Not enmity; possession inconsistent with the true owner's title.
67
New cards
AP state of mind: what are the three approaches?
Objective/irrelevant (UK, Hogan); good-faith mistaken trespasser (Bassindale); aggressive trespasser who knowingly claims (Hubbard), who in some states must pay FMV (forced sale). True owner's state of mind never matters.
68
New cards
AP: what does continuous mean?
Not constant. Absence means nothing; abandonment (AP voluntarily gives up) or interruption (owner's actual entry or a judicial action) restarts the clock.
69
New cards
AP: what is color of title and what does it get you?
Defective deed. Not required anywhere, but may give a shorter SOL, constructive possession of all described land after actual possession of some, and a hostility presumption.
70
New cards
AP: what are the two kinds of tacking?
(1) Physical: deed from X to Y includes land X adversely possessed. (2) Successive APs: needs privity (reasonable connection between occupants). Howard v. Kunto: privity allowed even where the occupied parcel was the wrong one.
71
New cards
AP boundary doctrines: how does each work?
Agreed boundary (uncertainty plus agreement); acquiescence (less than SOL is evidence of agreement); estoppel (one neighbor's representations plus other's reliance, or silence while the neighbor spends).
72
New cards
AP: how are mistaken improvers treated?
Intentional encroachers can always be forced to remove. Innocent improvers: force a conveyance, let owner buy at FMV, or order removal after weighing hardship.
73
New cards
AP disabilities (tolling): which ones count, and when are they measured?
Minority, unsound mind, incarceration. Tolling postpones the START of the SOL, never interrupts it. Measured at the moment of entry; later disabilities are ignored; disabilities do not stack (no tacking of disabilities).
74
New cards
AP tolling math: what are the three situations?
Situation 1: no disability at entry, SOL runs normally. Situation 2: disability ends before tolling period runs out, SOL starts at the end of the disability (ex: SOL 21, TO 16, entry 2000 gives title 2023). Situation 3: disability outlasts tolling period, SOL starts when tolling period ends (ex: TO age 2, entry 2000, tolling 10, title 2031). Tolling can only lengthen the period for the AP, never shorten it.
75
New cards
AP: who can you NOT adversely possess against?
The government need not watch its land like a private owner. Also: you can AP only against the person entitled to possession (a life tenant, not the remainderman).
76
New cards
Marengo Cave (Ind.): what was the holding?
Cave entrance on one owner's land; question whether commercial use of the cave is open and notorious against the owner above. Squatter's claim failed.
77
New cards
AP: where does the possessor's title come from?
AP is NOT a transfer from the true owner. The old title is extinguished and the AP holds a NEW title that relates back to the day of entry.
78
New cards
Quiet title vs. ejectment: who sues in each?
Quiet title: AP sues to have title declared in her. Ejectment: true owner sues to remove the possessor, and AP pleads AP as a defense.
79
New cards
AP relation back: does the possessor owe the owner for profits earned?
When AP wins, ownership dates from entry, so AP owes the true owner nothing for profits earned (Andy and the apple orchard).
80
New cards
AP continuous use: is seasonal use enough?
Use as a true owner of that type of land would (seasonal cabin, summer home, one month a year is enough if that is normal use).
81
New cards
AP: can permissive use ripen into title?
Permissive use never ripens into title (neighbors using a shared yard by informal agreement).
82
New cards
AP exclusivity: what if two neighbors share a driveway?
A driveway used by both neighbors fails exclusivity; AP must exclude the true owner.
83
New cards
AP tacking: can a changing group of squatters tack?
No privity between a changing group of transients, so none gains title.
84
New cards
AP interruption: what happens when the owner removes the fence?
True owner's entry and removal of the fence restarts the clock (Tom v. Frank).
85
New cards
AP against a life tenant: what does the possessor get?
AP runs only against the person entitled to possess. Against a life tenant AP gets only the life estate (pur autre vie); the remainderman can eject when the life tenant dies.
86
New cards
AP color of title: example with a defective deed
A defective deed (seller was an unauthorized trustee) gives constructive possession of all described land even if only part is occupied.
87
New cards
AP state-of-mind problem: what intent helps the possessor (Armen)?
To prevail Armen needs intent to own: "I intend to improve up to my line, whatever it is, and no further" is the weakest state of mind. Best facts for the true owner: a jurisdiction requiring knowing bad faith plus a trespasser who did not intend to take the strip.
88
New cards
AP in caves: is underground use open and notorious?
Underground use not open and notorious to the owner above (Marengo Cave).
89
New cards
AP improvement remedies: knowing vs. innocent encroachers
Knowing encroacher can be made to remove; innocent encroacher: balance hardships or owner transfers title for FMV. A knowing trespasser does not lose her own land.
90
New cards
AP and the government: example (national park)
No AP against a national park or government land.
91
New cards
AP disability problem (SOL 10, tolling 10, majority 18): how do you solve it?
Heir age 3 in 2013, entry 2014: disability existed at entry? Only if the true owner at ENTRY was disabled. If so, SOL starts at the earlier of end of the disability or end of the tolling period. No tacking of disabilities (Otto incompetent 2015, died 2025, heir age 5: SOL runs 2025 to 2035).
92
New cards
AP against an FSD vs. an FSSCS: when does the clock run?
After the FSD condition happens, holder's possession is adverse immediately (reverter is automatic): SOL runs from the event. After FSSCS condition, possession is permissive until owner exercises the right of entry, so AP clock does not run.
93
New cards
Is every adverse possession also a trespass?
All AP begins as trespass, so the owner's trespass claim exists even if title is lost.
94
New cards
What are the elements of a valid gift?
Donative intent, delivery, acceptance. Intent plus the right kind of delivery under the circumstances makes the gift.
95
New cards
Gift: what is donative intent?
Present intent to transfer ownership now, not later.
96
New cards
Gift: what is actual (manual) delivery?
Physical change of custody. Required whenever it is possible.
97
New cards
Gift: what is constructive delivery?
Handing over access or control (keys to a car).
98
New cards
Gift: what is symbolic delivery?
Handing over a representative object or writing (a letter or deed).
99
New cards
Gift: when is acceptance presumed?
Presumed for gifts of value.
100
New cards
Gift: when can't a gift be taken back (irrevocability)?
Once all three elements are met, the property is the donee's and the gift cannot be taken back.