1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
gestalt approach
An organized whole that is perceived as more than the sum of its parts
Importance of problem representation
Consider problem solving as a process involving reorganization and restructuring
Wallas (1926)
Wallas (1926)
Preparation (initial representation)
Illumination (insight)
Incubation
Preparation (initial representation)
Consciously investigating the problem from all angles, gathering data, and defining the challenge
Illumination (insight)
The sudden, intuitive "Aha!" moment or flash of insight when the solution surfaces (often preceded by an intimation or a fringe-consciousness feeling that an answer is near)
The sudden realization of a problem’s solution
Metcalf and Wiebe (1987): “Feeling of warmth” procedure
Metcalf and Wiebe (1987): “Feeling of warmth” procedure
The purpose was to demonstrate a difference between how people solve insight and non-insight problems
Different types of problems: algebra vs. insight
More likely to have an “aha” experience with insight problems
What is an “aha” experience?
restructure/reorganize/re-represent the problem
Shows People progress through the problem space as they solve a problem
Incubation
Stepping away from active, conscious thought while the mind unconsciously processes and reorganizes the information
Silveria (1971)
Results:
30 min straight: 55%
30 min split by ½ hour: 64%
30 min split by 4 hours: 85%
Explanation?
…

modern views of problem solving
Problems representation
Task conditions
Task instructions
Prior knowledge
leads to…
Water Jar Problem: B-A-2C
mental set
the tendency to approach a problem in a certain way because of preconceived notions
Oftentimes do this because the method worked in the past
Matchstick problem
Arrange six watches to form four equilateral triangles
9 Dot Problem
Without lifting your pencil from the paper, draw no moe than four lines that will cross through all nine dots
John and Mary riddle
John and Mary were found dead in a locked room. The following objects were found in the room with them: some water, a table, a dog, a chair, and broken glass. How did John and Mary die?
Wiley (1998)
Wiley (1998)
Used a variant of the remote associates task:
Blue–knife–cottage
Cheese
Method: high and low baseball knowledge groups
Gave words set in which the first wors was baseball related
Baseball interpretation ultimately doesn’t work
Plate→broken→shot (glass)
Results: High domain knowledge can actually hurt creative problem-solving when misleading information is present.
When a puzzle included a misleading clue related to their area of expertise (such as baseball), experts solved significantly fewer problems than novices who lacked that specialized knowledge.
Fixation effect
Bilalic et al. (2008)
Method:
Used chess experts
Asked to find the shortest way to checkmate
Two solutions: well-known, 5 moves vs. less known, 3 moves
Results:
Encountering a misleading, familiar chess problem reduced the problem-solving performance of chess experts down to the level of players roughly three standard deviations below them in skill
Even high-level chess experts (Candidate Masters, Masters, and International Masters) fall victim to the Einstellung effect when a familiar, suboptimal solution is readily available.
The Paradox of the Expert
“Heavier than air flying machines are impossible.” Lord Kelvin, president, Roya Society, 1895
“No flying machine will ever fly from New York to paris” Orville Wright
Novel object
Doesn’t carry the same expectations like things we’re familiar with or things with specific functions
Maier (1931): two string problem
candle problem (Duncker 1945)
only 39% solved within 10 minutes
functional fixedness
tendency to use an object only in its customary or usual way
Fortress story
Radiation problem
analogically problems
Solving by analogy
Transfer
transfer
the ability to shift experience from one problem solving problem to another
Source problem→target problem
Gick and Holyyoak (1980)
Method: Exp 4
Read fortress story (told for a memory test)
Gave radiation problem to solve
No-hint group vs. hint group
Results:
20% transfer vs. 92% transfer
Failure to spontaneously transfer
Novick and Holyoak (1991)
Requirements for transfer:
Noticing (retrieval of appropriate problem)
Mapping
Adapting
Which appears to be the issue in the Gick and Holyoak (1980)?
Perfectto et al. (1983) Method
Gave statements; had subjects rate them for truthfulness
“Before any game, there is no score.”
“A minister marries several people each week.”
3-minute delay
Gave problems with a direct connection to earlier statements
Problems with access
Forms of similarity
Similarity in surface features
Similarity in underlying structure
Overattention to surface features
