1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what are the two instrumental policies of tort law
loss minimization and loss distribution
loss minimization defintion
deterrence, actors are more likely to be careful if they are always liable
loss distribution definition
spreading the costs of the harm across a wider group rather than leaving the full burden on a single individual (who has insurance/deeper pockets?)
corrective justice
doing wrong to another person and injuring them creates a duty for the wrongdoer, requiring damages be paid to restore the moral equilibrium
idea behind correction justice: what happens when a defendant harms the plaintiff what does that do
immediately creates a moral right of the plaintiff to recover damages from the defendant defendant to restore the moral equilibrium
civil recourse meaning
a duty to repair the wrong or compensate the victim does not arise automatically, but rather exists only as prescibed by tort law (state-imposed duty)
impact of civil recourse: the obligation to pay damages is created by what
the law which follows corrective justice principles
responsable compensation meaning
to make the plaintiff whole as if they never suffered an injury
what questions are for the judge
questions of law (ex. duty) and directed verdict (reasonable jury could only find one way)
what questions are for the jury
questions of fact (breach, causation) and questions of application of the law to the fact
what is the holding in Ives
the NY court of appeals reversed the decision in favor of the defendant not paying worker’s compensation benefits because the statute was unconstitutional under the state and federal due process clauses
what are the six principles that must be true for the Ive’s decision to be correct?
Constitutions prevail over statutes, and the Courts decide when constitutions conflict with statutes
both the federal constitution and the NY state constitution have “due process clauses” that guarantee against the deprivation of property without due process of the law
due process of law means that the defendant is entitled to be judged fundamentally by the same law in place at the time of the adoption of the constitutions
“fault is required for liability” was one of the basic principles in place at the time of the adoption of the constitutions
the workers’ compensation statute created liability without fault
social, economic, and moral consideration do not matter to the legal argument
what is incorrect about the principle that Due Process of law means that the defendant is entitled to be judged fundamentally by the same law in place at the time of the adoption of the constitutions
cannot be right given the historical development of no-fault to requirement of negligence (Brown v. Kendall)
this is an original meaning varient of originalism
just six years later, SCOTUS rejected the idea that a “person has a vested interest in any rule of law, entitling him to insist that it remain unchanged for his benefit”
what is incorrect about the principle that “Fault is required for liability” was one of the basic principles in place at the time of the adoption of the American (federal and state) constitutions
cannot be right given the historical develop of tort law (english writ system)
the fundamental law at the time of the foundation of the American Republic was that no fault was required
what is inccorect about the principle that “Social, economic, and moral considerations do not matter to the legal argument”
this does not stand given how many cases we saw throughout the semester that decided cases on policy grounds
what are the key characteristics of the pre-industrial america/english writ system:
no fault/strict liability standard
each category of writ brought its own process, procedure, and substantive law
what are the two main kinds of writs
writ of trespass and writ of trespass on the case
describe the writ of trespass
employed when the injury resulted immediately/directly from the defendant’s actions
applied no fault strict liability
did not need to prove actual damagesw
what is the classic example of the writ of trespass
a defendant throws a log onto a highway, hits the plaintiff, and injures them
what are the decendants of the writ of trespass
trespass to the land and battery and assault
describe the writ of trespass on the case
injury was consequential/indirect from the actions of the defendant
had to prove fault and actual damages
what is the classic example of the writ of trespass on the case
defendant throws a log onto the highway and later, a horse trips over it, and the plaintiff is tossed from the carriage and is injured
descendants of the writ of trespass on the case
negligence
what are the key characteristics of the classical negligence regime/industrial revolution era of tort law development:
there was an explosion of cases of injury and the rise of big employers
beginning of requiring the plaintiff prove fault on part of the employer
what are the three affirmative defenses which developed in the classical negligence regime
fellow/servant rule, assumption of the risk, and contributory negligence
describe the fellow servant rule
an injured employee could not recover from the employer for an injury caused by the tortious conduct of another employee
what is the writ of trespass on the case example case that we have
weaver v. ward
holding of weaver v. ward
even if the plaintiff did not have intention, they were still liable
what case obliterated the distinction between the writ of trespass and the writ of trespass on the case
brown v. kendall
what is the impact of brown v. kendall
to recover, the plaintiff must show that the defendant was acting without due care (neglignce)