Unit 6: Sentencing and Appeals Procedure

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/66

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

67 Terms

1
New cards

What are the five purposes of sentencing under s 57 SA 2020?

Punishment of offenders; reduction of crime (including deterrence); reform and rehabilitation; protection of the public; reparation by offenders to those affected. Applies to offenders aged 18+.

2
New cards

When does the court not need to have regard to the five purposes of sentencing?

Where the sentence is fixed by law (e.g. murder), the offence has a statutory minimum, or the defendant is a dangerous offender.

3
New cards

What did the Sentencing Code (Sentencing Act 2020, in force December 2020) change?

It consolidated sentencing legislation into a single reference point. It did not change substantive law, maximum penalties, judicial discretion or the existing guidelines.

4
New cards

Who prepares sentencing guidelines, and what is a court's duty regarding them?

The Sentencing Council. Every court must follow relevant guidelines unless satisfied it would be contrary to the interests of justice.

5
New cards

What new guideline did the Sentencing Council introduce on 1 September 2025?

The "Imposition of Community and Custodial Sentences" guideline, setting out the general approach to sentencing and how to deal with specific issues.

6
New cards

What must a court consider when assessing seriousness under s 63 SA 2020?

The offender's culpability and any harm the offence caused, was intended to cause, or might foreseeably have caused.

7
New cards

What are the four levels of culpability, from most to least serious?

Intention to cause harm (planned is the highest); recklessness; knowledge of the specific risks; negligence.

8
New cards

What types of harm may be caused by an offence?

Physical injury, sexual violation, financial loss, damage to health and psychological distress (to individuals or the community).

9
New cards

What is "prevalence" in sentencing?

In exceptional circumstances a local court may treat an offence more seriously if it is prevalent in the area and there is evidence it is causing harm to the community at large.

10
New cards

What are the four statutory aggravating factors?

Previous convictions (where reasonable given nature and time elapsed); offence committed on bail; racial or religious aggravation; hostility based on sexual orientation or disability.

11
New cards

When will previous convictions be treated as aggravating?

When the court considers it reasonable, having regard to the nature of the conviction and time elapsed. Likely if recent and/or for similar offences.

12
New cards

Give examples of non-statutory aggravating factors.

Planned or premeditated offence; groups or gangs; targeting vulnerable victims; drink or drugs; use of a weapon; gratuitous violence or damage; abuse of trust; victim working in the public sector or providing a public service; high value (including sentimental) of property; failure to respond to previous sentences.

13
New cards

Give examples of mitigating factors.

Acting on impulse; greater than normal provocation; mental illness or physical disability; very young or old; minor role; genuine fear; attempts at reparation.

14
New cards

What does s 73 SA 2020 require on a guilty plea, and what is the rationale?

The court must take into account the stage at which the plea was indicated and the circumstances. Rationale: avoids a trial and spares victims and witnesses from giving evidence if made early.

15
New cards

When is the full one-third guilty plea reduction available?

Only where the plea is indicated at the first stage of proceedings (e.g. first hearing in the magistrates' court, or indication there for an indictable-only offence followed by a guilty plea at the first Crown Court hearing). Limited exceptions if it was unreasonable to expect a plea then.

16
New cards

What is the maximum plea reduction if a guilty plea is first indicated after the first stage (e.g. at the PTPH)?

One-quarter.

17
New cards

What is the maximum plea reduction for a plea on the first day of trial ("door of the court"), and during the trial?

One-tenth on the first day of trial; may be reduced further, even to zero, if entered during the trial.

18
New cards

Do remorse or the strength of the prosecution case affect the guilty plea discount?

No. The discount depends on the stage at which the plea was indicated, not remorse or the strength of the prosecution case.

19
New cards

What was held in R v Hodgin [2020] EWCA Crim 1388?

Where it is not procedurally possible to enter a plea in the magistrates' court, there must be an unequivocal indication of intention to plead guilty. "Likely to plead guilty" is not enough for full one-third credit.

20
New cards

What is the totality principle and what is an "associated offence"?

The court assesses the overall offending, not each offence separately, to ensure proportionality. An associated offence is one convicted in the same proceedings, to be sentenced at the same time, or taken into consideration.

21
New cards

What are offences taken into consideration (TICs)?

Other offences a defendant asks the court to consider when sentencing. They must be similar to, or less serious than, the offence of conviction.

22
New cards

What are the advantages of TICs to the defendant and to the police?

Defendant: "wipes the slate clean", so no later prosecution for them (and they often add little to the sentence). Police: improves clear-up rates without a fresh prosecution.

23
New cards

What are the eight steps in the sentencing guidelines approach?

1 Offence category; 2 Starting point and category range (aggravating/mitigating factors); 3 Reduction for assisting the prosecution; 4 Guilty plea reduction; 5 Extended sentence; 6 Totality; 7 Compensation and ancillary orders; 8 Giving reasons.

24
New cards

How does Step 1 of the guidelines work?

Court assesses harm and culpability to place the offence in Category 1 (greater harm and higher culpability), 2 (either) or 3 (lesser harm and lower culpability), which gives the starting point sentence.

25
New cards

Which steps of the eight-step approach are most important in practice?

Steps 1, 2, 4 and 8.

26
New cards

What must the court do at Step 8 under s 52 SA 2020?

Give reasons: explain the effect of the sentence and of non-compliance, identify the guidelines followed, and explain any departure to a lesser sentence than the guidelines recommend.

27
New cards

What did R v Arie Ali [2023] EWCA Crim 232 decide about suspending short custodial sentences?

Where the short custody threshold is crossed, courts may suspend or impose a community order, and can treat current prison population pressure as an exceptional factor justifying suspension.

28
New cards

What is the difference between concurrent and consecutive sentences?

Concurrent: served at the same time (total is effectively the longest). Consecutive: one starts after the other finishes (total is the sum).

29
New cards

What does the Totality guideline say the overall sentence should be, and what adjustments are usual?

It should reflect all the offending (overall harm, culpability, aggravating and mitigating factors) and be just and proportionate. Consecutive usually needs a downward adjustment; concurrent usually needs an upward adjustment.

30
New cards

What is the Sentencing Council's fourfold approach to sentencing multiple offences?

Sentence each offence by the guidelines; decide concurrent or consecutive (a mix may suit three or more offences); test the total is just and proportionate; explain the structure clearly.

31
New cards

When will concurrent sentences ordinarily be appropriate?

Offences arising out of the same incident or facts; or a series of offences of the same or similar kind, especially against the same person.

32
New cards

When will consecutive sentences ordinarily be appropriate?

Unrelated facts or incidents; distinct offences in the same incident with an aggravating element needing separate recognition; similar offences where concurrent sentences would not reflect overall criminality (e.g. Bail Act offences, domestic abuse or sexual offences against the same person).

33
New cards

When will a defendant's representative ask for a pre-sentence report (PSR) before plea?

Only if D will plead guilty to all offences on the full prosecution facts and co-operate with Probation, is likely to be sentenced in the magistrates' court, and the offence is serious enough for a community order.

34
New cards

What must the defendant understand about a PSR before plea?

It gives no indication of sentence and all options remain open; the court decides whether to consider it; the court may sentence without one if unnecessary.

35
New cards

What does s 30 SA 2020 require regarding PSRs, and is it truly mandatory?

The court must obtain and consider a PSR before deciding on the custody threshold and length, or community sentence requirements. Not truly mandatory: s 30(4) says a sentence is not invalidated if imposed without one.

36
New cards

When may a PSR be unnecessary under the 2025 guideline?

When the court has enough information about the offence and offender, e.g. custody is inevitable given seriousness, or there is already a recent PSR.

37
New cards

What are the four parts of a plea in mitigation?

1 The likely sentence; 2 The offence (minimise aggravating, stress mitigating factors); 3 The offender (personal mitigation); 4 The suggested sentence.

38
New cards

What should the suggested sentence in a plea in mitigation be like?

Realistic and at the lower end of the range in the court's mind. If it matches the PSR recommendation, emphasise that.

39
New cards

Why is it unwise to argue the offence was committed only because D was drunk or on drugs?

The court is likely to treat it as aggravating. Evidence of addiction, however, can support a rehabilitative community order (e.g. drug rehabilitation or alcohol treatment requirement).

40
New cards

List the main types of personal mitigation.

Age; health (including mental illness); early guilty plea and co-operation with police; voluntary compensation; remorse (positive steps, not just an apology); good character or explaining previous convictions; family circumstances; low risk of reoffending.

41
New cards

What was held in R v Seed; R v Stark [2007] EWCA Crim 254?

Absence of previous convictions is important mitigation that may make custody inappropriate even if the custody threshold has been crossed. A guilty plea or strong personal mitigation may also justify a non-custodial sentence where the threshold was only just passed.

42
New cards

What is the "sentencing pyramid" (top to bottom)?

Custody; suspended sentence; community sentence; fine; discharge (conditional or absolute).

43
New cards

What is the custody threshold under s 230 SA 2020?

The court must not impose custody unless the offence (or combination with associated offences) was so serious that neither a fine alone nor a community sentence can be justified.

44
New cards

Does passing the custody threshold mean custody must be imposed?

No. It is a necessary, not sufficient, condition (Seed; Stark).

45
New cards

What is the effect of s 230(4) SA 2020?

The custody threshold test does not apply where the offender fails to express willingness to comply with a community sentence.

46
New cards

What does s 231(2) SA 2020 say about the length of a custodial sentence?

It must be the shortest term (not exceeding the maximum) commensurate with the seriousness of the offence, or the offence and associated offences.

47
New cards

What is the maximum custodial sentence in the magistrates' court, and in the Crown Court?

Magistrates: 12 months for a single either-way offence or for more than one either-way offence. Crown Court: up to the maximum for the offence.

48
New cards

Where is a custodial sentence served by an offender aged 18-21?

In a young offender institution (YOI), not prison.

49
New cards

What is the general rule on early release, and what are the exceptions?

Adults are released halfway through the sentence. Exceptions: relevant offences committed after 10 Sept 2024 with a sentence under 5 years are released at 40% (not violent or sexual offences); serious violent and sexual offences of 4+ years are released at two-thirds.

50
New cards

What are "offenders of particular concern"?

Offenders convicted of very serious offences (e.g. terrorism, child sex offences). No automatic release at halfway; they may apply for parole from the halfway point until sentence end, then are released on licence.

51
New cards

What sentences must the court impose on a dangerous offender?

Automatic life imprisonment, discretionary life imprisonment or an extended sentence (details are beyond the SRA syllabus).

52
New cards

When can a custodial sentence be suspended, and for how long?

Custody threshold must be met first, then circumstances must justify suspension. Sentences of 14 days to 2 years (12 months in the magistrates' court) can be suspended for a 6 month to 2 year operational period. Sentences of 2-3 years: up to 3 years (s 288(2A), orders on or after 22 March 2026).

53
New cards

What is the presumption of suspension under s 277A SA 2020?

For offenders aged 21+ receiving custody of not more than 12 months on or after 22 March 2026, the sentence is presumed suspended unless exceptional circumstances relating to the offence or offender justify not doing so.

54
New cards

What requirements may accompany a suspended sentence?

Requirements under s 287 SA 2020 (the same as for a generic community order), complied with during the supervision period, which must end no later than the end of the operational period.

55
New cards

When does a suspended sentence take effect?

If D fails to comply with a requirement, or commits a further offence during the operational period and the court sentencing for it orders the suspended sentence to take effect.

56
New cards

What can a court do on breach of a suspended sentence?

Activate in full; activate for a shorter or lesser term; make requirements more onerous; or extend the operational or supervision period. It must activate (in full or part) unless that would be unjust. It may also impose a fine of up to £2,500 instead of activation.

57
New cards

How is an activated suspended sentence usually served relative to the new sentence?

Consecutively to the sentence for the new offence (e.g. 3 months activated + 4 months new = 7 months).

58
New cards

Which court deals with breach of a suspended sentence?

If imposed by the magistrates, the magistrates' or Crown Court. If imposed by the Crown Court, generally only the Crown Court.

59
New cards

What is the threshold for a generic community order under s 204(2) SA 2020?

The offence (or combination with associated offences) must be serious enough to warrant a community order. The Sentencing Council has low, medium and high bands.

60
New cards

Which community order requirements are the most common, and what are the limits on unpaid work?

Unpaid work is the most common: 40-300 hours.

61
New cards

What are the limits on exclusion, supervision and attendance centre requirements?

Exclusion: not exceeding 2 years (electronically monitored). Supervision: up to 3 years. Attendance centre: 12-36 hours, only for offenders under 25.

62
New cards

List other community order requirements.

Rehabilitation activity; programme; prohibited activity; curfew (tagged); residence; mental health treatment; drug rehabilitation; alcohol treatment; foreign travel prohibition; alcohol abstinence and monitoring; electronic monitoring; drug testing.

63
New cards

What happens on breach of a community order?

First breach without reasonable excuse: warning. A further failure within 12 months: back before the court, which must make the order more onerous or revoke and re-sentence (without the custody threshold). For wilful and persistent failure, it may revoke and impose custody, even if the offence was not imprisonable.

64
New cards

What can the court do if D commits a further offence during a community order?

Allow the order to continue, or (if in the interests of justice) revoke it (e.g. if custody is imposed for the new offence), or revoke and re-sentence for the original offence having regard to compliance.

65
New cards

What is a Newton hearing?

A "trial on the facts" held where D pleads guilty but disputes the prosecution's version of events and the dispute affects sentence. The judge hears evidence from both sides and decides the factual basis for sentence to the criminal standard (R v Newton (1983)).

66
New cards

What is a basis of plea and what are the possible outcomes?

A defence document setting out D's version of events for the offence admitted, usually to remove aggravating features. If accepted by the prosecution and judge, sentence follows it. If rejected and the difference is material, a Newton hearing follows.

67
New cards

What can a judge do with an absurd basis of plea?

Reject it and sentence on the prosecution version without a Newton hearing. The judge is the final arbiter and may reject a basis even if the prosecution accepts it.