1/11
Vocabulary flashcards covering the puzzle of non-existents, Plato's riddle of nonbeing, and Bertrand Russell's Theory of Descriptions.
Puzzle of Non-existents
The philosophical problem of explaining how we can make true and meaningful statements about entities that do not exist (such as Pegasus) without referring to nothing or being forced to believe in mystical entities.
Plato's Riddle of Nonbeing
The classical puzzle cited by W.V. Quine stating that nonbeing must in some sense be, otherwise what is it that there is not.
Subsistence
A postulated mode of being or presence in the understanding, suggested as an alternative to physical existence to account for non-existent entities like Pegasus.
Logically Proper Names
For Russell, words, phrases, or symbols that always possess individual reference, are theoretically unstructured (their internal structure is irrelevant), and succeed in referring through an act of naming (e.g., "Boethius", "David Hume", "This", "That").
Definite Descriptions
In Russell's framework, theoretically structured expressions that describe without always referring, taking the grammatical form "the x", where "x" is a singular common noun or noun phrase.
Indefinite Descriptions
Descriptions that possess the grammatical form "an x", where "x" is a singular common noun or noun phrase, and which may refer to multiple items or fail to refer at all.
Russell’s Theory of Descriptions
The philosophical account proposing that talk about non-existent objects can only be meaningfully conducted by using descriptions rather than logically proper names.
Russell's Tripartite Analysis
The breakdown of a sentence containing a definite description (e.g., "The present King of France is bald") into three conjunctions: (i) at least one exists, (ii) at most one exists, and (iii) whatever is that thing has the predicate property.
Ontological Innocence
A virtue of Russell's theory whereby descriptions do not commit us to the reality of non-existent objects, relying instead only on real-world properties, relations, or concepts.
Disguised Definite Descriptions
Ordinary proper names in natural language (such as "Pegasus" or "Sherlock Holmes") that actually function logically as hidden definite descriptions (e.g., "the flying horse described in Greek mythology").
"On Denoting" (1905)
The seminal philosophical paper published by Bertrand Russell in the journal Mind introducing his Theory of Descriptions.
"On What There Is" (1948)
The influential paper by W.V. Quine addressing ontology, Plato's riddle of nonbeing, and the puzzle of non-existents.