1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Informed Consent
agreement or permission accompanied by full notice about the care, treatment, or service that is the subject of the consent
the process that takes place between a physician and patient
Mohr v Williams
one of the precursor cases that stated patients have the right to complete immunity of his persons from physical interference of others
Scholendorff vs Society of New York Hospital
most important case for consent, every human being of adult years and sound mind has a right to determine what shall be done with his own body, and a surgeon who performs an operation without his pts consent is committing assult
The requirement for informed consent is grounded in
autonomy/respect for persons
4th and section 1 of the 14th
Informed Component of Informed Consent
adequate disclosure of information and adequate comprehension by patients or surrogates of what is disclosed
Consent Component of Informed Consent
voluntary decrision or agreement on tha part of a competent person
5 Elements of Informed Consent
disclosure
understanding/comprehension
voluntariness
competence
consent
Disclosure
element of informed consent, physician should thoroughly document the communications process
can be the reasonable physician standard, the reasonable pt standard, or the subjective pt standard
Salgo v Leland Stanford
case that set the precedent for the informed component of informed consent (abdominal aortic aneurism)
all the facts which mutually affect the pts rights and interests and of the surgical risk, hazard and danger, if any
Natanson v Kline
more specific case on how much medical info should be disclosed, should be of that which a reasonable medical practitioner would make under the same or similar circumstances
so long as it was motivated only by the patient’s best therapeutic interests and he proceeded as competent medical men would have donw
Reasonable Physican Standard of Disclosure
the right amount of disclosure is what other reasonable physicians would disclose
Reasonable Patient Standard of Disclosure
patient might want more information that a medical professional would, informed consent depends on the individual circumstances of a patient
Canterbury v Spence
case that determined reasonable patient standard
Subjective Patient Standard of Disclosure
the amount of information a patient needs is what should be disclosed
some patients might desire more information than the standard “reasonable” patient, and the physician must provide information to that standard
6 Legal Minimal Disclosures
the pts diagnosis
the nature and purpose of a proposed treatment or procedure
the risks and benefits of a proposed treatment or procedure
alternatives and associated risks and benefits
the risks and benefits of not receiving or undergoing a treatment procedure
any potential conflicts of interest
Understanding
element of informed consent, an exchange of information where the patient is encouraged or subject to ask questions
health literacy principles are helpful to establish patient understanding, promoting shared decision making is also beneficial
Health Literacy Principles
never assume understanding
know your audience (the patient’s level of health literacy)
translate medical information into everyday language, limit to essential information and prioritize
use visual aids where possible
have patients repeat back and explain (or “teach-back”) the information you have provided
if language is a barrier, use a certified medical translator if possible
document the patient’s understanding in the EHR
invite questions
Promoting Shared Decision Making
encourage the patient to play an active role in decisions, ensure that the patients are informed, protect the patient’s best interest, try to persuade patients
Voluntariness
element of informed consent, decision must be free from coercion or manipulation

Persuasion
argument using reason and evidence that can be used when informing patient
Competence
element of informed consent, determined by a court or judge
physicians can determine capacity, if they can make reasonable decisions based on rational reasons
can be assessed by physician during conversation, does not have to be done by a specific test (but can)
3 Elements of Capacity
capacity to reach a decision based on rational reasons
capacity to reach a reasonable result throught decision
capacity to make a decision at all
Consent
element of informed consent, if a pt with substantial understanding ad in substantial absence of control by others intentionally authorizes a professional to do something
Signed Consent Fomr
not a substitute for truly informed consent, rather a documentation or the informed consent process
4 Exceptions to Informed Consent
lack of decision-making capacity
emergencies
waiver (they want someone else to make medical decisions)
therapeutic privilege (when giving the pt information would be harmful to them)
Translators
must be licensed/trained medical translator
can use translation services
What should be done in the case of an emergency (if possible)?
advance directives/living will
find a surrogate who will make descisions
Standard of Care/Best Practices
A properly negotiated informed consent benefits both the physician and the patient – a therapeutic alliance is forged in which the physician’s work is facilitated because the patient has realistic expectations about the results of the treatment, is prepared for possible complications, and is more likely to be a willing collaborator in the treatment