1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Deviation from ideal mental health
Someone with ideal mental health would tick all 6 of jahodas boxes. If a person fails to tick most of these boxes, or deviates significantly from one of them they would be classified as abnormal
Positive self attitude
self respect and self esteem
Self actualisation
achieving personal growth and progress
Autonomy
being independent and self reliant
Mastery of environment
ability to navigate work and social situations
Accurate perception of reality
realistic and objective views about the world
Integration
ability to resist stress, deal effectively with life challenges
Deviation from ideal mental health strengths
positive approach. This could reduce stigma around mental health as if no one can fulfil all criteria all the time, this portrays mental illness as more ordinary
Deviation from ideal mental health weaknesses
According to the criteria, most of us would be identified as having a mental illness. Jahoda’s criteria are also quite difficult to measure
Cultural relativism - many of the criteria are culture bound -e.g. self actualisation is relevant to individualist cultures but not collectivist, so if the criteria was applied to collectivist cultures it would result in higher mental illness.
Deviation from social norms
Anyone who behaves differently from accepted social norms
Social norms
shared beliefs of what is deemed acceptable behaviour within a specific social group or culture.
They vary across cultures, communities, generations and historical periods.
Deviation from social norms strengths
They are flexible to account for individual and situation - normal for toddler to scream and tantrum but not an adult
Deviation from social norms limitations
aren’t objective facts - they are subjective so depend on who decided
They change over time so what is considered a disorder today might not be in the future
A deviation from social norms may just be eccentric not mentally ill e.g. wearing 18th century clothes today
Failure to function adequately
person is unable to navigate everyday life or behave in the necessary ways to live a ‘normal’ life e.g. going to work, washing
This can cause distress and suffering for the individual and/or others.
Failure to function adequately strengths
provides clear guidelines for diagnosis of abnormality as it is focused on observable signs that an individual is not coping e.g. lack of hygiene, clear behavioural distress signals. These observable signs allow for the individual to receive help
Failure to function adequately limitations
who decides if someone is failing to function adequately - judgement depends on person making decision
Adequate functioning is different across cultures - different values of indépendance
Some people choose an unconventional life e.g. irregular work
Statistical infrequency
behaviour is regarded as abnormal if it is statistically uncommon/rare or it is not present often or regularly in society:
Often 2 standard deviation away from the mean
Behaviour can be measured as abnormal or normal according to its position on a distribution graph
Statistical infrequency strength
In some situations it’s appropriate for mental illness e.g. intellectual disability is defined as 2 standard deviations down from the mean iq.
Statistical infrequency weaknesses
Some rare behaviours are desirable, not a mental illness e.g. high iq
Rare behaviour is different in each culture