1/110
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What had been seen in the last years of Henry VIII’s reign?
Factional struggle
What appeared to have ended the factional struggle seen in the last years of Henry’s reign?
The triumph of Somerset and the ‘reformist’ faction over the ‘Catholic’ faction with the defeat of Henry’s plan for a balanced Regency Council.
What event strengthened the Catholic faction despite the reformists domination of the government?
Events of summer of 1549 gave the Catholic faction an opportunity to reassert itself.
What was the impact of the 1549 unrest for the ruling elite?
Although unrest in countryside put down, ruling elite concerned by disorder. Some of rebel’s complaints against them.
Impact of the 1549 unrest on Somerset
Disquiet within governing circles about the personal nature of Somerset’s government revealed through letters from Paget. Led to the formation of the anti-Somerset faction.
What did the anti-Somerset faction have in common?
Group had little in common except dislike of Somerset’s methods + policies.
Who did the anti-Somerset faction include?
Paget, Warwick (made Duck of Northumberland, 1547) Wriothesley.
What were the motivations for 3 key members of the anti-Somerset faction?
Wriothesley - Somerset’s religious policies
Warwick - seen opportunity to advance own power
Paget - concerned about Somerset ignoring his advice
What events provided the anti-Somerset faction with the opportunity to act?
The events of the summer of 1549
What did Somerset do as his power declined?
He retreated to Hampton Court with Edward.
What did Somerset do on 5 October 1549?
He summoned loyal subjects to Hampton Court to defend him and the king, but moved the next day to Windsor with Edward.
What did Edward do after Somerset took him away with him?
He fell ill, claimed he was a prisoner and banned his uncle. He stated that Somerset had threatened riots if he was removed from power.
How did Somerset respond to Edward’s claims and what was the result of this?
He denied them but could not contradict the king and was removed within a week.
Was Warwick’s triumph guaranteed following Somerset’s removal?
No, far from.
Why was Warwick’s triumph not guaranteed?
The Council contained a majority of religious conservatives who did not trust Warwick.
What did Warwick do to try and help consolidate his rise to power? Was this successful?
He brought his own allies so that he had a Protestant majority, but in early December, there were rumours of a Catholic plot to remove him.
How did Warwick respond to the rumours of a Catholic plot to remove him?
He seized the opportunity, declaring any who attacked Somerset were attacking him.
What had happened by January 1550?
The leading Catholics, the Earls of Arundel and Southampton had been dismissed and Warwick was Lord President of the Council.
What did Warwick do to further enhance his power?
He placed his own supporters in important positions around Edward.
What was Warwick forced to do in order to succeed and what impact did this have?
Forced to ally with more religiously radical members. Would impact on religious developments.
What did Warwick attempt once he was secure?
A reconciliation with Somerset.
What was the impact of the factional struggle from October 1549 until early 1550 and the crisis in October?
Factional struggle didn’t effect administration of country which continued to function and did not impact on the efficiency of the government. Crisis in October short-lived and did not threaten the monarchy.
What happened to Somerset?
He was released from jail by Warwick, his goods were restored and his daughter married Warwick’s son. He was restored to court and the Privy Council.
When and why was Somerset executed?
22 January 1552 because he continued to plot in an attempt to recover his position.
Was the evidence used to execute Somerset accurate?
Some may have been fabricated to justify his death.
What was the greatest threat Edward caused to the stability of the monarchy?
His age.
How old was Edward when he took the throne?
9 years old
What did Edward have no experience in when he took to the throne?
diplomacy (needed to be calm under pressure)
warfare
Examples of previous minors on the throne in England
Henry III - 9, civil war broke out after he came of age
Richard II - 10 (1377), deposed in 1399 because of his rule after he came of age
Henry VI 8 months (1422), although reign witnessed Wars of the Roses, England relatively stable during minority
Edward V, 12 (1483), imprisoned + probably murdered by uncle + supposed protector, Richard III, lost him support _ aided Henry Tudor in his claim
General analysis of the previous experiences of minors on the throne
In many instances ok as minors, but faced problems once came to age. Also clearly weak and subject to violence and risk of life from others wishing to consolidate power.
What were the problems with having a minor on the throne?
Concerns would create instability:
unable to lead troops in battle
other states might look to exploit weakness of minor + attack
England might return to civil war as had happened in C15
minor would not be able to control factional struggles similar to those of last years of Henry VIII
in age of personal monarchy, concerns about image, difficult to portray Edward as a powerful / militarily adept
How did Edwards later image compare to initial expectations?
Later image as sickly child not true when came to throne, there was every expectation in 1547 that he would reach adulthood + produce an heir
What had Henry done to try and reduce tensions and secure the Tudor dynasty?
1543 - issued a Third Succession Act: if Edward died without heirs, throne would pass to Mary; ‘should the Lady Mary die without heirs, then the crown shall pass to the Lady Elizabeth and to her heirs’
What did Henry VIII Third Succession Act change and what did it not?
Reversed the earlier Succession Acts which excluded Mary and Elizabeth from succession, did not reverse their illegitimacy.
Where did Henry confirm the Third Succession Act?
In his will. As his health declined in 1546 he was aware Edward would come to the throne as a minor + wanted to try and avoid disputes about the succession.
What did Henry establish which show his concern about political stability under Edward as a minor king?
The Regency Council
What was the Regency Council?
A balance between ‘reformists’ led by Seymour (later Duke of Somerset) and ‘Catholics’ under Norfolk and Gardiner.
Who and how was the Regency Council undermined by?
Paget and Denny who left plenty of space in the king’s will for changes to the king’s wishes to be made. Appears details about the Council only added when king close to death + unable to prevent them. Task made easier as Norfolk removed + Gardiner in the Tower.
Who controlled the dry stamp and what was it’s significance?
Denny controlled the dry stamp of the King’s signature which could be inked in, meaning his signature wasn’t actually required to change the will.
What were Denny and Paget able to do following the king’s death and who did this help?
They were able to keep Henry’s death quiet for a few days allowing the reformists to consolidate their positions and Somerset establish himself + exercise virtual royal power.
Was Somerset’s assumption of power surprising? Why?
Unsurprising - Edward’s uncle + had built up a reputation as a successful soldier during the campaigns against Scotland in the 1540s
What was the transfer of power to Somerset like?
Smooth
What were the arguments for and against the Regency Council?
Against the Regency Council - council of 16 with every member having equal voice means very unlikely decisions would be reached.
Questions as to the legality of Somerset’s power as it went against Henry’s wishes for the Regency Council.
What was a serious concern about Mary’s accession?
That she was female.
What had been the only other previous result of a female ruler in England?
In C12, Matilda. Resulted in civil war as many had refused to accept Matilda as queen and supported Stephen instead.
What law did some countries exclude women from?
The Salic law. A C11 law from France which excluded women from succeeding to the throne.
What is potentially one of the reasons Henry VIII was so concerned about having a male heir?
Because he believed a female ruler would create dynastic weakness.
What were some of the reasons it was feared a female ruler would weaken the monarchy?
would not be able to control faction
would not be able to lead an army into battle
expected to marry - who to marry + expectation would be subservient to their husbands
What were problems associate with Mary marrying an Englishman or a foreigner?
Englishman - power of her husband’s family would increase + they might dominate the court
Foreigner - fears the country would be dominated by foreigners
Who was John Knox and what did he write in 1558?
Scottish theologian. The First Blast and Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women.
What did John Knox express in his tract?
His view that it was unnatural and insulting to God for a woman to rule.
What caused more problems than Mary’s gender?
Her decision to marry Philip of Spain.
Who were the two realistic candidates Mary could have married?
Edward Courtenay, Earl of Devon, backed by Gardiner
Philip of Spain, back by Paget
What made Courtenay an eligible candidate?
He was descended from royal blood
Why was Mary’s preference for Philip?
The marriage would bring England closer to the Habsburgs, the family yo which Mary’s mother, Catherine of Aragon, was related
What was the potential advantage Philip could offer but also risk?
He was a powerful ruler who could protect Mary.
She was expected to be subservient to him and therefore could be dragged into wars which would not benefit the nation.
What fear played a significant role in Wyatt’s rebellion of 1554?
Fears that England would be dragged into foreign wars which did not benefit it as a result of Mary’s marriage to Philip of Spain, a foreigner
What is an argument for the success of female rulers?
Could be argued Mary’s skill defeated Wyatt’s rebellion, and therefore that female rule was able to preserve the monarchy.
When did Mary inform the Council that it was her intention to marry Philip and how did they respond?
Informed them on 27 October 1553. There was a petition from the House of Commons opposing her decision.
How did Mary respond to the petition from the House of Commons?
She ignored it.
When was a marriage treaty presented to the Council and subsequently approved?
Presented - 7 December 1553. Approved - January 1554.
What were the treaty and reassurances unable to prevent?
Rebellion
When did Rebellion break out and when did plotting begin?
Plotting begun as soon as there were rumours of the marriage. Rebellion broke out in January 1554, only 6 months after the defeat of Lady Jane Grey.
What can the rebellion be used as evidence of?
The instability caused by a female ruler
Who was involved in the plotting of the 1554 rebellion?
Members of the political elite, led by:
Sir James Croft
Sir Peter Carew
Sir Thomas Wyatt
What positions had the men leading the rebellion previously held and what were their fears?
Held office under Henry VIII and Edward. Feared would be replaced by Spaniards who would dominate the court and government.
What was the initial plan of the rebellion of 1554?
A four-pronged rising based in Devon, Leicestershire, the Welsh borders and Kent.
What was the actual result of the rising?
Only the rising in Kent actually rose.
What are the debates surrounding the cause of the rebellion?
Proclamation of marriage main cause publicised - would gain more support from people as honing in on sense of nationality, religious rebellion would only gain half the support as people divided in beliefs.
Wyatt was a Protestant and the other leaders all had links with reformed with.
What had the rebels planned and who betrayed them?
Rebels had planned to depose Mary and marry Elizabeth to Courtenay. Courtenay disclosed the scheme and forced the rebels to act early.
Evidence that Wyatt’s rebellion of 1554 was a threat.
A royal force under Norfolk sent to confront the rebels deserted.
The rebels got to the gates of the city of London
What were factors of the rebellions defeat and what did they show?
Mary’s resolution and refusal to leave the city.
A sign that a female ruler was not necessarily weak.
What did the rebellion have an impact on despite its defeat?
The stability of the marriage. It did not take place until 12 months after Mary came to the throne and after the marriage Philip spent more time abroad than in England limiting his influence to, at best, a distant confidant.
What was one of the major concerns of a female leader?
That she would be unable to control factions.
What is an example of when Mary had appeared unable to control factions?
Over her proposed marriage, two of her leading councillors supported different suitors.
What were the fears of the impact of a Spanish marriage on factions?
Would create factional strife between English courtiers, who they believed would dominate the court + be given positions within the administration.
Is there any evidence that the Spanish marriage had an impact on administrative efficiency?
No.
What sort of size was Mary’s Privy Council and why?
Large - she brought in her own supporters who had helped her gain the throne but also kept many experienced administrators.
Why did some argue Mary’s Privy Council was ineffective?
Because of it’s large size
Evidence to challenge the view that Mary’s Privy Council was ineffective due to it’s large size.
rare for all councillors to be present
average size of meetings similar to those held under Northumberland
committees established in 1554 which excluded casual councillors
1555 - ‘inner circle’ established
Philip’s departure in 1555 + death of Gardiner in November 1555 allowed Paget to dominate and establish a conciliar from of government
Did Gardiner and Paget get along?
No, many clashes.
What were some examples of clashes between Gardiner and Paget?
Mary’s marriage
The revival of the heresy laws
When did parliament reject and agree to the heresy laws
Rejected in April 1554.
Agreed when they had guarantees that monastic lands would not be restored to the Catholic Church.
What does the initial rejection of the heresy laws suggest and what is a counter argument for this?
That Mary’s religious policies were unpopular.
The struggle to reintroduce them was part of the factional struggle between Paget and Gardiner, because the same legislation that had initially been rejected was passed once Paget and his supporters backed out.
Were Gardiner and Paget problematic for Mary?
Not majorly, despite the delay in introducing the legislation and the desire of Gardiner and Paget to persuade the queen to support their policies, they were able to put aside their differences for much of the reign
What was the impact of the arrival of Cardinal Pole?
Can be argued arrival of Cardinal Pole as papal legate changed nature of court politics.
What has it been suggested Mary did because she distrusted her councillor’s advice?
Mary was aware of the divisions among her councillors, and therefore had everything referred to Cardinal Pole or to the Spanish ambassador, Simon Renard.
Was faction a bad thing?
No - debates over policy in the Privy Council were usually constructive. Elizabeth was able to use it to great effect to control government by playing one group against each other. In Edward’s reign no evidence to suggest that the struggles created inefficiency / prevented the government + administration from working.
When did Edward VI’s health begin to deteriorate?
In the early months of 1553, continued to decline despite treatment.
According to ___ the throne was supposed to pass to ___
The Succession Acts and Henry’s will / Mary, Edward’s half-sister
What developed during the spring and summer of 1553?
A plot to change the succession so as to exclude Mary.
Who do most accounts suggest to be the schemer of the plot?
Work of the Lord President of the Council, Northumberland.
What do the accounts suggest to be Northumberland’s reasons for the plot?
essential to preserve his power
as a Protestant he would lose power when the Catholic Mary came to the throne
What was part of Northumberland’s plot and attempt to secure power?
He arranged the marriage of his son, Guildford Dudley to Lady Jane Grey. Soon followed by Edward changing his will and naming Jane Grey as his heir.
What is the evidence to suggest that Edward was the driving force behind the attempts to change the succession?
He was playing a greater role in government, attending Privy Council meetings and setting some agendas
Edward was a committed Protestant and wanted to stop the throne passing to his Catholic half-sister
He wanted the religious reform programme he had started to continue
When was the Devise for the succession initially drawn up?
May 1553
Who did the Devise name as the successors and what was the problem with this?
It named the male heirs of the Grey family as the successors.
There were no male heirs and there was no likelihood of any being born before Edward died as his health was rapidly declining.
What did the alteration the initial Devise entail?
Jane Grey was made heir
How did the change to the initial Devise benefit Northumberland?
When Jane Grey became named successor, his power increased. When Guilford married Jane, she was not heir.
How was the plot managed and who does this suggest was behind it?
Plot managed poorly, suggests Edward was behind it