1/64
judicial organization and administration
how many other different types of courts in the US that arent the typical ones?
Traffic, housing, drug, military (separate laws), bankruptcy, tax, patent
what are article iii courts?
federal courts: Supreme Court, Federal Appell courts, federal district courts (trial courts). NOT state courts. they are authorized by Article iii of the constitution. lifetime appointments, appointed by pres and approved by senate (not elected), can only be removed for cause through impeachment
main courts you think about when you think about US courts
federal, state, federal appell, federal district, state appell, state trial
how do state judges operate differently from federal judges?
elected (in some capacity), term limits, additional courts: small claims, drug
what happens in a small claims court?
(judge judy) informal, low dollar disputes (under $1000), no lawyers, therapeutic
what happens in drug courts?
addresses issues of addiction in a more humane way, kinda like a college w a graduation = rehab oversight, DA kinda operates like this too
what happens in bankruptcy courts?
federal! specialized and unique bc theres a LOT of bankruptcies.
what happens in a patent court?
federal, but goes to specialized court for appeals. separate patent lawyers and judges. v sciency. ONE appellate authority
what are article i courts?
legislative courts that DON’T have full judicial authority. federal. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims, Court of Appeals for Armed Forces, U.S. Tax court.
do mediation and arbitration courts have any judicial authority?
not really. no precendential value and not overseen by an actual judge (sometimes retired judges will serve as mediators)
what is mediation and arbitration?
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) used to solve legal conflicts outside of traditional courtroom. less formal and less expensive. can be binding (decision binds both parties) and non-binding (suggestion for settlement)
why would people want non-binding arbitration?
it brings the two parties closer together. less extreme view into a more moderate one.
who can be an arbiter?
anyone can. agreed to and trusted by both parties. there are professsionals. court can provide a list if parties want.
where do courts get their authority from?
federal courts get it from article iii of the constitution. ONE court (Supreme court), other courts created by congress but they arent forced to.
what does the constitution say about judges?
judges should stay away from politics to make public trust them more and more accountable.
The Founders were divided. What did the Federalists believe in?
wanted a stronger central government, saw articles of confederation and how it failed they didnt want that again. wanted federal courts, natinoal banks, etc. Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, James Madison.
The Founders were divided, What did the anti-Federalists believe in?
wanted a stronger state government, didn’t want the tyranny of the british again. they wanted a bill of rights in the constitution. Patrick Henry, Samuel Adams Thomas Jefferson (kinda)
Bill of rights debate?
constitution under the 5th amendment didnt limit how states could treat their citizens in the beginning. anti-federalists thought clause was too vague and wanted bill of rights for promised protection of freedoms
what does SC have “original jurisdiction” over?
cannot be removed. involves ambassadors, public ministers and consuls, cases where state is a party (can start at SC).
what does SC have “appellate jurisdiction” over?
can be removed. lower court appeals (cannot usually start at SC), issues of federal law and cases involving 2 or more states, ppl from different states, state and citizen of diff state)
biggest difference between appellate and original jurisdiction?
congress can alter the judiciary’s appellate jurisdiction as it sees fit.
why grant federal courts jurisdiction over a case between diff states, etc?
this is “diversity jurisdiction”. choice of law issue: different states have different laws. state must claim which laws they want to use, but its so complicated that it just goes to the federal courts
what was the first thing that the judiciary act of 1789 did?
first congress dominated by federalists, passed act to establish a bunch of lower federal courts (at first, 13 district courts for each state and 3 appellate courts w 3 judges each (eastern, middle, and southern))
what was the second thing the judiciary act of 1789 do?
defined jurisdiction of new courts (congress can decide parameters of federal appellate jurisdiction)
what is judicial review?
court can overrule/strike down/void a law that congress has made.
basic details of marbury v. madison?
Federalists appointed a bunch of federalist judges bc they were afraid next administration was going to undo all of their work. Marshall (previous secretary of state) was supposed to hand out these letters but he forgot! so AFs refused to mail them. Marbury was one of the confirmed-not-mailed would-be judges and he sued claiming that his confirmation was valid even though it was never mailed. Marshall was also promoted to chief justice and is now overseeing his trial due to his OWN negligence!
how did court rule in Marbury v. Madison?
judicial review. it expanded the power of the court while making the public happy.
critiques of Marbury v. Madison ruling? (1)
counter-majoritarian difficulty. allows unelected judges to overturn acts of an elected (majoritarian, represents the popular will) legislature
critiques of Marbury v. Madison ruling? (2)
founders knew about judicial review, but did not explicitly write it into the constitution to give judiciary that power
arguments that judicial review should exist? (1)
protects the constitution. constitution is no good if it has unconstitutional laws and no institution to police it
arguments that judicial review should exist? (2)
Some argue that founds DID want judiciary to have power of judicial review. they simply assumed judiciary would have the power
arguments that judicial review should exist? (3)
need it to check and balance other branches
arguments that judicial review should exist? (4)
court needs it to act as a check on majoritarian will. we have rights that the majority cannot trample on.
what is certiorari? “cert”
SC votes to take a case (mysterious on how they decide to take a case, sure on that they need 4 votes to approve cert). largest possible minority to approve cert.
1925 SC changed the way it accepts appeals. changed to petitions for certiorari. what does this mean? why is it relevant to an expanding federal court system?
SC is now discretionary. they get to set their own agenda, they get to pick what trials they want to hear, and dont have to hear every case. this expands their power
how many circuits do we have?
normally 11, 12 if you add DC, 13 if you add Federal
SC is more likely to take cases about?
congress and pres, USA (US attorney general), constitutional law, between USA and foreign country, circuit splits (esp over important topics)
what are some “alternative courts”?
part of judiciary expansion. magistrate courts, “specialized courts” (like drug), Alternative Dispute Resolution (not technically courts): Mediation and Arbitration
what is a Magistrate Court?
routine issues that come up a lot
What matters do state courts decide?
state constitution and state law
what do we do if 2 states are involved?
car accident example. choice of forum issue: deciding which geographical location has legal right to handle a dispute. ultimate ruling: ehhh it depends. all factors are relevant.
car crash example: why might one say the trial should take place in Nevada?
convenient for Tim, maybe he’s hurt and cant travel to CA
car crash example: why might one say the trial should take place in CA?
accident happened in CA, all witnesses in CA, police who responded are in CA.
car crash example: what law should apply?
choice of law issue: which state’s law should they apply? court will decide (they can be persuaded that another state’s laws should apply!)
another way that a different state’s law can be held to be controlling?
parties can agree contractually to apply a certain state’s laws if they have a dispute. common w corporations “contracts of adhesion”
what is a “contract of adhesion?”
pre-written agreement created by one party with significantly more bargaining power and presented to the other party on a “take-it-or-leave-it” basis.
car example: can federal courts have a say abt accident? can time sue in federal court?
tim can sue if injury exceeds $75k. DIVERSITY JURISDICTION.
car accident example: why would tim sue?
non-biased ruling
what do federal courts handle? what matters do federal courts adjudicate?
questions of federal law. US constitution, US statues, treates, matters concerning more than one state (diversity jurisdiction)
what power do federal courts have over the other branches?
primary check is power of judicial review. can also interpret laws in a way congress doesn’t like, can neuter a law without fully voiding it.
how does the court have a large degree of independence?
lifetime tenure (unless impeached), salary is guaranteed.
what power does other branches have over the court? (1)
nomination process, controls WHO serves in federal judiciary
what power does other branches have over the court? (2)
control court’s budget
what power does other branches have over the court? (3)
control size of courts. can court pack: can put more judges that think similarly
what power does other branches have over the court? (4)
controls court’s appellate jurisdiction (obergefell: theatrened to removed court to adjudicate marriage)
what power does other branches have over the court? (5)
people can simply refuse to abide by court’s decision (constitutional crisis)
what power does other branches have over the court? (6)
they can impeach judges
what does it mean when someone says that a study lacks external validity?
results do not hold in the real world, only works for sample
what is a confound?
another variable is ACTUALLY causing relationship between IV and DV, not the ones you were testing
what does it mean when something is “statistically significant”?
95% confidence interval
when might a study be overpowered?
finding a result that isn’t intended due to the large sample size
what does it mean when a sample is biased?
sample is different from population you want to examine
what does it mean when someone says “the construct validity of study is flawed”?
you arent ACTUALLY measuring what you want to measure
what does it mean to question a study’s causal direction?
direction goes the other way. X→Y BUT Y ACTUALLY →X
what are reputational concerns (satisficing)?
ppl tend to avoid giving answers that place them in a poor light (ex: in a survery, dont wanna say how much they actually make or if they hate their job while in their workplace)