1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Chapter VII: determination
UNSC "determines" security issue:
*Wide discretion
*Only agression legally definied
* What counts as a "threat" or "breach"?
* Not necessarily about military force, a state, or international
* e.g. HR abuses
* Legal effect: can trigger collective action measures (e.g. sanctions, use of force
Chapter VII: Action with Respect to Threats to the Peace, Breaches of the Peace and cts of Agression
Chapter VII: authorizing collective action measures
UNSC may authorize
a) non-forcible measures (e.g. econ, sanctions, arms, embargoes, travel bans, creation of tribunals, etc.
b) forcible measures
*Chapter VII resolutions authorizing the use of force (e.g. Iraq 1990, Libya 2011) Merely authorizes does not obligate states to use of force
No standing UN military- rely on members to voluntarily enforce
Use of force beyond the UN Charter
UN Charter mum about: Unilateral (not equal to UNSC) interventions not against "territorial integroty or political independence" or "inconsistent with the Purposes of the UN"
a. to protect nationals abroad
b. by invitation (consent)
c. for humanitarian reasons
Protection of nationals abroad
Non-combatant evacuations (rescue missions)
When government uses armed force to rescue, evacuate, or defend citizens from imminent foreign threat
*Often w/(tacit) approval of the state
* Or if no effective govt
* Not always considered "use of force"
e..g. (appropoate): Israel: 1976 Uganda (Entebbe airport), US 1980 Iran (failed Op. Eagle Claw)
* At times v. questionable
*e.g. US in Panama/Grenada, Russia in Georgia/Ukraine
Possible legal basis (controversial)-CPW
* Self defense extends to protection of nationals abroad (Art. 51)
* Neccesity and proportionality
* Art 2(4) exempt not equal against "territorial integrity or political independence"
Intervention by invitation of a state
State consent to other state using force on its territory
Possible legal basis
*CPW if consent is given (sovereignity)
*Exempt from Art 2(4)
* Not in non int'l conflicts
*Not against terr. integ./indep/
* Must be "invited"- forcible intervention in dom. conflict prohibiyed
*UNGA 1970 Declaration on Friendly Relations
* Nicargaua case
Conditions of intervention by invitation of a state
Must serve a lawful purpose under IL
* not equal to genocide, agression, suppressing self-determination
Invited by a legitimate government
* does not equal support to rebels, regime change- violates non-intervention
*e.g. US (Cold War)- Nicaragua (+ Afghanistan, etc.)
* Only UNSC can support force on insurgent's side (e.g. Libya 2011)
* Legitimate govt can be unclear (e.g. Ethiopia in Somalia 2006) (e.g. French exited Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger after 2020 coups
*Can be withdrawn at any time (e.g. Niger 2023)
Geniune consent (freely given, valid, not coerced
*US-Grenada (alleged)
*USSR- Afghanistan (puppet)
* Uganda-DRC (initial invitation withdrawn)- Armed Activities
Article 2 Section 4
Prohibition of force and Scope of force
Humanitarian intervention
Military intervention to stop/prevent grave and widespread human rights violations (w/out invitation)
Examples of cases without UNSC authorization. Is it unlawful or not
Kosov (1999)- NATO
Iraq no-fly zones (1991-2003)- US/UK (France)
* Only UK used "humanitarian" justification
Rwanda genocide (1994)
* Largely a case of nonintervention- influential in developing R2P
* Later French intervention: too late + to protect pereptrators of genocide against reprisals
Examples of cases with UNSC authorization. Always lawful
Libya (2011)- NATO
* Res. 1973 "All necessary measures to protect civilians"
* Mandate: no-fly zones
* But Qadafi overthrown: annoyed China, Russia- fear pretext for regime change (+ support for rebels)
* UNSC divergence since- e.g. no support for intervention in Syria
Legality and arguments in favor of humanitarian favor
Unilateral use of force for humanitarian purpose (e.g. ending/preventing grave and widespread HR violations)
Arguments in favor
* Not directed against terr. integrity or pol. independence
* Not "inconsistent" w/UN purposes
* States have a duty to save lives+ protect HRs
But no recognized legal "right" to intervent in IL (w/out UNSC authorization)
*Open to abuse
* States (+ UNSC) always careful to note "unique" character of each intervention
* Unwillingness to set precedent- violates non-intervention
e.g. Kosovo Report: NATO intervention was "illegal" but legitimate
Kosovo (1999) vs Ukrain (2014/2022)
In both cases (Unilaternal no UNSC autho.) use of force agaisnt a state (Yug., Ukr.) Largely justified on humanitarian grounds
Key difference: Russia benefited: annexations (1970 UNGA Declaration on Friendly Relations), HR violations? (Some re: langauge but not "grave and widespread", no evidence of genocide)
The Repsonsibility to Protect (R2P)
Humanitarian intervention has no basis in IL- unless UNSC-authorized (No unilaterial right to intervent- against non-intervention norm + Art 2(4)
But most agree grave and widespread HR violations should be stopped (e.g. Rwandan genocide, Balkans()
R2P- an attempt to balance these
* Major development in how we think about sovereignity and intervention
* Not a legal norm (yet)- nonbinding (soft law)
But increasing acceptance (emerging norm)
*Unanimous adoption by UNGA (2005 UN World Summit)
* Common in UN resolutions incl. 100 UNSC res. (through China/Russia often abstain)
R2P
State sovereingity implies responsibility and the primary responsibility for the protection of its people lies within the state itself
Where a population is suffering serious harm, as a result of internal war, insurgency, repression or state failure, and the state in question is unwilling or unable to halt or avert it, the principle of non-intervention yields to the international responsibility to protect
Shift from:
* right to intervene- to responsibility to protect
* soverignity as control- to sovereignity as responsibility
A politically more acceptable reformulation of "humanitaran intervention" but
1. high gravity threshold (limited to genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity) (not any HR abuses)
2. Still does not authorize unilateral measures- collective measures authorized by UNSC
* But what if UNSC fails to act (e.g. Syria, Myanmar, Gaza, etc.)
* Powerless in Ukraine, China?
Humanitarian intervention def.
Right to intervent (state-centerd), no basis in IL (territorial integrity), Military action (reactive only), Justification: Protection of (unspecified) HRs
R2P def
Responsibility to protect (victim-centered)
Basis in IL (UNSC authorization)
Military action in last resort (non-military to prevent, react, rebuild)
Justification: Limited to 4 categories of grave HR violations (genocide, ethnic cleansing, crimes against humanity, war crimes)