1/77
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Main Argument
a woman’s money, legal status and marriage prospects were all tied to her class and family. Money moved through dowries, settlements and jointures, and the law (coverture) erased her legal existence once she married. P&P shows these pressures in the Bennet sisters, Georgiana Darcy, Caroline Bingley and Elizabeth.
Marriage changes status in two opposite ways
Marriage limited a woman’s legal rights but immediately raised her social status, whatever her class. A married woman always took precedence over unmarried women.
Class decides how much freedom you have in choosing
Arranged marriages lingered longest among the upper classes, who had the most at stake in money, property and rank. Even so, few high-society parents arranged totally mercenary alliances (only monetary motivations).
How courtship changed over time
Earlier, the suitor asked the family first. By the enlightened Regency era, that was outmoded and young people could choose their own mates, provided parents did not veto the choice.
Dowry (Regency)
what a responsible family gave to compensate the future husband for their daughter’s lifelong upkeep. It was used for her spending money, her income in widowhood, and provision for her children if one or both parents died. Most dowries were modest. Mr Bennet called dowries bribes to worthless young men to marry his daughters.
Marriage settlements (articles
legal documents that set the financial terms of a marriage when substantial property was involved, like a modern prenup. Only about 10% of marriages had them because they were expensive. In P&P, Lydia’s settlement with Wickham has Mr Bennet allow her £100 a year during his lifetime.
Pin money
a woman’s disposable income, money she could spend without answering to her husband. Common law only required a man to provide his wife’s “necessities,” so pin money supplied the “luxuries” that kept up her accustomed lifestyle. In P&P, Mrs Bennet gushes over the pin money she expects Jane and Elizabeth to have. Elizabeth later gives Lydia gifts from hers rather than taking Lydia’s requests to her husband.
Dower
a widow’s right to inherit a share of her husband’s property. a traditional common-law right that entitles a widow to a portion of the property or estate left behind by her deceased husband
Jointure
a settlement on a bride by her future husband of a freehold estate secured for her widowhood. It came into practice with the Statute of Uses (1535). To receive it, the wife had to surrender her dower.
Settlements to the children
marriage settlements also provided for the couple’s children, but most children did not inherit vast sums. A woman’s dowry and other settlements on her went to her children (sons and daughters) on her death. Additional funds could be settled on the children from the father’s estate, with the amounts stated in the marriage articles.
Coverture
the legal state of a married woman. Her legal existence disappeared and her husband assumed the legal existence of both. Settlements were necessary because her legal position changed so sharply. It began once she was engaged, so if she owned property she could not dispose of it without her betrothed’s approval.
Under coverture the husband owned all property, had custody of the children, conducted the family’s business, and even owned the wife’s earnings. He could physically chastise her, divide her from friends and family and severely limit her movements.
Blackstone (1765): “the very being or legal existence of the woman is suspended during the marriage, or at least incorporated and consolidated into that of the husband,” and her condition during marriage is called her coverture.
Ended by the Married Women’s Property Act of 1884, which gave married women the same property and legal rights as unmarried women or widows. So coverture lasted through the whole Regency and most of the 19th century.
Primogeniture
the principle that the eldest son inherits the family lands and fortune. Eldest sons set to inherit faced more parental sanctions than younger siblings.
Endogamy
marrying within your class. Upper-class men with large fortunes must marry endogamously, wealthy and perhaps titled women, to keep their fortune and family name.
Exogamy
marrying outside your class or means. A wealthy woman was not allowed to marry a man of lesser means (exogamy).
Heiress
a woman with a large fortune. Upper-class women with large fortunes (non-titled bourgeois heiresses) were expected to learn to love, or at least tolerate, the husband chosen by their father or brother. Heiresses were sought by titled men whose families were in declining fortune, and many young peers married them to shore up family finances.
Marriage market language
the language of trade (bargaining, “portion,” “establishment,” “connections”) used in proposals. It shows that courtship was a financial calculation.
Double-voicedness
two voices in one speech. In Darcy’s first proposal, his sincere love is mixed with the voice of his aunt, Lady Catherine, and with class pride.
Class & Marriage: Who Faced What Pressure - Upper-class women with large fortunes
Expected to accept the husband their father or brother chose.
P&P examples: Georgiana Darcy and Caroline Bingley.
Darcy prevents Georgiana from marrying Wickham, a fortune-hunter (P&P, ch. 35, Regency).
Class & Marriage: Who Faced What Pressure - Upper-class women with modest fortunes
May sacrifice themselves on the altar of family duty to help pay off family debts.
Elizabeth Bennet faces this pressure, especially from her mother, when Mr Collins (heir to her father’s estate) proposes.
Elizabeth realizes Wickham rejected her because of her modest fortune (P&P, ch. 36).
Young women with unmarried sisters faced more parental intrusion, since one of them had to marry very well (the Bennet sisters).
Unmarried women needing support turned first to brothers and sons.
Class & Marriage: Who Faced What Pressure - Upper-class men with large fortunes
Must marry wealthy (perhaps titled) women within their class, e.g., Darcy is expected to marry his cousin, Lady Catherine de Bourgh’s daughter.
A wealthy man might be excused for marrying a poorer woman, especially if pretty with good manners (Darcy marries Elizabeth).
Class & Marriage: Who Faced What Pressure - Upper-class men with modest fortunes
Second-born sons who won’t inherit the estate or a large fortune.
Under pressure to marry wealthy women or heiresses, precisely because their own fortunes are modest and they need to maintain an upper-class lifestyle.
What is coverture and why did marriage settlements exist?
A woman’s legal position changed dramatically at marriage. Her legal existence disappeared and her husband assumed the legal existence of both, starting once she was engaged. He owned property and her earnings, had custody of the children and controlled the family’s business. Settlements were necessary to protect her money and her children’s. Blackstone (1765) defined it. It lasted until the Married Women’s Property Act of 1884.
Marriage reduced a woman’s legal rights but raised her status. Explain.
Her legal rights shrank under coverture, but marriage immediately raised her social status, no matter her class. A married woman always took precedence over unmarried women. This is why marriage was so attractive despite its legal costs.
6. How did marriage proposals change by the Regency?
Earlier, a suitor applied to the family first, and if the father or guardian disapproved he dared not approach the woman. In the Regency this was outmoded: young people had the right to choose, provided parents did not veto it. Until 21, both parties required parental consent. After 21, approval was highly desirable (parents often contributed to the couple’s upkeep) but not essential.
7. Why were heiresses both protected and pressured?
Upper-class heiresses were expected to accept the husband their father or brother chose. They could not marry a man of lesser means (exogamy), which is why Darcy blocks Georgiana’s match with Wickham. Titled men from declining families sought heiresses to restore their finances, so wealth made a woman a target for fortune-hunters.
A. Compare the unsuccessful proposals of Mr Collins and Mr Darcy to Elizabeth
Setting: P&P, Regency era; Collins proposes in ch. 19 and is refused, Darcy proposes in ch. 34.
Collins: when she refuses he falls back on marriage market jargon, which has been his measure of the match all along. He lists his situation, his connections to the De Bourghs and his relationship to the Bennets, and reminds her that her small portion means she may never get another offer. He insists her “no” is just “words of course” (what “elegant females” do to increase a man’s love). The speech reminds her of her weak bargaining position.
Elizabeth’s reply: she is a “rational creature speaking the truth from her heart” and wants to be believed, so her refusal is clear and plain.
Darcy: his proposal fails because it also borrows its terms from Lady Catherine, just like Collins’s. His love is sincere, but the language of family and class pride suffuses it, so his aunt’s voice intrudes on his own passion (double-voicedness, Bakhtin’s dialogism).
Both depend on marriage market calculations. Darcy calls her connections “inferior” and expects her to accept on that basis. This shows the language of trade is not reserved to one class.
Conclusion: both proposals fail because they rely on class and money language instead of treating Elizabeth as an equal, which ties back to the class and marriage themes above.
B. How did money, law and class shape marriage choices in the Regency?
Money: dowry, settlements, pin money, jointure and dower
Law: coverture and why settlements were needed.
Class: the four-part grid (heiresses, modest-fortune women, wealthy men, second sons), plus endogamy, exogamy and primogeniture
Conclusion: marriage gave women status but cost them legal rights, and class set how much choice they had.
C. What happened to a woman’s property and status when she married?
Before: she could own property, but once engaged she needed her husbands approval to dispose of it.
:coverture, meaning no legal existence, with her husband owning property, her earnings and custody of children.
Protections: dowry, settlements (only ~10% of marriages), pin money, jointure.
Status: marriage immediately raised social status.
Main argument
Over the Georgian era (1714-1837), marriage shifted from an ideology of arranged marriage to an ideology of companionate marriage. Even so, marriage kept features of a business transaction, and women were still treated as objects and commodities in the marriage market. Austen (1775-1817), a product of the Georgian era, wrote several novels in the Regency (1811-1820), and they reflect this.
What drove the change from bargain to companionate
Enlightenment ideas about freedom, equality and individual rights made marriage a matter of individual choice, not parental mandate.
The core question behind the shift from arranged to companionate
To whom did the right to exchange the female body belong?
The new problem companionate marriage created
Choosing your own spouse let marriages cross class, status and economic lines, which advanced social mobility and threatened the social interests that arranged marriage protected.
Ideology of arranged marriage
marriage as a business transaction arranged by parents and guardians. Sons and daughters were treated as assets or pawns in efforts to gain or maintain wealth, connections and power.
Ideology of companionate marriage
young people chose their spouses by the end of the Georgian era. It was never free of business features, because both sides still brought property, dowries, fortunes, trades, skills, social connections and the ability to provide heirs.
Conduct manuals/literature
the equivalent of today’s self-help books, and they originated in medieval literature. They advised how to find the right mate by those criteria, and their function was conservative.
Patriarchal exchange
the system in which women are objects traded between men through marriage. Women can also embody patriarchy, such as Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine de Bourgh in P&P, who arrange the exchange of their daughters with men they choose.
Entailment
if a family had no son, the property was inherited by the closest male relative rather than going to the daughters and their husbands. Titles and land passed to the eldest direct male heir. The gentry invented it to prevent the erosion of its class by aspiring bourgeois professionals who wanted status by marrying into it.
Accomplished woman (Regency):
a woman with the skills that made her a social asset to her husband. Core skills were education and enough mathematics to run a household, sewing (with decorative needlework a bonus), gardening, food preservation, and knowing servants’ work and household remedies. Truly accomplished women could also sing, dance, play an instrument, draw and paint, and speak French or Italian to entertain his guests.
Patriarchy in Pride and Prejudice (Regency, 1813)
Women under patriarchy are objects and commodities in a system of exchange (marriage).
Women can also embody patriarchy: Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine de Bourgh arrange the “exchange” of their daughters.
Opening line, ch. 1: “a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife.” He is “considered the rightful property of some one or other of their daughters.” So the marriage market treats men and women as property.
Accomplished women in P&P (Regency, 1813)
Ch. 8: Bingley and Darcy discuss what makes a woman accomplished.
Bingley’s traditional view: music, painting, singing, drawing, dancing, modern languages.
Darcy’s counter-traditional view: “improvement of her mind by extensive reading”, which makes him a spokesman for Austen.
The Bennet girls had little formal education. Jane and Elizabeth have excellent manners but not the typical accomplishments that draw excellent suitors. Elizabeth’s wit was considered a disadvantage.
Entailment in P&P (Regency, 1813)
Mr Bennet has no son, so the estate is entailed to his closest male relative, Mr Collins, who will inherit when Mr Bennet dies.
That is why Collins proposes expecting acceptance. Elizabeth’s dowry is small, so her bargaining position is low.
1. What is the difference between the ideologies of arranged and companionate marriage?
Arranged marriage treated marriage as a business transaction run by parents and guardians. Children were assets or pawns in the effort to gain or maintain wealth, connections and power. Companionate marriage, which took hold by the end of the Georgian era (1714-1837), let young people choose their spouses. Even then, marriage kept business features, because both sides brought property, dowries, fortunes and connections.
2. Why did arranged marriage decline?
Enlightenment ideas about freedom, equality and individual rights shifted attitudes. Marriage became an individual choice, not a parental mandate. The key question was who had the right to exchange the female body.
3. What problems did companionate marriage create?
It could cross class, status and economic lines, and so advanced social mobility. That jeopardized the social interests that arranged marriage had served by negotiating class, status and money.
4. What was the conservative function of conduct literature?
Conduct manuals (the self-help books of their day, originating in medieval literature) advised people on finding the right mate by societal criteria. Their purpose was conservative, because they taught people to meet the system’s expectations, not to change it.
5. Explain entailment and why it existed.
If a family had only daughters, the property passed to the closest male relative, not to the daughters and their husbands. The gentry invented it to stop aspiring bourgeois professionals from rising by marrying into it. In P&P, Mr Bennet’s estate is entailed to Mr Collins.
6. What did “accomplished” mean in the Regency, and how does P&P challenge it?
It meant useful and ornamental skills: household management and mathematics, needlework, gardening, and for the truly accomplished woman, music, dancing, drawing and languages to entertain her husband’s guests. In ch. 8, Bingley holds the traditional view, and Darcy adds “improvement of her mind by extensive reading.” The Bennet girls lack typical accomplishments, and Elizabeth’s wit counted against her.
7. How are women both objects and agents of patriarchy in P&P?
Women are commodities in a system of patriarchal exchange. But Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine also embody patriarchy, arranging their daughters’ exchange with the men they choose. So patriarchy is not only men acting on women.
8. What does P&P’s opening line show?
It shows the marriage market’s view of men and women as property. A single man with a fortune “is considered the rightful property of some one or other of their daughters.” The line is ironic about how families treat suitors as goods to be claimed.
B. How does Pride and Prejudice show the commodification of women in the marriage market?
Patriarchal exchange: Mrs Bennet and Lady Catherine arrange their daughters’ exchange.
Entailment: the estate goes to Collins, which leaves the daughters dependent on good marriages.
Blazon (ch. 8): Bingley’s list of skills treats a woman as a social asset, and Darcy’s “extensive reading” pushes back.
Bargaining position: Collins proposes expecting acceptance because Elizabeth’s dowry is small.
Blazon
it alludes both to a system of patriarchal exchange and to the bourgeois marketplace, with exchange at equal value by aligning male and female blazons. An itemized praise of a woman's traits that often treats beauty as a marketable asset
what was different/new about Courtship novels (1740-1820)
it was new because women were not autonomous, free individuals. Daughters were under their father’s authority, which included an arranged settlement negotiated on class and money. It is progressive and feminist,
Main argument
Austen interrogated the practices and terms of the marriage market, which commodified women, and suggested alternatives to the subject positions society made available to women in her period. Her alternative to the marriage bargain is companionate marriage.
The marriage bargain vs. the companionate marriage in P&P
Marriage bargain: Lydia’s marriage to Wickham.
Companionate marriage: Elizabeth and Darcy; Jane and Bingley.
To reach this ideal, Austen overturns the traditional use of the blazon in the courtship novel.
Michie’s (2011) two key arguments (slide 9)
The 19th-century 1) marriage plot of the novel of manners argues about the private and personal realms but also the social, economic and political realms.
The novel has traces of two disciplines-discourses that emerged at the time (and separated from aesthetics in the 18th century): political economy and anthropology.
Political economy vs. anthropology in novels of manners
Political economy shows up as money, inheritance, and marriage as an economic transaction.
Anthropology shows up as marriage rules, gift-giving, and the social meaning of exchange.
Marriage bargain
marriage as a financial arrangement. In P&P, Lydia’s marriage to Wickham.
Companionate marriage
marriage based on a partnership of equals, as in Elizabeth and Darcy and Jane and Bingley.
Marriage plot (19th-century English novel)
the most common plot in the novel of manners: a hero positioned between a wealthy, materialistic, status-conscious woman who might enhance his social position and a poorer, more altruistic, psychologically independent woman. It emerges in P&P.
The rich woman (heiress) in novels
The heiress isn’t a real character but a symbol of showy, worrying new money, which the hero must reject so the novel can seem like it’s about virtue and not wealth.
Novel of manners:
the type of 19th-century novel Michie analyzes, built around social behavior, marriage and money. (p&p)
Patrilineage
lineage based on descent on the paternal line.
Exogamy
marrying outside your group.
Endogamy
marrying within your group. The heiress had to be exchanged endogamously to keep property in the group.
Engrossment
accumulating and concentrating wealth. the heiress shows that capitalism is aimed at amassing, not exchanging or circulating property.
1. Austen’s alternative: from the marriage bargain to companionate marriage (P&P, 1813)
Austen questions the commodification of women in the marriage market.
Contrast: Lydia and Wickham (bargain) vs. Elizabeth and Darcy, Jane and Bingley (companionate).
Method: she overturns the traditional use of the blazon.
2. The blazon overturned: Lady Catherine confronts Elizabeth
Elizabeth withstands the demands of patriarchy expressed by two women who are the agents of the exchange: Lady Catherine and Darcy’s mother.
Lady Catherine retorts with the “normative taxonomy of the blazon” (family, fortune, rank).
Elizabeth’s radical argument: she rejects Lady Catherine’s arguments for class endogamy and insists that, as a gentleman’s daughter, she is Darcy’s equal.
The blazon overturned: Elizabeth’s rejection of patriarchal courtship
She recommends a new ethic for female behavior and a new subject position from which to consider societal wisdom about equal marriages.
The blazon overturned: Darcy humbled
Darcy is eventually grateful for the humbling experience of his first proposal. “Darcy humbled is the patriarchy humbled.”
Lizzy taught him the measure for marriage is no longer his blazon (fortune and class prestige) but his “pleasing,” assessed only from her subjective point of view.
In the new system of companionate marriage, the terms of the blazon are emptied of value.
P&P’s critique of endogamy and engrossment
P&P opposes endogamy: Elizabeth doesn’t marry her cousin Mr Collins, and Darcy doesn’t marry his cousin Miss de Bourgh.
Novel uses exogamous marriage to critique engrossment and lack of social mobility.
P&P marriage between a rich man (Darcy) and a poorer woman (Elizabeth) is a form of spiritual, emotional or psychological exogamy, bringing nonmaterialist values into story
What alternative to the marriage bargain does Austen offer in P&P?
Companionate marriage. The marriage bargain is Lydia’s marriage to Wickham. The companionate marriages are Elizabeth and Darcy and Jane and Bingley. To reach this, Austen overturns the traditional use of the blazon in the courtship novel. She also interrogates the commodification of women and offers different subject positions.
How does Elizabeth respond to Lady Catherine, and why does it matter?
Lady Catherine speaks for patriarchy, as one of two women who are the agents of the exchange (with Darcy’s mother). She retorts with the normative taxonomy of the blazon. Elizabeth rejects class endogamy and says that, as a gentleman’s daughter, she is Darcy’s equal. This withstands patriarchal demands and models a new ethic for female behavior.
What does “Darcy humbled is the patriarchy humbled” mean?
After Elizabeth’s refusal, Darcy is grateful for the humbling experience of his first proposal. Lizzy taught him that the measure of a marriage is no longer his blazon (fortune and class prestige) but his “pleasing,” which only she can judge. Under companionate marriage, the terms of the blazon are emptied of value.
What is the “marriage plot” Michie describes?
In the 19th-century novel of manners, a hero is positioned between a wealthy, materialistic, status-conscious woman who could advance his position and a poorer, more altruistic, psychologically independent woman. It emerges in P&P. The rich woman is the vulgarity and wealth the hero must avoid, and she carries cultural anxieties about changing forms of money.
Why is the heiress a “block to exogamy and progress”?
For anthropologists, modernity meant freedom to marry whom you wanted and individual ownership. But under patrilineage, heiresses could inherit, and if she married outside the group, the property went with her. So she had to marry endogamously, while all others could marry exogamously. This reveals the limits behind the freedoms.
How does P&P critique endogamy and engrossment?
Miss Bingley wants to join commercial wealth with Darcy’s landed estate, and Lady Catherine wants two cousins’ properties to become one. Both endorse endogamy and engrossment. Elizabeth doesn’t marry Mr Collins and Darcy doesn’t marry Miss de Bourgh, so the novel opposes endogamy. Austen uses exogamous marriage to critique engrossment and lack of social mobility. Darcy marrying poorer Elizabeth is “spiritual, emotional or psychological exogamy” that brings nonmaterialist values into the Darcys.
How does Pride and Prejudice (1813) overturn the blazon and move from the marriage bargain to companionate marriage?
Setup: Austen interrogates the marriage market’s commodification of women.
The bargain: Lydia and Wickham.
Lady Catherine’s confrontation: two female agents of patriarchy, the normative taxonomy of the blazon, Elizabeth’s radical argument (gentleman’s daughter, Darcy’s equal, rejects class endogamy).
Elizabeth’s rejection of patriarchal courtship: she recommends a new ethic and subject position.
Darcy humbled: “Darcy humbled is the patriarchy humbled”, and “pleasing” replaces the blazon.
Result: companionate marriage (Elizabeth and Darcy; Jane and Bingley), and the blazon’s terms are emptied of value.