Topic 3: (digestible) intention to create legal relations

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/14

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

15 Terms

1
New cards

1. What is intention to create legal relations? 

1.1 Definition 

Intention to create legal relations means that the parties intend their agreement to have legal consequences, so that it can be enforced through the courts. 

In contract law, not every promise becomes a legally enforceable contract. 

For example, imagine two situations: 

Situation A — A promise between friends 

Sarah tells her friend Emily: "I'll give you £20 if you help me clean my bedroom." 

Emily agrees. 

Depending on the circumstances, this might simply be a friendly arrangement rather than a legally enforceable agreement. 

Situation B — A commercial agreement 

Sarah owns a cleaning company and agrees to pay Emily £20 to clean an office. 

This is more likely to be legally enforceable because it takes place in a commercial context. 

The important difference is whether the parties objectively intended to create legal obligations. 

Note: You can make the same statement and it would have 2 different consequences 

1.2 Why is intention important? 

The law needs to distinguish between: 

  • Promises that are part of ordinary social or family life. 

  • Agreements that the parties intend to be legally enforceable. 

Without this distinction, people might try to sue one another for ordinary promises that were never intended to have legal consequences. 

For example, a friend promising to meet you for lunch does not ordinarily create a contract. 

1.3 The two main presumptions 

A presumption is a starting assumption made by the law, which may be displaced by evidence. 

Type of agreement 

Starting presumption 

Domestic and social agreements 

No intention to create legal relations 

Commercial agreements 

Intention to create legal relations 

Important: These are rebuttable presumptions, not absolute rules. 

A domestic agreement can be legally binding, and a commercial agreement can be non-binding. 

The court must examine the circumstances. 

2
New cards

2. The objective test for intention 

2.1 What is the objective test? 

The courts determine intention objectively rather than subjectively. 

This means they do not simply ask what each person privately believed or intended. 

Instead, they examine the parties' words, actions and surrounding circumstances to determine whether their agreement objectively demonstrates an intention to be legally bound. 

Objective versus subjective intention 

Subjective intention: What a person privately thinks or wants. 

Objective intention: What a reasonable person would understand from the parties' words and conduct in the circumstances. 

Example 

Imagine James signs a commercial agreement to supply 100 computers to a company. 

Privately, James thinks: 

"I don't really want to be legally bound by this." 

However, he signs the agreement and behaves as though it is a business transaction. 

The court will not necessarily accept his private thoughts as evidence that there was no intention to create legal relations. 

Instead, it examines the agreement and the circumstances objectively. 

2.2 Attrill v Dresdner Kleinwort Ltd (2013) 

Legal principle: Intention to create legal relations is assessed objectively. 

The lecturer refers to Elias LJ, who explained that intention is determined objectively rather than by reference to the actual state of each party's mind. 

Explanation 

The court does not need to discover exactly what each person was privately thinking. 

Instead, it asks whether their words and behaviour objectively indicated an intention to enter into a legally enforceable agreement. 

Significance 

This case establishes the approach courts take when deciding whether contractual intention exists. 

Application: If someone argues that they never personally intended to be legally bound, the court will consider whether that argument is consistent with the objective circumstances. 

The slides also refer to Kajima Construction Europe Ltd v Children's Ark Partnership Ltd (2023) as supporting authority for the objective approach. 

The slides do not provide the facts or detailed judgment in Kajima. 

2.3 Maple Leaf Macro Volatility Master Fund v Rouvroy (2009) 

Legal principle: A party's undisclosed subjective intention not to be bound does not necessarily prevent a contract from arising. 

Facts provided in the lecture : One party signed a contract despite not subjectively intending to be legally bound. 

Judgment : Longmore LJ explained that a contract could exist even though one party did not privately intend to be bound when signing. 

Explanation : Imagine you sign a contract to sell your car for £5,000. 

You later claim: 

"I signed it, but I never really intended to sell my car." 

The court will examine the objective evidence. 

If your words and actions clearly demonstrated agreement, your private intention may not prevent the contract from being enforceable. 

Significance 

This reinforces the objective approach. 

A person cannot necessarily escape contractual liability simply by claiming that they secretly did not intend to enter a binding agreement. 

3
New cards

3. Commercial circumstances do not automatically establish intention 

Although commercial agreements are generally presumed to be legally binding, the surrounding circumstances remain important. 

3.1 Blue v Ashley (2017) 

This case demonstrates that a promise made between people who have a commercial relationship may still lack contractual intention. 

Facts 

  • Mike Ashley was the owner of Sports Direct. 

  • Jeffrey Blue was a consultant. 

  • Ashley promised to pay Blue £15 million if Blue could get Sports Direct's share price to double. 

  • The promise was made in a public house. 

  • Several pints of beer had been consumed. 

  • The conversation was jocular, meaning joking or light-hearted. 

Blue later sought to enforce the promise. 

Legal issue 

Did Ashley's promise create a legally enforceable agreement? 

Judgment 

The court held that the promise was not legally binding. 

Reasoning 

Although Ashley and Blue had a commercial relationship, the circumstances did not objectively demonstrate an intention to create legal relations. 

The conversation was informal, involved alcohol and took place in a joking atmosphere. 

Explanation 

Imagine your boss says at a party: "If you double our company's profits, I'll give you £1 million!" 

Everyone is laughing, drinking and joking. Even though your boss is someone you work with, the statement might not objectively be understood as a serious contractual promise. 

The court must look at the whole situation. 

Legal principle 

The commercial nature of a relationship does not automatically make every promise within that relationship legally enforceable. 

Application to problem questions 

Look for facts suggesting that the promise was not seriously intended, such as: 

  • A joking or exaggerated statement. 

  • An informal social setting. 

  • Alcohol consumption. 

  • The absence of serious negotiations. 

  • Other circumstances suggesting that a reasonable person would not understand the promise as legally binding. 

However, none of these factors automatically prevents a contract from arising. They must be considered together. 

4
New cards

4. Domestic and social agreements 

4.1 The general presumption 

Domestic and social agreements are generally presumed not to create legal relations. 

This commonly includes arrangements between: 

  • Spouses. 

  • Family members. 

  • Friends. 

  • People making informal social promises. 

However, this presumption can be rebutted. 

The courts consider the circumstances, particularly whether the parties were dealing with one another seriously and whether the agreement involved financial commitments or reliance. 

4.2 Balfour v Balfour (1919) 

Legal principle: Ordinary domestic agreements between spouses are generally presumed not to create legal relations. 

Facts 

  • Mr Balfour worked as a civil servant in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka). 

  • His wife remained in England because of health problems. 

  • Mr Balfour promised to pay his wife £30 per month as maintenance. 

  • Later, their relationship broke down. 

  • Mr Balfour stopped making the payments. 

  • Mrs Balfour brought legal proceedings to enforce the promise. 

Legal issue 

Was the husband's promise to pay £30 per month a legally enforceable contract? 

Judgment 

The court held that there was no intention to create legal relations. 

Atkin LJ explained the importance of distinguishing ordinary domestic arrangements from legally enforceable contracts. 

Reasoning 

The promise was made within the context of an ordinary marital relationship. The court did not regard it as an agreement intended to create contractual obligations. 

Explanation 

Imagine a husband tells his wife: 

"I'll give you £100 every month to help with expenses." 

If this promise is made as part of their ordinary domestic relationship, the law will generally presume that they did not intend to create a contract. 

The fact that money is involved does not automatically make the promise enforceable. 

Significance 

Balfour v Balfour establishes the starting presumption for domestic agreements. 

Exam application: If a problem involves an agreement between spouses who are living together amicably, begin by considering the domestic presumption. 

Then examine whether the facts provide evidence rebutting it. 

4.3 Merritt v Merritt (1970) 

Legal principle: An agreement between separated spouses may demonstrate an intention to create legal relations. 

Facts 

  • Mr and Mrs Merritt jointly owned a house. Their marriage broke down, and Mr Merritt left the family home. He agreed to pay his wife £40 per month. 

  • Mrs Merritt agreed to use the money towards the mortgage. Mr Merritt signed a document stating that if his wife paid the charges connected with the house until the mortgage was fully repaid, he would transfer the property into her sole name. 

  • Mrs Merritt fulfilled her obligation and paid off the mortgage. However, Mr Merritt refused to transfer the house. 

  • Mrs Merritt brought legal proceedings to enforce the agreement. 

Legal issue 

Was the agreement legally enforceable despite being made between husband and wife? 

Judgment 

The court held that there was an intention to create legal relations. Lord Denning MR distinguished this situation from Balfour v Balfour. 

Reasoning 

The couple were no longer living together in an ordinary harmonious marital relationship. They were separated and negotiating their financial affairs. 

The agreement was also recorded in writing. These circumstances demonstrated that the parties intended their agreement to have legal consequences. 

Explanation 

Imagine a married couple separates. 

They agree in writing: 

"If you pay the remaining mortgage, I will transfer the house into your name." 

One spouse pays the mortgage. 

The other then refuses to transfer ownership. This is different from an ordinary promise made during a happy marriage. The parties were negotiating a serious financial arrangement following separation. The court is therefore more likely to find contractual intention. 

Significance 

Merritt v Merritt demonstrates that the domestic presumption can be rebutted. 

It also shows why the context in which an agreement is made is crucial. 

4.4 Comparing Balfour and Merritt 

The lecturer specifically emphasises that these cases are not incompatible. 

They reached different conclusions because the factual circumstances were different. 

Factor 

Balfour v Balfour 

Merritt v Merritt 

Relationship 

Ordinary marital relationship 

Marriage had broken down 

Agreement 

Monthly maintenance promise 

Mortgage payments in return for transfer of house 

Written agreement 

No equivalent signed property agreement identified 

Written and signed agreement 

Context 

Domestic arrangement 

Serious financial negotiation following separation 

Intention 

Not established 

Established 

Outcome 

Not enforceable 

Enforceable 

Why is this comparison important? 

The law does not simply say: 

"All agreements between married people are unenforceable." 

Instead, it asks whether the circumstances objectively demonstrate contractual intention. 

A domestic relationship creates a starting presumption, but the evidence may rebut it. 

Exam technique 

  • When comparing cases, do not simply memorise their outcomes. 

  • Identify the material factual differences explaining why the courts reached different decisions. 

  • This is the analytical skill highlighted in the lecture. 


5
New cards

5. Rebutting the domestic presumption through reliance 

5.1 What is detrimental reliance? 

Detrimental reliance occurs where someone acts on a promise and, as a result, changes their position in a way that disadvantages them. 

For example, someone might: 

  • Sell their home. 

  • Give up employment. 

  • Spend substantial money. 

  • Move to another location. 

  • Give up an existing financial opportunity. 

Such conduct may provide evidence that the parties regarded their agreement as serious and legally significant. 

Detrimental reliance does not automatically create a contract, but it may help rebut the presumption against contractual intention. 

5.2 Parker v Clark (1960) 

Legal principle: Substantial reliance on a domestic agreement can help demonstrate intention to create legal relations. 

Facts:

  • The lecture describes an agreement involving two couples. 

  • One couple agreed to sell their house and use the proceeds to assist their daughter in purchasing a flat. 

  • They acted in reliance on an arrangement under which they would live with an elderly couple and receive a benefit connected with the elderly man's will. 

  • The couple acted on the arrangement by selling their property and changing their financial position. 

Legal issue : Was this merely a domestic or social arrangement, or did it have legal consequences? 

Judgment : Devlin J held that the agreement was enforceable. 

Reasoning : The parties had acted seriously on the arrangement. The significant change in circumstances and financial reliance supported the conclusion that the agreement was intended to be legally binding. 

Explanation:

Imagine an elderly couple tells their friends: 

"Sell your house and come to live with us. We will provide you with accommodation and make arrangements for you to benefit financially." 

The friends sell their home because they trust this promise. 

Later, the arrangement breaks down. 

It would be difficult to treat the agreement as merely a casual social promise when the friends had taken such significant steps in reliance on it. 

Significance 

This case shows that domestic or social circumstances do not necessarily prevent contractual intention. 

Key point: The more serious and substantial the reliance, the stronger the evidence that the parties intended the arrangement to have legal consequences. 

5.3 Radmacher v Granatino (2010) 

The lecturer refers to this Supreme Court case in the context of nuptial agreements. 

What is a nuptial agreement? 

A nuptial agreement is an agreement made by spouses or prospective spouses concerning financial arrangements associated with their marriage. 

For example, a couple might agree how certain assets should be treated if their marriage ends. 

Legal significance 

The lecture uses Radmacher v Granatino to illustrate that agreements connected with marriage may have serious legal significance rather than being treated as ordinary informal domestic promises. 

Important qualification 

The legal treatment of nuptial agreements involves family law principles as well as questions of intention. 

The Supreme Court's approach does not mean every nuptial agreement is automatically enforceable as an ordinary contract. 

The central principle is that courts may give significant weight to such agreements, subject to considerations including fairness and the circumstances in which they were made. 

The slides do not provide the full facts or reasoning, so this is the appropriate level of detail for the present lecture. 

6
New cards

6. Commercial agreements 

6.1 The general presumption 

Commercial agreements are generally presumed to be intended to create legal relations. 

This is because business transactions usually involve serious financial obligations. 

Examples include: 

  • Employment agreements. 

  • Supply contracts. 

  • Business partnerships. 

  • Commercial sales. 

  • Agreements between companies. 

If a company agrees to supply goods in exchange for payment, the law will ordinarily assume the parties intended the agreement to be legally enforceable. 

However, this presumption is rebuttable. 

6.2 How can the commercial presumption be rebutted? 

The parties may expressly state that their agreement is not intended to create legal obligations. 

One example is an honour clause. 

An honour clause indicates that the parties intend their agreement to operate as a matter of honour or goodwill rather than as a legally enforceable contract. 

Example 

Two businesses agree: 

"We will supply your products, but this arrangement is binding in honour only and is not intended to create legal obligations." 

This wording provides evidence that the parties do not intend the arrangement itself to be enforceable in court. 

However, the effect of the clause depends on its wording and context. 

6.3 Rose & Frank Co v JR Crompton & Bros Ltd (1925) 

Legal principle: Express wording can rebut the presumption of contractual intention in commercial agreements. 

Facts and context 

The parties entered into a commercial arrangement containing an honour clause. 

The clause indicated that the arrangement was not intended to be a formal legal agreement enforceable in court. 

Judgment 

The honour clause was effective in preventing the overarching arrangement from being treated as a legally enforceable contract. 

Explanation 

Imagine two companies agree to work together but expressly state: 

"We trust one another to follow this arrangement, but we do not want this overall agreement to create legal obligations." 

Although the relationship is commercial, the express wording may demonstrate that the parties intended to rely on business honour rather than contractual enforcement. 

Significance 

Commercial intention is presumed, but clear evidence can rebut that presumption. 

A further distinction is that individual transactions carried out under a broader non-binding arrangement may still create enforceable contracts. 

6.4 Jones v Vernon's Pools Ltd (1938) 

The lecturer refers to football pools coupons containing statements that agreements were binding in honour only. 

Legal principle 

Express wording denying legal enforceability may rebut the commercial presumption. 

Explanation 

A football pools operator could include terms stating that the arrangement was not intended to create legally enforceable obligations. 

The case illustrates how express language can influence whether an agreement creates legal relations. 

Significance 

Both Jones v Vernon's Pools and Rose & Frank demonstrate the importance of examining the actual wording used by the parties. 

7
New cards

7. Commercial intention despite informal or unusual wording 

7.1 Edwards v Skyways Ltd (1964) - Take time to study this case 

Legal principle: A promise made in a commercial or employment context may be legally binding even when described as an ex gratia payment. 

Facts 

The claimant worked as an airline pilot. 

He was made redundant. 

Under his employment arrangements, he had two options concerning his pension: 

  1. Recover his pension contributions. 

  2. Receive his full pension when he reached the age of 50. 

The British Airline Pilots Association had negotiated an additional arrangement. 

If the pilot chose the first option, the employer would make an ex gratia payment equal to his pension contributions. 

The pilot chose the first option. 

However, the employer refused to make the additional payment. 

The employer argued that the promise was not intended to create legal relations. 

What does ex gratia mean? 

Ex gratia means a payment made voluntarily or as a gesture of goodwill, rather than because of an existing legal obligation. 

However, using this expression does not necessarily mean a promise to make the payment cannot itself become contractually binding. 

Judgment 

The court held that there was an intention to create legal relations. 

Reasoning 

The agreement arose in a commercial employment context. 

The employer had not provided sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption of contractual intention. 

The description of the payment as ex gratia was not enough. 

Explanation 

Imagine your employer promises: 

"If you agree to take early retirement, we will give you an additional goodwill payment of £10,000." 

You agree to retire. 

The employer later refuses to pay, claiming that goodwill payments are not legally binding. 

The court would examine the whole arrangement rather than simply accepting the employer's label. 

Significance 

The language used to describe a payment does not necessarily determine whether the promise to make it is legally enforceable. 

The objective circumstances remain crucial. 

8
New cards

8. Commercial transactions and the existence of a contract 

8.1 Esso Petroleum Ltd v Commissioners of Customs and Excise (1976) 

Facts and context 

Esso Petroleum offered commemorative coins connected with the 1970 Football World Cup as part of a promotional scheme. 

The legal dispute concerned the characterisation of the promotional transactions. 

Judgment 

The lecture records that the issuing of the commemorative coins was not a sale. 

Explanation 

A promotional item may be provided as part of a commercial arrangement without necessarily being sold as a separate item. 

The fact that a transaction has commercial significance does not answer every legal question about its nature. 

Significance 

The case illustrates the need to distinguish between: 

  • Whether an arrangement has contractual significance. 

  • Whether a particular transfer constitutes a sale. 

These are separate questions. 

The slides give only the brief outcome, so the detailed tax and statutory reasoning is not covered here. 

9
New cards

9. Long-term commercial relationships 

9.1 Baird Textile Holdings Ltd v Marks & Spencer plc (2002) 

Legal principle: A long-standing commercial relationship does not automatically establish an enforceable long-term contractual commitment. 

Facts 

  • Baird Textile Holdings supplied clothing to Marks & Spencer. 

  • The relationship had continued for approximately 30 years. 

  • Marks & Spencer eventually terminated the commercial relationship. 

  • Baird argued that the long-standing relationship created an agreement under which Marks & Spencer could not terminate without reasonable notice. 

  • Baird claimed that reasonable notice should have been three years. 

Legal issue 

Could the long commercial relationship establish an enforceable obligation requiring Marks & Spencer to give three years' notice? 

Judgment 

The court rejected Baird's claim. 

Reasoning 

  • Marks & Spencer had deliberately avoided entering into formal long-term contracts with Baird. 

  • The existence of a long-standing business relationship was not sufficient to establish the particular continuing contractual obligation alleged. 

Explanation 

  • Imagine a clothing manufacturer supplies the same retailer for 30 years. 

  • The retailer regularly orders clothing, and the manufacturer relies heavily on those orders. 

  • One day, the retailer stops ordering. 

The manufacturer argues: 

"We have worked together for 30 years, so you must give us three years' notice before ending the relationship." 

The court cannot automatically assume such an obligation exists simply because the parties have traded for a long time. 

It must establish whether the relevant contractual obligation actually arose. 

Significance 

The case demonstrates that commercial relationships do not automatically produce every contractual obligation that one party expects. 

The court must consider the parties' objective intentions and the terms of their dealings. 

9.2 Connection with relational contract theory 

The lecturer links this case to relational contract theory, discussed in the first lecture. 

A relational contract is associated with an ongoing relationship involving cooperation, trust and repeated dealings. 

For example, a supplier and retailer may work together for many years rather than carrying out a single isolated transaction. 

However, the existence of a relational commercial relationship does not automatically establish a binding long-term contract or particular termination rights. 

This is the connection highlighted by Baird. 

Additional authority 

The lecture also refers to Mackie Motors (Brechin) Ltd v RCI Financial Services Ltd (2023) and directs students to page 165 of the textbook. 

The slides do not provide its facts, judgment or legal reasoning, so these cannot be reliably reconstructed from the lecture material alone. 

10
New cards

10. Agreements made 'subject to contract' 

10.1 What does 'subject to contract' mean? 

The expression subject to contract is commonly used to indicate that the parties do not intend to become legally bound until a formal contract is completed. 

For example, imagine two companies negotiating a property sale. 

They agree on a proposed price of £500,000. 

However, their correspondence states: 

"Agreement subject to contract." 

This normally indicates that they do not intend the negotiations themselves to create a final binding contract. 

Why is this important? 

  • Commercial negotiations can take place over several stages. 

  • Parties may agree on some important terms before they are ready to become legally committed. 

  • The phrase helps distinguish negotiations from a completed contract. 

10.2 What happens if the words are missing? 

  • The absence of the expression subject to contract does not automatically mean that a legally binding agreement exists. 

  • The court must still establish whether the parties objectively intended to be bound. 

10.3 SMIT Salvage BV v Luster Maritime SA (2024) 

Legal principle : The absence of the expression subject to contract is not decisive. 

Judgment 

  • The lecturer refers to Males LJ in the Court of Appeal. 

  • At paragraph [20], the court explained that the absence of the expression was not decisive. 

  • At paragraph [71], the court emphasised that an intention to be bound needed to be demonstrated unequivocally. 

  • On the facts, that intention was not established. 

What does unequivocally mean? 

  • It means clearly and without ambiguity. 

  • In this context, the court required clear evidence demonstrating that the parties intended to become legally bound. 

Explanation 

  • Imagine two companies exchange messages negotiating a shipping agreement. 

  • They discuss prices, services and other details. 

  • Neither company uses the phrase subject to contract. 

  • However, their communications do not clearly demonstrate that they have reached a final binding agreement. 

  • The court should not simply conclude that a contract exists because the protective phrase was absent. 

Significance 

  • The court must examine the parties' objective intention in the circumstances. 

  • The absence of 'subject to contract' is not the same as positive proof of contractual intention. 


11
New cards

11. Executory and executed agreements 

11.1 Executory agreements 

An executory agreement, in the simplified distinction used by the lecture, is one where neither party has yet performed any part of the agreement. 

Example 

Sarah agrees to paint James's house next Saturday for £500. 

James agrees to pay when the work is completed. 

At this stage: 

  • Sarah has not painted the house. 

  • James has not paid. 

  • Performance has not begun. 

The agreement is executory. 

Why does this matter? 

When neither party has performed, there may be less practical evidence demonstrating how seriously the parties treated their arrangement. 

However, an executory agreement can still be fully legally binding. 

Performance is not always required before a contract comes into existence. 

11.2 Executed agreements 

The lecture uses executed to describe agreements where performance has commenced. 

Example 

Sarah agrees to paint James's house for £500. 

She buys the necessary materials and begins painting. 

James allows her to continue. 

The parties' actions may provide evidence that they understood their arrangement to be serious. 

Why does performance matter? 

Courts are often reluctant to conclude that no contract exists where parties have already acted in reliance on an agreement or commenced performance. 

This is partly because refusing to recognise an agreement may create unfair or commercially unrealistic outcomes. 

Terminology qualification 

In wider contract law, an executed contract can also refer to a contract whose obligations have been fully performed. 

The lecturer uses the term more broadly here to emphasise the evidential significance of performance having begun. 

11.3 Unilateral agreements 

The lecturer introduces unilateral agreements and refers to Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co (1893), which will be covered in the next lecture. 

A unilateral contract commonly involves a promise made in return for the performance of a specified act. 

Example 

A company promises: 

"We will pay £1,000 to anyone who finds our missing equipment." 

A person who finds the equipment and satisfies the offer's conditions may become entitled to the reward. 

The person making the offer promises to pay if the specified act is completed. 

The person accepting the offer does so through performance. 

The lecture highlights the significance of performance by the offeree in unilateral agreements. 

12
New cards

12. Why courts are more willing to recognise agreements after performance begins 

The lecturer explains that intention is often easier to identify where parties have started performing their obligations. 

Example 

Imagine two companies negotiate a supply arrangement. 

They do not finalise every detail in writing. 

However: 

  • The supplier begins delivering products. 

  • The buyer accepts the deliveries. 

  • The buyer starts making payments. 

Their conduct provides strong evidence that they intended to establish a commercial relationship with legal consequences. 

By contrast, if the parties had only discussed possible future deliveries, establishing a binding agreement might be more difficult. 

Important distinction 

Performance can provide evidence of contractual intention, but it does not automatically resolve every other requirement for contract formation. 

The courts must still consider issues such as agreement, certainty and any applicable formalities. 

12.1 Section 9 Sale of Goods Act 1979 

The lecturer refers to s.9 Sale of Goods Act 1979 in connection with the courts' willingness to recognise agreements where performance has occurred. 

Section 9 concerns the ascertainment of price in contracts for the sale of goods. 

In particular, it allows the price to be determined in several ways and provides for a reasonable price where appropriate. 

Explanation 

Imagine a supplier delivers goods to a retailer. 

The retailer accepts them, but the parties have not expressly fixed a price. 

Section 9 may assist in determining the price, rather than necessarily treating the absence of an agreed figure as fatal to the contract. 

This supports the broader point that the law may seek to give practical effect to commercial dealings. 

However, s.9 is specifically concerned with price; it does not itself establish a general rule that every partly performed agreement is binding. 

12.2 Case authorities mentioned by the lecturer 

The lecture directs students to compare several cases concerning the enforceability of agreements and the significance of performance. 

Case 

Connection with the topic 

Foley v Classique Coaches Ltd 

Commercial performance and the enforceability of agreements. 

May & Butcher Ltd v The King 

Problems arising where essential contractual terms remain unsettled. 

Hillas & Co Ltd v Arcos Ltd 

Interpretation of commercial agreements and certainty of terms. 

Scammell v Ouston 

Uncertainty in contractual terms. 

British Bank for Foreign Trade Ltd v Novinex Ltd (1941) 

Denning J's analysis, identified for further reading. 

The slides list these authorities without explaining their detailed facts or holdings. 

The lecturer's main point is that courts may approach an agreement differently when the parties have already begun acting upon it. 

This is especially relevant when considering whether an arrangement is sufficiently definite and intended to have legal consequences. 

13
New cards

13. Connecting the cases together 

The lecture can be understood through four central questions. 

Question 

Key authorities 

Main lesson 

How is intention determined? 

Attrill, Maple Leaf, Kajima 

Use an objective assessment. 

Are domestic agreements binding? 

Balfour, Merritt, Parker 

Begin with the domestic presumption, then examine the circumstances and reliance. 

Are commercial agreements binding? 

Rose & Frank, Edwards, Blue, Baird 

Commercial intention is presumed but can be rebutted or may not be established on the facts. 

Does wording or performance matter? 

SMIT Salvage, Parker, and the cases on certainty 

Examine the parties' words, conduct and whether performance has commenced. 


14
New cards

14. Key terminology 

Term 

Meaning 

Intention to create legal relations 

Intention that an agreement should have legally enforceable consequences. 

Presumption 

A starting legal assumption that may be rebutted. 

Rebuttal 

Evidence showing that a presumption should not apply. 

Objective test 

Assessment based on outward words, conduct and circumstances rather than private thoughts. 

Subjective intention 

A person's private state of mind. 

Domestic agreement 

An agreement arising in a family or household context. 

Commercial agreement 

An agreement made in a business or commercial context. 

Honour clause 

Wording indicating that an arrangement is not intended to be legally enforceable. 

Ex gratia 

A payment described as voluntary or made without an existing legal obligation. 

Detrimental reliance 

Acting on a promise in a way that changes one's position disadvantageously. 

Subject to contract 

Wording generally indicating that parties do not intend to be bound until a formal contract is concluded. 

Executory agreement 

In this lecture, an agreement where performance has not begun. 

Executed agreement 

In this lecture, an agreement where performance has commenced. 

Unilateral contract 

A contract in which a promise is accepted through performance of a specified act. 


15
New cards

15. Final revision summary 

The central principle is that not every agreement is intended to create a legally enforceable contract. 

Domestic and social agreements are generally presumed not to create legal relations, whereas commercial agreements are generally presumed to do so. 

However, these presumptions are not conclusive. 

The courts assess intention objectively, considering the parties' words, conduct and circumstances. 

For domestic agreements, separation, written terms, serious financial commitments and detrimental reliance may help establish contractual intention. 

For commercial agreements, honour clauses, informal joking circumstances or evidence that negotiations remained incomplete may demonstrate a lack of intention. 

Finally, where parties have already begun performing an agreement, their conduct may make it easier to establish that they intended legal consequences. 

The most important examination skill is distinguishing the cases based on their facts, rather than simply memorising whether the court found a contract.