The CEC and Other ECs Bill 2023 (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/13

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

The Rajya Sabha recently approved the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Bill, 2023, responding to a directive from the Supreme Court of India to bring transparency to the appointment process

14 Terms

1
New cards

What was the supreme court ruling that started this bill?

  1. The Supreme Court directed the establishment of an independent mechanism for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs) in the Anoop Baranwal v Union of India case, 2023

  2. The SC highlighted the need for a committee comprising the Prime Minister, Chief Justice of India (CJI), and the Leader of the Opposition for appointing the CEC and ECs.

2
New cards

Which article and clause gave the President the power to elect the CEC?

Article 324, Clause 2

3
New cards

What was the issue with the president electing the CEC?

The Parliament didn’t pass any Law which effectively made the President’s (i.e., the executive’s) powers permanent to appoint CEC and ECs.

The supreme court then found in the aforesaid case that giving the executive the power to appoint the CEC was incompatible with the independence of ECI.

The reason for this is obvious: In a parliamentary system, the executive is drawn from the ruling party, and is, hence, a player in the electoral game.

Giving the executive the power to appoint the CEC, therefore, is akin to giving a player the power to appoint the referee.

4
New cards

What are some of the issues with this bill?

Provides Executive Supremacy: The Election Commissioners bill replaces the CJI with a cabinet minister nominated by the PM. Which again gives the Executive a clear majority — and, therefore, a decisive say — in the appointment of the Election Commissioners.

, the selection committee consisted of:

  1. The prime minister (chairperson)

  2. The leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha (member)

  3. A Union cabinet minister nominated by the prime minister (member)

Against the Will of the Constitution Framers:

The intention of the framers of the Constitution was to secure and guarantee the independence of ECI. Which is why they provided the President (executive) the power to appoint ECs as a stop-gap arrangement, in the expectation that Parliament would enact a law that would secure and guarantee the independence of ECI.


An Umpire who is Subordinate to the Team Captain: A former chief election commissioner said that the most concerning aspect of the new legislation is the downgrading of the status of election commissioners as well as the CEC from being at par with Supreme Court judges to that of cabinet secretary.


Limiting Eligibility to Civil Servants: Restricting eligibility to individuals who have held a position equivalent to the Secretary to the government may limit the diversity of backgrounds and expertise in the ECI.

5
New cards

Changes by SC (What did SC Highlight)

Prime Minister, Chief Justice of India (CJI), and the Leader of the Opposition for appointing the CEC and ECs.

Union minister replaced by CJI

6
New cards

Shift in Equivalence of CEC?

The salary and conditions of service of the CEC and ECs will be equivalent to that of the Cabinet Secretary, shifting from the previous equivalence to a Supreme Court Judge.

7
New cards

WHats the removal process for CEC and EC?

The Bill retains the constitutional provision allowing the CEC to be removed like a Supreme Court Judge, while ECs can only be removed on the recommendation of the CEC.

8
New cards

Is there a safeguard from legal proceedings?

The Bill safeguards CEC and ECs from legal proceedings related to actions taken during their tenure, provided such actions were in the discharge of official duties.

9
New cards

What is the South African Model?

  1. In South Africa, the selection process involves key figures such as the President of the Constitutional Court, representatives of the Human Rights Court, and advocates for gender equality.

  2. Emphasis on diverse representation ensures a broader perspective in the electoral body.

10
New cards

What is the United Kingdom Approach?

In the U.K., candidates for the electoral body are subject to approval by the House of Commons.

Parliamentary involvement adds a layer of scrutiny and accountability to the selection process.

11
New cards

What is the United States Procedure?

In the U.S., the President appoints members to the electoral body, and the appointments require confirmation by the Senate.

The dual-check system ensures a balance of power and prevents unilateral decisions.

12
New cards

What is the eigibility for being appointed as EC/SEC?

Eligibility includes holding (or having held) a post equivalent to the Secretary to the central government.

A Search Committee headed by the Cabinet Secretary proposes a panel of names to the Selection Committee.

13
New cards
14
New cards