VLRC and Royal Commission (Legal U4 Aos2 Part A)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/16

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

17 Terms

1
New cards

A problem with the law is identified: VLRC inquoiry

  • Around 1 in 6 women + 1 in 15 men affected by stalking.

  • As a result of technological advancements, types of stalking behaviour have evolved and can now be conducted without physical proximity to the victim.

  • Stalking behaviours occur in both family violence and non-family violence contexts - but more has been done to address stalking in family contexts.


2
New cards

Term of Reference: VLRC

  • February 2021, VLRC received a t.o.r from Vic Attorney-General to investigate Victoria’s response to stalking, and similar conduct, specifically non-family violence stalking.

  • Main task: To investigate + report on Vic’s legal responses to stalking, harassment, and similar conduct - including Personal Safety Intervention Order (PSIO) system.

  • T.o.r stated that an interim report was due 31 December 2021, with the final report due on 30 June 2022.


3
New cards

VLRC Term of Reference Specifics:

- In conducting a review - t.o.r  required the VLRC to consider:

  • Legislation concerning stalking, harassment, or similar conduct, (esp. Personal Safety Intervention Orders Act 2010 (Vic) and how it differs from Family Violence Intervention Orders under Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic))

  • Barriers to reporting stalking + how law can further promote safety + wellbeing of victims.

  • Sentencing practices and available sentencing options for stalking offenders.

  • The existing criminal offences that apply to stalking, harassment, and similar conduct under the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) and the evidence required to establish each offence


4
New cards

Investigation Process: VLRC

  • VLRC conducted an extensive examination of the matters within the terms of reference.

  • Received 115 written submissions, and 254 responses to an online form for people who have experienced stalking - submissions were from community + organisations

  • Consultations were conducted with 36 different parties/stakeholders - eg: eSafety Commissioner, the Judicial College of Victoria, and Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service.



5
New cards

Report and Recommendations: VLRC

  • Produced an interim report 22 December 2021.

  • Findings of interim report focused on police response to stalking + how earlier intervention may reduce interaction between victims, offenders, and the CJS.

  • Following the investigation VLRC produced its final report w. 45 recommendations for reform

  • The final report was tabled in parliament on 21 September 2022.


6
New cards

KEY RECOMMENDATIONS FROM VLRC:

  • The Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) should be amended to make the stalking offence clearer and easier to apply.

  • Victims should have easier access to financial and practical support

  • Victims should be supported by independent advocates to guide them through every stage, from reporting the stalking activity to accessing support services and any court actions.

  • The civil personal safety intervention order (PSIO) system should be improved, with guidance to help identify and prioritise stalking cases.

  • We need community education on stalking, and training about stalking for judicial officers and people who work in the justice system.


7
New cards

Government Response: VLRC

  • May 2024, Vic. Gov. announced changes to the stalking offence + improve the PSIO system.

  • November 2025, Gov. introduced legislation implementing 2 recommendations from report:

    • Amending section 21A of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) to better set out the elements of the stalking offence, and to clarify the meaning of ‘course of conduct’- so that the offence of stalking is easier to understand and apply in practice.  

    • Allowing interim Personal Safety Intervention Order to be made on the court’s own motion. This will enable PSIOs to be made by the court, without requiring the person to make a separate application, increasing the court’s ability to protect victims.


8
New cards

VLRC Strengths:

  • Government connection: Terms of reference come from the Attorney-General - recommendations more likely to be considered by Parliament.

  • Community consultation: Consults the community, experts and interest groups - recommendations reflect community needs + values.

  • Expert & thorough research: Conducts in-depth research and consultation with experts - informed recommendations that address social/legal issues.

  • High implementation rate: 75% of VLRC recommendations have been implemented in full or part - demonstrates its effectiveness in influencing law reform.


9
New cards

VLRC Limitations:

  • No obligation: Government is not required to consider or implement VLRC recommendations - recommendations may be ignored.

  • Limited scope: Usually restricted by the Attorney-General’s terms of reference - can only investigate specified areas of law.

  • Time-consuming: Extensive research and consultation can make the law reform process slow.

  • Limited to Victoria: Can only recommend changes to Victorian law, not Commonwealth legislation.


10
New cards

Strengths of a Royal Commission

  • Comprehensive investigation: Extensive research, evidence and expert input → well-informed recommendations that can effectively address the issue.

  • Independent: Independent from government → investigations can be conducted without political bias.

  • Coercive powers: Can compel witnesses to give evidence under oath and require documents → helps uncover the truth and gives Parliament a better understanding of the issue.

  • Community involvement: Public hearings + community submissions allow the public to express concerns and influence law reform.


11
New cards

Limittions pf Royal Commissions

  • Rare: Highest form of inquiry → only established in rare/exceptional circumstances, limiting their use.

  • Expensive: Require significant staff, experts and resources → can be costly.

  • Not binding: Government/Parliament is not obliged to implement recommendations → findings may not result in law reform despite the time and money spent.

  • Government control: Government decides whether to establish a Royal Commission + sets its terms of reference → may avoid inquiries into politically damaging issues or limit what can be investigated.


12
New cards

Why was the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion established?

  • 14th December 2025 - Recent deadliest terrorist attack.

  • Mass shooting during a Hanukkah celebration at Archer Park, Bondi Beach, Sydney

  • Antisemetic terrorism attack killing 15 people, injuring 41

  • Overall dramatic increase of antisemetic attacks across Australia

  • Established 9 Jan 2026 called for a Commonwealth Royal Commission

  • Commonwealth inquiry was necessary to investigate national security, intelligence, federal law enforcement, border control and immigration/visa settings — beyond NSW powers.


13
New cards

What were the Terms of Reference of the Royal Commission?

Investigated:

  1. Nature & prevalence of antisemitism in Australian society/institutions.

  2. Law enforcement & agency responses to antisemitism.

  3. Circumstances of the Bondi Beach attack.

  4. Social cohesion & counter-extremism measures.


14
New cards

How did the Royal Commission investigate the issue?

  • All states & territories invited to participate → national approach.

  • Investigated the attack, antisemitism, law enforcement responses and social cohesion through its Terms of Reference.


15
New cards

What were the Royal Commission's interim findings and recommendations?

  • Interim Report: 30 April 2026 → focused on Bondi attack + urgent matters.

  • Made 14 recommendations (some classified).

  • Found existing legal/regulatory frameworks did not prevent agencies from responding to the attack → no urgent legal changes required.

  • Recommendations aimed to strengthen national counter-terrorism arrangements/capabilities.

  • Government accepted all recommendations directed at it and committed to working with states/territories.


16
New cards

What were some recommendations of the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion?

• The procedures adopted by NSW Police for Operation Jewish High Holy Days should apply to other high-risk Jewish festivals and events

• Consideration be given to making the Commonwealth Counter-Terrorism Coordinator's role full-time (previously part-time)

17
New cards

Q: How did the Royal Commission influence law reform?

  • Created law reform momentum by investigating the causes and responses to antisemitism/terrorism.

  • Government announced measures before/alongside the inquiry, including:

    • new hate speech laws

    • tougher gun laws + national firearms review

    • stronger powers to address unlawful places of worship.

  • Demonstrates Royal Commissions can prompt governments to act on significant issues, even before a final report.