1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the organic analogy used by functionalists, and how do society and biological organisms function as systems?
→ Functionalists use an organic analogy to describe society, comparing society to a biological organism.
→ Both organisms and societies are self-regulating systems of inter-related, interdependent parts that fit together in fixed ways.
→ In the body, these parts are organs and cells; in society, they are institutions (such as the education system and the family) and individual roles (such as teacher and mother).
What are 'system needs', and why are they essential for both biological organisms and the social system?
→ Organisms have basic needs, such as nutrition, and will die if these are not met.
→ Similarly, functionalists see the social system as having basic needs that must be met if it is to survive.
→ For example, society's members must be socialised if society is to continue.
What is a 'function' according to functionalists, and how do parts of the system contribute to survival?
→ The function of any part of a system is the contribution it makes to meeting the system's needs and thus ensuring its survival.
→ Just as the circulatory system of the body carries nutrients and oxygen to the tissues, the economy helps maintain the social system by meeting the need for food and shelter.
What is the central question sociology tries to answer for Parsons, and how does he argue social order is achieved?
→ For Parsons, the central question that sociology tries to answer is 'how is social order possible?' and how individuals are able to cooperate harmoniously.
→ Parsons argues that social order is achieved through the existence of a shared culture or, in his words, a central value system.
→ A culture is a set of norms, values, beliefs, and goals shared by members of a society, providing a framework that allows individuals to cooperate by laying down behavioural rules and defining goals to pursue.
What is 'value consensus', and what role does it play in maintaining society according to Parsons?
→ Social order is only possible so long as members of society agree on these norms and values, which Parsons calls value consensus.
→ Value consensus is the glue that holds society together.
How does value consensus make social order possible by integrating individuals into the social system?
→ The basic function of the value consensus is to make social order possible by integrating individuals into the social system, directing them towards meeting the system's needs.
→ For example, to ensure people's material needs are met through work, there needs to be a set of specific rules of conduct or norms, such as rules about punctuality and how to obtain jobs.
How does socialisation act as a mechanism for ensuring individuals conform to shared norms?
→ Socialisation ensures the system's needs are met by teaching individuals to want to do what the system requires them to do.
→ Through the socialisation process, individuals internalise the system's norms and values so that society becomes part of their personality structure.
→ Different agencies of socialisation, such as the family, education system, media, and religion, all contribute to this process.
How does social control ensure conformity, and what is the overall result of integrating individuals into a shared value system?
→ Social control uses positive sanctions to reward conformity (such as college diplomas for educational success) and negative sanctions to punish deviance (such as stigmatising dropouts as layabouts).
→ Because individuals are integrated through socialisation and social control into a shared value system, their behaviour is oriented towards pursuing society's shared goals and meeting its needs.
→ Individual behaviour becomes relatively predictable and stable, allowing cooperation between people and making orderly social life possible.
What are individual actions and status-roles in Parsons' model of the social system?
→ At the bottom of Parsons' model are individual actions, where each action we perform is governed by specific norms or rules.
→ These norms come in clusters called status-roles.
→ Statuses are the positions that exist in a given social system, such as a teacher, while roles are sets of norms telling us how the occupant of a status must carry out their duties, such as not showing favouritism and being knowledgeable.
How do status-roles, institutions, and sub-systems build up to form the social system as a whole in Parsons' model?
→ Status-roles come in clusters known as institutions, such as the family being made up of related roles like father, mother, and child.
→ Related institutions are grouped together into sub-systems, such as shops, farms, factories, and banks forming the economic sub-system whose function is to meet society's material needs.
→ Finally, all of these sub-systems together make up the social system as a whole.
What is the AGIL schema, and which sub-system meets the need for Adaptation?
→ Parsons identifies four basic system needs known as the AGIL schema, where each need is met by a separate sub-system of institutions.
→ Adaptation: the social system meets its members' material needs through the economic sub-system.
What is Goal Attainment in Parsons' AGIL schema, and which sub-system performs this function?
→ Goal Attainment: society needs to set goals and allocate resources to achieve them.
→ This is the function of the political sub-system, through institutions such as parliament.
What is Integration in Parsons' AGIL schema, and which sub-system fulfils this role?
→ Integration: the different parts of the system must be integrated together to pursue shared goals.
→ This is the role of the sub-system of religion, education, and the media.
What is Latency in Parsons' AGIL schema, and what two key functions does the kinship sub-system provide?
→ Latency refers to processes that maintain society over time.
→ The kinship sub-system provides pattern maintenance (socialising individuals to go on performing the roles society requires) and tension management (providing a place to let off steam after the stresses of work).
How does Parsons distinguish between instrumental needs and expressive needs within the AGIL schema?
→ Adaptation and goal attainment are instrumental needs, where instrumental refers to the means to an end, such as producing food to sustain the population.
→ Integration and latency are expressive needs, since they involve the expression or channelling of emotions.
→ By carrying out their respective functions, the four sub-systems ensure that all society's needs are met and social stability is maintained.
What are the two types of society identified by Parsons, and how do their norms differ?
→ Parsons identifies two types of society: traditional and modern, each with its own set of norms.
→ In modern society, individuals pursue their individual self-interest, achieve their status, and are all judged by the same universalistic standards (such as equality before the law).
→ In traditional societies, individuals are expected to put collective interests first, status is ascribed, and they are judged by particularistic standards (such as different laws for nobles and commoners).
What is 'structural differentiation', and how does Parsons use the organic analogy to explain how societies evolve?
→ For Parsons, social change is a gradual, evolutionary process of increasing complexity and structural differentiation.
→ Using the organic analogy, organisms evolved from simple structures like amoebas (where a single cell performs all essential functions) to complex organisms like humans with many different organs each performing a specialised function.
→ Similarly, in traditional society, a single institution (the kinship system) performs many functions: organising production and consumption (adaptation), providing political leadership (goal attainment), socialising members (latency), and performing religious functions (integration).
→ As societies develop, the kinship system loses these functions to separate, functionally specialised institutions such as factories, political parties, schools, and churches, each meeting a different need.
How does Parsons explain gradual social change through 'moving equilibrium'?
→ Parsons sees gradual change occurring through moving equilibrium.
→ As a change occurs in one part of the system, it produces compensatory changes in other parts.
→ For example, the rise of industry brings a change in the family from extended to nuclear, allowing society to gradually change from one type to another.
What is Merton's (1968) internal criticism of Parsons' assumption of 'indispensability'?
→ Parsons assumes that everything in society (such as the family and religion) is functionally indispensable in its existing form.
→ Merton argues this is an untested assumption and points to the possibility of 'functional alternatives'.
→ For example, while Parsons assumes primary socialisation is best performed by the nuclear family, one-parent families or communes may perform it just as well or better.
What is Merton's internal criticism of Parsons' assumption of 'functional unity'?
→ Parsons assumes all parts of society are tightly integrated into a single whole or unity, each part is functional for all the rest, and change in one part has a knock-on effect on all other parts.
→ Merton argues complex modern societies have many parts that are only distantly related, meaning some parts have 'functional autonomy' (independence) from others.
→ For example, it is hard to see connections between the structure of banking and the rules of netball.
What is Merton's internal criticism of 'universal functionalism', and what is the central point behind his criticisms of Parsons?
→ Parsons assumes everything in society performs a positive function for society as a whole, whereas Merton argues some things may be functional for some groups and dysfunctional for others.
→ The idea of dysfunction suggests there may be conflicts of interest and that some groups have the power to keep arrangements in place that benefit them at the expense of others (an idea developed further by conflict theorists).
→ The central point behind Merton's criticisms is that we cannot simply assume, as Parsons does, that society is always and necessarily a smooth-running, well-integrated system.
What is Merton's distinction between 'manifest' and 'latent' functions, and how does the Hopi Native American rain-dance illustrate this?
→ Manifest functions are the intended functions of a social activity, whereas latent functions are the unintended functions that actors themselves may not be aware of.
→ For example, in times of drought, the Hopi Native Americans performed a rain-dance with the manifest (intended) function of producing rain, which from a scientific viewpoint is unlikely to achieve its goal.
→ However, the ritual also had a latent (unintended) function of promoting a sense of solidarity in times of hardship, when individuals might otherwise be tempted to look after themselves at the expense of others.
→ Merton's distinction is useful in helping to reveal the hidden connections between social phenomena that actors themselves may not recognise.
Why is functionalism criticised for being 'teleological'?
→ Teleology is the idea that things exist because of their effect or function.
→ For example, the functionalist claim that the family exists because children need to be socialised is teleological because it explains the existence of the family in terms of its effect.
→ Critics argue that a real explanation identifies a cause, which logically must come before its effect, whereas functionalism explains the existence of the family in terms of socialisation, which can only come after families already exist.
Why is functionalism criticised for being 'unscientific'?
→ Critics argue that a theory is only scientific if in principle it is falsifiable by testing, which is not true of functionalism.
→ For example, functionalists see deviance as both dysfunctional (since society's needs can only be met if individuals conform) and functional (such as by reinforcing social solidarity).
→ Because deviance is treated as both functional and dysfunctional, the theory cannot be disproved and is therefore unscientific.
Why do conflict theorists such as Marxists criticise functionalism for its inability to explain conflict and change?
→ Conflict theorists argue that functionalism's inability to explain conflict and change arises partly from the organic analogy, which views organisms as stable, harmonious systems where all parts work together for the common good.
→ Marxists argue that society is not a harmonious whole, but is instead based on exploitation and divided into classes with conflicting interests and unequal power.
→ Stability is simply the result of the dominant class preventing change through coercion or ideological manipulation, and 'shared' values are merely a cloak concealing the interests of the dominant class.
Why do conflict theorists view functionalism as a 'conservative ideology legitimating the status quo'?
→ Functionalism focuses on harmony and stability rather than conflict and change, and relies on assumptions of 'universal functionalism' and 'indispensability', which justify the existing social order as inevitable and desirable.
→ Critics argue this approach legitimates the privileged position of powerful groups who would have the most to lose from any fundamental changes in society.
What is Wrong's (1961) action perspective criticism of functionalism's view of the individual?
→ Wrong (1961) criticises functionalism's 'over-socialised' or deterministic view of the individual.
→ In the functionalist view, the social system uses socialisation to shape people's behaviour so they meet the system's needs by performing prescribed roles, leaving individuals with no free will or choice, acting as mere puppets whose strings are pulled by the social system.
→ From an action perspective, this is fundamentally mistaken because while functionalism sees human beings as shaped by society, the action approach argues that individuals create society by their interactions.
Why do action approaches criticise functionalism for 'reifying' society?
→ Functionalism reifies society by treating it as a distinct 'thing' over and above individuals, with its own needs.
→ By contrast, action approaches argue that society is not a thing 'out there' with its own independent existence.
→ For action approaches, the only social reality is the one that individuals construct by giving meaning to their worlds.
What are the postmodernist criticisms of functionalism?
→ Postmodernists argue that functionalism assumes society is stable and orderly, meaning it cannot account for the diversity and instability in today's postmodern society.
→ In the postmodernist view, functionalism is an example of a meta-narrative or 'big story' that attempts to create a model of the workings of society as a whole.
→ According to postmodernists, such an overall theory is no longer possible because today's society is increasingly fragmented.
What is the overall conclusion regarding functionalism's contributions, and what does Craib (1992) note about Parsons' theory?
→ Functionalism seeks to answer the fundamental question of how social order is possible, even though its answer neglects conflict and is too deterministic.
→ Merton's notion of dysfunctions and his distinction between manifest and latent functions provide useful starting points for research.
→ Many of functionalism's critics end up 'borrowing' its basic notion that society is a system of interdependent parts.
→ Finally, as Craib (1992) notes, Parsons' theory 'has its faults, but at least it is a theory of society as a whole'.