1/138
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Classification of Crimes by Potential Punishment
Infraction: Warning; no potential for jail time or custody at all.
Misdemeanor: Lesser crime for which max penalty is incarceration for up to 1 year in county jail, fine, or both.
Felony: Serious crime carrying the potential for state prison time (greater than 1 year).
Wobbler: A crime that can be charged/punished as either a felony or a misdemeanor depending on statute and specific facts.
Definition of Actus Reus
The physical element of a crime; a guilty physical act or omission. The act must be voluntary (unconscious acts or physical reflexes do not incur criminal liability).
There is no legal duty to act or rescue another person, even if it is morally outrageous not to render aid. Moral duty does not equal criminal legal duty.
Five (5) Legal Exceptions Creating a Duty to Act
Failure to act constitutes a breach of legal duty when:
1. Statute imposes a duty to care for another (e.g., child neglect laws, teacher/student duties, statutory rescue laws).
2. Status relationship exists between parties (e.g., parent/child, spouse/spouse).
3. Contractual duty of care assumed (e.g., babysitter, lifeguard, nursing home caregiver, bodyguard).
4. Voluntary assumption of care and secluded the helpless person so as to prevent others from rendering aid (Jones v. US).
5. Defendant created the risky situation that put the victim in peril.
Rare Statutory Rescue Requirement
When a person is aware that another is in grave danger, he or she must render assistance if it can be done without endangering oneself or interfering with important duties. (Very rare statutory exception).
Jones v. United States (ROL)
In order for a defendant to be convicted of a crime for a failure to act, the prosecution must prove that the defendant was under a legal duty to act (e.g., contractual or voluntary assumption of care with seclusion).
Mosley v. Scully (Kitty Genovese Case)
In order for an individual to be held liable for a failure to act, there must be a recognized legal duty. Bystanders and neighbors have no general legal duty to rescue or call police absent a specific legal relationship.
Specific Intent vs. General Intent
Specific Intent: The actor actively desires the prescribed criminal consequences to follow his act/omission, or has a specific conscious objective to achieve the result. Can be negated by voluntary intoxication or honest mistake of fact.
General Intent: Requires only that the actor intended to perform the physical act itself; specific awareness or desire of unlawful consequences is not required. Intent is inferred from committing the act.
Doctrine of Transferred Intent
"Intent rides on the bullet." Specific intent to kill is not person-specific; it is an intent to kill a human being. If D shoots intending to kill X, misses, and hits Y, the intent to kill transfers to Y. Crimes are punished as offenses against society.
Note: Passion also rides the bullet (Voluntary Manslaughter provocation transfers to unintended victim).
Strict Liability Offenses
Offenses that do not require proof of mens rea or criminal intent regarding one or more elements. Commission of the prohibited act alone completes the offense (e.g., statutory rape, public welfare regulations). Mistake of fact is no defense.
First-Degree Murder (M1)
Elements:
1. Unlawful killing of a human being.
2. Specific Intent to Kill (NOT intent to GBI).
3. Premeditation and Deliberation (or committed via enumerated felony / lying in wait / poison / bomb / torture).
Second-Degree Murder
Definition: Unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought.
Elements (must have one of the following):
1. Specific Intent to Kill (without premeditation)
2. Specific Intent to Cause Serious Bodily Harm / Great Bodily Injury (GBI)
3. Willful & Wanton Life-Threatening Conduct (Depraved Heart)
4. Felony Murder II (unintentional killing during inherently dangerous felony)
Serious Bodily Harm
A serious impairment of physical condition, including but not limited to: loss of consciousness, concussion, bone fracture, protracted loss or impairment of function of any organ/member, wound requiring extensive suturing, or serious disfigurement.
Premeditation
Definition: Premeditation occurs if the person has an appreciable period of time to actually reflect on the consequences of taking the life of another individual.
Factors:
1. Planning Activity: Evidence of prior design or planning.
2. Prior Relationship / Motive: Relationship history (e.g., jealousy, hatred, financial gain).
3. Nature of Killing: Manner of killing consistent with a pre-designed plan.
4. Drawn-Out Act: Act carried out in a manner allowing time for reflection.
State v. Ramirez
Premeditation requires actual reflection upon the consequences of taking another's life. Passage of time alone provides the opportunity to reflect, but actual reflection must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Voluntary Manslaughter
Definition: An intentional killing mitigated down from Second-Degree Murder (NOT a complete defense).
Elements:
1. A killing that otherwise qualifies as Second-Degree Murder.
2. Defendant acted in the subjective throes of an overriding emotional passion / sudden heat.
3. An average reasonable person in the shoes of the actor would be so provoked (objective provocation).
Provocation — Mere Words Rule
Rule: Verbal provocation or mere opprobrious words alone are NOT sufficient to constitute adequate provocation for Voluntary Manslaughter.
Exception: Informational words (e.g., sudden confession of severe harm/rape to a loved one) can be sufficient to provoke a reasonable person.
Suprenant v. State
Mere words or a spouse's statement that a relationship is over do not constitute sufficient provocation to warrant a jury instruction on Voluntary Manslaughter.
Imperfect Self-Defense
Occurs when D holds an honest subjective belief that deadly force is necessary to defend against impending death/GBI, but that belief is objectively unreasonable. Negates malice aforethought and mitigates Second-Degree Murder down to Voluntary Manslaughter.
Willful & Wanton Life-Threatening Conduct
Elements:
1. Gross (criminal) negligence / recklessness.
2. High degree of (acute) awareness of the potential for human death.
3. Accompanied by a "don't care" attitude or a hint of viciousness.
4. NO social utility in the conduct (distinguishes W&W from Involuntary Manslaughter).
State v. Burley
In second-degree murder based on extreme indifference to human life, the existence and extent of indifference are questions of fact for the jury.
Involuntary Manslaughter
Elements (General Intent):
1. The act (or omission) is intentional.
2. The death is unintentional.
3. Committed with gross or criminal negligence (a gross deviation from the standard of care of a reasonable person).
Distinction: Presence of social utility helps differentiate Involuntary Manslaughter from Willful & Wanton M2.
Noakes v. Virginia
An involuntary manslaughter conviction will be upheld if a defendant should have known that particular reckless conduct (e.g., placing a heavy crate on top of a crib) was likely to cause substantial harm or death.
State v. Powell
The violation of a statute or ordinance designed to protect public safety (e.g., allowing vicious dogs to run loose), resulting in death, constitutes culpable negligence supporting involuntary manslaughter.
Felony Murder II
Rule: An unintentional killing that occurs during the commission or attempted commission of a felony.
Elements:
1. Underlying felony is inherently dangerous to human life (dangerous 100% of the time).
2. Killing is independent of assaultive, life-threatening conduct (felony cannot merge into murder).
3. Death occurs "in the perpetration" of the felony.
Felony Murder — "In the Perpetration" & Safe Harbor Rule
Definition: Death occurs in perpetration if it would not have occurred but for the felony. Includes all acts leading to and coming from the felony until the felon reaches a place of temporary safety (safe harbor).
Factors: Spatial/temporal proximity, possession of fruits, active pursuit by authorities.
People v. Portillo
For purposes of felony murder, the underlying felony is complete only when the perpetrator reaches a place of temporary safety.
State v. Blair
For felony murder, there is no independent mens rea requirement related to the victim's cause of death.
Felony Murder I
Rule: Felony Murder II elevated to First-Degree Murder if the underlying felony is one of the Enumerated Inherently Dangerous Felonies (BARRRK / BARRKKT):
1. Burglary
2. Arson
3. Rape
4. Robbery
5. Kidnapping
(Also: Torture, Mayhem, Bombing). Premeditation is NOT required.
Parties to Crime
Principal: The actual perpetrator who performs the criminal act.
Accomplice / Aider & Abettor: One who aids, abets, encourages, or instigates the commission of the felony. Liable for the substantive offense.
Accessory After the Fact: One who renders assistance, concealment, or escape to a felon after the crime is completed.
Aiding & Abetting Elements
Requirements:
1. Actual knowledge of the perpetrator's unlawful purpose.
2. Specific intent to encourage, promote, assist, or facilitate the commission of the crime.
3. Affirmative act or omission that aids, promotes, encourages, or instigates the crime.
Rule: Mere presence at the scene is INSUFFICIENT to establish liability. Presence is also not strictly required (remote aider).
Extent of Accomplice Culpability
An accomplice is charged with and convicted of the same substantive offense as the principal. Under the natural and probable consequences doctrine, an accomplice is also liable for any other crime committed by the principal that was reasonably foreseeable in furtherance of the intended crime.
Baker v. Alaska
A defendant charged as a principal to a crime may be convicted as an accessory/accomplice, and vice versa. Parties to a crime are held equally culpable.
Causation
The cause which, through its natural and foreseeable consequence, unbroken by any sufficient intervening cause, produces the injury which would not have occurred but for the cause.
Timeline: Original Act → Intervening Cause → Resulting Injury/Death
Causation Intervening Cause Analysis
To determine if D is proximately liable when an intervening force acts:
1. Did the intervening act substantially contribute to the resulting injury? - If No → Original act is the cause.
If Yes → Proceed to Q2.
2. Was the intervening act foreseeable?
If Foreseeable (Dependent) → Chain unbroken; original actor remains liable.
If Unforeseeable (Independent / Freakish) → Intervening act is superseding and cuts off D's criminal liability.
Causation Exceptions — Intended Consequences & Victim Negligence Rules
Rule 1: An intended consequence is NEVER remote. If D intended the exact harm in that manner, unforeseeability of the mechanism does not sever liability.
Rule 2: Negligence of the victim does NOT sever causation unless the victim's negligence was the sole cause of the injury.
Commonwealth v. Root
Involuntary manslaughter requires unlawful or reckless conduct which is the direct and proximate cause of death. Swerving into oncoming traffic by a competing drag racer is an independent, non-foreseeable intervening act that severs proximate cause for the surviving racer.
People v. Acosta
An injury must be the actual and foreseeable result of an act for the act to be the proximate cause. A collision between police helicopters during a ground chase was extraordinary and unforeseeable, severing proximate cause for the fleeing driver.
Battery
Definition: The unlawful application of force to the person of another or items closely associated with the body.
Elements:
1. Unlawful: Unjustified, unexcused, and unconsented.
2. Application of Force: Direct or indirect physical contact (harmful or offensive).
3. Mens Rea: General intent (gross/criminal negligence is sufficient). Extent of physical injury is irrelevant.
Adams v. Commonwealth
A touching under the battery statute requires an intentional, offensive, or forcible contact. Directing a laser beam into an officer's eyes constitutes an unlawful application of force.
State v. Gordon
To establish battery causing bodily injury, the prosecution must prove the victim suffered physical pain, illness, or an impairment of physical condition.
Assault
Common Law Attempted Battery Theory:
Specific intent to commit a battery.
Substantial step taken toward committing battery (provoking fight-or-flight).
Jx Split: Requires actual present ability vs. apparent present ability.
Tort Apprehension Theory:
Specific intent to create reasonable apprehension of immediate battery.
Victim must be aware of D's act.
Victim's apprehension must be objectively reasonable.
People v. Yslas
An assault is complete when there is a clear intent to commit violence accompanied by acts that would cause personal injury if not interrupted (advancing with a hatchet toward victim).
Stalking
Rule: Any person who purposefully or recklessly engages in a course of conduct directed at a specific person and knows or should know that the conduct would cause a reasonable person to:
1. Fear for safety or safety of third person, or
Suffer emotional distress.