1/78
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Three Models of Judicial Decision-Making
Legal Model (ruling by law/precedent), Attitudinal Model (ruling by personal policy preferences), and Strategic Model (ruling strategically under internal/external constraints).
The Legal Model
Judicial decision-making framework holding that judges decide cases based on facts evaluated in light of established legal rules, statutory language, intent, and precedent.
Plain Meaning / Textualism
Legal model approach where judges interpret laws strictly by the plain, clear, literal language of the statutory or constitutional text.
Framers' and Legislative Intent
Legal model approach where judges look beyond raw text to determine the literal intent of the lawmakers or constitutional framers who drafted the text.
Framers' Intent applies to Constitutional interpretation (discerning what 1787 delegates intended using the Federalist Papers and convention records). Legislative Intent applies to Statutory interpretation (discerning what Congress intended using committee reports, floor debates, and roll-call votes). Both fall under Originalism in the Legal Model.
Originalism
Judicial philosophy (championed by Scalia and Meese) holding that the Constitution must be interpreted according to its original public meaning at the time of ratification.
Living Constitution
Theory of constitutional interpretation holding that constitutional provisions evolve over time to reflect changing societal values and modern circumstances.
Log-Rolling (Legislative Intent Challenge)
Log-rolling is when politicians trade votes ("I'll vote for your bill if you vote for mine"). This makes it hard for judges to find a single "legislative intent" because many lawmakers only voted for the law to get a political deal, not because they agreed on what the law meant.
Precedent / Stare Decisis
Legal model doctrine requiring judges to follow past judicial rulings applied to similar facts to ensure legal consistency and stability.
Ratio Decidendi
The material facts and foundational legal reasoning of a judicial opinion that creates binding precedent for future cases.
Obiter Dicta (Dicta)
Remarks, hypotheticals, or extra commentary in an opinion that are unnecessary to resolve the immediate case and carry no binding legal precedent.
The 5 Ways to Treat Precedent
Distinguishing (facts differ), Limiting (narrowing reach), Ignoring (bypassing without overruling), Overruling (explicitly overturning), and Extending (applying rule to new context).
Distinguishing Precedent
Showing that the factual circumstances of the present case differ from a prior case, making the precedent inapplicable.
Limiting Precedent
Reconsidering a prior legal ruling to narrow its application to a specific, restricted set of circumstances.
Ignoring Precedent (Sub Silentio)
Bypassing or stepping around a prior judicial ruling without explicitly declaring it overruled.
Overruling Precedent
Explicitly declaring a past judicial decision and legal rule to be overturned and no longer binding law.
Extending Precedent
Applying an established legal rule from a past case to expand its reach into a new legal or factual context.
The Attitudinal Model
Judicial decision-making framework asserting that justices decide cases primarily based on their own unconstrained personal, political, and ideological policy preferences.
Attitudinal Model: Search & Seizure Example (Segal & Champlin)
Demonstrates that justices vote to uphold or strike down 4th Amendment searches based on whether case facts (search intrusiveness) align with their personal ideological thresholds.
Why SCOTUS Justices Are Unconstrained (Attitudinal Model)
Justices have life tenure, sit at the top of the judicial hierarchy (no fear of reversal), control their docket via certiorari, and rarely seek higher political office.
The Strategic Model
Judicial decision-making framework asserting that while justices seek policy goals, they must act strategically by anticipating the actions of colleagues and external political branches.
3 Components of the Strategic Model (Epstein & Knight)
1) Policy goals; 2) Strategic interdependence (calculating others' actions); 3) Institutional context (rules structuring choices).
External Constraints / Separation of Powers (Strategic Model)
Justices must account for Congress and the President because the Court lacks enforcement power and Congress can override statutory rulings or alter jurisdiction.
Internal Constraints / Majority Coalition Building
To establish binding precedent, SCOTUS justices must strategically bargain and adjust opinion language to secure at least 5 votes (or 2 votes on 3-judge appellate panels).
Specific Support
Short-term public approval or satisfaction with the Supreme Court's specific policy outputs and individual case rulings (measured via job approval polls).
Diffuse Support (Legitimacy / Reservoir of Goodwill)
Long-term institutional trust, loyalty, and respect that causes citizens to accept the Court's authority even when they disagree with specific decisions.
Positivity Frames
Media coverage displaying judicial symbols (robes, marble courthouse, solemn procedure) that reinforce the public's diffuse support and institutional loyalty.
Descriptive Representation
Whether the composition of the bench reflects the demographic characteristics (such as race, gender, or professional background) of the general population.
Substantive Representation
Whether judges from underrepresented backgrounds actively rule in ways that advance the specific policy interests and legal rights of those demographic groups.
Individual Effect (Judicial Diversity)
Whether a judge's demographic background or prior career directly alters how that specific judge votes on the merits of a case.
Panel Effect (Judicial Diversity)
Whether the presence of a diverse judge (e.g., female or minority) on a multi-judge panel causes colleagues to change their voting behavior.
Informational Account (Judicial Diversity)
Theory that diverse judges bring unique personal or professional experiences to panel deliberations, providing informational cues that influence colleagues in specialized legal areas.
Venire
The master pool of prospective jurors summoned to the courthouse, typically drawn from voter registration lists and driver's license rolls.
Missouri Venire Selection
Missouri compiles its jury pool (venire) by combining voter registration lists with driver's license records.
Jury Size Rules
Federal criminal trials require 12 jurors and unanimity; states are constitutionally permitted to use smaller juries (down to 6 jurors) in non-capital criminal cases.
Voir Dire
The questioning process ("to speak the truth") of prospective jurors by the judge and attorneys to identify biases and select a jury.
Challenge for Cause
A request to remove a prospective juror based on demonstrated, articulated bias or inability to follow the law (unlimited in number).
Peremptory Challenge
A limited number of requests allowing attorneys to excuse a prospective juror without stating a reason, subject to constitutional protections against discrimination.
Batson Test (3-Step Procedure)
1) Opponent raises inference of racial/gender discrimination; 2) Striking party offers race/gender-neutral reason; 3) Judge determines if purposeful discrimination occurred.
Reading: Unah (2009)
Examines decision-making theories, contrasting the legal model (precedent, originalism, intent, balancing) with the attitudinal model, Solicitor General influence, and public opinion.
Reading: Murphy
Analyzes legal reasoning by example (Cardozo, Levi, Goodhart), ratio decidendi vs. dicta, precedent treatments, and empirical limits of stare decisis (Segal & Spaeth).
Reading: Segal & Champlin
Demonstrates the attitudinal model, showing that justices' personal policy preferences and ideological values strongly predict their votes in 4th Amendment search-and-seizure cases.
Reading: Epstein & Knight (Ch. 1)
Presents the strategic account of judicial choices, showing how justices navigate institutional rules and anticipate colleagues and external branches to achieve policy goals.
Reading: Gibson, Caldeira & Spence (2000)
Analyzes Bush v. Gore, finding that the controversial decision did not erode SCOTUS institutional legitimacy due to the buffering effect of diffuse support.
Reading: Ura & Merrill
Distinguishes specific support from diffuse support, examining how public opinion influences Court behavior while institutional standing maintains judicial authority.
Reading: Harris & Sen (2026)
Finds that judges with prior career experience as public defenders are less punitive, resulting in lower incarceration rates and shorter prison sentences.
Reading: Boyd, Epstein & Martin (2010)
Shows that adding a female judge to a 3-judge panel significantly increases the likelihood that male colleagues vote for sex discrimination plaintiffs (panel effect).
Reading: Lieberman (2011)
Evaluates scientific jury selection, concluding that while case-specific legal attitudes offer some predictive value, evidence strength remains the primary determinant of trial outcomes.
Reading: Vidmar & Hans
Examines the legal history, democratic function, and procedural dynamics of juries, including voir dire and scientific selection methods.
Case: Craig v. Boren (1976)
Landmark case where Justice Brennan strategically established "intermediate scrutiny" for sex discrimination to build a 5-justice majority rather than risking failure with strict scrutiny.
Case: Bush v. Gore (2000)
Controversial 5-4 ruling resolving the 2000 presidential election recount; studied by Gibson et al. to prove that diffuse support shields Court legitimacy from high-profile political backlash.
Case: Williams v. Florida (1970)
Supreme Court ruling holding that 6-person juries in state criminal trials are constitutionally permissible under the 6th Amendment.
Case: Swain v. Alabama (1965)
Ruling that striking Black jurors via peremptory challenges in a single case did not violate Equal Protection unless a systematic, multi-case historical pattern was proven (overruled by Batson).
Case: Batson v. Kentucky (1986)
Overruled Swain, holding that using peremptory challenges to exclude jurors based on race in an individual trial violates 14th Amendment Equal Protection.
Case: Texas v. Johnson (1989)
First Amendment flag-burning case cited by Scalia to illustrate that Originalism forces judges to rule against their personal political preferences.
Case: General Electric Co. v. Gilbert (1976)
SCOTUS ruled pregnancy discrimination was not sex discrimination under Title VII; Congress strategically overrode the Court by passing the Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978.
Case: Strauder v. West Virginia (1880)
Landmark ruling declaring that state statutes explicitly excluding Black citizens from jury pools violate the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.
Case: Hoyt v. Florida (1961)
Upheld automatic jury exemptions for women based on traditional gender roles; later overturned by Taylor v. Louisiana (1975).
Case: AT&T v. FCC
Slide example of Textualism / Plain Meaning analysis, interpreting whether corporate entities qualify for "personal privacy" rights under federal statute.
AT&T argued that because FOIA defines the noun "person" to include corporations, the adjective "personal" covers corporate privacy. SCOTUS ruled 8-0 that in ordinary English grammar, "personal" applies exclusively to human individuals. Importance: Landmark Plain Meaning / Textualism precedent ensuring corporate records cannot be shielded from public FOIA requests under personal privacy claims.
The Conflict: AT&T tried to use a technical loophole—arguing that since a corporation is legally a "person," it has "personal privacy."
The Ruling: SCOTUS said no—in everyday English, "personal" refers to humans, not companies.
Why Textualism: The Court relied strictly on plain dictionary definitions and normal English grammar.
Quote: Alexander Hamilton (Federalist No. 78)
"The judiciary… has no influence over either the sword or the purse… It may be truly said to have neither FORCE nor WILL but merely judgment; and must ultimately depend upon the aid of the executive arm even for the efficacy of its judgments."
Quote: Edwin Meese III
"Those who framed the Constitution chose their words carefully… It is incumbent upon the Court to determine what that meaning was" (Original Intent).
Quote: Justice Joseph Story
"Where the words are plain and clear, and the sense distinct and perfect arising on them, there is generally no necessity to have recourse to other means of interpretation" (Plain Meaning).
Quote: Justice Hugo Black
"No law means no law" (Literal First Amendment Textualism).
Quote: Justice William J. Brennan Jr.
Originalism is "little more than arrogance cloaked in humility" (Critique of Originalism).
Quote: Justice Benjamin N. Cardozo
Described legal reasoning as matching "the colors of the case at hand against the colors of many sample cases spread out upon the desk… When the colors do not match… then the serious business of the judge begins."
Quote: Judge Frank M. Coffin
"If precedent clearly governed, a case would never get as far as the Court of Appeals: the parties would settle" (Indeterminate Law in Hard Cases).
Quote: Justice Sandra Day O'Connor
"The Court's power lies… in its legitimacy, a product of substance and perception that shows itself in the people's acceptance of the Judiciary as fit to determine what the Nation's law means" (Planned Parenthood v. Casey).
Quote: James L. Gibson & Gregory A. Caldeira
"To know courts is to love them" (Positivity frames and diffuse support).
Video Specifics: Justice Antonin Scalia Interview
Scalia defends Originalism, rejects the Living Constitution, notes his vote in Texas v. Johnson forced him to protect flag-burning against his personal stance, and highlights his close friendship with Justice Ginsburg.
Graph: Public Approval by Federal Branch (Gallup 2000–2014)
Visual line chart showing the Supreme Court consistently maintains higher public approval (50–70%) than the President or Congress over time, illustrating baseline diffuse support.
Graph: Supreme Court Approval by Political Party (Gallup 2000–2025)
Visual line chart showing severe partisan divergence: Republican approval surged to ~75% while Democratic approval fell to ~11% following major ideological court decisions.