1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is Rachels’ minimum conception of morality
It is the effort to be the guide to how someone acts by reasoning and putting into consideration how it will affect others between choosing to act.
What is Cultural Relativism as a Normative Theory
the core claim that the moral code of a society determines what is right within that society. If a society’s code says a certain action is right, then that action is right, at least within that culture. Cultural relativists cannot argue for universal tolerance as that would itself be a moral universal truth,
What is the relationship between cultural relativism and tolerance for other cultures
Cultural Relativism is motivated by a desire to promote tolerance for other cultures but does not support universal tolerance. Tolerance is a good thing and we should not condemn other societies for being different but we do not need to be CR to be tolerant. CR forces us to accept that their intolerance is “right” for them.
What is the difference between an Objective claim and a Subjective claim, according to Shafer-Landau?
An objective claim is one whose truth does not depend on whether anyone approves it or believes it to be true, it is independently of human opinion. A subjective claim one whose truth is dependent on individual feelings.
What are “Normative Subjectivism” (NS) and “Meta-ethical Subjectivism” (MES)?
Normative Subjectivism - If a person deep down believes something is right/wrong, then it it is to YOU
Meta-ethical Subjectivism - It is subjectivism that denies that moral judgement can be true or false. It suggests that ethical statements are not about objective facts, but reduce to factual statements about the feelings of individuals.
What are the unwelcome consequences of NS, and which of those consequences are resolved by MES
The consequences of NS are moral infallibility, the problem of disagreement, and abritrariness. MES resolves the problem of disagreement but suggesting that moral language is used to express attitude or to persuade others.
What is Psychological Egoism
The theory that people act and behave in pursuit of their own interests
What are the arguments in favor of PE and what are the problems with those arguments?
In favor: People always do what they most want to do and because helping others produces a sense of self-satisfaction, people only help others to get that good feeling.
Rachels’ response: We often act out of a sense of obligation or duty and you do not help a child in order to feel good. You feel good because you cared about the issue.
Understand what Rachels means when he describes PE as “unfalsifiable”
The theory is defined in such a way that it is impossible to prove wrong which makes science and logic, meaningless.
What is Ethical Egoism
A normative theory about how we ought to behave, our only duty is to do what is best for ourselves.
Describe the Divine Command Theory in detail. According to that view, what makes moral claims true or false? Give a detailed description of the theological reason for rejecting the theory given by Rachels. Argue whether this is an adequate refutation of the theory.
The Divine Command Theory is that whatever God commands as what is morally right/wrong, then it is correct since God commanded it. Rachel's argues that to worship God requires recognizing Him as an absolute authority with an unqualified claim to obedience. However, a truly autonomous moral agent cannot surrender their independent judgement to any external authority. Unconditional obedience required by the DTC is incompatible with human moral dignity.
What is Rachels' theological reason for rejecting the Divine Command Theory?
Rachels argues that the theory implies morality is arbitrary (God could command cruelty, and it would become good) or that God is subject to an independent moral standard, which undermines the theory.
What is a flaw of normative subjectivism raised by Shafer-Landau?
Normative subjectivism implies that individuals are morally infallible as long as they are sincere, making moral disagreement impossible.
What is a serious problem for metaethical subjectivism?
It struggles to explain how moral progress is possible or how we can meaningfully disagree about moral facts, as it reduces moral statements to expressions of personal taste.
What are the two readings of "morality varies from culture to culture"?
The uncontroversial reading: Different cultures have different moral beliefs.
The controversial reading (Normative Cultural Relativism): What is actually right or wrong is determined by a culture's beliefs
Can one meaning of cultural relativism be true without the other?
Yes, cultures can have different beliefs (uncontroversial) without it being true that there is no objective moral truth (controversial).
What features of the world make moral claims true for (A) Cultural Relativism, (B) Normative Subjectivism, (C) Metaethical Subjectivism, and (D) Divine Command Theory?
A) Cultural standards, (B) Individual attitudes, (C) Nothing (they are expressions of emotion), (D) God's commands.
What makes moral claims true according to Ethical Egoism?
Whether the action promotes the individual's long-term self-interest.
Is the Theory of Natural Law an Objective or Subjective view?
Objective, as it holds that moral truths are grounded in human nature and can be discovered through reason.