1/155
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a negligence claim?
There is an act or omission which breaches a duty of care owed by one party (defendant) to another (claimant)
As a consequence of that breach, one party causes loss and damage to the other party (claimant)
4 elements of the tort of negligence
1. The defendant must owe a duty of care to the claimant
2. The defendant must breach that duty of care
3. The breach must cause damage to the client
4. The damage must not be too remote.
4 types of tort
1. Negligence
2. Nuisance
3. Ryland v Fletcher
4. Trespass
What is Duty of care?
Duty of care is a legal concept that states whether one party can be liable to another in negligence.
*It can only be relied upon by a claimant where they have suffered physical damage
Standard of proof for negligence/tort
The burden of proof is on the claimant.
The standard of proof is on the balance of probabilities.
What are examples of established duties of care?
Doctor to patient
Road user to road user
Teacher to pupil
Employer to employee
Manufacturer to consumer
If there is not an established duty, the duty of care test must be applied:
1. The General Test (The Neighbour Principle)
2. Incrementally and by analogy
3. Caparo v Dickman: Three stage test
Duty of care - The General Test (The Neighbour Principle)
You must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your neighbour.
Duty of care - Incrementally and by analogy
The first approach taken by the courts means that if a duty of care has been found to exist previously:
- looking to precedents decided by the courts, or
- where the situation is analogous to one in which a duty of care has been found to exist
Duty of care - Caparo v Dickman: Three stage test
1. Was it reasonably foreseeable? Would a reasonable person in the defendant's position have foreseen the damage/harm?
2. Was there a relationship of (legal) proximity between the Claimant and the Defendant?
3. Is it Just and Reasonable to Impose a Duty of Care?
Duty of care - investors
1. The accounts knew the nature of the transaction which the claimant had in contemplation
2. The accounts knew that the advice would be communicated to the claimant either directly or indirectly
3. The accounts knew that it was very likely that the claimant would rely on that advice or information in deciding whether or not to engage in the transaction in contemplation without independent enquiry
4. The claimant relied on the advice to their detriment
Special duty of care problems - omissions
The general rule is that a duty of care is not owed for omissions, ie failing to act to prevent harm to the claimant and the law does not impose liability.
Exceptions to the rule that a duty of care is not owed for omissions
1. Defendant has a high degree of control over Claimant
2. Occasion where there is a duty to act positively/Defendant has assumed responsibility for the Claimant
3. Defendant creates a dangerous situation and fails to deal with it or make it worse
Exceptions to the rule that a duty of care is not owed in relation to acts of third parties
1. Where there was a special relationship between the claimant and defendant
2. Where there is a special relationship between the defendant and a third party such as a relationship of control or supervision
3. Where someone creates a source of danger and it is reasonably foreseeable that a third party would interfere
4. Where there is a failure to take steps to stop the danger created by a third party
Duty of care - police
Where the police expressly or impliedly undertake a duty (e.g., protecting a specific individual), they may owe a duty of care.
Operational failures (e.g., negligent acts during an arrest) may give rise to liability, whereas policy decisions (e.g., resource allocation) typically do not.
Negligence: Breach of Duty
Claimant must show that (tort) was caused by Defendant's breach of duty for failing, objectively speaking, to meet the desired standard of care.
What is the test for Breach of duty?
1. The court first assesses how the defendant ought, in the circumstances, to have behaved, ie what standard of care the defendant should have exercised (a question of law).
2. The court then decides whether the defendant's conduct fell below the required standard (a question of fact) on the balance of probabilities
General standard of care
The defendant must meet the standard of care that which would be expected of a reasonable person.
The courts do not take into account the personal qualities of the defendant.
In deciding the standard of care to be expected, the court will take into account the following factors:
Foreseeability of the risk of harm
Foreseeability of the severity of potential injury
Cost and practicality of taking precautions
Public benefit
Common practice
The current state of knowledge
Professional standard of care
Defendants purporting to possess a skill or profession will be judged by a reasonable person with that same skill or trained in the same profession.
Wiltsher v EAH
The junior doctor should show the same level of competence as any doctor skilled for their post.
They should call on more expert assistance when he feels out of his depth.
Bolam v Friern Hospital
A doctor must meet the standard of their profession at the time of the alleged negligence.
If a responsible body of medical opinion supports the method or treatment used by the doctor, they may not be considered negligent even if others would have acted differently
If the doctor did act in accordance with a reasonable body of professional opinion, but lacked logical analysis, the doctor will still be negligent
Montgomery (warning patients about the material risks)
The test of materiality:
would a reasonable person in the patient's position be likely to attach significance to the risk or the doctor is or
should the doctor be reasonably aware that the particular patient would be likely to attach significance to it
Special standard of care:
Where the defendant suffers from a disability
Where the defendant suffers an illness
Sporting activites
Emergency situations
State of knowledge
The under-skilled defendant
Children
Standard of care: Proving breach of duty
Must be proven on the balance of probabilities via:
direct evidence
civil evidence Act
Res ipsa loquitur
Proving breach of duty - what happens where there are no relevant witnesses?
Breach can be proved via -
1. Res Ipsa Loquitor
2. S11 of The Civil Evidence Act 1968
Proving breach of duty - Res Ipsa Loquitor
‘the thing speaks for itself’. Allows the court to infer negligence from the nature of an accident itself.
Proving breach of duty - S11 of The Civil Evidence Act
A defendant who has been convicted of a criminal offence is presumed, in any subsequent civil proceedings, to have committed that offence.
Previous convictions are not relevant.
Negligence: Causation (single and multiple)
It must be proved that the defendant's breach of duty actually caused the damage by the claimant, and that the damage suffered was not too remote from the breach.
Factual causation - Single cause
But for' test: X must establish causation in fact. But for the defendant's breach of duty, would the harm to the claimant have occurred?
Factual causation - Multiple cause (The material contribution approach)
This applies when the claimant must show that the defendant's breach of duty materially contributed to the harm they suffered.
Factual causation - Multiple cause (The material increase in risk approach)
This principle applies where it is not possible to prove that the defendant's breach caused the harm but rather increased the risk of harm occurring. (It refers to mesothelioma cases)
Factual causation - Multiple cause (The claimant is injured more than once)
Where a claimant (or his property) has already suffered damage, a later defendant who causes a subsequent injury should be liable only to the extent that he makes the claimant's damage worse.
Factual causation - Multiple cause (Consecutive causes of harm)
When a consecutive cause occurs but does not supersede the earlier negligence, the original tortfeasor remains liable for the harm caused up to that point.
Factual causation - Loss of chance
Where the claimant's loss dependent on the hypothetical action of a third party, the claimant will succeed only if he is able to show that there was a real or substantial chance, rather than a mere speculative chance, of the third party acting apply the on the balance of probabilities test ie. it must be more than 51% likely to occur.
Factual causation - Divisible injury: proportionate damages
Divisible injury applies where it is possible to apportion the harm caused by different defendants or events. The core principle behind proportionate damages is fairness: a defendant should only be responsible for the part of the injury that their actions caused.
Asbestosis is a divisible disease
Factual causation - Indivisible injury: contribution between tortfeasors
An indivisible injury occurs when the harm caused by different defendants cannot be separated or attributed specifically to each party's actions. In such cases, the entire injury is treated as one whole, and all responsible parties are held jointly and severally liable.
Mesothelioma is an indivisible disease
Breaking the Chain of Causation
1. The conduct of the claimant has been so carless or unreasonable that his injury can no longer be attributed to the negligence of the defendant
2. An independent act of nature causes the claimant's damage
3. The third party's intervening act was intention or reckless
Breaking the Chain of Causation - Actions of the third party
The chain of causation will not be broken where:
1. the intervention was instinctive
2. the negligent action of a third party which the defendant ought to have foreseen as a likely consequence of his negligence.
The act must be unforeseeable and sufficiently independent of the defendant's original wrongdoing.
Breaking the Chain of Causation - The actions of the claimant
The claimant's act (after the defendant's act) has to be entirely unreasonable in all the circumstances for it to break the chain of causation, otherwise the act will simply be a natural event.
Legal causation - Remoteness and loss
Was the loss which the claimant sustained recoverable in negligence? Claimants are compensated only for the proximate and direct consequences of the negligence they suffer.
The burden falls with the defendant to prove the loss is too remote to be recoverable by the claimant.
Legal causation - Reasonable Foreseeability test (Wagon Mound)
Oil spillage damaging the slipway was foreseeable BUT the substantial fire affecting the wharf and moored boats was unforeseeable due to oil being difficult to ignite on water
Legal causation - Reasonable Foreseeability test (Wagon Mound)
1. The 'similar in type' rule: Defendant will only be liable if the particular kind of damage/injury was reasonably foreseeable. It is not necessary to foresee the precise way in which the injury is caused
2. The 'egg-shell skull' rule: Defendant takes the Claimant as he finds him. This means that if the claimant suffers a particular disability or has a particular condition, they can recover in full from the defendant for their losses, even though the defendant could not have foreseen the full extent of the claimant's loss.
Damages
The aim is damages is to put the claimant in the position they would have been in if the tort had not been committed.
The Measure of Damages
The aim of damages in tort is to put the claimant in the same position he would have been in if the tort had not been committed. Where the claimant of damages cannot restore the claimant's position, the purpose of damages is compensatory.
The courts will take steps to avoid overcompensation
Mitigation of Loss
The claimant should not profit from the incident and must take reasonable steps to keep the losses that he is claiming to a minimum.
The One Action Rule
A claimant can bring only one claim based on one set of facts. Once an award of damages has been made, a claimant cannot go back to court with a second claim simply because the injury worsens rather than improves.
General damages
These relate to losses which cannot be precisely calculated and must be assessed by the court at trial.
Non-pecuniary losses: paining and suffering, loss of earnings
Future pecuniary losses: future loss of earnings & medical care
Special Damages (Compensatory)
This is the claimant's actual loss to the date of trial.
Past and pecuniary losses: For quantifiable losses, loss of earnings, medical care, cost of travel and accommodation
Pecuniary losses
Those which are capable of mathematical calculation in money terms.
Non-pecuniary losses
Those which are not capable of being calculated in money terms.
Loss of earnings post-trial: Multiplier x Multipicand = SUM
Multiplicand: The court to ascertain the claimant's gross annual loss as at the date of the trial.
Multiplier The court then needs to calculate for how long the claimant will lose this money - the period of future loss.
Damages for death - for fatal claims: Claim brought By Estate of Deceased The Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1934
Claims can only be pursued by the personal representative (executor or administrator) of the deceased's estate and damages are awarded to the estate.
- Paining and suffering up to date of death
- Loss of earnings up to date of death
- care/services up to date of death
Damages for death - for fatal claims: Claim brought by Dependants of Deceased Fatal Accidents Act 1976
The claim can only proceed if
1. the claimant would have been able to sue successfully before he died
2. the claimant must be a dependent: Dependants include a spouse, civil partner/cohabitee, children, parents, siblings and person treated by the deceased as his parent
3. the claimant must have a reasonable expectation of financial benefit from the deceased.
- Bereavement award
- dependency claim for dependants suffering financial losses
- funeral expenses
Claim brought by Dependants of Deceased Fatal Accidents Act 1976 - time limits
Any action under the Act must be brought within 3 years from:
- The date of the death
- The date of knowledge of the person for whose benefit the action is brought
Claims for pure economic loss (arising from either a negligent act or misstatement)
Where a claimant suffers damage that is classed as pure economic loss, that loss is not recoverable. There is no duty of care owed in tort of negligence to a claimant with pure economic loss.
Only consequential economic loss that stems from property damage is recoverable.
Consequential economic loss
Financial loss sustained due to another harm caused by negligence
Pure economic loss
Financial damage suffered as the result of the negligent act of another party which is not accompanied by any physical damage to a person or property.) PEL is only recoverable when there is a negligent misstatement.
Examples of pure economic losses that are not recoverable include:
- Economic loss caused by acquiring a defective item of property
- Economic loss unconnected to physical damage to the claimant's person/property
- Economic loss caused by damage to the property of the third party
- Economic loss where there is no physical damage caused by actions or statements
Exceptions to the Pure Economic Loss Rule
1) Negligent misstatement: via a special relationship e.g D assumed responsibility for the advice, C relied on it and D knew or ought to have known that C would rely on it for a known purpose.
2) Negligent services: where D assumes responsibility e.g writing a reference, or disappointed beneficiaries of a negligently drafted will.
For a duty to be owed under negligent misstatement, we have to cover the 3 principles of:
1. special relationship of trust and confidence existed between the parties
2. where a party preparing the statement showed a voluntary assumption of risk
3. where there was reasonable reliance on the statement in the circumstances
Pure economic loss - duty of care - social situations
If the two individuals are friends, there is unlikely to be a trust relationship, which is normally found in business contexts. The general rule is that, usually, no duty of care will be owed in respect of advice given in a social situation because there is no assumption of responsibility.
BUT this can be rebutted where a friend claims to have knowledge of something (ie. cars) where the claimant has no knowledge
Pure economic loss: exclusion of liability and exclusion notices
Two important requirements defendant needs to satisfy:
1. Reasonable steps must have been taken to bring the exclusion notice to the claimant's attention before the tort was committed.
2. The wording of the notice must cover the loss suffered by the claimant.
Pure economic loss: exclusion of liability and exclusion notices - UCTA
Negligence (s.2 UCTA): Any exclusion or limitation of liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence is void (Section 2(1)). For other forms of loss (e.g., economic loss), an exclusion clause is only valid if it passes the reasonableness test (Section 2(2)). The exclusion clause must be fair and reasonable in light of the circumstances known to the parties at the time the contract was made.
Reasonableness Test (s.11 UCTA): Courts will consider factors such as the relative bargaining power of the parties, the availability of insurance, and the clarity of the exclusion clause.
Pure economic loss: exclusion of liability and exclusion notices - CRA
Negligence and Economic Loss (s.65 CRA): prohibits traders from excluding or restricting liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence. This is an absolute bar.
The fairness test looks at factors like the clarity of the term, its transparency, and whether it was presented in a way that gave the consumer a real chance to understand and negotiate it.
Transparent and Prominent Terms (s.68 CRA): Exclusion notices and terms must be transparent (plain and intelligible language) and prominent (clearly brought to the consumer's attention)
Limited duty situation: Claims for psychiatric harm
Pure psychiatric harm is psychiatric harm suffered without physical impact.
Claims for psychiatric harm - Primary victims
A primary victim is someone who was actually involved in the incident by being in the actual area of danger of reasonably believed he was in danger.
Claims for psychiatric harm - Primary victims test
1. Have been brought on by a sudden shock (ie. sight or sound of a horrifying event)
2. It must be a medically recognised psychiatric illness (or shock induced condition)
3. They must have been in the danger zone or reasonably believed themselves to be in the danger zone
Claims for psychiatric harm - Secondary victims
A secondary victim is someone who is not involved in the incident in the same way ie. witnesses injury to someone else; OR fears for the safety of another person).
Claims for psychiatric harm - Secondary victims test (Alcock)
1. Foreseeability of psychiatric harm - It must be reasonably foreseeable that a person of normal fortitude in the claimant's position would suffer a psychiatric harm (objective test)
2. Proximity of relationship - The claimant must have a close relationship of love and affection with the person who is endangered by the defendant's negligence.
3. Proximity in time and space - The claimant must be present at the accident or its immediate aftermath OR the claimant must see or hear the accident, or its immediate aftermath, with his own unaided senses.
4. Proximity of perception - The claimant must perceive (see or hear) the accident, or its immediate aftermath, with his own senses.
Pure psychiatric harm: rescuers
If a rescuer has been in the actual area of danger, they are a primary victim. A duty of care is owed to a primary victim, provided there is a foreseeable risk of physical injury (even though the injury he in fact suffers is pure psychiatric harm).
If a rescuer has not been in the actual area of danger so that they have not been exposed to any risk of physical injury, they will be classed as a secondary victim.
Employers' primary liability (statutory basis)
Employer's liability is most prominently enshrined in the Health and Safety at Work ect Act 1974. This imposes upon an employer a duty to ensure, as far as is reasonably practicable, the health, safety and welfare of all employers.
Employers' primary liability (common law basis)
An employer owes a duty to take reasonable care of its employee's safety while at work. The duty is to take reasonable steps to provide:
1. competent staff
2. adequate material (ie. plant and machinery)
3. a proper system of supervision
4. a safe place of work
Employers' primary liability - common law basis - Competent staff
Employee knows/ought to know of the risk posed by a particular worker to his colleagues. The risk being posed by the worker could be of psychological as well as physical harm. (ie. bullying in the workplace)
Employers' primary liability - common law basis - Adequate materials such as equipment and machinery
Where an employer does provide plant and/or equipment to his employees but it is inadequate in some way (problems caused by age of the machine, lack of serving, and inspection, inherent defects ect)
Employers' primary liability - common law basis - A proper/safe system of work and supervision
This includes the physical layout of the job, the sequence in which the work is carried out, and, where necessary, the provision of training, warnings, notices, safety equipment and the issue of special instructions.
Employers' primary liability - common law basis - Stress at work
A duty to provide a safe system of work can extend to an employee who has suffered stress as a result of his work. under the Hatton Guidelines: was injury to health through stress at work reasonably foreseeable?
Employers' primary liability - common law basis - breach
Consent (volenti non fit injuria)
Consent relates to the concept that the claimant has consented to the activity which carried a risk of harm and should not be able to blame the defendant when the risk causes harm or damage.
Test for Consent (volenti non fit injuria)
1. Claimant's knowledge and risk: the claimant must have full knowledge of BOTH the nature and extent of risk. Mere knowledge the risk exists is not sufficient.
2. Claimant's consent - the defendant must prove that the claimant freely consented to the risk of injury (either expressly (by statement) or impliedly (by actions).. Knowledge of the risk is not consent. A child or someone detained under the Mental Capacity Act unable to freely consent.
Consent (volenti non fit injuria) examples
Passengers - The defense of consent can be used where a passenger willingly accepts the risk of being injured by the negligence of the driver.
Involvement in sporting events - Participants in sporting events are generally considered to consent to the inherent risks associated with the sport, including the risk of injury from legitimate activities within the rules of the game.
Definition of Contributory negligence
Contributory negligence applies when the claimant is partly to blame for the damage or its extent. Has the claimant failed to take reasonable steps for their own safety?
Test for Contributory negligence
1. Carelessness on the claimant's part: the claimant failed to take reasonable care for their own safety
2. The carelessness contributed to the claimant's damage - did the claimant's carelessness contribute to the damage suffered by the claimant?
Examples of Contributory negligence (seatbelts)
Courts find that wearing a seatbelt would mean injuries prevented - 25% reduction
Courts find that wearing a seatbelt would mean injuries less severe - 15% reduction
Courts find that wearing a seatbelt would mean no difference - 0% reduction
Contributory negligence - special claimants
A. Children - whether an ordinary child of the claimant's age would have taken more care for his safety than the claimant did.
B. Rescuer: a rescuer will be judged against the standard of the reasonable rescuer.
C. Dilemma cases: A claimant who acts in the 'agony of the moment' due to the defendant's negligence will not be contributory negligent if the court is satisfied that the claimant's actions were a reasonable response to the danger.
Illegality (ex turpi causa non oritur actio: no action arises from this disgraceful case)
Illegality is successful when it is the main act out of which the injury arose.
Test for Illegality
1. Close connection: can the defendant establish that there is a close connection between the illegal action of the claimant and the injury the claimant has suffered?
2. Public policy: would it be contrary to public policy to allow the claimant a remedy?
Definition of necessity
Necessity is raised as a defence justifying a course of action in response to a threat of greater harm. It is strictly construed and narrowly applied.
Definition of vicarious liability
Vicarious liability is the liability of one person for torts committed by another ie. where a person may be held liable for the actions of a third party because of the relationship between the two parties.
Three essential elements for vicarious liability
1. Was the tortfeasor an employee of the defendant? The worker must be an employee (as opposed to an independent contractor).There must be a contract of service.
2. The employee must have committed a tort - wrongful and unauthorised modes of carrying out an authorised act.
3. The employee's tort must have been committed in the course of his employment
Vicarious liability - Was the tortfeasor an employee of the defendant? (Tests)
1. Integral test: The employee's activity is likely to be part of the business activity of the employer. Is the individual integral to the business or just an accessory?
2. Control test: The employee will, to a greater or lesser degree, have been under the control of the employer.
3. Economic reality test:
The employee in return for a wage provides work or sill for the employer
The employee agrees that they will work under the control of the employer
the other provisions of the contract are consistent with it being a contact
Test which the courts use to impose vicarious liability between an employer and employer is - is it fair, just and reasonable to impose vicarious liability?
Non-delegable duties: the employer may be held jointly liable with an independent contractor if the employer owes a duty which they cannot transfer or delegate.
A. Duty of care: Duty to ensure certain tasks related to safety or health) are carried out properly.
B. High-risk activities: Arise where there is a significant risk of harm, such as in hospitals, schools, or dangerous activities.
C. Vulnerability of the claimant: (e.g., children, patients).
Vicarious liability - Agency workers/loaned employees
Who had control over the worker's activites at the time of the negligent act?
- Which organisation gives instructions on how the tasks are to be performed?
- Who provides the necessary equipment for the worker to carry out their duties?
- Which organisation supervises and monitors the worker's actions on a day-to-day basis?
When does vicarious liability not apply ie. when is the tort NOT committed in the court of the employment?
There must be an unbroken sequence of events between the initial act and subsequent tort to hold the employer liable for the employee's actions
Detour v frolic
Detour: A "detour" occurs when an employee deviates slightly from their work tasks but still acts within the general scope of their employment
Frolic: This occurs when an employee substantially deviates from their work duties for personal reasons. This deviation is so significant that it cannot be seen as part of their employment
What happens if an employer if found liable for negligence of their employee?
They are both liable (joint tortfeasors) this means that the employer may recover costs of damages from the employee.
Defences to vicarious liability
Employer's Indemnity: A formal legal right available to employers under common law - Where an employer (or their insurers) has paid out compensation to someone having been found vicarious liability, the employer has a common law right to claim indemnity (i.e. its full loss) from the employee who actually committed the tort. Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978
Gentleman's Agreement: This is an informal understanding between the employer and the employee that indemnity will not be pursued unless there is evidence of collusion or wilful misconduct on part of employee (used to handle claims in situations involving loaned employees or agency workers)
Occupiers' Liability Acts
Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 (in relation to visitors)
Occupiers' Liability Act 1984 (in relation to non-visitors)
What would a claimant need to establish for Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 (Visitors)
1. establish that they have suffered loss due to the state of the premises;
2. identify the occupier;
3. prove that they are a visitor;
4. establish that the occupier failed to take reasonable care for the visitor's safety.
Occupiers' Liability Act 1957 - Occupier
An occupier is the person who controls the land or premises, and need not be the owner.
Control
The controlling concept is whether the person who exercises a sufficient degree of control to allow or prevent others entering.