1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Elements of Negligence
Duty of care
Breach of duty
causation
Actual - But-for
Proximate - Foreseeability
Damages
Hand Formula
B<pL
Burden<probability of harm x gravity of injury
If the burden is less than the probablity of harm and gravity of injury, then you must do the action (burden) to NOT be negligent
Impossibility Defense
failure to comply with a statute can be excused if it is impossible ot follow the statute
Duty of Land Possessors rule
Default - person must exercise reasonable care under the circumstances
3 common exceptions that raise or lower:
Possessors of land and entrants
common carriers and passengers
drivers and guest-passengers
Premises Liability
Traditional rule - possessor’s duty depends on the injured person’s legal status on the property
Invitee - reasonable care under circumstances
Licensee - limited duty - particularly for known hazards
Trespasser - generally the lowest duty
Invitee
Public Invitee - invited to enter as a member of the public
- Enters for a purpose for which the property is held open to the publid
- mere public access or tolerance is insufficient, the possessor must INIDACTE that public entry is expected or encouraged
Business visitor - Enters for a purpsoe directly or indirectly connected with business dealings with the possessor
Duty of care: Invitees
Dangerous conditions known or discoverable by the possessor
A possessor may be liable for physical harm to an invitee when all 3 conditions are satisfied
knowledge - Possessor knows or through reasonable care should discover, the dangerous condition and recognize its unreasonable risk
Foreseeability - the possessor should expect that invitees will not discover the danger, appreciate it, or protect themselves against it
failure to protect - the possessor fails to exercise reasonable care to protect invitees from the danger
Liability is not automatic following an accident
Licensee
Licensee is a person privililged to enter or remain on land by virtue of the possessor’s consent
i.e. social guest, door to door solicitors
Liability generally requires
Possessor knows or has reason to know of the condition and recognizes its unreasonable risk
the possessor should expect that the licensee will not discover or appreciate the danger
possessor fails to exercise reasonable care to maek the condition safe or warn the licensee
the licensee does not know or have reason to know of teh condition and its risk
Trespassor
lowest duty of care
trespassor enters or remains on another’s land without a privilege created by consent or otherwise
land possessor generally must refrain from willful condcut towards trespassors
Constant trespassers - applies when the possessor knows that trespassers repeatedly enter a limited area and maintains a highly dangerous artificial condition likely to cause death or seriosu bodil harm that they are unlikely to discover
Known trespassors - applies when the possessor knows or has reason to know that trespassors are dangerously close to a highy deangerous artifical condition and htey are unlikely to discover or appreciate the risk
BOTH PROVISIONS MAY IMPOSE A DUTY TO USE REASONABLE CARE TO WARN ABOUT HAZARDS
Trespassing Children
possessor may be liable when the following elements are met
Children are likely to trespass where the condition exists
the possessor knows or should know of the condition and its unreasonable risk of death or seriosu bodily injury
Because of their youth, the children do not discover the condition or appreciate the risk
the possessor fails to exercise reasonable care to eliminate the danger or otherwise protect the children
Doctrine is not triggered merely because a child is injured while trespassing
Simple version of duty of care
Invitee - find, fix, or warn
Licensee - if you know of dangerous condition, warn or fix
trespassor - dont intentioanlly or willfully hurt them (if known/frequent - warn of hidden, artifical conditions)
Common Carriers
Common Carriers owe passengers a heightened duty of care beyond ordinary reasonable care
Elevator in public building
ambulance
bus
No duty to rescue rule
A person genreally has no affirmative duty to rescue a stranger
cannot make matters worse through one’s conduct
exceptions - special relationships
innkeepers and their guests
possessors of land held open to the public and their invitees
caregivers or counselors who take custody of people who depend on them for protection
companions engaged in a social venture
Erie
Voluntary safety measures can create an affirmative duty when others reasonably rely on them
Voluntary Undertaking
A person who undertakes services for another, knowing or having reason to know that those services will reduce the risk of physical harm, must exercise reasonable care when either
failure to exercise reasonable care increases the risk of harm beyond what existed before the undertaking
the recipient or another person relies on the undertaking being performed with reasonable care
important distinctions
merely adopitng a policy does not automatically establish liabilty for every violation
the undertaking must meet the applicable conditinos for imposing a duty
courts exavmine the scope of the undertaking and whether the defendant’s conduct increased risk of induced reliance