1/8
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Osterholtz 2025
Anna Osterholtz is a bioarchaeologist who works at Mississippi State University
She is an expert in the analysis of fragmented and commingled human remains
She also has a strong research interest in the relationship between the living and the dead and how it is negotiated through mortuary practices – the article you’re reading is an example of that work
Theory – Poetics and processing
The repeated mentions of ‘Poetics’ refer to a theoretical framework whose basics you’re already familiar with:
This model discusses mortuary treatment (processing the body by embalming, removal of the soft tissues etc.) as communication
Those who send the message (process the corpse) interact with those who receive it (witnesses), making mortuary processing a kind of performance
This communication can express and reinforce the way the dead person is seen – as a respected elder, a social inferior, a dangerous criminal, etc.
How the body is processed is part of this communication – e.g., bodies disposed of as trash in 19th c medical schools (p. 301) were reclassed as medical ‘objects’
This communication may cement social stratification and power relationships
Dead bodies in museums
Osterholtz’s article focuses in part on the complex ethical problems surrounding the curation and display of the dead
The dead have a long history in museums including
Cabinets of curiosity – early (before ca. 1850) collections of natural ‘wonders’ and ‘curiosities’ kept by scholars and the wealthy
Anatomical museums – collections for medical instruction
As public museums emerged, mummies and other archaeological dead bodies became part of their collections and are still included in many collections today – used in research and education
Reevaluating dead bodies in museums
The issues discussed by Osterholtz illustrate some important questions we face today:
How should we respond to changing ethical standards?
How do we balance competing interests of research, education, the dead and their descendants?
How do we acknowledge and try to address past injustices?
This discussion began with a 20th c movement challenging the excavation, study and display of Indigenous ancestors
Skeletal collections, power and race
Anthropology emerged in Europe & the USA in the 1800s and its early ideas reflect the attitudes of those cultures
The first collections of archaeological human remains were formed in the 1800s, in the context of those attitudes
These collections later became the core of growing 20th c university and museum skeletal collections in many nations
Anthropological views on race changed over the 20th century, and by the 1950s/1960s, anthropological theorists rejected the idea of white superiority.
In the USA and Australia, passage of local state laws created pressure leading to national-level legislation to protect graves and repatriate remains (Australia in 1984, USA in 1990)
In Canada there is no federal law governing this, but provincial laws on human remains and heritage sites, plus internal ethical guidelines of museums and universities, provide many of the same protections
Skeletal collections, power and race: Anthropology emerged in Europe & the USA in the 1800s and its early ideas reflect the attitudes of those cultures
Early researchers (including anthropologists) claimed that humans were divided into clear biological races, and that white people were scientifically proven to be mentally, morally and culturally ‘superior’
These inaccurate claims were used by colonial powers to justify practices such as slavery and colonization of Indigenous lands
Skeletal collections, power and race: The first collections of archaeological human remains were formed in the 1800s, in the context of those attitudes
In places such as USA, Canada and Australia this involved excavation without the permission and against the wishes of Indigenous peoples
Skeletal collections, power and race: Anthropological views on race changed over the 20th century, and by the 1950s/1960s, anthropological theorists rejected the idea of white superiority. But:
This did not change the 19th c history/origins of the collections
Excavation of indigenous archaeological burials against the wishes of descendants and without their permission continued. This was defended as a key part of the study of humanity’s past – and thus ‘more important’ than the wishes of indigenous groups
Skeletal collections, power and race: This began to change in the 1970s
Protests began to be organized in the USA, Canada and Australia
Local grassroots activists like Maria Pearson called for protection of Indigenous burials and repatriation of Indigenous human remains