MTH References Revision

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/16

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

17 Terms

1
New cards

Whatmore, 2006

  • Materialist efforts during the more-than-human turn centre on new ways of approaching the nexus between bio (life) and geo (earth) as the modality of life is politically and technologically entangled; this is a recharge and return rather than a sudden encounter

  • This shift is bound up in an intensification of the interface between life and informative science and politics as witnessed in several public controversies since the 1990s including GM and robotics were entanglements create a new interest in animal cultures, posthumanism and affect 

  • A return to the livingness of the world shifts from the idea of the world ‘out there’ to the corporality of the ‘in here’ human where the body bridges the gap between technology and ecology 

  • Attention is focused on the attention of bodily involvements in the landscape co-fabricated by more-than-human bodies and interrogate the human as a subject of ongoing co-fabrication; energies are redistributed to focus on the connection between bodies and worlds as humans are always in composition with nonhumanity 

  • There is a shift from discourse to practice, meaning to affect, an effort towards more than human enquiry and politics of identity to a politics of knowledge brought about by mundane and intimate aspects of social life where biogeography are entangled

  • There is a departing from human exceptionalism to distributed agency as the capacity to act is not exclusively human, this is now distributed across heterogeneous assemblages; this decentralising raises issues in experimental methods, political and ethical responsibilities and environmental politics


2
New cards

Whatmore, 2008

  • The Enlightenment dualism between nature and society has endured a pervasive tension in the configuration of scientific knowledge and authority in geography and Empire as institutional and ontological separations prevail; however, there is now a reawakening of the question of nature

  • Hybrid geographies trace a range of social theories to emphasize interactions and positionality, they study the living rather than social life in a plural and heterogenous articulation of collective capacities

  • Social agency is radically decentered and spun between social actors, it is decoupled from the subject/object binary and entwined in many new combinations in actor-networks where a multiplicity of different agents hold each other in position; non-humans are vital in networks of collective capacity where divisions are eroded in a purified world

  • Corporal properties and situated knowledges are key in this commotion of networks composed of multiple actors as the body, motion and relation come to shape knowledge and hybridities

  • The nature/society binary is refused to instead accept a world inhibited by heterogeneous social encounter in plural networks


3
New cards

Lorimer & Hodgetts, 2024

  • MTH geographers begin by rejecting the dualistic ontology that understands humans as exceptional and defined in opposition to Nature, this stemmed from 5 beginnings in law, news, film and academia that began to understand that nature is not single, timeless and separate but instead there is a new multiple understanding of material worlds

  • There is a rethinking of nature and humans in a non-dualistic manner that moves towards a human-nature hybridity and entanglement as the humanist ideal of the rational, separate and elevated human is abandoned 

  • Material agency is extended to many actors other than humans, claims to Western scientific universal truths are replaced by an understanding of knowledge as situated and made and relations and processes make up humans and natural systems

  • Multinaturalism captures the new multiplicity of worlds to conceptualise the hybrid, non-dualistic relations MTH scholars draw attention to


4
New cards

Lorimer & Hodgetts, 2024

  • Humanism has been a dominant paradigm in Western thought and culture for several hundred years with the idea that humans are exceptional and separate from the rest of nature in a dualist ontology; this was theorised by a collection of philosophers responding to the Dark Ages to recentre culture on human understandings rather than myth, superstition and religion

  • This claims that man is at the centre of all and entirely distinct from animals and nonhuman entities, humans are a special category of life on a pedestal and at the middle of the universe distinguished by their capacity to reason and pursue moral action; nature was a set of resources amenable to technological improvement

  • The dualist ontology began to be challenged by scientific revelations in evolution and the human as a holobiont hosting a number of organisms, work on human and animal cognitions and environmental science also challenged this

  • The epistemology of truth as objective was also challenged as scientists were called on to account for bodies, practices and technologies involved in creating knowledge, science occurred in context and alienated nature

  • Politics of humanism were also questioned as it emphasis the potential for human freedom however this was not unequally distributed as colonialism and slavery racialized and dehumanised those who did not fit into the ideal figure of the universal straight white man; human centrism also led to consequences for animal suffering and environmental harms


5
New cards

Lorimer, 2012

  • The recent diagnosis of the Anthropocene represents the public death of a modern understanding of nature as removed from society as humans become an earth changing force; nature is no longer pure, singular and stable and environmentalism should be reoriented as a result

  • This single nature should be reconceptualised into a multinaturalism where ecology is multiple, evolving, affective, valued and contested in hybrid forms; this challenges the privileged place of the human subject in environmental change

  • There is a shift to fluidity of time as nature is nonlinear and in non-equilibrium; interdisciplinary approaches draw from animal studies, postcolonialism and feminism to reshape agency and time with a growing interest in networked diverse spaces formed from human and nonhuman ecologies and mobilities

  • A universal science is reshaped to give nature a voice to speak for itself as agency is redistributed and there is value placed on the ability to adapt; there is a new commitment to assemblages, affect, experimentation and epistemological pluralism

  • As a result, conservation must shift to adapt to uncertainties associated with climate change and the Anthropocene to shift to openness, recovery and discovery, there is a new enthusiasm for experimental and emerging futures displayed in restoration and rewilding or reintroduction of keystone species

  • Conservation moves away from action plans and targets to experimental modes, epistemological pluralism and non-human dynamics that are fluid rather than static targets 

  • Scholars and practitioners must embrace multinatural geographies and approaches that are process-oriented, attuned to more than human agency and committed to managing emergent hybrid environments ethically in a rapidly changing world


6
New cards

Barry, 2020

  • Scientific research is set up in a paradigm that allows environmental problems to be treated as negative and along the lines of a model leading to a particular solution, Foucault and ANT see problems as a positive account that opens up to a field of multiple possible solutions and future problems

  • There is a need to venture outside of mathematics and beyond the standardised procedures of the lab to address environmental problems that are situational, specific and associated with a wide range of thoughts

  • Nature is supplied agency in problems and representations as well as publics having a role in the definition and resolution of problems as public involvement in politics is multiple and draws out particular characteristics of contested objects in political life; problems should be resolved not through the application of a technique but through democratic debate by multiple concerned publics

  • Environmental problems are caught up in a nexus of relations with political, economic and cultural concerns as multiple lines of contestation are gathered in a single political situation; this opens up to a range of future and contestable possibilities part of long-term unfolding public controversies; this is also formed through techno-ecological encounters as elements, chemicals, non-human forces and infrastructures interact in unpredictable ways 

  • There is a need to be attentive to the emergence of problems as a product of social and economic forces that pre-exist the problematization combined with situations as situationally specific and geographically variable forming inevitable differences and solutions

  • The ANT produces a sociological approach to the study of problems to move away from life sciences to politically researching environmental problems, their historical dynamics and situated nature; this forms a call for interdisciplinary research and collaboration between natural and social scientists, historians, experts and non-experts


7
New cards

Whatmore, 2009

  • Knowledge controversy events give rise to new ways of practicing relations between science and democracy that focuses on environment knowledge claims and technology, this leads to a distribution of expertise including that of social scientists in ‘hot situations’ of ontological disturbance

  • Controversies see expertise redistributed to ever growing varied cast of characters and disorder conditions to force a slowing down of reasoning, this creates space and opportunities to form different awareness of problems and situations; where scientific knowledge claims were once called upon to settle disputes, contestation now becomes a matter of routine

  • Interdisciplinary practices sees knowledge production formed from a distributed web of experts from a wide variety of sites driven by a logic of innovation and societal accountability promoting policy relevance

  • Controversies are mapped in paristan science moving towards the hybrid nature of socio-technical MTH encounters and are tackled through the emergence of demoscience and competency groups that attempt to map and navigate uncertainties by slowing down and interrogating claimed universal explanations

  • There is a shift from a knowledge economy to a knowledge polity where controversies are generative events mobilised to articulate an associative politics concerned with the capacity of citizens to act together and seek multilingual interpretations with commitments to MTH knowledge practices, socialisation of scientific knowledge and investment in redistributing expertise


8
New cards

Haraway, 2013

  • Academic and activist feminist enquiry has repeatedly tried to come to terms with the question of what is meant by positivist objectivity as the imagined onlooker constitutes an invisible conspiracy of masculinity, science and philosophy with grants and laboratories that can affect others by telling parables about objectivity and scientific methods

  • Social constructions maintain the ideological doctrine of scientific method and epistemology formed through the ‘God trick’ and gaze from nowhere; however, feminism activism seeks to deconstruct truth claims of hostile science through subjectivity, agency and embodied accounts of the truth to dismantle scientific search for translation, convertibility and universality 

  • The embodied nature of vision can conquer the gaze from nowhere as vision comes from a specific body in a subjugated position allowing for adequate, sustained and transforming accounts of the world that emerge from below privileging contestation, deconstruction, webbed connections and transformation of knowledge systems 

  • Subjectivity is understood as multidimensional forming positioning as a key practice in grounding knowledges with responsibility for politics and ethical struggles for understanding difference formed through the mediation of organs,technologies and cultural lenses that form our vision, embodiment and material-semiotic fields of meaning; here location, positioning and situating breaks down the God trick through the view from the body that is complex, contradictory and structuring

  • The object of knowledge is pictured as an actor with agency that should be engaged with, this seems the breaking down of boundaries between animals and humans alongside further imagined boundaries allowing for deconstruction of universality and methods 

  • Feminism embodiment and situated knowledges seek accountability, politics and ecofeminist approaches to lean to converse with the world and its multiplicity; this beckons a practice of responsible positioning, conversation and solidarity across partial perspectives


9
New cards

Despret, 2013

  • Field reports rarely mention how scientists bodies are actively involved while they observe animals and are often seen as a disembodied observer; however, having a body renders possible reciprocity to understand companionship and see what matters in the animal world

  • Seeing the world from an animal’s perspective allows the scientist to engage their body with what the animals observe, sense, feel or live to rebuild the world as animals perceive it; the seek to understand not just what something means by why it matters by understanding the sympathy and effect to an animal other

  • The scientist cannot hope to understand animals without putting themselves in their place and constructing empathetic affinities through entangled relationships, this forms a partial perspective attuned to the animal; the researcher never attains a complete view of the animals experience but an incomplete connection enabling humans to see together with another without claiming to be another

  • The body is therefore transformed from an unscientific tool to one that can be shaped, forged, refined and used as an experimental and technical tool to build and witness partial affinities; the body learns politeness through habituation to respond respectfully to animals and communicate on their own terms

  • This enactment of the body blurs the line between the knowing subject and known object through an embodied choreography that makes the stuff of animal life and empathy possible


10
New cards

Latour, 2004

  • The body is not a fixed biological substance, but an interface that is moved, put into motion and transformed by interactions with other entities both human and non-human as it learns to be affected in multiple primary and secondary qualities sensitive to multiple controversies and affects

  • Articulation sees the body become more articulate as it acquires tools, training and instruments that allow it to be registered by and react to a wider variety of external stimuli in a multiverse that shifts what we sat, feel and act based on interactions with the registered world; articulation does not converge into a single, final discussion but instead can proliferate into more differences and meditations as it becomes more sensitive

  • Science has traditionally progressed by enforcing conditions that see subjects reduced to passive roles in an all purpose methodology often generalised as white coats and labs transmitting objectivity onto subjects; however, critiques suggest that good science allows subjects to resist preconceptions and surprise the scientist by creating environments that maximise the potential for dispute and allows entities to express their own complexity rather than neatly fit into predefined categories; here the scientist becomes empathetic and closer to the object

  • Good science no longer neutralises objects to gain control, but equips them to actively resist and shape the account being made of them; the scientist then learns to be affected by the result


11
New cards

Goldman, 2007

  • There remains a boundary between Indigenous and scientific knowledge that is brought into question when managing rangeland in Tanzania and the habitats/migration corridors of the wildebeest that play a central role in savanna ecology

  • The Maasai have a particular interest in understanding the movement and birthing patterns of wildebeest as they follow the rain and lead to green grasses, but avoid grazed spaces when the animals are birthing to avoid risk of transmittable fever; scientists track them to to map corridors, establish territorial protection zones and population dynamics; there is a disjuncture between Maasai knowledge and contribution to scientific dialogues linked to historically powerful discourses over what counts as valid knowledge tied to colonial endeavours

  • There is a need integrate Indigenous knowledge into science; however, translation verifies scientific superiority so building bridges and dialogues is preferred to accommodate valid, active and fluid knowledges; scientific practice is exposed in the messiness of data collection to undo the great divide and form a new space for dialogue that recognises the situatedness, successes and weaknesses of different knowledge spaces

  • Scientists use counts, aerial and ground surveys etc. problematised with obstructions, assumptions of constant positions, extrapolation and irregular observations; Maasai use shared knowledge from elders and observations from living and herding on the land; they can offer ideas on alternative locations from experience of elders, recent sightings and knowledge of where water was; they offer explanations based on habitat selection, avoidance of predators and links to reproduction cycles where scientists consider grass quality

  • Different theories should be combined in active hybrid knowledge spaces that form conservation areas and employ game scouts in an active participation of knowledge claims viewed as partial knowledges embedded in particular spaces; the acceptance of knowledges presents a more dynamic picture of population trends and suitable policy decisions


12
New cards

Landstrom et al., 2011

  • Computer simulation modelling offers opportunities for redistricting expertise between science and affected publics in relation to environmental problems; competency groups aim to harness energy generated in public controversy and enable other than scientific expertise to contribute to environmental knowledge in an unravelling of expertise

  • Public participation in science is introduced to form trust and prevent conlift, this allows for coproduction of knowledge between scientists and publics in a local context outside of the laboratory through a practice of dissociating from institutions and methods and attaching to new actors, communities and open ended agendas

  • CGs in Pickering and Ryedale bring science outside of institutional networks to learn about local catchment processes from community knowledge, perspective and values

  • Models were shifted from hydrological and hydraulic to instead work for specific localities in layering topographies, timescales and social factors; the behind the scenes practice was transformed and outputs were interpreted by extended research collectives to facilitate thinking through flood problems in novel ways

  • The bund model was defined internationally with the value of multiple sources accepted by local communities and the EA to inform new efforts to solve flooding in democratic science working alongside affected localities

  • New attachments and alignments allow science to map onto local knowledge in framings that are no longer general but particular and local


13
New cards

Todd, 2016

  • Latour did not mention any Inuit or Indigenous thinkers in a speech with great similarities to the concept of Sila showing a need to reference Indigenous thinkers in a direct, contemporary and meaningful way; they should not be filtered through white intermediaries but cited and quoted directly and generously as thinkers in their own right

  • Euro-Western academic narratives of the Ontological Turn and more-than-human sentience are repackaged by white academics who ‘discover’ agency, sentience and organisational ideas that Indigenous scholars have discussed for millenia; however, they are ignored as occurring outside of dominant Euro-Western thought

  • In lecture halls in Europe practices of erasing Indigenous bodies continue with an erase of Indigenous epistemes and locations alongside asserting nature/culture split as universal in a structural violence that forms systems and practices where Indigenous thinkers are not present; there is a need for care, respect and ontological self-determination

  • The European academy continues to not address racist and colonial roots alongside debt to Indigenous thinkers, there is a racial imbalance, vidinos of labour, practices of racism and Indigenous thought that must be filtered through white intermediaries to be seen as credible in the white public space of anthropology

  • European thinkers replicate Indigenous thought with no awareness of the ongoing colonial moment this upholds, there is a need to erase colonial violence and be responsible to silence and neo-colonial logics of the Euro-Western academy that have formed an epistemic violence

  • Indigenous thinkers fight for self-determination, recognition of asserting ideas on their own terms, being present and forming an ethical relationality where there is a reciprocity of thought and attention to those who speak alongside us

  • To decolonise the academy is to review prejudice and bias alongside the systems that privilege certain voices and silence others, to consider the whiteness of departments and cite Indigenous thinkers as knowledgeable; scholars must move part empty theoretical turns and actively practice decolonial citations, ethical accountability and support for Indigenous intellectual sovereignty


14
New cards

Country et al., 2016

  • Indigenous led understandings of relational space/place draw on the concept of ‘Gurrutu’ to illustrate the limits of Western ontologies and open up possibilities for other ways of thinking and theorising space/place as emergent and co-becoming; the Country has authority to speak for itself

  • Co-becoming shows how everything exists in a state of emergence and relationality; space is dynamic, emergent and participatory as well as always being made in a fluid open form

  • ‘Gurrutu’ is a complex kinship that underlies all relationships to see everyone and everything bound in flows that are mediated in mother-child relationships’, there is balance in all things that must be maintained in relationships of care or obligation past a place/space binary to emotional and diverse patterns that constitute space through distinct and valued knowledges

  • Everything is entangled in a web of connectivity which is constantly in motion and co-becoming, this is a post-humanist world where MTH actors are active and influential through communication and seasons; co-becoming is not human-centred but allows all in ‘Gurrutu’ to move together and speak their own languages 

  • Embodied engagement fosters knowing of more than human agency to shift from dominant ocular-centric Western perspectives of place to those where living and learning the patterns and co-existence in everyday life is only way to understand social, multifaceted spaces as there is know separation between experiencing and knowing only an active knowing

  • Time is also cyclical and dynamic connected through influential histories that change all agents every, it is non-linear as place is dynamic and always shifting towards an imagined and emergent future

  • Co-becoming becksons an ethics of care and responsibility that is embodied and brings about questions of justice and power; there is a need to recast imaginations from conceptualisations of actors and place that produce colonising and imperial projects but towards understanding place/space and ourselves in new ways of co-becoming, relationality and enactment

  • New meanings from Indigenous led theory that should be incorporated ind authorship and the academy emerge from beyond the Anglo-American nexus, they call for small stories that are nuanced and situated; this speaks to kinship and cycles of place and time occurring everywhere and calls for a rethinking of human-centric hierarchies/knowledge systems and attention to connections that bind and co-constitute the world


15
New cards

Hinchliffe et al., 2016

  • In Western states emerging infectious diseases are conceptualised as emergencies in waiting and are understood through socio-ecological focus on mutable microorganisms that are now less fixed and less predictable, they are able to jump, mutate and take advantage of new conditions to move through dense and rapid transit routes in a global connectivity that is more infectable that ever

  • Government elements see public and private institutions organising for these events as infectious disease becomes part of a logic and practice of security, here biosecurity captures the measures and policies that governments, commercial and other organisations put in place to reduce the risk of disease and prepare for consequences; these may be mutually reaffirming 

  • There are questions over the formation of biosecurity as a discourse and practice alongside justifying anticipatory governance through defining threats and emergencies in ideological framings, this attention may be making matters worse

  • Diseases are now understood, marshalled, measured, generated and even ignored in particular ways based on stories and politics that inform action

  • Relationality is applied to diseases as they are seen as systems made up of hosts, microbes, environments, controls and governance; an infectious disease is a multi-faceted outcome of changing relations that make microbes more or less likely to effectively generate disease; there is no longer a focus on a single agent or pathway but a suite of issues including disease management and governance

  • As biopolitics managed and organises conceptualisations of diseases there are new spaces and opportunities opened up to imagine and enact the politics of disease and what counts as a disease emergency


16
New cards

Barua, 2018

  • Nonhuman forces and potentials configure the scope of capitalism accumulation and are co constituted in the economic, nonhuman life is continually brought into the realm of capital to harness living potential as a source of value and reconfigure nonhuman beings as lively or animal capital; this shows a need to form a new category of the economic where living capacities influence political and economic organisation

  • This challenges the notion of nature as an unproblematic stage where the economy takes place and dualisms of nature placed outside of society, political ecology shows how capital is contingent on appropriation, enclosure and commodification of nature where nature has agency 

  • Animal work and nonhuman labour play crucial roles in the shadows of capitalism where they participate in metabolic labour through passive accumulation and biopolitics alongside ecological labour forming conditions necessary for regeneration of ecosystems and affective labour through human contact and interaction; this metabolic, ecological and affective labour are central to the hidden spaces of production and reproduction 

  • Animals are also shaped into lively commodities with the capacity to resist and deflect human action, commodity potential show how the material-semiotic animal commodity is constructed differently for different animals through constructions of value and commodity biographies where diverse encounters shape commodity life and resistance; at commodity surfaces intimate points of encounter emerge through sensory and affective registers to show how practices can operate differently depending on what ecologies are being commodified and generations of resistance

  • Circulation shows how animals are value in motion through rendering of new meanings and biological circulation of genes, supply chains etc. which flow with different levels of ease; this is also shaped by flows of branding, advertising and images that can form spectacles of animals to make them more appealing and increase consumption

  • To analyse capitalism requires accounting for more-than-human agency to trace how animal work, lively commodities and circulation interlock and shape modern capitalism


17
New cards

Collard, 2013

  • Every year ARCAS Wildlife Rehabilitation Centre received 200 to 700 animals confiscated while being smuggled for the pet trade to be transformed into companion commodities, return to the wild is seen as a form of decommodification attempted through misanthropic behaviours; both processes product particular natures with different shapes and ecological/ethical stakes

  • Animals are lively commodities that have a wildlife and a commodity life, they are sentient and aware of surroundings, sensations and relations; commodity life is dependent on wild life as animals in the global wildlife trade are diminished to undead things in the formation of a specific commodity companion to live in prolonged, controlled and intimate contact with owners by stripping former lives and intensifying human ties

  • The objective of this commodification is to sever it from ecological and biological supports without killing it, it takes on a new form of life where it become animate, controllable and encounterable; these new ties are severed in unmaking and decommodification as an ecological process of wildlife rehabilitation

  • Animals at ARCAS are neither fully commodities or wild beings but in a liminal state, they still generate profit as many volunteers pay to work at the centre through an eco-tourism and they remain dependent on humans which entrenches an idea of the human as a saviour, a hierarchical human-nature binary and the idea of nature and wildlife as untouched and pristine

  • The exploitative conditions of the bioeconomy and reconfiguring of animal subjects mean that in the making and unmaking of commodities animal bodies and lives are subject to invasion, manipulation and control