1/51
Looks like no tags are added yet.
who describes white collar + corporate crimes as ‘crimes in the suites’
Timmer and Eitzen (1989)
what do they describe more visible, w.c street crimes as
‘crimes in the streets’
what did Pearce (1976) call white collar + corporate crimes
the ‘crimes of the powerful’
what did Sutherland (1949) introduce (4)
the idea of white collar crime
crime is not just a w.c phenomenon
crime is present in all sections of society
crime committed by the more affluent in society who abused their positions within their m.c occupations for criminal activity for personal benefit
what are both white collar and corporate crimes under the umbrella term of
‘economic crime’
how does croall (2007) define white collar + corporate crime
white collar → committed by m.c individuals who abuse their work positions for personal gain, at the expense of employers, the gov or clients
corporate → Slapper + Tombs (1999) describes as offences committed by large companies, or individuals acting on behalf of companies, which directly benefit the company rather than individuals and involve increased profits or the survival of the organisation
what is white collar crime also known as
occupational crime
what is corporate crime also known as
organisational crime
what are 6 explanations for white collar + corporate crime
strain theory, anomie and relative deprivation
control theory
differential association
marxist explanations
labelling theory
edge work
what are 7 reasons why white collar + corporate crimes are underrepresented in official statistics
hard to detect
often without personal or individual victims
may benefit both parties involved
hard to investigate
often a lack of awareness that a crime has been committed
institutional protection means they are often not reported and prosecuted
even if reported, offenders have a better chance of being found not guilty
what does this misrepresentation create
a misleading impression that most crime is committed by the w.c
evaluation of white collar + corporate crime explanations (2)
they fail to give reasons why not all individuals or corporations turn to crime to resolve their problems, or are prepared to take the risks in doing so
marxist explanations (which see corporate crime as inevitable in competitive criminogenic capitalist societies) don’t explain why in some countries where there is no pressure for profitability, corporate crimes and corruption are still found (eg former communist Russia + Eastern Europe, public organisations like the army, police + gov)
theories explaining w.c crime
strain + anomie (merton)
subcultural theories (cloward + ohlin, Cohen, miller)
control theory (hirschi)
marxist/non marxist theories (gordon, Chambliss, box, snider, Pearce etc)
labelling theory (Becker, cicourel, lemert)
left realism (lea and young)
right realism/rational choice and opportunity/new right (murray, Clarke)
postmodernism (Katz, lyng)
what is Hirschi’s control theory
attachment, involvement, commitment + belief (the 4 social bonds) are more likely to be fractured in w.c members lives. this means these 4 social controls no longer possess the same power in preventing people from committing crimes
3 evaluations of these theories attempting to define w.c crime
they dont explain why all those in the same circumstances in the poorest sections of the wrong class don’t turn to crime (and why most dont)
there is a vast amount of crime that remains undetected and unrecorded, or offenders haven’t been caught, so we dont know who offenders are → unrepresentative view of offenders
there is widespread evidence of crime committed by members of other social classes which may be undetected and unrecorded, or dealt with outside the criminal law even though criminal offences may have been committed
what are the 6 types of corporate crime
paperwork + compliance
environmental (‘green’) crimes
manufacturing offences
labour law violations
unfair trade practices
financial offences
what are paperwork + non compliance crimes
offences when correct permits or licences aren’t obtained, or companies fail to comply with health and safety and other legal obligations e.g Grenfell Tower, cladding didn’t meet fire safety precautions efficiently enough
what are environmental (‘green’) crimes
damage to the environment caused deliberately or through negligence, including the pollution of land, water supplies and air through the discharge, emission and dumping of toxic substances e.g Thames Water company fined £2.3 million for ‘foreseeable’ pollution
what are manufacturing offences
offences such as the incorrect labelling of products and false advertisement, producing unsafe consumer goods and counterfeit goods e.g products haven’t gone through adequate testing to check if safe (chemicals, costumes in flammable materials) e.g thalidomide tragedy of 1950s + 1960s, babies born defected and genetically disabled due to pregnancy drug not being tested properly
what are labour law violations
neglect of health and safety regulations, failing to pay minimum wage, causing or concealing industrial diseases e.g gov website names and shames companies for underpaying staff
what are unfair trade practices
false advertisement and anti-competitive practices, such as price fixing e.g in 2011, UK supermarkets were fined £50 million for fixing the price of milk and cheese, costing consumers £270m more than they would normally pay
what are financial offences
tax evasion, concealment of losses and debts e.g in 2012, global companies like Amazon and Starbucks were revealed by the gov to failed to pay their share of taxes, through various legal offshore financial centres where taxes were lower than in the UK
what are the 6 explanations for white collar and corporate crime
strain theory and relative deprivation
control theory
differential association
marxist explanations
labelling theory
the seduction of crime and edge work
what is strain theory and relative deprivation
m.c people innovate and turn to crime due to relative deprivation → they have achieved Merton’s social goals legitimately, but its not enough. they are fuelled by greed and power
what is control theory
individuals who carry out corporate crimes to benefit companies are driven by socialisation into, and conformity to, self-seeking, aggressive management cultures, which encourage ruthless business practices when competing with other companies
what does Nelken (2012) suggest
strain and control theories converge in explaining some offenders → some successful people have the material goods associated with success, but may have got into financial difficulties to maintain the lifestyle. therefore, they use illegitimate means to resolve these difficulties, maintaining their reputation and affluent lifestyle
what is differential association
if people associate with others who commonly support illegal activities, then they are more likely to commit crime themselves, either for personal gain (white collar) or to benefit the business (corporate)
who proposes differential association
Rutherland (1983)
what are marxist explanations
marxists like Box (1983) and Slapper and Tombs (1999) argue the push to criminogenic capitalism → the need to maintain profits in an increasingly global market means that (if this cannot be achieved legally) than illegal means will be used. this leads to crimes like price fixing, industrial espionage etc.
what is labelling theory
Nelken suggests these offences are more likely to escape labelling as ‘criminal’ because they are often similar with regular business practices
what does croall (2007) note about corporate crime
its often not accompanied by a direct intent to cause harm → eg dumping of toxic waste is not deliberately intending to kill or injure people, even if that is the effect, and so they appear ‘‘less criminal’’ than offences like burglary
what else does nelken point out
powerful individuals or corporations employ accountants and lawyers to develop techniques of neutralisation in order to redefine their crimes as non-criminal oversights, mistakes or errors rather than a deliberate attempt to break the law
what is the seduction of crime and edgework
Nelken, Katz + Lyng → the world of high finance shows a subculture in which the excitement for young men of living life in the fast lane is as important as the money benefits, suggesting the seduction of crime lures a lot of criminals in
what is a ward
segment of a town or city
what did Roger houchin (2005) find
there was a strong relationship between living in the most deprived wards in Scotland and being in prison → the imprisonment rate in the 27 most deprived wards was roughly 4x what is was in Scotland as a whole
what did Omolade’s 2014 study find
as a study of 2171 prisoners in England and Wales (2006/7):
43% had no educational qualifications
only 6% had a degree or equivalent
36% were unemployed at time of sentence
60% were claiming benefits
what is one way of testing whether there really is more crime committed by the w.c than the higher classes
self-report studies
what did The Offending, Crime and Justice Survey (2003-2006) find
a study on a sample of 5000 10-25 year olds, found the social class of the family wasn’t significantly associated with the likelihood of offending and drug use
what was self report offending found to be statistically linked to
single-parent families, having a parent living with a new partner, inconsistent parent discipline etc.
what does this suggest
factors relating to social control influence whether young people are likely to commit offences
prisoners are…
3-4x less likely to have gcses in English or maths
what did a university of Cambridge study find
w.c accents (liverpool, Newcastle) are stereotypes as sounding ‘guiltier’, potentially leading to bias in the justice system
what did the Ministry of Justice’s latest data find
25% of prisoners in England and Wales have spent time in care prior to imprisonment
what are 7 reasons for the under-representation of white collar and corporate crimes
they’re hidden from view and hard to detect
they’re often without personal or individual victims
they may benefit both parties concerned
they’re hard to investigate
there’s often a lack of awareness that a crime has been committed
even if these crimes are detected, they’re often not prosecuted and dealt with as criminal acts
even if reported and prosecuted, offenders have a better chance of being found not guilty
why are they hidden from view and hard to detect (2)
Clarke (1990) and Croall (2001) point out these crimes are relatively invisible, as they take place in the workplace - offenders appear to be completing their normal jobs
corporate cover ups and networks of influence by powerful business mean some corporate offences may never actually be discovered, or only discovered once the damage has already been done (eg Thalidomide drug and babies in 1950s/1960s
why are they often without personal or individual victims (2)
Croall (2007) points out that there is less obvious, personal harm (or ‘blood on the streets’) and victims appear impersonal, like a company, the gov, the NHS etc., rather than individuals
Clarke points out these are often ‘complaintless’ crimes, as there is no individual victim to report a crime
why may they benefit both parties involved
in terms of bribery and corruption, whether for business or personal reasons, both parties may stand to gain something, and therefore both parties will be in trouble if discovered and seek to conceal the offence, making it harder to detect
why are they hard to investigate (2)
even if offences like business or computer fraud are suspected, they often involve some form of technical or insider knowledge, making many offences complex
their investigation requires a lot of skill and expert knowledge, which local and even national police forces may lack, making the extent and duration of offenders hard to discover and investigate
why is there often a lack of awareness that a crime has been committed (3)
Croall (2007) suggests victims may lack the expertise to know whether they are, for example, being misled or defrauded, and may be unaware of any harm to them
she suggests this happens with offences where individual losses are very small or barely perceptible (eg pollution, food adulteration, false descriptions of consumer goods)
victims may blame themselves for making ‘risky investments’
why are offenders often not persecuted and dealt with as criminals, even if they are caught (3)
many harmful corporate crimes of business only lead to a reprimand, fine or enforcement notice from regulatory bodies and gov agencies (eg Health and Safety Executive) rather than police action and persecution through the CJS
white collar crimes are often concealed by institutional protection (e.g employee embezzlement from customer bank accounts) and are rarely reported to protect the reputation of the business. this avoids loss of public confidence
suspected offenders may be dealt with internally e.g sacked, forced to retire
why do offenders have a better chance of being found not guilty, even if reported and prosecuted (3)
most juries, like the public, hold the stereotype that crime is a mainly w.c phenomenon rather than committed by affluent and respectable m.c people
defendants are often of the same social background as judges and magistrates, and may appear more honest and plausible, so less likely to be found guilty
their offence are more likely to be seen as temporary lapses in otherwise good behaviour, and receive more lenient sentences than w.c offenders
in general, the higher you are in the social class hierarchy: (5)
the less likely are your crimes to be detected
the less likely are your crimes, if detected, to result in your arrest
the less likely you are, if arrested, to be prosecuted
the less likely you are, if prosecuted, to be found guilty
the less likely you are, if found guilty, to be given a prison sentence