P8: The Responsibility Gap Arugment

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/7

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

8 Terms

1
New cards

What is the Responsibility Gap Argument against LAWS?

It argues that deploying weapons is wrong if no one can justly be held responsible for civilian casualties, and because no one can be held responsible for strongly autonomous LAWS, deploying them is wrong.

2
New cards

In the GI Robbie example, how was Robbie trained, how effective is it, and what does it do when passing unarmed farmers?

GI Robbie was trained by Ada and achieves 10% lower civilian casualties than humans, but it mistakenly classifies unarmed farmers as hostiles and kills them.

3
New cards

Who are the three candidate entities that could potentially be held responsible for Robbie's actions?

The candidates are Ada (the programmer), General Mills (the commander), or Robbie (the machine itself).

4
New cards

Why does Robert Sparrow argue we cannot hold Robbie morally responsible?

Sparrow argues moral responsibility requires suitability for punishment, and we cannot punish an artificial machine because it cannot suffer.

5
New cards

What two reasons support the Responsibility Requirement Claim (respect and consequences)?

Basic respect for enemy lives requires holding someone accountable for taking them, and lacking accountability makes prosecuting war crimes impossible.

6
New cards

How can someone reject the Responsibility Requirement by appealing to respect for civilians?

Deploying an AI like Robbie that reduces civilian casualties by 10% demonstrates greater actual respect for civilian lives than sending fallible human soldiers.

7
New cards

What two further claims support Sparrow's view that Robbie cannot be held responsible?

An entity cannot be held morally responsible if it is inappropriate to punish it, and punishing an entity is impossible if we cannot cause it to suffer.

8
New cards

How does Boonin argue we can hold entities responsible without punishment? What options and examples does he give for Dr. Ross and Robbie?

Boonin argues responsibility can be assigned non-punitively via license revocation or compensation (e.g., revoking a negligent doctor's license). Similarly, Robbie can be held responsible by revoking its operational authority or using its labor to compensate victims.