1/80
Looks like no tags are added yet.
How do we know today what happened in ancient Greece more than 2,300 years ago
Through literary sources, inscriptions, coins, archaeological evidence, and historical analysis using Quellenkritik (source criticism).
How do we evaluate conflicting accounts of Alexander's deeds
By comparing sources using Quellenkritik (external & internal criticism) and Quellenforschung (researching sources).
What other sources do we have for the history of Alexander
Literary accounts, official inscriptions, coins, sculptures, mosaics, and battle sites.
What is the best-case scenario for historical accuracy in ancient sources
Works written by eyewitnesses or those who interviewed eyewitnesses.
Who is an example of a meticulous ancient historian
Thucydides, who emphasized eyewitness testimony and verification (Peloponnesian War, 1.22.2-3).
What were ancient Greek texts originally written on
Papyrus rolls, later copied onto parchment codices in Late Antiquity.
What are common issues with textual transmission over time
Copying mistakes, scribal errors, and omissions, leading to divergent manuscript traditions.
What is textual criticism
The process of comparing multiple manuscripts to identify errors and reconstruct the earliest possible version of a text.
Why is Alexander's historiography a paradox
Despite official records, many original accounts are lost.
What is an example of contradictory accounts about Alexander
The death of Callisthenes.
How did Curtius Rufus describe Callisthenes' death
Torture and execution.
said he died under torture, that his was innocent and any plot to kill the king. said calisthenes was of fine charcter and this was barbarous
How did Plutarch describe Callisthenes' death
Some say he was hanged, others say he died from illness.
Chares says that he was ijmporsioned for 7 months and died befoer he could be seen vy the council grossly overweight
How did Arrian describe Callisthenes' death
Ptolemy claims crucifixion, Aristobulus claims disease.
ptolemy son of lagus says that he ws put on the racki and crucified
How did Justin describe Callisthenes' death
He was mutilated and confined in a cage
falsely alleged that Callisthenes was party to a conspiracy that was afoot against alexander
What is Quellenkritik
A method of evaluating sources by assessing their authenticity and reliability.
source criticism
What is Quellenforschung
Researching which authors relied on earlier sources.
researching the sources
What is Quellenanalyse
The study of a source's historical context.
source analysis
What are the two types of Quellenkritik
External criticism and internal criticism.
What does external criticism assess
Authenticity, authorship, and date.
Origin: Locate the source in time and place • Authenticity: Is the source what it purports to be?
What does internal criticism assess
The author's intent, bias, and reliability.
• Author’s background: What could he have known?
• How far (in time and space) was the author removed from the event he reports?
• How did the author get his/her information? Eyewitness? Which sources did he use? ➔ Quellenforschung (Tracing the information back to the original source)
• Author’s intention (Does the author want to inform, idealize, criticize? What’s his/her relationship to the people described? Any indicators for biases?)
• Genre and style
Why might eyewitness accounts still be biased
Authors could omit or distort details to protect reputations.
Which tradition is based on Cleitarchus' dramatic storytelling
The Vulgate Tradition.
more hostile towards alexadner
Which tradition is based on Ptolemy and Aristobulus' military accounts
The Official Tradition.
Who was Callisthenes of Olynthus
Alexander's court historian.
• Deeds of Alexander (Ἀλεξάνδρου Πράξεις), written in Greek
• Glorification of Alexander’s campaigns and achievements, Alexander as Homeric hero, a new Achilles (executed in 327 BC)
A LOST CONTEMPORARY SOURCE
Why was Callisthenes executed
He opposed Alexander's Persian-style court rituals.
Who was Ptolemy I Soter
A childhood friend of Alexander who later ruled Egypt.
• Memoirs or History of Alexander, written in Greek
A LOST CONTEMPORARY SOURCE
What did Ptolemy write about
A military-focused history of Alexander's campaigns.
• A first-hand account of Alexander’s campaigns, emphasizing military aspects. Views himself as legitimate successor of Alexander. Few outright lies but suppression of truth
Who was Aristobulus of Cassandreia
An engineer under Alexander.
What did Aristobulus emphasize in his writings
Geography and chivalry.
• A historical account of Alexander’s campaigns (written, in Greek, after 290 BC), • Flatterer, praises and whitewashes Alexander (chivalrous, ‘social drinker’), includes geographical and practical details
Who was Cleitarchus
A historian who never traveled with Alexander but interviewed eyewitnesses.
Why is Cleitarchus important
His History of Alexander shaped the Vulgate Tradition.
• Wrote one of the most popular histories of Alexander, in Greek, perhaps around 310 BC ➔ known to Ptolemy and Aristobulus • Focused on sensationalism, drama, and vivid storytelling ➔ appealing to a broad audience. • Foundation of the ‘vulgate’ tradition of Alexander's history, influencing later writers like Diodorus, Pompeius Trogus (➔ Justin), and Curtius Rufus
Who is the most reliable historian of Alexander
Arrian.
What is Arrian's main work on Alexander
Anabasis of Alexander. 7 books
Wrote a detailed military and historical account of Alexander’s campaigns, based primarily on the works of Ptolemy I and Aristobulus; critical approach; avoids sensationalism ➔ considered the most reliable Alexander historian
What sources did Arrian rely on
Ptolemy and Aristobulus.
What are characteristics of the Vulgate Tradition
Sensationalized and dramatic accounts.
Which historians represent the Vulgate Tradition
Diodorus, Quintus Curtius Rufus, and Justin.
What is Plutarch's main work on Alexander
Life of Alexander.
• Draws on both the ‘official’ and the ‘vulgate’ tradition
What is Plutarch's focus in his biography
Alexander's character and moral lessons.
• A biographical account of Alexander’s life, emphasizing his character, personal virtues, and vices; focuses on moral lessons and character analysis rather than historical narrative.
What is the Alexander Romance
A legendary, mythical biography of Alexander.
attributed to an anonymous author known as "Pseudo-Callisthenes."
Alexander is son of last Pharaoh of Egypt (Nectanebo), practices magic and spells, encounters monsters and exotic peoples
What are examples of non-literary sources for Alexander
Inscriptions, coins, sculptures, mosaics, and battlefield archaeology.
What do Alexander's coins often depict
Alexander as Heracles or with Zeus Ammon's horns.
Why are inscriptions valuable for studying Alexander
They provide official Macedonian records.
What famous mosaic depicts Alexander
The Alexander Mosaic from Pompeii.
What archaeological sites provide evidence of Alexander's battles
The Lion Monument at Chaeronea.
, containing the remains of Thebes’ Sacred Band
How did Arrian describe Callisthenes' death
Ptolemy said crucifixion; Aristobulus said disease.
How did Plutarch describe Callisthenes' death
Conflicting reports of hanging or long imprisonment.
How did Curtius and Justin describe Callisthenes' death
They emphasized torture and mutilation.
What does Callisthenes' death reveal about Alexander's historiography
Different traditions present contradictory narratives.
Why is reconstructing Alexander's history difficult
Many original sources are lost, and surviving ones contradict each other.
What is the role of Quellenkritik in Alexander studies
It helps assess reliability, bias, and accuracy of sources.
What is an example of a lost primary source on Alexander
Ptolemy's Memoirs.
What are the two major traditions in Alexander's historiography
Official Tradition and Vulgate Tradition.
What are examples of material evidence for Alexander's rule
Inscriptions, coins, sculptures, and battle sites.
What was the original material used for ancient Greek books
Papyrus rolls.
What replaced papyrus in Late Antiquity
Parchment codices.
What is conjectural emendation
A method of reconstructing lost words or phrases in ancient texts based on context.
What is the role of philologists in studying ancient texts
They compare manuscripts to identify errors and reconstruct accurate versions.
How did ancient historians sometimes distort events
By exaggerating, omitting details, or reshaping narratives for political or rhetorical purposes.
What does the phrase "historical paradox" refer to in Alexander's case
Despite official records, his history remains ambiguous due to lost sources and later conflicting accounts.
What does the term "vulgate" mean in the context of Alexander's history
It refers to sensationalized, dramatic accounts based on Cleitarchus.
Why is Arrian's account considered more reliable than Curtius Rufus'
He relied on Ptolemy and Aristobulus, who were eyewitnesses.
What is the main issue with relying on later historians like Justin
He wrote centuries later, relying on secondary, often exaggerated sources.
What evidence suggests Cleitarchus' history influenced later writers
Many dramatic elements in Curtius Rufus, Diodorus, and Justin resemble Cleitarchus' known style.
How does coin evidence support Alexander's claim to divinity
His coins depicted Zeus Ammon's horns, associating him with the god.
what elese did arrain of nicomedia writ
Also wrote Indica (a description of Alexander’s campaigns in India and Nearchus’s voyage).
Diodorus Siculus (Library of History, Book 17, in Greek)
VULGATE
Part of a larger universal history, told year by year, includes Alexander’s life and campaigns, drawing from Cleitarchus and other sources, simplistic and accessible
Quintus Curtius Rufus (History of Alexander the Great, in Latin)
VULAGTE
• Influenced by the ‘vulgate’ tradition (Cleitarchus), several books are lost
• A vivid, highly rhetorical and dramatic account of Alexander’s campaigns, often focusing on his personality, leadership, and moral struggles
Justin (Epitome of the Philippic Histories of Pompeius Trogus)
VULGATE
A condensed version (=epitome) of Pompeius Trogus’s lost history, focusing on major events and themes. • Pompeius Trogus, a Romanized Gaul, writing in the 1st century BCE, wrote a universal history, focused on Philip and Alexander and also followed the ‘vulgate’ tradition (Cleitarchus)
who was hypomnemata?
LOST CONTEMPORARY SOURCE
Personal notebooks, contained last plans of Alexander, read out to army, unclear whether they were authentic
Chares of Mytilene
lost contemorary
• Alexander’s court chamberlain
• Stories about Alexander Τὰ περὶ Ἀλέξανδρον (in Greek)
• Focused on court life, gossipy anecdotes, his work was read by Aristobulus and Plutarch. Whitewashes Alexander’s character..
Onesicritus of Astypalaea
lost contemporary
• Chief helmsman and historian who traveled with Alexander’s fleet. • Alexander’s Deeds, in Greek • Included many fantastical and exaggerated accounts of Alexander’s exploits, particularly about India and its wonders; criticized for embellishments, but his work influenced later authors.
Nearchus of Crete
lost contemorary
• Childhood friend and admiral of Alexander’s fleet • Voyage of Nearchus (Indica), in Greek. • Described his naval expedition from the Indus River to the Persian Gulf, including geographical observations and encounters with new cultures. Nearchus' work influenced later geographers like Strabo; source for Arrian’s Indica
Eumenes of Cardia
Lost contemporary
• Alexander’s secretary and archivist. • Eumenes likely recorded the Ephemerides or Royal Diaries, which were valuable to later historians
One problem of Quellenforschung:
Basic assumption: that later writer simply copied earlier lost source ➔ deprives later writers of literary agency
why dont aristobulus ptolomey and chares agree on things that they we all eyewitnesses to
➔ All three are eyewitnesses, should agree about what happened (see Arrian’s criticism), but they might have reasons not to tell the truth •
➔ Whom should we believe? • Not Chares (apologetic tendency) • Not Aristobulus (apologetic tendency) • Probably Ptolemy
• Aristobulus of Cassandreia?
(Greek, engineer and military officer under Alexander)
Ptolemy son of Lagus
(Macedonian childhood friend, general, successor in Egypt)
Chares of Mytilene
(Greek, Alexander’s chamberlain)
Stemma
Through collation of manuscripts (shared mistakes)
Critical Edition by
philologist