1/42
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Minos (second circle)
- Inferno V
- Judge of dead in classical mythology, also King of Crete
-Beast who hears sinners' confessions, twirls his tail around himself the # of times that corresponds to the circle they should go to
"There stands Minos, horrible, snarling, examines their offences at the entrance, judges, and despatches them according as he girds himself; I mean that when the ill-born soul comes before him it confesses all. And that discerner of sins sees what is the place for it in Hell and encircles himself with his tail as many times as the grades he will have it sent down."
Francesca (2nd cricle, the lustful)
C5: 2nd circle of lust
-Trapped in eternal whirlwind (swept away by passion)
-Adulterous love affair with her husband's lover after reading about Guinevere & Lancelot
-Wants her life to resemble that a book, very passive/abdicating responsibility
'Love, which is kindled in the gentle heart, seized man for the fair form that was taken from me, and the manner afflicts me still. Love, which absolves no one beloved from loving, seized me ... Love brought us to one death.'
Francesca falls in love with her husband's brother, Paolo; her speech, which makes the courtly love tradition into love's accomplice, elicits so much pathos and is so moving, illustrating the affective power of the word and the capacities of speech to move us. One of the only active verbs she uses is "we read" (the reading draws the lovers' eyes together), "he ... kissed" (she does not even engage first in this action). Suggestion: displacement of desire is the cause of her current misery. The same act (reading) that led to Augustine's salvation is the cause of Francesca's perdition. Words can move us to good or to evil (duality) - pursuing the poetic calling therefore necessarily entails a certain amount of risk, a truth Dante realizes by the end of the canto. Prompts the poet to wonder - is he running the risk of flagrant misinterpretation? (reason why he "swoon[s]") Should he be writing this poem or keeping silent? Hope: poem will affect transformation and lead others from misery to happiness, concern: poem will lead others astray.
o "We read one day for pastime of Lancelot, how love constrained him. We were alone and had no misgiving. Many times that reading drew our eyes together and changed the colour in our faces, but one point alone it was that mastegred us; when we read that the longed-for smile was kissed by so great a lover, he who never shall be parted from me, all trembling, kissed my mouth. A Galeotto was the book and he that wrote it that day we read in it no farther" - Francesca to Dante pilgrim
Charon
Introduced in Canto III, cowards.
- Appropriated from classical mythology
- Ferries souls across the river Acheron to Hell
And lo, coming towards us in a boat, an old man, his hair white with age, crying: "Woe to you, wicked souls, hope not ever to see the sky. I come to bring you to the other bank, into the eternal shades, into fire and frost; and thou there art a living soul, take thyself apart from these that are dead.
On that the shaggy jaws of the pilot of the livid marsh, about whose eyes were wheels of flame, were quiet
The demon Charon, with eyes of burning coal, beckons to them and gathers them all in, mistin with the oar any that linger
Dante can't cross the Styx on the boat because he needs a 'lighter vessel'-- he needs to be dead. But Virgil convinces him to make an exception.
Charon hits wayward souls with the oars to keep them in the boat if they try to escape.
Casella, purgatorio 2
Warning against purely aesthetic experience.
Poetry as an interruption of higher and loftier goals.
Art CAN play a role in the remaking of the world, but HOW?
· Casella is a local Florentine singer who is the first figure to smile. Although he is recognizable, he is not fully tangible, as illustrated by Dante's failed embrace.
He sings a canzone, written by Dante, about Lady Philosophy, Love that discourses to me in my mind. The sweetness of Casella's tune puts the souls who surround him into a sort of peaceful reverie, which Cato interrupts, forcing them to resume their journey
(eagerness to ascend fraught by temptation to look back in nostalgia, leading to confusion of reason).
Message: God becomes manifest to the soul not by its listening to a song but by its climbing of a mountain.
Dante tries to hug this soul and goes right through. He sings a song, but Cato admonishes them for delaying; a friend of Dante and a poet. Canto II of Purgatorio
- Florentine musician of Dante's day: set some of D's verses to music
- Arrives on ship of souls, Casella's passage to Purgatory has been delayed
then I knew who it was and begged him that he would stay a little and talk with me. He answered me: "Even as I loved thee in my mortal flesh, so do I love thee freed; therefore I stay. But thou, why are thou on this journey?
And I: 'If a new law does not take from thee memory of practices of the songs of love which used to quiet all my longings, may it please thee to refresh my soul with them for a while, which is so spent coming here with my body.'
Love that discourses to me in my mind he began then, so sweetly that the sweetness sounds within me still. My Master and I and these people who were with him seemed as content as if nothing else touched the mind of any.
Ulysses (8th circle, fraudulent, false counselors)
Inferno XXVI
Ulysses portrayed as a somewhat deceptive, talented speaker who uses rhetorical flourishes very obviously
Uses a captata benevolentiae
Dante constantly calls his speech a "picciola orazione"
Not guided by virtue, which is his error:
Tries to access purgatory without the sanction of God, on his own initiative.
Odyssey as an allegory of the human soul: but Ulysses' journey is misguided
Repetition of 'not, not, not' at the beginning to show that U is really neglecting his family
Dante 'considers' too far: 'consideramus.' Beyond stars, knowledge, etc...
Ulysses' fatal mistake is to equate virtue and knowledge
- Swathed in flames
- An instruction to Dante not to repeat his mistakes, arrogance of going where "men should not pass beyond": Dante ought to "curb his powers" lest they run stray of virtue
- He and Diomed were Greek chiefs in the Trojan War, beguiled Achilles' into abandoning his wife to join them, concealed prophecy of Achilles' death, stole Pallas Athene and damned their city, came up with wooden horse
not fondness for son, nor duty to an aged father, nor the love I owed Penelope which should have gladdened her, could conquer within me the passion I had to gain experience of the world and of the vices and the worth of men..
'O brothers,' I said, 'who through a hundred thousand perils, to this so brief a vigil of the senses that remains to us choose not to deny experience, in the sun;s track, of the unpeopled world... You were not born to live as brutes, but to follow virtue and knowledge. My companions I made so eager for the road with these brief words ...
Brutus (9th circle, betrayer of benefactors and lords)
- Inferno XXXIV, Circle 9
- Brutus & Cassius murdered their rightful lord and benefactor, the chosen founder of the Empire, Julius Caesar. B and C fought on Pompey's side in civil war, were defeated, Caesar pardoned them and gave them high offices, Cassius enlisted B to kill Caesar and re-establish the Republic
- Not just personal treachery, treason against divine order (D viewed empire as part of divine scheme)
Of the other two who have their heads below, the one that hangs from the black muzzle is Brutus-see how he writhes and utters not a word...
Cato (purgatory entrance)
On shores of Purgatory, a pagan God places as general guardian of mountain
- Fought in civil war against Caesar, took his own life in Utica in the prospect of defeat rather than survive the freedom of the republic
- Medieval mind: ideal of pagan virtue, hero and martyr of liberty
- He died for political liberty in Utica, which parallels the liberty of the soul Dante seeks (liberty = virtue)
Cato was Pagan statesman of late Roman republic, opposed Julius Caesar, committed suicide to avoid losing Roman liberty but still urged son to submit to Caesar, thereby acknowledging the importance of the Empire
Search for liberation - common tie between Cato and Dante pilgrim
Dante searches spiritual liberation, Cato political liberation
His suicide is bad but not terrible, still in purgatory, because suicide was an 'act of generosity' to transcend violence. An offering of the self as a victim.
Cato was revered in the middle ages as a hero
Shows Rome in Purgatory: with Aeneas. Vs. Rome in Hell. Second face of Rome.
Prefaces Purgatory as an effort, in one sense, to reconstruct the morality and history of Rome
I sw beside me an old man alone, worthy by his looks of so great reverence that no son owes more to a father; his beard was long and streaked with white, and his hair the same, a double tress falling on his breast; the rays of the four holy starts so adorned his face with light that I saw him as if the sun were before him.
'Who are ye that have fled the eternal prison against the blind stream?' he said, shaking those venerable locks. 'Who has guided you or who was your lantern incoming forth from the profound night that holds in perpetual blackness the valley of Hell? Are the laws of the abyss thus broken, or has a new decree been made in Heaven, that, being damned, you come to my cliffs?
But if a lady from Heaven moves and directs thee, as thou sayest, there is no need of fair words; let it suffice thee to ask me for her sake. Go then, and see that thou gird him with a smooth rush and bathe his face so as to remove from it all defilement, for it would not be fitting to go with the eye dimmed
Caiaphas, circle 8, fraudulent
Inferno XXIII: hypocrites w leaden cloaks and Caiphas crucified
- Caiphas was a Jewish high priest who plotted to kill Jesus, presided over trial
- Thought it was expedient for one man to die to save the populace
High priest under whom Jesus was condemned, declared that it was expedient to make one man suffer for the good of the people. Of note here is that Virgil writes something eerily similar, claiming that one life shall be given for many (Trojan - sacrificed) à significance: related to Dante's ongoing effort to distance himself from Virgil (Dante = perfect prophet, Virgil = imperfect prophet)
o "That transfixed one thou art looking at counselled the Pharisees that it was expedient to make one man suffer for the people. He is stretched naked, as thou seest, across the way and must feel the weight of each that passes" - Fra Catalano to Dante pilgrim
'That one thou art looking at counselled the Pharisees that it was expendient to make one man suffer for the people. He is stretched naled, as thou seest, across the way and must feel the weight of each that passes; and in the same fashion his father-in-law is racked in this ditch, and the rest of that council which was a seed of evil for the Jews.' Then I saw Virgil marvelling over him that was stretched crosswide so vilely in the eternal exile.
Piero Delle Vigne (7th circle, 2nd girone, against self)
Inferno XIII: suicide, circle 7, the violent, 2nd girone, against self.
- Chief advisor of Emperor Frederick II, became his Chancellor and was a poet; accused of treason, he was blinded and imprisoned and committed suicide
13: Piero delle Vigne was a rising political advisor to Frederick II; he was very ascendant until his career was cut short by his political rivals. He was the so-called bearer of the keys to Frederick's heart; this faith and loyalty made him the object of disdain, setting secular narrative (political ideology) as a rival to sacred narrative (just a pawn).
o Piero's contrapasso/punishment is therefore fitting; the body of the tree he is trapped in offers him no natural outlet; he has so much intellect but no body to give voice to it. Shows him that he naturally DOES seek a body. During the Last Judgment, his body, which he views as a burden, will return to torment him as a weight on his branches.
o Parallel between Piero and Dante - Dante was also very depressed ("dark wood"), particularly during his exile
'I am he that held both the keys of Frederick's heart and turned them, locking and unlocking ... The harlot ... inflamed all minds against me ... My mind, in scornful temper thinking by dying to escape from scorn, made me, just, unjust to myself.'
Brunetto latini (circle 7th, 3rd girone, violent against gode, sodomites)
Inferno XV: sodomites, circle 7, violent, 3rd girone, violent against god, the sodomites
Dante's teacher. Now, the disciple becomes the poetic judge of the teacher.
Wrote in french, betrayed his native language.
Taught Dante "hour by hour how man makes himself eternal." Yet he is eternal in sin, not in glory.
Is narcissistic and seeks remembrance for personal gratification
Brunetto believes in chance, not divine guidance: a fatal flaw.
Brunetto mistakes the purpose of Dante's journey and is unable to see this grace (Dante notes that GOD leads him home)
o Brunetto's knowledge, collected in his work, is not fruitful and does not lead anywhere meaningful (misperception that earthly glory equals immortality, insistence on paternity - Treasure as surrogate for immortality
"Let my treasure, in which I yet live, be commended to thee; and I ask no more" - Brunetto to Dante pilgrim
- Notary and Guelf leader in Florence, his Treasure in French and Little Treasure tells of an allegorical journey which may have suggested Dante's poem
- Dante's guardian and teacher, D has great fondness for him
- Violence against vernacular by writing in French or gay
-Prophesizes Dante's future
For in my memory is fixed, and now goes to my heart, the dear and kind paternal image of you when many a time in the world you taught me how man makes himself immortal
He seemed not the loser among them, but the winner ...
Beatrice
Object of Dante's earliest love at age 9; the woman whom he will meet in Paradise. The epitome of all earthly goodness and beauty, now that she has died [in middle of VN,], she is also imbued with a heavenly virtue that allows her to appear and sometimes guide him as he makes his way to her.
The crux of his connection between poetry and love. He writes poetry in order to love her more fully; he loves her so that he may write better poetry.
Love also allows him to have faith: credas ut intelligas.
Her name means 'bringer of bliss
A lady called me, so blessed and so fair that I begged her to command me. Her eyes shone brighter than the stars, and she began to speak to me with angelic voice in sweet, low tones: .... My friend, who is no friend of fortune, is so hindered on his way on the desert slope that he has turned his back for fear ... I am Beatrice who bid thee go. I come from the place where I desire to return, Love moved me and makes me speak.
Only those things should be feared that have the power to do us ill, nothing else, for nothing else is fearful ...
Judas
Betrayed Jesus
''That soul up there which has the greatest punishment,' said the Master, 'is Judas Iscariot, who has his head inside and plies his legs without."
Ciampolo, Priest JOhn Paul, 8th Circle (the fraudulent chruch)
- Inferno XXII: guilty of barratry
In the Malebolge, hooked and brought up by one of the guardians of the pit, a barrator, tells Dante of the identity of some of the other people in the pit
- Ciampolo is hooked by the devils (the Malebranche, "Evil Claws") that patrol that ditch, and pulled out of the boiling pitch where the grafters are immersed, which represents their sticky fingers and corrupt deals. Threatened by the devils, Ciampolo tells Dante the identity of some of the other grafters punished there. Ciampolo eventually tricks the devils, and makes his escape back to the boiling pitch.
Oderisi da Gubbio
Purgatorio XI: vain painter
One of the three prideful souls that we meet in XI>
An artist, calls attention to Dante's pride in his own work
He's a miniaturist: thinks he can encapsulate grand things in a small way (hubristic perhaps)
He says, though, that all art is ephemeral, everyone, no matter how good, will be surpassed, so its futile to take pride in your work
Cimabue and Giotto, Guido and Guido... then dante tho
- Master of painting in miniature, illuminated manuscripts
- Recognizing him, Dante refers to Oderisi as honor of Gubbio and the honor of that art of illumination sought after in Paris? Oderisi replies that vanity brought him here; that the brush of his pupil, Franco Bolognese is more worthy
O empty glory of human powers, how briefly lasts the green on its top unless it is followed by an age of dullness! In painting Cimabue thought to hold the field and now Giotto has the cry ...
Belacqua, purgatorio 4
lethargic
- tries to discourage dante from going up mountain
- delayed his repentas and thus must delay purgatoin
Condemned to wait in ante-purgatory because he did not repent for his sins in life: kind of like a prison sentence
Dante's old friend, they're very intimate
One of them, who seemed to me weary, sat clasping his knees and holding his face low down between them.
Who shows himself more indolent than if sloth were his sister...
Farinata degli Uberti 6th circle, (heretics)
Head of Florentine Ghibellines when Guelfs were twice expelled from the city (D is a guelf)
-D respects Farinata bc he loves his noble fatherland more than he hates his Florentine enemies
-Warns him of exile
-Heretic bc follower of Epicurus
Since they denied the immortality of the soul, their eternal punishment is to be entombed in fiery coffins, the dead among the dead, within the city of Dis
Came to be known as Florence's hero, because he stood up to the Ghibelline party of which he was a leader, and prevented them from destroying the city
Yet really less bipartisan than he appears
More interested in Dante's ancestors than himself: shows he's really just interested in genealogy, not bipartisanship
Language of people, kindred, law...
Ciacco (3rd circle, gluttony)
Inferno XI, the gluttonous (name means hog)
Punished by precipitiation.
Glutton. Emphasizes the reduction of people to bodies, to animality.
Prophesies that factions will come to blood: tying together food and violence
Both a violation of Aristotle's mean, here
The body politic, corpus politicum, is eating itself: political cannibalism.
Gluttony is punished by exposure to three forms of precipitation (originates from food, then converted to moisture). Accordingly, Ciacco is the recipient of three politically-related questions from Dante: what will come of Florence (Ghibeline vs. Guelf conflict), are there any good people left (cryptic response - 2 just men), and what is the cause of all the corruption (pride, envy avarice). Important here also is the biotheological implications of Ciacco's story. There is a suggestion Ciacco's identity (or radical moisture, medieval conception of genetic material) might have become diluted over time through excessive eating; proof for this reading lies in his first words (recognize me) and his last words (remember me)
First Florentine he encounters, prophesied about future of the city
- Ciacco foretells a future war and the defeat and expulsion of one party. He concludes his prophecy, and Dante asks where he can find certain good citizens of Florence. Ciacco tells him that they are much further down in Hell because they committed crimes far worse than his, and that Dante will see them if he travels deeper into Hell. Ciacco then swoons and falls unconscious into the muck.
After long strife they shall come to blood and the party of the rustics shall drive out the other with much offence ... Pride, envy, and avarice are the three sparks that have set these hearts on fire...
But when thou shalt be in the sweet world I pray thee bring me to men's memory.
Cassius (circle 9, treacherous, against lords)
Inferno XXXIV, Circle 9
- Brutus & Cassius murdered their rightful lord and benefactor, the chosen founder of the Empire, Julius Caesar. B and C fought on Pompey's side in civil war, were defeated, Caesar pardoned them and gave them high offices, Cassius enlisted B to kill Caesar and re-establish the Republic
- Not just personal treachery, treason against divine order (D thot empire divine scheme)
the other Cassius, who looks so stalwart.
Bertran de Born (8th circle, 9th pouch)
Inferno XXVIII: makers of discord
- Supposedly instigated the rebellion of the Prince ("young king") against his dad, King Henry II
-Carries his severed head like a lantern
I made rebellion between the father and son .... Because I parted those so joined I carry my brain, alas, parted from its root in this trunk; thus is observed in me the retribution.
8th Circle, 9th Pouch, the Perfect Contrapasso
Mentions contrapasso: "thus is observed in me the retribution."
Sower of discord.
Carries his severed head as if a lantern: to show the effects of his discord-sowing
Guido Cavalcanti (heretics, 6th circle)
Cavalcante was a Guelf supporter and therefore Farinata's enemy. He asks Dante where his son is and misinterprets Dante's pause as confirmation that his son is dead. Dante also claims he is being led to or by one Guido held in disdain, mostly likely referring to God.
Guido would have been disdainful of God because he was an Epicurean and denied the soul's immortality, disdaining the elusive "one" or the unicity of the intellect. Characterized by excessive concern for his own kin and for disdain of God (heretic); Dante therefore seems to conclude that there is no such thing as a purely intellectual sin and that our excessive preoccupations/intellectual convictions can and do impinge on our behavior.
o "If thou goest through this blind prison by height of genius, where is my son and why is he not with thee?" - Cavalcante to Dante
o "How saidst thou 'he held'? Lives he not still? Strikes not the sweet light on his eyes?" - Cavalcante to Dante
Friend and fellow poet
Part of Dolce stil novo movement
Most famous poem is canzone Donna Mi Prega (A Lady Asks Me)
Justifies violence as a form of living
Breaks w Dante bc religious skeptic - doesn't appreciate Beatrice
Nessus (7th circle)
Infenro XII, seventh circle
Centaur, "trusty guide," that leads them along the Phlegethon
- Centaurs make sure no one escapes the outer rings of violence
That is Nessus, who died for the fair Dejanira and himself avenged himself
Appointed by Chiron, head centaur, to guide Dante and Virgil, points out Alexander, Attila the Hun, and others who were tyrants.
Terza rima
Italian for "third rhyme"
- ABA BCB CDC DED
- 3 line stanzas (tercets) with interlocking rhymes: 1st and 3rd line rhyme, middle rhymes with 1st+3rd of next stanz
Hendecasyllabic meter:
11 syllables per line
Contrapasso
Contrapasso: retribution. The punishment fits the crime. Derived from: Contra + Patior: To suffer the opposite.
The proud being forced to bend to the pavimento underneath heavy stones: the weight of their pride.
-Francesca caught in the winds of passion
-thieves robbed of their identity
-Bertran del Born parted from his head as he parted father and son
-sodomites have to wander a barren, infertile desert
-treacherous caught in the frozen lake.
Allegory
A literary device, a metaphor, in which a character, place or event is used to deliver a broader message about real-world issues and occurrences (e.g. Old Man of Crete)
- 2 types of allegory: of poets and of theologians (bibical). Dante seems to break down divide
Claimed to write allegory of theologians, but still a poet...
Assonance Consonance
the repetition of a vowel sound or consonant sound within words in proximity
Personification
attribution of human characteristics to otherwise inhuman things
I made rebellion between the father and the son; Ahithophel did no worse for Absalom and David with is wicked goadings.
Because I parted those so joined I carry my brain, alas, parted from its root in this trunk; thus is observed in me the retribution."
Io feci il padre e 'l figlio in sè ribelli:
Achitofèl non fè più d'Absalone
e di David coi malvagi punzelli.
Perch'io parti' così giunte persone,
partito porto il mio cerebro, lasso!,
dal suo principio ch'è in questo troncone.
Così s'osserva in me lo contrapasso."
Bertran del Born, Inferno 28, Sower of Discord (traitors,),
8th Circle, Malebolge
Makers of Discord, subset of the Fraudulent
Bertran, a famous noble and troubadour, supposedly instigated the rebellion of the Prince ("young king") against his father, King Henry II in the 12th century.
Just as he severed the most human of ties, that between a father and son, so too is his own body separated; he is forced to carry his severed head as a lantern.
Context: Bertran is noting the contrapasso: he divided what should be whole, the closest family tie, so now his head is divided from his body. What he enacted on others is now enacted on him.
Ah, how great a marvel it seemed to me when I saw three faces on his head; one in front, and that was red, the two others joined to it just over the middle of each shoulder and all joined at the crown.
Oh quanto parve a me gran maraviglia
quand' io vidi tre facce alla sua testa!
L'una dinanzi, e quella era vermiglia;
l'altr'eran due, che s'aggiugnìeno a questa
sovresso 'l mezzo di ciascuna spalla,
E sè giugnìeno al luogo della cresta;
Dante, Description of Satan, Canto 34.
Context/detail: Here dante employs all of his descriptive power to indicate a monster worse than all that have come before. Because before his sin, he was the noblest angel, now, in a reversal, he is the worst—lowest and most horrific—monster.
9th circle, Judecca, lowest and innermost zone of Cocytus, those treacherous to lords and benefactors
Satan: perversion of holy trinity, the crown an ironic nod to his attempt to unseat God, Satan, so cunning and striving, relegated to speechless beast, forced to implement the justice of God, whom he tried to overthrow
"Many times that reading drew our eyes together and changed the colour in our faces, but one point alone it was that mastered us; when we read that the longed-for smile was kissed by so great a lover, he who never shall be parted from me, all trembling, kissed my mouth. A Galeotto was the book and he that wrote it; that day we read in it no farther."
'Per pìu fïate il occhi ci sospinse
quella lettura, e scolorocci il viso;
Ma solo un punto fu quel che ci vinse.
Quando leggemmo il disïato riso
esser baciato da cotanto amante,
questi, che mai da me non fia diviso,
La bocca mi baciò tutto tremante.
Galeotto fu il libro e chi scrisse:
quel giorno più non vi leggemmo avante'
Francesca, talking about how she came to sin in lust with Paolo to Dante and Virgil Canto V.
Context: Francesca and Paolo, the brother of her husband, commit adultery after reading the story of Lancelot and Guinevere. Her story demonstrates the danger of taking art at its face value; it emphasizes the persuasive power of poetry and how it can be misinterpreted, a warning both to Dante and to the reader.
2nd circle of lust
Trapped in eternal whirlwind (swept away by passion)
Adulterous love affair with her husband's lover after reading about Guinevere & Lancelot
Wants her life to resemble that a book, very passive/abdicating responsibility
Through me the way into the suffering city,
Through me the way to the eternal pain,
Through me the way that runs among the lost.
Justice urged on my high artificer; My maker was divine authority, The highest wisdom, and the primal love. Before me nothing but eternal things Were made, and I endure eternally. Abandon every hope, who enter here.
'Per me si va ne la città dolente,
per me si va ne l'etterno dolore,
per me si va tra la perduta gente.
Giustizia mosse il mio alto fattore;
fecemi la divina podestate,
la somma sapïenza e 'l primo amore.
Dinanzi a me non fuor cose create
se non etterne, e io etterno duro.
Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'intrate'.
These are the words inscribed above the gates to Hell, Canto III.
Context: Before Canto III, Dante described himself as in a dark wood; now, he is entering hell for real. The words prophesy Dante's—and our—journey through hell. The words foreshadow the punishment that await those who have sinned, and provide a theological framework for Hell
Abrupt opening, three time repetition
In the book of my memory, after the first pages, which are almost blank, there is a section headed Incipit vita nova. Beneath this heading I find the words which it is my intention to copy into this smaller book, of if not at all, at least their meaning.
In quella parte del libro de la mia memoria dinanzi la quale poco si potrebbe leggere, si trova una rubrica la quale dice: Incipit vita nova. Sotto la quale rubrica io trovo scritte le parole le quali è mio intendimento d'assemplare in questo liberrlo, e se non tutte, almeno la loro sentenzia.
These are the opening sentences of Vita Nova, Dante's book of poetry and prose concerning his love for Beatrice.
The words reflect Dante's belief that his life did not really start until he met Beatrice.
Plays w temporal structure and memory
Combines autobiographical with prose with poetry
After they had talked together for a time they turned to me with a sign of greeting, and my Master smiled at this; and then they showed me still greater honour, for they made me one of their number so that I was the sixth among those high intelligences.
Da ch'ebber ragionato insieme alquanto,
volsersi a me con salutevol cenno;
e 'l mio maestro sorrise si tanto;
e più d'onore ancora assai mi fenno,
ch'e sì mi fecer della loro schiera.
sì ch' io fui sesto tra cotanto senno.
Dante narrating
Canto IV; Limbo; the unbaptised and the virtuous pagans.
Context: Dante places Homer, Horace, Lucan, and Ovid in Limbo, because although they were unbaptized, their poetry is virtuous and elevates them. Dante's vision of them including him among their ranks indicates his pridefulness, or at least, his aspirations.
he first circle: virtuous heathens
Reconciling classical tradition w Christian one
Distinction between Dante the pilgrim and Dante the poet collapses
Dante's emphasis on numbers
Balance between pride in work and humility
He answered me: "Not man; once I was man, and my parents were Lombards, both Mantuan by birth. I was born sub Julio, though late in his time, and I lived at Rome under the good Augustus, in the time of the false and lying gods. I was a poet and sang of that just son of Anchises who came from Troy after proud Ilium was burned."
Rispuosemi: 'Non omo, omo già fui,
e li parenti miei furon lombardi,
Mantovani per patrïa ambedui.
Nacqui sub Julio, ancor che fosse tardi,
e vissi a Romo sotto 'l buono Augusto
al tempo delli dei falsi e bugiardi.
Virgil speaking to Dante.
Encounter with Virgil, Canto I.
When Dante and Virgil first meet. Careful to include some theology here... right before Virgil decides he will be Dante's guide
Dante is lost, afraid, and alone. He starts in a dark wood. He then attempts to climb a sunny hill, but the sight of three beasts (leopard, lion, and she-wolf: lust, pride, covetousness) cause him to run away.
and a valley at a mountain's base. He sees a leopard, lion, and she-world and begins to run. He sees Virgil, and calls out asking for pity from the man or shade.
V is the ideal poet: prophet of Roman Empire and foreteller of Christ
V guides him throughout the realm of reason
Your knowledge cannot stand against her force; for she foresees and judges and maintains her kingdom as the other gods do theirs. The changes that she brings are without respite: it is necessity that makes her swift; and for this reason, men change state so often. She is the one so frequently maligned even by those who should give praise to her— they blame her wrongfully with words of scorn. But she is blessed and does not hear these things; for with the other primal beings, happy, she turns her sphere and glories in her bliss.
Vostro saver non ha contasto a lei:
questa provede, giudica, e persegue
suo regno come il loro li altri dèi.
Le sue permutazion non hanno triegue:
necessità la fa esser veloce;
sì spesso vien chi vicenda consegue.
Quest' è colei ch'è tanto posta in croce
pur da color che le dovrien dar lode,
dandole biasmo a torto e mala voce;
ma ella s'è beata e ciò non ode:
con l'altre prime creature lieta
volve sua spera e beata si gode.
Virgil speaking to Dante about fortune Wheel of Fortune, Canto VII. Occurs near the avaricious and the prodigal.
4th circle of the hoarders and spenders
Dante asks who is this fortune who holds wealth in her clutches
Fortune serves as a foil to Plutus, the god of wealth punished at the beginning of the canto
Minister of God's providence in contrast with the disordered will of men
Dante rejects the idea that fortune spins her wheels at random: kindred of angels, exercising divine ends
Love, that can quickly seize the gentle heart,
took hold of him because of the fair body
taken from me—how that was done still wounds me. Love, that releases no beloved from loving, took hold of me so strongly through his beauty that, as you see, it has not left me yet. Love led the two of us unto one death. Caina waits for him who took our life."
Amor, ch'al cor gentil ratto s'apprende,
prese costui de la bella persona
che mi fu tolta; e 'l modo ancor m'offende.
Amor, ch'a nullo amato amar perdona,
mi prese del costui piacer sì forte,
che, come vedi, ancor non m'abbandona.
Amor condusse noi ad una morte.
Caina attende chi a vita ci spense".
Francesca, Canto V!
(a) Why is the frozen lake in the lowest circle of Hell (Cocytus) a suitable place for the punishment of traitors? Describe the general contrapasso for treachery.
They must freeze because they bereft others of love and connection.
The lowest part of hell is the one furthest from love; it is cold with betrayal and ill will.
People who betrayed others, gave them the slip, are now frozen together.
(b) Why is Dante so upset by the sight of the contorted soothsayers, and why does Virgil rebuke him for this show of compassion?:
They are in Canto 20, the fraudulent. Dante is upset because they cannot look forwards; only backwards.
Virgil rebukes him because that's what they deserve! They gave false prophecies, so they don't deserve to see into the future. He says that they committed a terrible sin by appropriating divine will, so that's what they get :/
(c) What does it say about Dante, himself an exiled victim of partisan politics, that he presents Farinata as both a political enemy and a defender of Florence?
It shows that Dante does not want to reduce the very complicated political situation of Florence. Farinata allows him to show that although the political division of Florence is entrenched, it is possible, in some sense, to rise above that: we see this through Dante's respect of Farinata. He calls him "magnanimous." Farinata was 'the one man to defend her before them all.' He represents the possibility of being a great man above the kind of party politics that led to Dante's exile.
(d) What might be Dante's purpose for choosing Cato, a pagan suicide who opposed Caesar, as the guardian of the mountain of Purgatory? Consider the effects of this decision, particularly on Virgil.
Although Cato is a pagan suicide—and as such might be expected to be found in Canto XIII of Inferno, the violent against selves—he is instead the guardian of Purgatory. This choice reflects Dante's judgement of Cato as indicative of a virtuous Rome; of a Rome that is self-sacrificing, patriotic, and able to move into the future. Contrast to Brutus and Cassius, who in Canto XXXIV are in the lowest rung of hell, and represent all that is bad in Rome.
Cato is willing to sacrifice self instead of ceding to Caesar, for the good of the nation, but he also gets grandson to accept caesar: perhaps indicates to Virgil that the lineage he began with Aeneas continues?
(e) What role does the number nine play in Vita Nuova? Why does Dante use repetition and how does it affect the reader's experience of the text? Why nine?
Symbolizes the connection that Dante is drawing between love and the divine; between Beatrice and God; between Poetry and Theology.
"She was a nine, or a miracle, whose root, namely that of the miracle, is the miraculous trinity itself."
Repetition allows the reader to feel a certain kind of inevitability, of fatedness, in the way things went down. Religion and poetry both rife with symbols; incorporating more of them—and creating motifs—only strengthens that connection.
Met her when he was 9, on the 9th day... 9 = 3 x Holy Trinity
Saw her again 9 years later, she greets him at 9 am
She died September 9th
Also 9 levels of hell...
"Philosophy, for one who understands," he said to me, "notes, not in one place only, how nature takes her course from the divine mind and its art; and if thou note well thy Physics thou wilt find, not many pages on, that your art, as far as it can, follows nature as the pupil the master, so that your art is to God, as it were, a grandchild."
'Filosofia,' mia disse 'a chi la 'ntende,
nota non pur in una sola parte
come natura lo suo corso prende
da divino intelletto e da sua arte;
e se tu ben la tua Fisica note,
tu troverai, non dopo molte carte,
che l'arte vostra quella, quanto pote,
segue, come 'l maestro fa il discente;
sì che vostr'arte a Dio quasi è nepote.
Inferno XI
Virgil speaking to Dante
Context
Canto in which Virgil explains the structure of hell to Dante, draws heavily on Cicero and Aristotle, whom "Philosophy" and Physics are a reference to
Virgil trying to explain how sins as different as blasphemy, sodomy, and usury, are all grouped as forms of violence against God: misuing your art, more broadly meaning your workmanship for evil is bad bc its linked to god
Art means workmanship
Vita Nuova
Autobiography mixed w prose and poetry
Retrieves memory of youth of falling in love at age 9 w Beatrice
Central cycle: must write to love her, must love her to write - he can love her through poetry
I have to love her greatly to write great poetry and I have to write great poetry to make her love me
B dies young (in middle of VN narrative) and belongs to a renowned family
"Vita nuova" = youth
Plays w temporal structure and memory
Life begins w B
Love is fed and feeds on imagination
Imagination takes place of philosophy