1/20
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What four environmental and situational constraints lead to decision biases when prioritizing efficiency?
Decision biases arise under complex decisions, uncertainty, changing information, and time pressure.
What is the Bounded Rationality Model, and why do humans rely on it instead of the Rational Model?
The Bounded Rationality Model describes how people simplify complex problems to make "good enough" decisions. Humans use it due to three primary constraints: 1. Cognitive limitations that prevent processing all available data. 2. High costs associated with gathering comprehensive information. 3. Our tendency to be satisficers—settling for an acceptable option rather than spending infinite energy searching for the absolute best.
What inputs are used in the Rational Decision-Making Model, and what are its key limitations?
The rational model relies on inputs (affects decisions) such as information, preferences, and goals. Its limitations include incomplete information, vague or conflicting goals, environmental changes, and brain processing limits (such as intelligence bounds, information overload, and time pressure).
What consequennces comes from Rationality?
Consequences from rationality are systematic biases: Lead to overestimations, bad investments and time pressures.
In the Carter Racing example, how does analyzing only partial data lead to a flawed choice?
Looking only at races with blown engines suggested a 29% failure rate. However, analyzing the full dataset—including races where no gasket failures occurred—revealed that the risk of gasket failure was actually low at higher temperatures.
Define Selection Bias and Survivorship Bias using the aircraft example.
Selection bias occurs when data is selected non-randomly, excluding critical information. Survivorship bias (a form of selection bias) occurs when analyzing only the elements that "survived" a process (e.g., examining returning airplanes with bullet holes) while ignoring those that did not (the lost planes that were shot down in critical unexamined areas).
What factors affect the decision-making of the individual?
Overconfidence biases, sunk cost fallacy and illusion of control.
What is the Overconfidence Bias (Better-Than-Average Effect)? Give the textbook statistic.
It is the tendency for individuals to overestimate their own qualities and abilities relative to peers. For example, 93% of students/drivers rate their driving skills as above average.
How does the Sunk Cost Fallacy warp decision-making?
It is the tendency to invest additional future resources into a failing scenario simply because prior investments have already been made, anchoring choices on past track records to "cut losses" rather than evaluating future net utility.
What is the Illusion of Control? Describe the classic light switch experiment.
It is the tendency to overestimate one's ability to influence events that are actually random or uninfluenced. In experiments, participants believed that turning a light switch on and off gave them direct control over light patterns that were actually flashing at random.
What factors affect the decision making in a group level?
Power distance, leadership style, lack of familiarity.
What are the pros and cons of high Power Distance in group decision-making, and how can teams overcome its drawbacks?
Positive: Improves overall group coordination. Negative: Reduces psychological safety, leading to fewer questions asked and less information sharing. Solution: Have lower-power members speak first to encourage open contribution and reduce conformity pressure.
What is Transactive Memory, and how does it help unfamiliar teams?
Transactive memory is a collective memory system through which group members encode, store, and retrieve shared knowledge together, allowing the team to leverage everyone's specialized expertise.
What factors affect the decision making in a system level?
Complex interactions, tight coupling
How does Complex Systems Theory explain why good decision-making can trigger unintended outcomes?
Complex systems consist of many interdependent components interacting with each other and their environment. Because of these interdependencies, system behavior is unpredictable, and localized decisions frequently trigger unintended downstream consequences.
What is Tight Coupling, and what are its three defining elements?
Tight coupling is a system structure where a breakdown in one subsystem rapidly propagates to trigger problems in other areas. Its three core elements are: 1. Time dependence: A very short window of opportunity to act (e.g., responding to a cybersecurity breach). 2. One dominant path: No alternative routes available to reach the goal (e.g., relying on a single supplier). 3. Very little slack: Personnel or resources are heavily burdened by constraints (e.g., a chronically understaffed hospital team).
How do we overcome decision biases:
Incentives, nudging and training.
How do Incentives improve decision quality?
Because people act in their own self-interest and tend to avoid unnecessary effort, providing financial rewards, awards, recognition, or accountability forces individuals to engage in deliberate, careful thinking.
What is Nudging? Provide three specific examples mentioned in the text.
Nudging involves changing how information or choices are presented to guide desirable behaviors without restricting freedom. Examples include: Altering Defaults & Framing: Setting optimal choices as the default. Choice Architecture (Google Example): Placing healthy foods closer and moving unhealthier foods farther away. Color-Coding Schemes: Using traffic light colors (green, yellow, red) to signal healthy vs. unhealthy options. Public Commitment Devices: Posting goals publicly on social media to increase psychological accountability.
How does Training & Feedback combat cognitive biases long term?
Providing direct feedback on decision biases—through tools like instructional videos or computer games—improves long-term decision-making awareness and self-correction.
What are the three steps for managing decision-making in complex systems, and what is a Premortem Exercise?
1. Identify influencing factors: Pinpoint individual, team, and external forces that could disrupt the system. 2. Map chain reactions: Trace downstream failure consequences. 3. Include contingencies: Plan reactions to system failures in advance. Premortem Exercise: A technique where a team imagines a project has already failed before it launches, working backward to identify and neutralize failure points in advance.