1/49
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what is fragile X and why is it useful for research
because it stems from a single gene abnormality, it allows study of links between genetic aetiology, cognition and behaviour from early childhood
FXS prevalence
1 in 4,000 males (Turner et al, 1996)
1 in 5000-8000 females (Crawford et al, 2001)
behavioural profile of FXS
social avoidance and anxiety, hyperarousal to sensory stimuli, distractibility, irritability, high activity level, repetitive motor behaviours, difficulty coping with change or unpredictable events and language problems
strengths in FXS
imitation, visual learning, sensitivity to others emotions and humour
what causes FXS at the chromosome level
narrowing (fragile site) at the end of some X chromosomes where the FMR1 gene is located
what does the FMR1 gene do
it produces the protein FMRP, required for brain development and function
what is the DNA basis of the faulty gene
the FMR1 triplet is CGG, repeated, and if the number of repeats is too large the gene becomes faulty
what are CGG repeat categories
short (6-50 repeats, most people)
premutation (50-200, gene still working no FXS)
full mutation (over 200, gene no longer produces FMRP)
how do consequences of the full mutation differ by sex
all men with the full mutation have FXS, whereas women with a full mutation on only one X are carriers
why are women less affected
only one X is switched on in each cell, so about half of cells have the faulty gene active and some FMRP is still produced
how is FXS inherited
tends to be passed on by carrier mothers, their daughters may be carriers with some symptoms and their songs may have full FXS
what is Down syndrome and its prevalence
Trisomy 21 (three copies of chromosome 21) described by John Langdon Down in the 1860s
affecting about 1 in 750-1000 live births (Morris et al, 2012)
facial features of DS
round face, flat facial profile, small chin, almond-shaped eyes, flat nasal bridge, and a protruding enlarged tongue due to a small oral cavity
what other physical features occur in DS
short neck, broad head, shorter arms and legs and a single palm crease
what health problems are common in DS
congenital heart defects (up to 50%), gastro-oesophageal reflux, sleep apnoea, thyroid dysfunction, and more leukaemia but fewer tumours (Hasle et al, 2000)
average life expectancy in DS
58.6 years (Glasson et al, 2002)
what did Collacott et al (1998) find about behaviour in DS
in 360 adults with DS vs 1829 with other intellectual disabilities, DS scored lower for aggression, antisocial behaviour, property destruction, disturbing others at night, scattering objects, attention seeking, self-injury, untruthfulness, excessive activity, absconding and noise
what other behavioural features are noted in DS
a predisposition to depression (Collacott et al, 1992) and poor persistence and a stubborn personality (Fidler, 2006)
what is the neurological profile of DS
reduced brainstem and cerebellum size, delayed myelination and fewer cortical granular neurons (Nadel, 1999) and smaller hippocampal volumes (Pinter et al, 2001)
link between DS and Alzheimers
more Alzheimers like plaques after age 35 (Arai et al, 1997)
what defines intellectual disability
deficits in intellectual functions confirmed by clinical assessment and standardised intelligence testing, deficits in adaptive functioning, and onset in the developmental period
what is the IQ in FXS and DS
FXS - males typically IQ 40-60 (mild/moderate intellectual disability) while females are less affected (Dykens et al, 2000)
DS - 40-60 as well, though variable
why are FXS and DS well suited to comparison
their IQ and mental age are often similar, so differences in behaviour and psychopathology may reflect syndrome-specific profiles
what are receptive and expressive language, and how are they tested
receptive language is comprehension (tested with BPVS)
expressive language is producing verbal and written language (tested with the WAIS/WASI vocabulary subscale)
what did Abbeduto et al (2003) test
receptive language using the Test for Auditory Comprehension of Language - revised TACL-R comparing group averages
showed no significant differences compared to mental age children for FXS but lagged for DS
what did Finestack & Abbeduto (2010) measure
expressive language with the Oral and Written Language Scale (OWLS) and Developmental Sentence Scoring (DSS)
FXS outperformed DS and typical children groups on OWLS and DS on DSS “sentence point” measure
what would you expect from the DS vs FXS language comparison
DS is generally characterised by a particular weakness in expressive language and grammar relative to nonverbal ability, which helps define a syndrome specific profile
what was the design of Munir et al (2000)
boys with FXS and DS compared with 2 mental age matched control groups (good vs poor attention) on a battery of attention and executive function tasks
what was the selective attention result (Munir et al, 2000)
targets identified in a visual search task: FXS < DS < control groups
what was the divided attention result
in the dual search task (targets as a proportion of the selective condition) FXS = DS < control groups
what was the sustained attention result
in the dual search task (targets as a proportion of the selective condition) FXS = DS = poor attender < good attenders
what did the walk task (behavioural inhibition) show
correct inhibition: FXS < DS = poor attenders < good attenders
what did the same opposite task (cognitive inhibition) show
time difference between same and opposite condition: DS < FXS < poor attenders < good attenders
what did Wilding et al (2000) find
error types in the visual search tasks differed between syndrome and control groups
FXS and DS had a similar pattern with FXS more impaired, probably reflecting difficulty inhibiting a previously successful response
what was Munir et al (2000b) on working memory
FXS, DS, a mental age control and a chronological age control compared on phonological loop (nonword repetition, forward digit span) visuospatial sketchpad (spatial memory task) and central executive (backward digit span, story retelling) tasks
why is this a good test of the Baddeley working memory model
each task maps onto a component (phonological loop, visuospatial sketchpad, central executive) so profiles show whcih component differs
what did Will et al (2018) - adaptive behaviour
adaptive behaviour between 0 and 36 months using parent-reported Vineland Adaptive Behaviour Scales
DS children demonstrated communication skills similar to their typically developing peers (up to 6 month)
deficits in communication began to emerge at 12 months
what domains does the Vineland cover
communication, daily living, socialisation and motor skills, plus an overall composite score
what is the summary of cross-syndrome differences
FXS and DS share intellectual disability (mental age may be similar) but the exact nature of the disability differs subtly
is the pattern consistent with impaired and intact modules
no, the pattern of difficulties does not fit the idea of impaired and intact modules
why is it easier to link genes and cognition in FXS
FXS involves the single gene FMR1, so measures of the mutation and FMRP expression can be correlated with cognitive and biological measures
what was the design of Bailey et al (2001)
53 boys with FXS (39 with full mutation) assessed with the Battelle Developmental Inventory (cognitive, adaptive, language, motor, personal-social) with blood smears using FMRP
what were Bailey et al’s results
FMRP significantly predicted total BDI score and each of five subdomains across the whole sample, but not when only full mutation boys were analysed (partial mutation effect or lack of power)
what was the design of Menon et al (2000)
10 females with FXS did a working memory task during fMRI (symbol every 2s at one of 9 locations, responded if location matched two steps back), with blood tests measuring FMRP
what did Menon et al (2000) find
activity in middle frontal and supramarginal gyri during the task was related to FMRP
suggests FMRP relates to frontal lobe activity
design of Cornish et al (2008)
40 premutation carriers and 60 comparison individuals did a battery covering inhibition, selective and sustained attention, visuospatial function and visual memory
why is mapping genes to brain and cognition harder in DS
an entire chromosome is involved, with greater expression of some but not all genes (Yahya-Graison et al, 2007) and wide individual differences in ability and ageing effects
what did Thomas et al (2020) study
links between brain volume and cognitive development in DS infants using MRI and the Mullen Scales of Early Learning (gross motor, visual reception, receptive and expressive language) in 5 infants compared with published group averages
what does Cornish et al (2004) argue
deconstructing the attention deficit in fragile X breaks FXS attention problems into specific components rather than a single deficit
what do sensitivity and specificity mean for cross-syndrome comparisons
sensitivity is detecting a real syndrome specific difference when present, and specificity is avoiding false differences, both affected by how groups are matched