1/73
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Class action suits
a small group of people sueing a large group of people
Justiciable disputes
a constraint on the courts requiring case be capable of being settled by legal methods
Amicus Curiae
"Friend of the Court" file briefs or even appear to argue their interest orally before the court; interest groups use this to try to sway the court
Original Jurisdiction
Courts that hear a case first, usually in a trial.
Appellate Jurisdiction
The power vested in an appellate court to review and/or revise the decision of a lower court
District Courts
The lower courts hear cases involving bankruptcy and civil suits under federal law.
Courts of Appeals
Intermediate appellate courts in the federal system.
Senatorial Courtesy
Deferring the selection of district court judges to the choice of senators of their own party and representing that state.
Stare Decisis
The doctrine that justices and courts apply and follow precedents when deciding cases to ensure consistency and stability
Precedents
A prior judicial decision that serves as a rule for settling subsequent cases of a similar nature.
Original Intent
Is a method of constitutional and legal interpretation that seeks to discern the original meaning of the words being construed
Judicial Review
power of the courts to review acts of other branches of government and the states
Judicial Restraint
courts should allow the decesions of other branches to stand
Judicial Activisim
Court should play a role in shaping national policies
Civil Law
body of laws which are concerned with the private affairs of citizens; housing, divorce, bankruptcy, property damage
Concurring Opinion
a signed opinion in which one or more members agree with the majority view but for different reasons
Dissenting Opinion
an opinion disagreeing with the majority decision in a Supreme Court ruling
Majority Opinion
a court opinion reflecting the views of the majority of the judges
Oral Argument
An opportunity for lawyers to summarize their position before the court and also to answer the judges' questions.
Senate Confirmation
the process outlined in Article Two of the Constitution, giving the Senate the authority to approve appointments made by the president
Writ of Certiorari
a request from the Court to order up records from a lower court to review the case
Rule of Four
At least four justices of the Supreme Court must vote to consider a case before it can be heard.
brief
A written statement by an attorney that summarizes a case and the laws and rulings that support it
criminal law
A law that defines crimes against the public order.
litigant
someone involved in a lawsuit
litigation
the process of taking legal action; lawsuit
writ of mandamus
Court order directing an official to perform an official duty.
Marbury v. Madison (1803)
This case establishes the Supreme Court's power of Judicial Review
Federalist #78
Argument by Alexander Hamilton that the federal judiciary would be unlikely to infringe upon rights and liberties but would serve as a check on the other two branches; justices have life tenure
Power of the Judicial Branch
interpret laws; determine the constitutionality and legality of actions
McCulloch vs. Maryland - Background
A state passed a tax on the Bank of the US, and the Baltimore branch refused to pay it. Ultimately, this was about the constitutionality of the US Bank.
McCulloch vs. Maryland - Issue
Supremacy Clause (Article VI)
McCulloch vs. Maryland - Holding
Determined that a bank chartered by the US government was constitutional based on the necessary and proper clause. States cannot tax federal entities because of the Supremacy Clause.
McCulloch vs. Maryland - Significance
Congress has implied powers necessary to implement its enumerated powers. This case established the supremacy of the U.S. Constitution and federal laws over state laws (Supremacy Clause). Created the doctrine of implied powers.
United States vs. Lopez - Background
A student in Texas brought a handgun into a school and was charged with a federal crime for violating the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990.
United States v. Lopez - Issue
Commerce Clause (Article I Section 8)
United States vs. Lopez - Holding
The Court determined that the GFSZA exceeded Congress's power under the Commerce Clause because it did not substantially affect interstate commerce.
United States vs. Lopez - Significance
This case marked a significant turning point in the interpretation of federalism. First time in nearly 60 years that the Court had limited Congress's power under the Commerce Clause and expanded the state's power.
Baker vs. Carr - Background
Tennessee's last redistricting was in 1901 and residents alleged that state congressional redistricting didn't take into account population shifts (from rural to urban areas).
Baker v. Carr - Issue
14th Amendment - Equal protection Clause (1962)
Baker vs. Carr - Holding
Supreme Court, in a 6-2 decision, ruled that the reapportionment issue is justiciable in federal court. The Court sent the case back to the district court. People can challenge unequal reapportionment and redistricting plans that may violate the Equal Protection Clause.
Baker vs. Carr - Significance
The Courts ruled this issue was justiciable and that all state districts must have relatively equal populations. It led to the "one person, one vote" rule.
Shaw vs. Reno - Background
The plaintiffs argued that the redistricting plan in North Carolina created one oddly shaped majority-minority district drawn primarily based on race.
Shaw vs. Reno - Holding
In a 5-4 decision, the Court sent the case back to the district court with the instructions to use a strict scrutiny standard to evaluate racial gerrymandering cases. The lower court ruled that using only race can be a violation because it opposes the "colorblind" ideal of U.S. law.
Shaw vs. Reno - Significance
District lines cannot be drawn SOLEY based on race (cannot gather those of the same race into voting districts). To this day, courts use this decision to show that using race to make decisions about voting districts, school districts, and housing laws may be unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause unless there is a compelling government interest other than race.
Marbury vs. Madison - Background
A judge appointed by one president did not receive his commission due to the incoming president's actions. The Secretary of State refused to honor the appointment.
Marbury vs. Madison - Issue
Article III
Marbury vs. Madison - Holding
The Court ruled that the Judiciary Act of 1789 was unconstitutional. The court asserted its authority to interpret the Constitution and declare laws unconstitutional.
Marbury vs. Madison - Significance
The Court established their power of Judicial Review- their power to declare an act unconstitutional.
Engel vs. Vitale - Background
The school board wrote a non-denominational prayer to be voluntarily recited in public schools in New York.
Engel vs. Vitale - Issue
1st Amendment - Establishment Clause (1962)
Engel vs. Vitale - Holding
The Court held that government-directed prayer in public schools is unconstitutional because it constitutes government endorsement of religion. The Court said this case was an unnecessary entanglement of church and state.
Engel vs. Vitale - Significance
Prayer can mainly be limited in public schools because kids are a "captive audience." This decision began the precedent to strike down religious practices of state officials in certain contexts (like prohibiting organized prayer at school events like football games and graduation ceremonies).
Wisconsin vs. Yoder - Background
State law required mandatory attendance in schools through the age of 16. Three Amish families refused to allow their children to attend public high school, claiming what was taught in school was contrary to their beliefs.
Wisconsin vs. Yoder - Issue
1st Amendment - Free Exercise Clause (1971)
Wisconsin vs. Yoder - Holding
The Court ruled in favor of the Amish parents, holding that the state's compulsory education law infringed upon their free exercise of religion.
Wisconsin vs. Yoder - Significance
It opened the door to religious exemptions for mandatory policies like vaccinations or military service. It also developed the precedent that parents were allowed to educate their children outside of either the public school system or traditional private schools.
Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent School District - Background
Students wore black armbands in protest of the Vietnam War and were sent home for violating school policy. The students who wore the armbands were suspended.
Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent School District - Issue
1st Amendment - Freedom of Speech (1969)
Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent School District - Holding
The Court ruled in a 7-2 decision that wearing armbands were protected as symbolic speech for students. Student speech can only be suppressed when it interferes with school operations.
Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent School District - Significance
Although this decision expanded free speech rights for students in schools, other Supreme Court decisions, Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier and Morse v. Frederick, have limited Tinker's application and have given school officials more discretion in punishing student speech.
Schenck vs. United States - Background
Defendants were charged with violating the Espionage Act by distributing leaflets encouraging people to resist the military draft during World War I peacefully.
Schenck vs. United States - Issue
1st Amendment - Free Speech Clause (1919)
Schenck vs. United States - Holding
The Court determined in a unanimous decision that the First Amendment does not protect messages that urge behavior that violates the law. This ruling created the "Clear and Present Danger" test.
Schenck vs. United States - Significance
This was the standard for free speech until the imminent lawless danger replaced it in the Brandenberg v. Ohio (1969) ruling.
New York Times Co. vs. the United States - Background
President Nixon tried to invoke prior restraint to stop newspapers from publishing leaked classified documents about the Vietnam War in the Pentagon Papers because it posed a danger to national security.
New York Times Co. vs. the United States - Issue
1st Amendment - Free Press Clause (1971)
New York Times Co. vs. the United States - Holding
In this per curiam decision, the Court struck down Nixon's action for violating the First Amendment using prior restraint without heavy justification of national security.
New York Times Co. vs. the United States - Significance
This case is considered a victory for the First Amendment's protection of the free press against government censorship. Prior restraint is presumptively unconstitutional and needs heavy justification for the government to prevent information from being published, even in situations where national security may be at issue.
Citizen's United vs. Federal Elections Committee - Background
A nonprofit organization produced a film critical of Hillary Clinton in 2008. The FEC regulated the film as an independent expenditure political advertisement. The nonprofit challenged the limits on campaign spending in the McCain-Feingold Act.
Citizen's United vs. Federal Elections Committee - Issue
1st Amendment - Free Speech (2010)
Citizen's United vs. Federal Elections Committee - Holding
The Court determined that corporations and unions are "persons," and their political spending is an independent expenditure and is considered protected free speech.
Citizen's United vs. Federal Elections Committee - Significance
This ruling opened up election influence by corporations through independent expenditures. Campaign spending by corporations and unions cannot be limited.
Shaw vs. Reno - Issue
14th Amendment - Equal Protection Clause (1992)